Uhbvnl And ORS v. Pushap Raj
!
#$%&$'$
"$( )*$)$ ", -+ .
//** '+ .0.
/0.- 1 % / 2 3#*4 ' 4 5 / +.+"
6-$& 7.-5 8+ 9,8:
+9
. ;;;
-$. +(0& .+:", &$.
-+6+-+.
-+%0,()+"
",,+: ++.1 ..+,6! -+:0 .6+&<,+: ++$"( .0$ $&+,6!
7+ :"8+"$+":+9 -+1
$+. +6+$"( + + +, 1+ -+$ $($"
&1.$ $"$" -+:$8$&.0$ -+1&
$&+, .0$ ,+:&
$"<$ -:".+=0+"
& +&$+ 1+ ) "+"
$"%0":
$") 7$"( 1 !+
-+$)10("+," $:+ ,
$..0+, +:8+ ! 99?@2 +&+:
$:$ !
::0"
*/2A
&&.06.+=0+"
6$&&.@" $:+. ,+) ",$..0+,6! +$&&+( & ",<-$).$:
&+ : -+
.<-$:-&+, $&$"( .1+ -+ 8+ )+"
.
+
-+< :".0)+ +&+:
$:$ !:""+:
$" .) && 1<+
- 77$- 8$"(:""+:
+,& , BC-++&+:
$:)+ $.$".
&&+,
++ < ! -+1 +)$.+.
"+&+:
$:1&+ $" .+ &+, ",&:7+,6D-+,+ .- ,6++".+",$"( -+6$&&.
.-<$"( -+ )+ + ,+ , .
1 .$":+ 4 "0 !9
> -+ 1&
) ,+ +=0+.
$)+ $" +1& :+ + 960 " $"
<
7+"-+1&
) ,+ +1 +.+"
$",
> :- "(+
,+ $8+)+ + "4 "0 !9
9-+< .$..0+, 6$&& 0"$ ..-<$"( &, + ,$"( .
?
","+< + ,$"( .
" -+ +1 +.+"
$"< ) ,+6!
"
+1& :+)+"
+ "
@
-++&+:
$:)+ + < .60 "
-++&+:
$:$ !.011&! 1 +)$.+.< .,$.:""+:
+,"
" )+, !9 ",+,8+ )+) ,
>
.7$"(
1 !
.0) 99?@2-+1&
$&+,:)1& 0",+ -+".0)+ / $":
9> 9 .1+ -+ ,+ -+$.
$:
".0)+ $.10 +.
+, +..
& 0)9B0 07.-+
.- 9E -+".0)+ 0)39,+1.$ +, ?
F $"=0+.
$".
! ,+ < .1 ..+,6! -+".0)+ 0) +.
$"$"( ),$.:""+:
$"( -++&+:
$:$ !.011&! -+.
$,:)1& .<$ -, <"6!
"
<$ &$6+ ! $&+.0$ -+ +
+ 9 .0$ $&+, " " $:+9 -+ ,+ . $&+, < $
+" .
+)+"
$.$"( $0.6%+:
$". ",( 8+ -+$ <"8+ .$"
. -+&+ "+, &:0
)+, &&<$"($..0+.2
C-+ -+ 1&
$.+"
&+, ,+: ++ ,+:&
$"
-+$)10("+," $:+ ,
$..0+, +:8+ ! . 99?@2 -++&+:
$:$ !@:
*/2A 9 $. $&&+( &&9 < "(9 <-$).$:
&9 $"1+
$8+9$"+
$8+90"& < 0&9"0&&8$,90&
8$ +.
.<+&& -+1 8$.$". & <9 0&+.9 +(0&
$".
..0:- +&$ 6&+ 6+.+ .$,+G// C-+ -+
$.+"
&+, " +:8+ "!
1
&&+(+, . 99?@2$" "!) ""+ + 0", . 9 9??@2 ,+1.$ +, $"
:)1&$ ":+ ,+ ,
+, >
&+ "+, 9 B0 07.-+
&"(<$ -$"
+ +.
+ F1+
""0)G// C-+ -+ 1&
$. +"
&+, ,+: ++ 1+ ) "+"
$"%0":
$" .1 !+, G// ? C-+ -+ 1&
$. +"
&+, ,+: ++ )
!
$"%0":
$" .1 !+, G// A C-+ -+ $." )
6&+G/ C-+ -+ 1&
- ."&:0..
",$ ",:
0.+ $"
$&+ .0$ G/ C-+ -+ -$.0 - .( "%0 $.,$:
$" +"
$"
! -$..0$ G/ C-+ -+ 1&
$.+.
11+,6!-$.<" ",:",0:
$&$"( .0$ G/ > C-+ -+ 1&
- .:":+ &+, 0+ ",)
+ $ &
-+0 G/ " .011 -+ .0$ $&+,9 -+ 1&
+D )$"+, +.- B0) ./C950 )++ $"(- ./C
-$).+&
+, ./C :0)+"
.D/ D/ ?9 7 ", 7#<+ +
2?2
&.1 ,0:+, -+,+ .+D )$"+,# $%+.-B0) 940"$ "($"++ C ",1 ,0:+,,:0)+"
.D ",DC@ -+&+ "+, &:0 9" -+6 .$. -+1&+ ,$"(.
11 +:$
$"(
+)+"
. -+<$ "+..+. -++8$,+":+1 ,0:+,6!
-+1
$+.9,+:$,+,$..0+. ?$"
80
",$..0+.
A > .9 ",,+: ++, (( $+8+, $,%0,()+"
",,+: ++9 $&+,
-+ $ .
& <-$:- < . ,$.)$..+, 6! -+ &+ "+, $.
$:
40,(+9 B0 07.-+
9 8$,+ %0,()+"
", ,+: ++ ,
+,
A +":+9 1 +.+"
& " &9 .) "! ..$D=0+.
$". & <<+ +
)+,960
$)+ (0)+"
.9&+ "+,:0".+&,$," 1 +.. -+.+ =0+.
$". #+ +,+ &$"(<$ - -+"+$..0+ $.+,6!&+ "+,:0".+&
.9$ <0&,6+ 11 1 $
+ - 8+ &7
-+$..0+.<-$:- 8+6++",+:$,+,6! -+&+ "+,:0 .6+&<-+&+ "+,
+:0
+&$+,01"8 $0.:$ :0& .-< -+1
)+ + . 6+ &&<+,6! ,+ .$ :0& ,
>>9D/?9) 7+.$ )
!"
$+&,
$:+ . :",0:
+(0& :-+:7$"( + .
&& ,.
1@60 "
",$"
::0
+)+ + .)0.
6+ +1& :+,<$ -$".$D )"
-. $"" -+ :$ :0& ,
9D/ 9<
-+ +8$.+, $D+,:- (+. + 11&$:
6&+ ) D$)0)1+ $, .$D
2A2 )"
-.9$+ - ++6$&&$"(:!:&+.$ :0& ,
9D/ 9($8+. ,+
$&. $" 6+
7+"9$":
.+ + $. 0",, ) (+,@,+ ,@ 60 "
@)$..$"(
&7. 60 +($.
$" 1
68+.
$, :$ :0& .9 -+ 1.$ $" +)+ (+. $.
-+ 6$&&. ,
+,
>
>9D/ ",D/? +.1+:
$8+&!9- , .
0.:,+ )+"
$"$"(E3<-$:-$)1&$+,
+ < .,+ ," -+6$&&.,
+,
>9
>9
>9
>9
>
>9D/A D/
0.:,+ + < .)+"
$"+,
.E3-+ +
+ 9 -+6$&&,
+,
9D/ 9.-<.
+ $.
< 7$"(.-<$"( -+:0 +"
+ ,$"( .
-+1 +8$0. + ,$"(
?
:: ,$"(&!9 -+ 6$&& < . $..0+, " :".0)1 $" 6 .$. -+ ,+
$&+, .-<
6!<-.+ +1 + < 0",,+ ,
60 A)"
-. -+ +
+ 9.0,,+"&! + .
+,< 7$"(9" .$. <-$:- -+6$&&,
+,
.$..0+,":".0)1 $"6 .$. D/>9 +1 6!4,
+,
9.-<.
+ < .EB3 . + ,$"("
, !< . 960 -+6+.
1
$.
$,:-+:7$"(
", +1 .<$ -0 "!" $:+ ",".$("
0 +.
<+ + 6
$"+," -+ +1 " -+6 .$. $, +1 -+49
< .7+, ,+1.$ 99?@296+$"(,$
+ +":+ + ,$"( )A
?
.)+"
$"+,
$" -$.6$&&9 -+1 +8$0. 8+ (+ + ,$"(.<+ + ,+,0:
+,&&,+." <+&&96+:
0.+8$ &&!
)+ $)+ 6+ + $..0 ":+ " $:+ ,
+,
9 -+ 1&
.06)$
+,
11&$:
$",
+,
9D/ 9
-+)+ + < .,+ $8+-+
22 )+ + < .60 "
" @
-+ 11&$:
$"< .) 7+, - $ # $%+.-949<-.06)$
+,-$. +1 ,
+ $.
&&!60 "
",1
$:0& +" 8$.$6&+ -+
+ <
)1+ +,<$ - -+.7+ :-!1$:
0 +
$ .," +",-+ +-+.
7+"6! .6+ + -+".0)+ 0) ",$"
+ < 0",
)1+ +,<$ - -+"60 "
..0:- -+6$&&$"(<
+," 8+ (+6 .$. ","$".
&&
$" -+"+<)+ + 9 8+ (+
"+)"
-<
7+" -+"+<)+ + 9 -+" ::0"
8+ - 0&+," -+ -+ - ",9 .1 ,0:+,+8$,+":+
&$+ )+ + < .< 7$"( ", +: ,+, + ,$"( ",$ ."
6 .$.
-+ " $:+ ,+1.$ 99?@2 < . $..0+, -+ 1&+ ,$"(. -++8$,+":+<+ +:"
,$:
!" $:+< .($8+" 1&
( $"( -$) " 11 0"$ ! 6+ + $D$"( -+
:".0)1 $"" -+6 .$. -+.+ $",$"(.9 .,+: ++, :+,<$ - 68+:"
,$:
$".9&+ "+,:0".+&
.9 <-$&+ (0$"( -$. +(0& .+:", &9 8+ !
$ &! ",$,&!.06)$
+" (( $+8+, ..0:-6! ,+: ++$"( +:"
+",+,
-+$ "&!( $+8 ":+$.
&+ "+, :0 . 6+&< - 8+ ,$ +:
+, " $"8+.
$(
$" $"
-+ :
.+
-+ +
+ 9 ,$ +:
+,
$
+ .0:- $"8+.
$(
$" -+
:".0)1 $" +"+ (!$. 0",1 !
6&+6!
<0&, 6+60", 1 ! )+960 -+<0&,6+($8+" " $:+ ",11 0"$ !
22 6+$"(-+ ,*+ "+,:0".+&:"
+",+,
$"8$+< $,,$ +:
$"9
& + ,!,+1.$ +,6!
.-0&," - 8+6++" ,+ +,
6+ + 0",+,9 .$ <0&,+
-+0& $)
+ +:8+ ! $":+ -+ + $. " :- &&+"(+ -+ %0,()+"
", ,+: ++ ,+: ++$"( $"
80
68+.
$,:"
+"
$"
,+.+ 8+. 6+ +%+:
+,":+ $.,+: ++, "," -$"($. 0",,0+ ",
+
-+ +$."=0+.
$" . +
$"$"(
,+1.$ .1+ $"
+ $) ,+ -+".0)+ 0)-+ 1&
$..
$&& -+:".0)+ ",$ 0& $)
+&!9 "! -$"($.
0",,0+ -$)9 +" -+&1&+..
-+!:
""
+:8+ )+ 0 $"( -+:0 .+ -+ $"(9&+ "+,:0".+& :0&," 1$"
0 "!$&&+( &$ ! 1+ 8+ .$ !$" -+$)10("+,%0,()+"
..+, 6! -+&+ "+, $ .
+ :0 +:0&, " + + "!
=0+.
$" & <)0:-&+...06.
&=0+.
$" & <<-$:-$..$"+=0 ""
-$.:0 +D+ :$.+$
+1<+ 0",+ +:
$"
-+/ -+:(+"
$",$"(. +: ,+,6! -+&+ "+, $ .
:0 - 8+6++" 0",
&&!: +:
",&+( &&!%0.
$+,-0.9"
0&
"6+ 0",$" -+$)10("+,%0,()+"
",,+: ++1 ..+,6! $ .
+:0 )+,+.+ 8+. 6+01-+&, -+ (0)+"
$.+, ".$,+ $"( -+
. ", :$ :0).
":+. -+ :
.+ " +,
68+9:01&+,<$ - -+ + .".
+2)+"
$"+,9 -$.0 $.
2 2 :".$,+ +,8$+<
&$.6+ +
)+ $ ",<$ -0 "!
.06.
":+9 -0.$ )0.
$& +.0&
&!9 -+$".
+(0& +:",11+ &$.,$.)$..+,9 -<+8+ 9<$ -" ,+ :.
. !" # %& ",%