← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/686/2016allowed

V.K. Goswami v. Punjab Small Industries & Export Corporation Ltd

2019-12-13Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih4 pages

    

  

     

   

  

 !

"#$ %& '$()*)%+, !- -



 

  

   



           



      

  !"!#$%

& '()*(# +#,* *($+(- ./0)($!- 10 $*!(223+)(#$(22!33(#$"

 *("*+&4( 5(.(/- ./0)($!- 10 $*! !"20#.!#$

 

   !

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

(#+#, $*! '7$*($$*!"(+.(223+)($+0# :("2!#.+#, )0#"+.! ($+0#'!10 !$*! 0:!  22!33($!

!

$4(7'!(..!.*! !$*($$*! !237$0$*!(223+)($+0#:("(3"0 1+3!.  '7  $*!  !"20#.!#$"   *! !10 !-  +$  )(##0$  '!  "(+.  $*($  $*!  "(+. (223+)($+0#  :("  4! !37  1+3!.  '7  $*!  (223+)(#$  (#.  :("  2!#.+#, )0#"+.! ($+0# #$*!3+,*$01$*!('0/!1()$"(#.)+ )&4"$(#)!"01$*!)("! (#.9!!2+#,+#/+!:$*($+$+"(2& !3!,(3+""&!:*+)*)(#'! (+"!.($(#7 $+4!!"2!)+(337+# $*!3+,*$ 01$*!=&.,4!#$01$*! &2 !4!0& $ +# "#)+'$.

)+/0 "+'

"+%#0$.

)+%.

#0.%1/0 2%#0$. /" $0".

)+/0 "+'

%#0$.*3 >+/+3?@-$*!2 !"!#$(223+)($+0#.!"! /!"$0 '!(330:!. #  /+!:  01  $*!  ('0/!-  $*!  2 !"!#$  (223+)($+0#  +"  (330:!.

4!#.4!#$  $0  $*!  , 0&#."  01  (22!(3-  ("  2 (7!.  10  +#  $*!  2 !"!#$ (223+)($+0#-+"2! 4+$$!. 4!#.!., 0&#."01(22!(3(22!#.!.(30#,:+$* $*!(223+)($+0#( !$(9!#0# !)0 .

$+"$*!)0#$!#$+0#01$*!3!( #!.)0&#"!310 $*!(22!33(#$$*($ $*!(22!(3.!"! /!"$0'!(330:!.0#$*!"03!, 0&#.$*($(#(223+)($+0# &#.!  .! ;&3!<10 (..+$+0#(3!/+.!#)!:("2 !1! !.'7$*! (22!33(#$0#A(30#,:+$*$*!(22!(3 0$+)!  +#  $*!  "(+.  (223+)($+0#  :("  +""&!.  '7  $*!  0:!

22!33($!0& $-$0:*+)* !237*("'!!#1+3!.*!(223+)($+0#:("0 .! !. $0'!*!( .(30#,:+$*$*!4(+#(22!(30#<@; #@;?-$*! "(+.(223+)($+0#(30#,:+$*$*!(22!(3:("$ (#"1! !.$0"04!0$*! 0& $ *!0& $-:*+)*1+#(337.!)+.!.$*!(22!(3-.+.#0$2(""(#70 .! 0#$*! (223+)($+0#10 (..+$+0#(3!/+.!#)!*!"(+.("2!)$*("'!!#10&#.$0'! )0 !)$("2! $*! !)0 .

!!2+#,+#/+!:$*!&#.+"2$!.1()$"0# !)0 .("(3"0$*! =&.,4!#$01$*!0#B'3! &2 !4!0& $+# "#)+'$.

)+/0 "+'

"+%#0$.

)+%.

#0.%1/0 2%#0$. /" $0".

)+/0 "+'

%#0$.*3 > +/+3?@-:*! !+#+$*("'!!#*!3.$*($$*!=&.,4!#$2(""!.'7$*!0& $ )(##0$"&"$(+#(#.$*!)("!*("$0'! !4(#.!.'()9$0$*!)0#)! #!.0& $ 10 1 !"*.!)+"+0#!+$*! 10 .!)+.+#,$*!(223+)($+0#2 +0 $0$*!.!)+"+0#0# $*!(22!(3+$"!310 (30#,:+$*$*!(22!(3-$*!2 !"!#$(22!(3.!"! /!"$0'! (330:!.'7"!$$+#,("+.!$*!=&.,4!#$01$*!0:!  22!33($!0& $(#.$*!

4($$!  !4(#.!.'()9$0$*!3!( #!. ..3+"$ +)$ &.,!-*(#.+,( *10 1 !"*.!)+"+0# #/+!:01$*!('0/!-$*!2 !"!#$(22!(3+"(330:!. *! +42&,#!.=&.,4!#$(#..!) !!2(""!.'7$*!0:!  22!33($!0& $.($!.

@A?+"-*! !'7-"!$("+.!*!(22!(3+" !4(#.!.'()9$0$*! ..3 +"$ +)$  &.,!-  *(#.+,( *  10  1 !"*  .!)+"+0#  +#  ())0 .(#)!  :+$*  3(: 2 !1! ('37:+$*+#C40#$*" ( $+!"( !.+ !)$!.$0(22!( '!10 !$*! ..3+"$ +)$ &.,!- *(#.+,( *0# #/+!:010 .! 2(""!.+#$*!4(+#)("!-#00 .! "( ! !D&+ !. $0'!2(""!.+#$*! !4(+#+#,2!#.+#,(223+)($+0#"

$($25$.

!3



      

*!$*! "2!(9+#, !("0#!.% 5!"0

*!$*! !20 $('3!

% 5!"0