High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/734/2016dismissed

Raj Kaur v. Kishan Kaur And ORS

2019-01-31Mr. Justice Amit Rawal7 pages

"#$$%&'&()"(*"+, - .

/# "01"*+ '&(%$2$%$"'$2!#3+*435 '

66$77"(# 8$+'*'

1&'3"(1"*+ '&(%$2$%$"'$2!#3+*435 '#3$+'

$'6(2$(#'

! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&

+$'$(#) +*(&73"23"-$(&+29%"#$:&#3 +&/"('3*"&(-29%"#$- +#3$"66$77"(# +8&;"'"37-$(&+29%"#$:&#3 ' +&,"(;"1"('"7-29%"#$ '8$2&;""(23&-29%"#$- +%"9$"#+<+$'6(2$(# ===== +*,&-( ..<

+ #3$ +$"'(' /$(#&($2 &( #3$ "667&%"#&(- :3&%3 &' '*66+#$2>,"("&2"9&#-2$7", ?2",'&(+$<&7&(4#3$"66$"7&'

%(2($2 '#"(2'2&'6'$2

66$77"(#<67"&(#&&'&( $4*7"+$%(266$"7"4"&('##3$ %(%*++$(#&(2&(4'"%#-:3$+$>,#3$'*&#+'6$%&&%6$++/"(%$#3$ "4+$$/$(##'$772"#$2 ..3"'>$$(2&'/&''$2>,#3$#+&"7*+# "(2"&+/$2&("66$"7

7"&(#&->,&7&(4#3$'*&#(

..-'*43##3$'6$%&&%

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

"+2","7&(43+$%$&9$2"(#3$+"/*(# --A<-&( ##"7 --A<&(%$ :"' 37&2",-"+2","7 &(43 :"'

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

&(43"(2#3&'"%#-&(#3$/(#36+&7- ..-:"'+$9$"7$2+/#3$ +$%$&6##3$7$##$+>,"+2","7&(43-+/#3$(%/$"D$6"+#/$(#- +$4"+2&(4#3$$(#+, --A<2$6'&#$2(>$3"7(&71*/"+ :&(4##3$2$(&"7#3$$D$%*#&(#3$"4+$$/$(##'$77-#3$+$"2&($'' "(2:&77&(4($''#3$67"&(#&:"'"7'$/63"#&%"77,2&'6*#$2#:"'"7' $D67"&($2#3"#"+2","7&(43:"'"22&%#$2#"7%37"(22&$22*$#7&9$+ %&++3'&' &(%$#3$6"+#&$':$+$"#9"+&"(%$-#3$#+&"7*+#+"/$2#3$ 77:&(4&''*$')< E

! '

)

7"&(#&&('*66+##3$$9&2$(%$$D"/&($2&#$$(:&#($''$' "(2 #$(2$+$2 &(# $9&2$(%$ "4+$$/$(# D

- %6, >"(; "%%*(# '#"#$/$(#D -63#%6&$'#3$%3$C*$'D #D

-"&2"9&# 2"#$2 ... D

- "667&%"#&(' 2"#$2 . D

"(2

-"&2"9&#2"#$2. D

?-"667&%"#&('2"#$2

"(2 D

- "&2"9&# D

@- 0"/">"(2&$' D # D - 63#'#"#%6,>"(;2+"#"(2%3$C*$'D

-2%*/$(#'"(2:+&#&(4 "(2 &(4$+ +&(#' D6$+# D A # D A- %6, >"(;

2%*/$(#D

?"(20"/">"(2&D

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

$"2&($''"(2:&77&(4($''3"'>$$(6+9$2#3+*43#3$#$'#&/(, F<

. 7$+;*> $4&'#+"+"(23&'6+$'$(%$:"'/"+;$29&2$D

"(2 D

3$+$/'#&77$4"7&#,%//&##$2>,#3$%*+#'>$7::"'#3"# "+2","7 &(43 :"' "22&%#$2 # "7%37- :3&%3 3"2 >$$( 6+9$2 >, +'3;3"##F<->*#"&7$2#(#&%$#3"#"+2","7&(43&(%"'$:"' *(">7$#22",<#<2",*(%#&('6+6$+7,-3$%*72(#3"9$>$$(2&(4 #3$#&/>$+>*'&($'' ",/$(#?--A<:"'&(7&$*#3$'*&#6+6$+#, "(2(#:&#3+$4"+2##3$'"7$#3$#&/>$+#+$$'('*66+##3$ "+$/$(#&($2 '*>/&''&('- +$7&"(%$ 3"' >$$( 7"&2 # #3$ 0*24/$(#' +$(2$+$2 >, #3&' *+# &( /01 2 1 344 1 2 1

51-66 7&6

5 2 13448925 2 1-.

6 !!2:2 ;. 3"9$3$"+2#3$7$"+($2%*('$7+#3$"66$77"(#-"66+"&'$2#3$ 6"6$+ >; "(2 #3$ 9&$: #3"# #3$+$ &' ( +%$ "(2 /$+&# &( #3$ '*>/&''&(' +3"23" 3$>+$";*6--A<3"2>$$("'*(2$+)< -A<%"'3( @. ..I ?-A<$"%3-##"7 .-A<(@ .. D "(2 D @!

--A<-&$-?-A<$"%3( ..9&2$D

--A<( ..J $D67"("#&(3"'%/$+#3&((#%7"&/&(4#3$+$7&$ '6$%&&% 6$++/"(%$ "#$+ 2$'6"#%3 7$4"7 (#&%$ 2"#$2 $+$&7&(4 #3$6+$'$(#'*&#-(. ..-67"&(#&9&2$DFA '*43# #3$ &(0*(%#&( "4"&('# #3$ 2$$(2"(# :3&%3 :"' :&#32+":( ( DFA!(#3$+'*&#DFA:"'&7$2( 3$'"/$:"'2&'/&''$2&(2$"*7#( @ DFA ! 7$"2&(4'

"+$:"(#&(4C*"2&'%7'*+$#3$"+$/$(#&($2#:'*&#'#$+#3$$D6&+, #3$ #"+4$# 2"#$- 67"&(#& &('#&#*#$2 "(#3$+ '*&# + &(0*(%#&( ( . DFA! :3&%3 :"' "7' 2&'/&''$2 &( 2$"*7# (

? ..- :3$+$"' #3$ 6+$'$(# '*&# :"'- "' (#&%$2 ">9$- &7$2 (

.. $"2&($''"(2:&77&(4($''-"'6$+#3$'$##7$27":-3"'#>$ +/#3$2"#$#3$"4+$$/$(#-#&77&#''*>'&'#$(%$-&7&(4#3$'*&#"(2 2*+&(4&#'6$(2$(%,-/*%37$''6"''&(4#3$2$%+$$6$+'(-:32$' (#%/$##3$%*+#:&#3%7$"(3"(2'-%"((#>$4+"(#$22&'%+$#&(*(2$+ $%#&( #3$ 6$%&&% $7&$ %# + "(, "7#$+("#&9$ +$7&$ $D67"("#&(3"'%/$+#3"'#:3,&7&(4#3$6+$9&*''*&#:"'(# 2&'%7'$2 (%$#3$+$:"'"7+$"2,">+$"%3-"6$+'(%7"&/&(4'&/67&%&#$+ &(0*(%#&( &( #3$ ">'$(%$ '6$%&&% 6$++/"(%$ 2$$/$2 # 3"9$ ">"(2($2'6$%&&%+$7&$"'6$+#3$6+9&'&(' +2$+ *7$ 3$ "+$/$(#&($26+6'&#&(7":3"'>$$(7"&2>,(K>7$#3$*6+$/$ *+#&( <432 +

4524'

7&5 344 <43 55

7&5 - !!2:2 = !!. # &' /'# &(#+&4*&(4 #3"# :3$( "0 1"*+ 67"&(#& :"'

'*//($2"'F<-'3$$&4($2&4(+"(%$">*##3$"4+$$/$(##'$77+ #3$2$#"&7'#3$6+6$+#,77#3$'$"%#+'7$"2#"(&++$'&'#&>7$%(%7*'&( #3"##3$67"&(#&/&'$+">7,"&7$2#6+9$#3$$D$%*#&(#3$"4+$$/$(## '$77-/*%37$''#3$&(#$(#&("(2&('*%3%&+%*/'#"(%$'-#3$2&'%+$#&("+, +$7&$+#3$"7#$+("#&9$+$7&$%*72(#3"9$>$$(+$/#$7,4+"(#$2

+#3$+$"'('/$(#&($2">9$-2(#&(2"(,&77$4"7&#,+ 6$+9$+'&#, &( #3$ %(%*++$(# &(2&(4' "%#- :3&%3 "+$ >"'$2 ( "66+$%&"#&(+"7"(22%*/$(#"+,$9&2$(%$4+*(2+&(#$+$+$(%$

&'/"2$*#-/*%37$''&(979$/$(#"(,'*>'#"(#&"7C*$'#&(7":

$'*7#"(#7,-#3$"66$"7&'2&'/&''$2 ( >-6 +*,&

841 ()/?'

,1514@2 <4

A4<

,151 50"

A4<