← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/565/2015disposed of

Dharamender And ANR v. Ravinder Singh

2015-12-01Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal17 pages

     

!" "#$%$&'







( )*"&+") &+ &!(") ,,"-- &!% .%  .$&+")$&/( "%,&+"&!

'



    

                 ! "#

$%  &'%(!)* +  # %  )* ,

&'%(!) '

%#%-).-( *

  /

    ! ! "#!   $% & $& '

   *#! *""  +    () !

      &% &$ $&&, "#!   $- &% $&

 

. +!

) / ,  .

$ 0 + 

 

.#   !

( 1#(2/! #!  ( $% &$ $& !

(   !

+  !   .# 

  #  +)     #  5#     # ( 

   #   !   

, &- $&&4 &%

$&&'

# +    #  + +!

 7#  ) .# # &% &$ $&&, / ,     / 4   # 0!  !   .  &% &% $&&,

'

 !  #   (!  )   ( 1#(2 /!  .   ) + ) +!

   (!  !   9 ( 1#(2/! !  :  !   $3 & $&&,  (#  # # &4

$&&,  . +) !  0 #   +  (9!#

  # !!

)

+     # ;# < =)      ;<= 1( 1!  ; +  +  7# !

# 

,  9!

 !#    " !  +) #! !

 +#     ( #.#(  ) +!

       !     )  + $>3  ) !

4>3  +  1( 1!  ;

 #  )  ! #  / %   #("   )

&?

    ! .#    ( &% &% $&&, !

(   @   . / ,

     / 4   #

%  # !  

.) / $&      ) #     # +    /!

 )      9   

- 5 ( !  +!

# +  

#2

          

  !

  !

!""#$% &   %'

( #% %  %)  ( *%%  +  , *

 %   %%  %&    !

!""#  , -

 %    .% +  , 

 %   )%  , #

           

 %% %  %  , 

          %  + &%%) 

 & ,



 /  0.  0. % +   , 

(

& A   $- &% $&

 #

 $ 4 '

+ 2 +!

2

!

  !

!""#$% &   %'

( #% %  %)  ( *%%  +  *

 %   %%  %&    !

!""#  -

 %    .% +  

 %   )%  1           #

$ 0

 # ( !# )    ) / 4  (# )  !     !    ) +  +! ) / , (!

#( !  )  + 

0

 # . #!

# / , +

  +    !

"#!   $- &% $&

=!

!! #   ( + 

+ + + 

 () !

.#   + # 

'

=+!

7# +  # 

 , !# 2

        5  %&5 ) 5  % &           %&    &      &    6$ 0!

    %      0 5  )       &   6$ 0! %/  &    6$ 0!5  %  6$ 0*     %   6$ ,0-  )  /   &+     /+          ) &    )      & /+  7 

  %6$ 0* & / %%      %/&&   6$ 0!)

23334

 .&  ) /+          %       

%%  + )   - (* 7 7

     %             %     ) &    + % /+  %    %     %%    %   9&%     )%!" :%%(;% 

   %         % &        %%   % %   &   0 

  &.& %    /+            %        ) +  /&  % + %  +  <   &      &   )%

28334

     +    $%&5  & &   ) 9&  /      )%  %    %        %)  )      %% %  +9/+   7 

@    #   # 

,   !    ! 



& &' $&&, !

#  !  #

@#



 

# @ !#  #  + 

 #  #    !   ) 

% @#

 $ 2 0  #  (# !

 #  # 0 !  #  + 

@#

 4  2 #  # 0 #  

0 # 7# ( !  # #



$ @#

 ' 3 , +  

#  + + 

! ) !  #

- B #   + 

(! # !  # @ )  5 '

/#



 

! !      #

$& B # #    +   :. 2$   #   !   ! = !   !#     1 !  #!  # ,      CC       CC +  !#  0  !  !#   (!

  / " 0  :. 24  !#    " +





$

B # #  ) + ! ! +   + ! # (  (#   ! 1 / # (  +!

!

  ( !

$$ B # !#  9   

 , +  ) ("

 & +   " !> +) !

#!

 +> 

 , #!  &% &$ $&&, +#    ! 

( 

!

$4 @ 

 , +    !

  +!

 @ )  &% &% $&&, +  1#(2/! #! .#    # +  !

 !  0    

 , +  )    @ .22   .   !!

!

#  

$'

B #  # #(   +

 "   # (!

   D2

/   2 .   / 4   # / 4    +    :. 24 (#  # #  :. 24 ) # !  

) +  :. 24 

$3

 D2$ "  2.      / 4 + (!

!   ) (# # / 4    :. 24 D24

    2. #!

( (  # !# (#  ! !#  #  0  D2$ "

# !!  E22E . # !

$, B #  #    . !

   !

  ! 

 # ) #(  #

$6 D2

 . +   #     # &% &$ $&&, @  ! 

() !

   / ,  / %

$% B # #  #  :. 2

 :. 24  !# "  !

:. 2

 "   .#

( #(#   ! !# " #(7#) #! )   ) ! 0 :. 2$  #!  #(#  ! !   !

 / ,  / %

$- =#  !! + !

 D2

  2. :. 2$ !

+ ! + # ( !

 ! B+ 

 # !  (!

)  9 )    # )    # !  )  # # / 4 1!# 

+ #) ( #!

4&   &% &% $&&, :. 24 #)  :.# ! !

 > (  1#(2/! 0   (    #!

!  

& &' $&&, :. 2%  +  !!

  9 ( 1#(2/! +) .#!



> + #  ( 1#(2/! &% &% $&&, +   0 !   $3 & $&&, :. 2,  !

#    ( 1#(2 /! &4

$&&, .#    

& $&&, !

#  !  

& &' $&&,  ) #   &4

$&&,

4$ 0  9  ( +  + 

"#!   

 ( ! . +!

)   #(  ) 0 + 

 #  E22E + !   ! 0 !

+ ! +  # (  ! 0 

(  ) (  !

  

B+ 

! + 

(!

# #     !    # ! )   . 1  .   !

( + !   !     #    + 

# ( ) .# !     # 5  + 

!    

4'

0  + E D2  D2$ D24  # (  7# 0 !# + !

# #!   #   0   !#     1#(7#         CC  !# / 0 !  !#   (!

  0    )  #   @  !#    + "



 1 + 

  #   +# ( "#  (! + 

  

@  # #   + 2 ! + 

# #



'

6   + (

 #  )  + 

! !  # # 5 '

/#



+ ) #    ;C( 1#

  -%%-0'-  1.2  #"  

 3

 

!

-)( !/+4152+54 1)  +#  .)   !

 0 !  

& &% $&&, ! #  +   #    # !    1  !

 #    +#  (  (( #  () # 

4, 1  #)  + +) !

 # / ,  

+ !

# ) # / ,   + 

#!  #  #   

0 "#!  + 

# ! )  5 '

/#



+ (! + 

!

 ! #  # 1 #



'

  # + 

!  

       -%%-0'-

 F#G #   #  

4% @ +  + 

 #

  '

6   ) 2  5 '

/#



 # (

4-  (!

# 7#  #   +# ( "# .  # + 

 #

  '

  ) !!

!  #

'&   ! 

  !        ) (    . #

  '

6 +#  ) )  #( !   ( + 

@ #  #  +# ( +# (! + 

      #  +# (!

# ) (  (

'

D  (    (9

+ 

       ( + 

& $& ,

'$    ( &  $&

  ;9