← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/7/2016allowed

Mohan Singh v. Gurdeep Singh Th Lrs Jagir Kaur And ORS

2020-01-14Mr. Justice Rajbir Sehrawat19 pages



     



    !"#  $  #%&'&(# &)*+,+%-+*"#./(#0 - 11+22%&"

- 3+.-/- /.*++1'&(# &)*+,+%-+*"#./(#0 - "#+.-  +-1&*+&"-      40

    5   

   

       



   

       

  !!    " # $



     " % 

  5$ .%2 # & ! '(  

  !   !   )!

     '(     * (!  ! '(           !     '(     *     ((+(    ( , -      (     '!        

       (  ' ! .  ! '    ! (  '      #  /!  

  '!      '+ (    

  /  '! '( !   ! 

  1 (          

        '(   

  ## ,22$  !    #45!   !    #2 ## ,223 6 !   !   !327%   6!!  '   00%2222849:  ( / ( (;

   #222222849: (;  '(      (   &    '(  " #, !('    !  !     7 !'   

( & !   /    / '  '  0# ,22$   . 02 ,22$   

 +      /          !  '      !  <     /  / !          

  !(  0# ,22$   

 !                '    

  '4 :!   = 22  3

>       ! (  

!  7  

  '4:! * 7 !  !  /  <  '!  /  !          

         '(   

  &    '

       (  #(     <'+ ( ,  44      " #   (     '(       ?! (             " #   '       2$ ,22=       " #   !(     !   '(   

  !     '+ (      '         7!   

  !'( !   

  !  &  " #,           !       <                    " #45 !    !      '     *  

( <  (    

*        ! !      

  !  !     # '7 < !  +   ' '  '(   

                        022222284  <  '(        !     (     00%222284*  ( &!    " #'    +  !    !      

 

&    (     

  <      (

 !        

 , ! '(  ! '        '! ('(  #      !    +   (  (   #!    ( $

 !  !       

  '(     !   +  /    (    !      +    &        & 

  >40 1  /   !   !  )  !  >4#    ! 7 7!     17>4,*           '  <7 !" ('*/  >43       !   *  !          !     " ( '*  

7     '                  !    .   #?>4# ?   " ,   ?>4, 

   !     #?>40 1 7) /   ?>43          (   &    / '(    %

!  '(         !     ' ( /    &  '      !  !(   '(  

     

    /       ' !  '    @ -!!!!  )!

     '    <    )!

  ,A 2= ,2#$  (     '( !   

     (       ( &  /  

   

 '(   &

    '(   '                   ! !      ! !     '  &!   ' (!   (     '(    -!      '(      !! !       ( #  ,    -       (      

+     /     (   ! !   +  (       '7'    & !   !  '    !          !     (     ' '    '(        !   ! ,  4 #@7#%       !

 !           (  '   &/ !  !      /   &        !         !               /   (   ! /            

'(        !    !    

  <   

   !  !  / '(! ! (   !   ( !!!   )!

        ' '(  

 > !!         8 

'

    !  + ' ( & 

(     

  '4:!     /  *!   B/' 4$4%+ '             '

  '(      8 

  !   ( !  B/' 4#   '!    &    (  '(            (    

      ( '7    7! (       /   !        ' /    (

 '             

  

         '(       " #    '(        " ,   &  

   ' ! (    '(       " ,       '(    1 ' !    

'    '(   ,     2# 2% ,22%  #$ 2= ,22@    7! (     >   '(   ,       '(   

  ( ! '       &        '(    5 ! #23 2= ,22A     !  

 

 ( !(   '   # <  

'         !      '(  !   < '

    (          ' 7!      

     '(  

   ('  /   !    (  !  <   !! !   (    !   '( '!           '      '

 '(          ( 7!    ( !  !     *     ! ' '7  ''(    (     &  #!?>4#     !  '     !  B/' 4#

     B/'  4, '( (!    !C  !   '  <        #44   " , '   ! !    "  (       !  '    B/' 438        !     " ( '   &      '  ! ' '7 *  !  (!'('     (  '  " (' !  !   

 

&             !    (   ! '      <  '

  '(         !        '!   (    '  &'             (   ?>4,*        !   B/'  4# 4,     B/'  438 *  !    /   !  '(  7!    " #45! " (   #45 !  ! !  B/' 4# B/'  4,   B/' 438

<      , !     !      /      " ,  ! (   !   '( # <        ( ?>4#5!      (7            '

   " ('

 ''(  

                                      !!    !    '

 '(             ( '(        ! '        (  (!  7   <  '   /      !    !  !      (   

     !   + (/     

> !  )!

          !"#

$%&'

()#**     '

       '  '(      '      + !  '! (!   (    & !         (     (       <             !    '   ( !   '     (! )!

     + & !)  !"    (,#

-  . .  (#/ *    '(         !  !    '(            (            '

    !  ! ' /                 +    ! +   (   !     ''( 

        (  <(!  +    !  !  + !      (   !(    '

       '(   

 '    )!

     '(    ' '  *  !          

 /      !  +  = :(!   !         " #  ,     ! ! '(     '

    !  B/' 4# '!       ( #   & ,     

      ! ''!   ,        '

         /             !  '     !   ( &           (!  !    

    !  + '!'(    '    '

 '(        !( !     (       !      '      8              !  < '

           !   '                   !  !           '

  '(         +  '' '(!  &   !    

     

      (   '     &     '(  " ( '      (   (     '  + !   '   '((" ('     '

 '(         ' ' '! / !  '   !    &   ' '(      ' $@22222849:  ((;             00%222284(  #2 &  8 " %!      (! (   '     !   !  (        '  '(           !    !    " %     !    '(         '         ( 7!  (   '      ! ( ! '(  !    '(          <    '

      

         '+              )'   (      +      (  +    (!  +      /    ''(  < '

    !       &   !      ! '  / '     '         '

  '(     %    +   '  

 /       

! !    (    !                 

       <   

  !   !             (      '  ') 

   + ! &   )!

      <!          .!)!      +

0 #

1* ,'.

  ,! 2  ,!#

  ,%3

  &    

    )!

       4  5

    !"!

!" !) .0 !#

/1$6.$$ ## <!    !        '    !         9;8 

     !    +   ' (  '     &   !    ' /    "  (    " ('''(  

 !  !                  /   !  +   7        (!    !  " ('  !    '(" (' ( ' (!+     (  !              " (         /   !   

&!    " (''(B/' 4 ' !  '     < 

 '     !    !'         ' (  '      B        (      !    '     !   B/' 4#  (     ( B/'  4,      !     " ( 'B/' 438

& '!C'( ?>40  # &!  '!  '(      !  ?>4,  ?>40

 !  ,   !        " #45 !        !  B/' 4#* !     B/' 4 ,     !     " ( '    !        #  ( /     '(  !   !   '       '7    !  ?>40     " 0  !C  !    !          B/' 4, &!  '      B/'  4, 7    4         

  &   ' !         B/' 4, !  (     (       '

/  &        ! '  '7      (    #,

 !              '! !  !   

           " ,              '  !      9;    (!      '   !      ' '(  !  &  #(    '      &    (   (!'! " ,    ,    #!'  .       ' (    !         " #   *           (   <   '  !           '(         !    ' '        !           &

        ' ' '   (    !    

    '     44 44 ' '!) (       <       !    ' ' !!  #( <    ! !  !      !        " ,  (   !   !   # &    (!       !  '     !   !  ,     

 #0

 !          '

     !     (   '              !  !   !( ' &  +            !     '  (      !   '  

        *       !  ( ( &  ! (' '('     !   '(   !  <  ! (  !        #3

 !       !      !     '         (     !   '! /  (4    ('   !        - (     +(        !  '  !     7  !   4/ ' <      *        

          !         /    '              !  '         !         '  '(      

 B/' 4,#4,,* /  ,A ,22$## ,22$ (      ' /  (            !  " ( !  B/' 4,#  

 " #45 !  (

  ! ?>4,        !     &                 !          

      !     !     '

    /  +  '(   $@2222284 < !    ( - ( !      (  ! !                  ' '  (    /    (!  " (     '(  '!    (        (  /       ( &           

! '     / (    (  (' +(  '(( !    !     #$ &         !      ! (   /      

/       <  #!  '         

         7!   (        17  &       # (! (

 (     /   !!    " (         ! (         (   !  ! <  !  !(    *  /      !    #%

 !      !    !     '      ( 7    

     ('(/ ! (   !  '           /     !!        7! (    

              .        !!     (        '  !     !     (    '( !!    !   '  '(   

  '7     (           !    -!           (  /     !                     '               '( / !    ! /  '(  !  !    1   !           "  (   ' (     !         ( '     

      !  !      '( 

< !   '    

    '       '(      !!      '   #@

 !   ( % '

     +     '       !             ('  !       % &)!

  '(      " %   (         !        ( !'                  *      (  /      

         +     +    &         +   !  (  '    B'   <!      ' !  !         (  . ',2#=   B      ( (   ! (!+          !  (   '  '(          (  (   +   (   !     / !   ' ''(     &    ( !                         (     <               &  

   ! (     > '    !       

      &  

  (    +  ' 7

    ! !     !   '  '')    +   (            ! !     (    '(      (   ! !  *!        '(       

<  (   +    ( !              

     +!       !              +   #A   '         !(  !'(          )!

        

!(  !     & )!

 '(      #= &!(*    !"#  $ 

  5