← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5473/2015dismissed

Sujan Singh Thr Lr Bimla And ORS. v. Rajbir Singh

2018-12-17Mr. Justice Sudip Ahluwalia7 pages

      

   

  !"

#$   %&

'((& #%&) 

 , # $   %&

*

  !" "#" - 

 - .

/

(! (0    1 +! (0  &*

    

  4& **+( (% & (5#(% (  (( *(6&)(  5#(%!- *!0('&&& **++(6&-+

'++ '(  %(& $#(% (( ((8  )(  4&4 +1 # &(' ((* +  0 !

'& &( #%& *- 

 &1

  +++%(+6 9#( &0 # 6& +

  & # / #

#++6( ( !* 

; %  0 6 #*

+1& %&  7<* 

&+

%'&   & #*

  (  * 6    *    $# 

      &  +  

+  ( % %&(& # 6

4&



  + +(#*

6&-+

((  '+( 0( 

&(=9 -* 

  & (  4&4 +1 # ' ((&(    0 6 &+ * 

+6# #(&* 6   *- 

 ' &0'&& ( +  % # %  (( ' 

  +  0'  (

 &  1 #     &  !$%&'()'*+*,)-.',)$&+%+*,)! /0/+1+20

!0

& #%&&% #  &( + & 

( &

+-+ ' # ++6 (  # 

*+

&  + >

 6

* 

6'6 #*

+1& %'

' ((! &4 +1 #  (&' 

( +

+&* 

&*   ?#

&(+ (6  (+0 ( !0 & #%&'&0 & &0 %  9#(  &      +   (  6

+++6  (+0  % 

 !& &( ?#(&  * 



 # ( % &(& # '

&

++& #+( #    6  &  #+  

(

!   (    &  *# *   &( ++%(+6% ( *6#*

+1& %&  7<*

&!'&&'& '0 !



( &#+ + =9 - 4&5#(% (  &)( # ' &++ %(6 &  -+     &  1 #     )(    5#(%!  - *!  '&  0(  & ($#(% ((  0 (& % &4 +1 '&&  &(  &+(  &  +        # +!   %  

 % ((  & & (! +6

#?# 0

2 &(

&1 #  !'34+.)'*'*5'*6)7%1.+87*57% '**'2+'.-+87*57%'**'*56)7%.!  / 0"'67.6$5+(+'279%6.

: (  & $#(% !&)( ) '  **++1 # &(&+( & # % (   ++&

 #+(

+6(* 0 & +( 

6 

 (6 

 &4    - * 6

+

!# #+( +(#*

  #  *- 



?# +6!  &  **++  1 #  

((  &  +  %  (    & -+ 7*  *

( (( (&)%+*  0

& 7*

  9# ( % & +(

0 7 4& ++ * 

0 6 0 & 

+'



'* #+ &4 +1 # @  (%  & '& ++6!

& +   7   #$   %&    (( (( 

**  & # *  0 #

 /'& !  ((% 9* 

    #?# +6!

  & +( **+

; % (&9*  ( *(%  & '&&! &  &&('++ '(!#$ *6   7<

   (&'( ( +&A 

 )** # 6! & # 6  + %& &(+ (6+*( ++&

4&  

9(  &  ( '&&' 

(

* ( !' 

*(



'&&!& %&  7  +&A    '  #; 6&)( #  (&  * ( 8 "

 0(  !# &($ (('(+ (& +(6!

 &' ( ( ($ (%   "

 &(!

# ' 

&*+ @(' *  # '&

'

'  9 (  &  0 6(6'&+ <9 

 &   %  '

'   '  ( ( 

 &  ?#     +    &  7  & +   "

 4&  &  ' % ($ ( & *# *    :

'&&(!

* ' ;

&+  7 '& '&  !%

((% 9*  (&  * (   : 9*  

( 

/ '0    !& +( **+

  (  &  9*   (  ((    :   (  &  * 0 #  (  ((   0('&&&( &(  #;     0



& #*

! *+6% &**+

' +(

  : (&  &  '($ ( 6

0 

++& %# ' #++6& (

**+

"

 (0(*  ( *(#?# +6

&(6!' ( (  4&   (  (  ((  "

  '  0  +( 

&++ %(6& 7  6%0 & #%&& #  (* % &4 +1 # 

6 ++' ++6 ( (9*  * 

8  B+

'

&6&

*

 !&( 0   ( *6& # %  0

 ( (&A    !'&& & ' %&&0 *( 6&4 +1 #  6 #*  1 #  &   $#

 4&  #+&  !&& (( *(%  &  +   7  

'  *  (  & #%&  &  )%+ *  0  '  0 #++6   

  ((      '&&  #++6 

( '*#

6 ( 0+  ** *   (6

 %(& (  ; #&(  & # B% '& # 6 %&  !&&0( +(

&+ *

7-+ 

& '&&!& #'( (!+ %& # #( C & 

!&1 # +  #+&** & &4 +1 #  '++) '  **++1 #  #+ +6(( %&#+  9

0

& 0 #++6# &++ %( ( #(0( !'&&'



 ((

&( (0

6'6  6*+( % &4 +1  B& 0 &+ # (6&)( 1 + &

* #+(; 6&+  0+ 6** *   (6  '&0' &0& (  ; #& (   (!

      * +

%(  ++    (   +    % 6   &

+ ( &( &)%+*  0!'&   &*   D # +6!

*  #  ' ((

#& 

&*  & + &# 

#& % (&

+6+%'& +( % &

'*(

96 %

8 ! (&**+*  ( % #&( +'+

E6 %

  # 6&& +  % 6 ++ 6 +% 



( (# % ( 5#(+- ( %

(#( 0 

8 +

%(*  (   &+

 # 6  &4 +1 (& 6 &  &  **++% (+ ((!& )( # ' +%( ((&  

 

&

 + (0( '&&#++6  0 & #%&&( %  (

#   ( (#+%  &( ( *

& *  (* +

%(+ (6

( + "

B'# & # (6&)(  + &&

 +'#++6   

+6 # 6  *6

 

 6+ '&&&(  # (6& + !

(&&(*#(* * 6 ?#

  #&%  0+#&

&

+0+# +'&&'& '

&

( 

*  & ( &   *

! 6 

( &

 % F  ;

#&# 

&&%&+6+( % %#+  

( **+'&  

0  *+( %

&    '  0  *+( 

  (     &  )(  4 +  1

0 &+!  )(   +    &  *

  &    (  0  & # 

6( ' % 

&1 #  &( 9&(

&  4 +  1  4&   (  +      0 -+



 %&(& #=9 -((  (0+# & &( (+6 

(&   + 2#& +(6'&&& + &(& +?# (& 4+ & * * 6

  ::+

&  ( &4 + # =9 -! (* #+ & & '&& &( *# &(& * * 6 

( 

*  !7<

+6!

 '&&&  +6% ( ++



6  + 

  &

( 

* & +*(6&

&# 

&& (  +'#++6  

+6(  #  % *6  ++%(+ !'&&

6&

 *+(( &)( # 

%0

6 (  + +6!

& # 

  ( &1 # 6&)(  +

&+  (#  %&  % &&&6  '++ %    # (  &   (  

       +    & *

7-+ &%+

'

&6  6

( 

(#+%  &%0  ( #    # #*&  !&1 #  (

  &*  **+!

'&& %+6( ( / "#"0     !"

 A&& *; %7 

(G >7

 A&&  * +G  >7