High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/74/2016dismissed

Ramesh Chander Batra v. Tarloki Nath Lama & ANR

2017-01-20Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul9 pages

#$%&% '

(

))** + $$ , * - (%.

$) ($

/ $( . 0-$%1)( "0 (

(% ,% % * (% ) $( 2* $ )) $((%32#( ( 4) $$5! * ( *$( ( 2"

6% 5!%$ )) * $( (% 32#( (

7 ) $$ 5! * &0* 2 0$ "

"6 $$#$$ ' *!$( (" $) (

, * - (%.

* $( *

( ") # (3( # ( !3( (% $( ) ) (! $ ( * (% )* ( $ ) (% )* (" (% $) (

$) ( " #*!" 9# .

*5 (% $ ,%$() ) (!% $ #( (%#

#(%

(% $% .

"( 6% #(%) ) (!6 $ * 2 (

5! 2 ((" (% 2

(% )*

2 ((% *$ 2 ((%) ) (! 4"'-

( 5 (%%$2 $ $

0 2$( :** ( ,%$" (% )*

6 (% 6 $ (% ) ) ($ ( (% (# (% (%

(% $% .

,% )*

% 0 * ! ) (( 5 (% (% ) ) ($$% # (% ((% ( ( % $5 #;*$0 6 (% ) ) (! 4" '-

" 6% $" % $ ( $% )# $ 2< < * 26(% )( #) **#($ 7" = 1 ("'-

$( (% 5* $( 5*2 7 ** ( (% $% $) (

(%) (( (%) ) ($"(%)*

) $$$$ (% $)(0) ( $ $) (%) (( 0 6 (( 2 #(6 $;((%$ $)(5(6(%# ,% 6 (( * ((%) ) (! 4 (% (" ( *($6 8 ( 5) # ,% " $ 0 *2 * ( ( ) (%)*

) ( (% )! (% 2 #( ( ,%

( (% )*

#(( (% (($ (% 2 #( 0( *(%( #$ 2 #(%$ 6% 6% 5!% #(( (% ( (% ) (( % * ! 5

( 5(6 (% )*

,% )*

0 ;% 2 (%

0($6(% % (% ( (%$

( ( ( $6 *$ #

(% 2 #( (

,% $ ( $) $$$$ (%$% )"$% 62 * (%$()* )( (%

*0* ,% 0 $ $ * * #2(% (% 2 (($ ( # = 60 "6%(% $ 0(% () (%)*

"($ *! ((% ((#"( $ 0 *(% ((% % * !$ *%$$% ) ) (! 7$% )# $ 2< <; <)( #) **#($ = 60 "(%

($$)( ! *)* ! (%) '( (%

( " (% # *$% (% ) (% ) ) (! %$ ) $$$$ $( ( $( (2 (% $ # * 2 6(% (% 3 2 ) ) (! (% $( $ = *$ # 0(%( 026 **5(6 (% $( $$% ) (%$% )$% 62 * (%$()* ,%( 026 **# $ 27> ) ($>";*$0*!5* 2$ ( (% )*

'( (% % ( $)

( )** $%(( $ $( ( # *$%2 (% $( ( (% $% ) (% 5*2 (% $( $$% # (% ((%6 **$

% 0* ) -$ 2*! 2(%$ ) ) (!

:%(% $) (

53( $(# *(

(% $( ( " $*(2 ( (% 2 %$ ) ) (!" (%

% $% 6 )% ( )! (% $ * ( 7

* #(% (%% $) % $# (% (% ( $% ) ,%)*

6 $$% -( (% (($ (%$ *6%% (% % **2*! ;(

5! %$$% ,%$ $ *$ ) ( **$ 5(6(% ($ ,% $ #)*(*!) * # -2 !$ * (%) ) (! # (% %$ 6 $%)6%%$( (% ;(( < ,%$ *6%%$5! (%$ #$ $$ ** 0 ,% % $(% (( # *$%(%) ) (!

( $(%*(* $( $ * 5! 3 2(%) ) (! $2*(6%%6 * $*(( ;$$0* (% 3 26 ** (%)*

$% ** $*(( 22 # *$%2(%) ) (! (% )*

,% % $ (% $( ( #)*((%$ # 2(%)! (%$( ,% ($6

$-# !(#$( #((%* # )*

(( ) $% 6%%*( *2 (%) $($( ( (%$(% 025$$"(% $) (

9# .

% * 6 (( $( (#( ( -2 ) *# ! 53( $ (% ( $( (% )*

* -$ # ( 5*(! * $$( # ($"( $ * ( 5(6(%)*

$ ($)( ,% % *$ * %$ 6 (( $( (#(( -2) *# ! 53( $(% ((%)*

$$( ))5!%$ 6 ( ( (% "(%$(6 $( #( 5 **$05(6(%

"6% (% 6$ *5 (% $ ,%$($ ( ) ) *!0 * (% $5

) % $ 0 5* $ ( ,%$ *$# 5!

0$ * (7

"6%%$) (( (%*

,% )*

* )* ( ( (% 6 (( $( (#( 6% (% 0 #($# 5! 6

(% 0 $ )* ( 6 $ ( ( (% 5 $$ )* 2$ (% ) ($" ** 62$$$6 #* (5!(%( *& ( :%(% )*

$ ((* ( (% * *

( (% (%$;*$0 6 ) $$$$

# 3 ) ( $() ) (! 7 = ("'-

?// :%(% )*

$ ((* ( (% *

( (% (%$ * (7

$** 0 ?// :%(% )*

$ ((* ( (% * ) # (3( $( 2(%

# $2 ! $( ( # *$%2 ! ) ( (%$() ) (! $$% 6(%$()* ? //

:%(% )*

$ ((* ( (% * ) # ( 3( $( 2 (%

# * (2 (2 ! % 2 (% $( ) ) (! (% 5 $$ (% $ * ( 7

?// :%(% (% )*

$ ((* ( (% # ( ! 3( $) ! ?// :%(% $(

$6(%(#?//

:%(% $($ () ) *!0 * (%) ) $

& ( 3 $( ?/ @ :%(% $ 5

) % $ 5* $ ( 6(% ( ( (% **2 2%($

(%$() ) (!?/ * . ( *& (032#( (

7 % $ (% $( $) (

( (%

( (% ( (%

$* ( 5;*$0 6 ) $$$$ (%# 3 ) (

7" = 1 ("'-

A(6 *$ * (% (% $ * ( 7

**2*! ;( 5! $) (

$**2 * ( !;((5! < B (% "(% $) # (*! $( # $2 ! $( ( (% $( ( 6%%# ! $*( 22 # *$%2 ! $( (

* ( !3( 6 *$ 2 ( # 0 (% $( ( $ 5!(% **2 **! * **!6%%% $ $ 2 ( (% 5*2 $) (

# 0 (% *5 (% 22 0 $( (%

$ 32#( " (%

* )) *5 (%* 6 (& ( '( (% $ # 6 *$ $#$$ 5! * ( * $( ( 2"

032#( ( 4 A( $ (%

$ #$( $" (% % * (% ) $( 2* $ )) = % #* ( (%

** 62$5$( ( *8$( $ * 6 :%(% 5 (% (% * & ($ 5* 6 2%(*!

)) ((%0 (% ? :%(% (%$($5 5!(%*#( ( ? :%(% (% (52(%5

) % $ $((*( ) ((%$ 2%(? . $* (% % 2 (% ((% 6 $0 ) (( 5(6(% $) (

(% 6(% 2 ( ) ) (! 4 7

A($6 2(% ((% **2) (( "(% $) ( ( *! $% )# $ 2< < (%) ) (!5 2

7$( ((% = 1 ("

,% **2 2 #( $ (%2 5( ) (( ,% 2 #( 2%( ( % 0 5 ;( $( #) ) ) :(% ( 2$( ( " $% #( (% ($ ;(2$%$ ! 2%( (%) ) (!

,% 6 ( ( (% $) ( 6 $ ) $$$$ (%$% ) $$% 62 * (%$()* )( (% *0* ,% $) ( (% ) (! 6 % * $ ((%$% ) $$% 62 * (%$()* (( %6(% (%6 (($( (#( (%5 $$ ( ( (

@ ,% $ 6 % *( ( (% $% ) # $ 2 <<;< << ;*2(% 6(% (% 6 **$ ' $ *" (% % *$ %#$* 2 ((%)* ) ) (%) ) (!( 5 $ * %$$2 ( $ A($ *!

( ) % $2(% 3 2) ) (! $( $"(% # 0(%( 026 ** 5(6(6 ) ) ($(%!

A% 0% * $* (%

) $(%#)232#($) $$5!(%& ($5* 6 ,% 2$ 5! (% & ($ 5* 6 6%% ( ( (6

!( ,% $) (

% $5 5*( ) 0(% (%$;*$0 6 ) $$$$ (%# 3 ) ( 7" = 1 ("'-

6%% $$% 6 * (%$()* **!( * $ 5(%

% ( ( ,%$ *;(5!

(% 6 $%*( 50 ( * ( !;((5! < <<; + (

) $$5!* &0* 2 0$ "

" / # '% 6 3 6 )) ( $ . & ##$$ 6(% ( ( $)((%#$5*2 ( ) ( 6(% 2 ( (% * $% $( ( =6 *$ (( ) ( 2 2(% (

( *) $( $6** $(% ( $( (

(% 2 $( (%6 **$ / $ (*!"%% $$5#(( ) ( (% ((% 0 (%$)

(*!) % $) ( $* (% $( $ ** (% $) (

" 6%% $ $)

(*! ;*$0*! 6 5! (% $) (

,% 6 ** (% $ ) ( $ $)

(*! $( (5! ,%(* $% 6(%6 **

(% $) (

$ 6 " $ ( ( (% 6 ** $) (

* ( $( 2 ,% $)( (% $22$($ (% ((% (% $( * (%* $ * $ *$ )( (% **$ $) (

6%% $ -$ (%$6 ** $) (

6%% * )) (*! 5 $ (% )% ( 2 )%$ A( % *$ 5 ) ( (% ( (% 6 -$ ** 0 (% ** (% )*

5 $ (% 0 * 2 (% # * 5 2 ** ,% $) (

% $ ) 0 (% ( % $ ;*$0 6 ) $$$$ (% # 3 ) ( 7" = 1 (" '-

$( *(%% ( ( ,% "

(%$ *;(5!

;( 7

$* 5*( 5* $** 0 $ (;((%$ *5! %$ 6 $%) 5! < A (% $ % " (% $) (

$ (

8 2 !( $((%$ ) ) (!5!6 ! !( $ ( 6%% % $ ( - )* $5$8( $( 2 (% " % $ *! % **22 (% #)( (%0 $) ( $ ( $ 5(( ((*(% %#$* ) $$$$$ (% $) (

() $$$$ 5(( ((*"% () $$(%$ # 2*!"(%$& ( $(% ( $5$( ( *8$( * 6

$$ (% ) $( 2* $ )) ,% $ **2 *(! ) 0 $(! (% #)2 32#($ $ ) $$ 5! (% & ($ 5* 6 (% $ # )%* ,% ) $( )) * $" $8(*!" $#$$

! 2(( :%(% $) -2D $ C$ :%(% ) ( 5*