Gurdarshan Lal v. State Of Punjab & ANR
!" # $% &&&
%% ' " (") "* + % (") ,#* # & &&& # ( - &./0/" #1 &/ #1
%%& &23 %)*4* "+ #1! % (") 5555
'# *"% #
% )"#* # # ##6&
& 6 +% #,1%7"#* 7" 1 8 " 9%%)"#* ## ##:&;&
+% # ##% 7"#* 8 " " %# +
% *
)"1 %#& & 0
%%#" )"% * # # / * #
%% 9
%# + "#
"% 9 # # # (/9 "%#1#*1 " / # 1 + +& / < # =&& ;
=& # ,#
% 9##
& & ;
:& 0
% "# ##&0
% "#" 4 >&= " */%
%&0
% %1*(*9 # %+" +&0## " #
% "%#&0 % 1#
% > 0%# ?"* * 4 ! #9 "1%& % %9* * # * %
" %"# ==: 2#(%,##62#@ ;:&0
% 9 3"# 1# )"#* ## & &6& . % %
%%#"*## "#"1%1 + % % "%# " "##9# # :&;& ;;;&8 "& 6& ## %# ) 9 *
% + ) %+ %
*," 9%#
%# + *" A#% " # " * # 19 # % 1" " #
#### /1 # ,# % 1 "
+& 2 " ## % * % "
+ *
# %9"% +
%# %%+%%*#@ " + % 1% *1 & ( "
+9/ +@ %9 + # "+ ,
8 " 1# >&
6
& & ;;;& >& 66
&6& ;;;9 #%+ + +8%3(9 &29## % "#"" +& =& 0 %%# %#+*1 9 # * % # " %%*# A # " # #"
# 191" &
@ %#* %%9*"9 #- "I. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to permanent injunction as prayed for? OPP II. Whether the suit is not maintainable? OPD III. Whether the plaintiff has not approached the Court with clean hands? OPD IV. Whether the plaintiff is estopped from his act and conduct to file the present suit? OPD V. Whether the suit has not been filed through a proper person? OPD VI. Relief."
2 # 1" %< #> %* (B %
#(B 4 *(B6 )4(B= ## #1## /.< (
%.< ( ".< (6 +)"#* ##& &6 .< (= * .< ( (; 4 ! #9 .< (
" .< (
(
# / .< ( :#!A>##&& ;: / & :& 0 ## < # / 4"
4% B # # #1#4 ! #9 .< 7 # +
: .< + A + ;;
;;; .< 6 4 ! #9 .< = @
= 9* " %# .< # 7 # +
.< & & * *"
% #,1%7"#*# #"& ;& 0
% #
% ," % # ##% 7"#* 8 " & 0 9 # # + % # ##% 7"#* 8 " &
& ** 1# +)"#* ## +% #
%%,"
% %#&
> 9"#(") #@ &
& $9 ," #9 3"#&
6& 21 # *"
#* "*% "%%+&
=& $ #"%
%%## ,"
%91
#%%*%+ +/*# 7 ##4 ! #9 %# # + %9 .< (; (
# %% #"
/ * #
%
"%1 # "
"# 7 # == (") $# 1" :&8" ##% #," %91 # # #*
% # "+ ,
##
& & ;;;# +%+ +8%3(9
*>&66 &6& ;;; 94 ! #9 9 *# @ &0 * # @ 1 1 " +
%9# # +&B # #
< /9 1 " +#
"%#91 / / % "*+," %9&8*#* 9 * ## 9 "%#9/ + # ## %&8" ## ," %9
# %%*%+ + #* #* " % # +
* # 1 %#* 1"" 1""9### 9 9 * # # %+ # "
%%+ " "&
% %%9##)"#* ## #&
# % #"%##
% /"%1 "%#
##"
.< (;(
9
%% % %## /< #=&& ;
=& #"
1# 9 *19# % %% 1" #9 ## 9 ##%**&B"" "
# #% 1" # @ ##9 " +# ," %91 *%+ %"## %%# 1 &
%
%% # #&
2 1 * "* # "%%+ # # # "
# +% #"% # "#
#1# &
:& * # #
% 9 %#
%9(") #8 + #
% #
#
%"# = (") ," ;
#
"# ,(,& * # #)"#* "
,"
,,
: %%9# + )"#*
;
,,6 :#
% ;& %+* "
%9 %# #9 # )"#* 3"%9 3" # #&
& 0% #,1%7"#* ###*">& 9 %"&2 >& 6=)"#* % # ,1%7"#*% %+#"#1#%# #&
;& ?," %9*9+# + 1" 4 ! #9 #7 # 1" # ## # "
" # 7 #&
% %# 1 & 0 % #
%% ," # ## +(B * "#< # #
% "
# # % "%1*" +#9 1# +% #
%% ,"
%&
% %#* %## %1* (*9 & 3" #* " + # "%1*" + # #9** +# %#*&0% #
%%," % %#*"&2 %
% %%+ 1 # "# "# #*"%## * & & 0 %1 % #"# + % #
%%," #"# -
:
"It is further submitted by the plaintiff that the said house on the suit land came into the possession of Ram Chand and now after the death of Ram Chand, the appellant-plaintiff is in possession of the same, the plaintiff is part time living in Phagwara and mostly he resides in the village. That the house and the land are being managed by the plaintiff, the plaintiff is maintaining two cows which are being tethered in the built area of khasra No. 40, the plaintiff on account of the exigencies of his work is unable to pursue his remedy in the Court x x x x." % #"# + % #
%% ," % %+ 9 % #
%% ," # ## +> %* + #*9 *&? ," %9" # ##
%* "# % " %9 % # #:&;& ;;;&?" ," %9 1 % #" 9 * #
%#*##" 1# # + +& 1""%# + %9# # 9"%# %* "% %+9%*%+ /* )"#%#%99 * %*1 9"# 1# # 9 * "# 1" " 9 # # # %9#"% 9 % & % # # #"# % 1"" " #& & * # 1" #
% 1" &2# # 1"%+ #
% 9
"%#&2## 9 / + @ # + "+ ,
8 " & <
%# 3"9#% # # #
"+ ,
8 " * >&
6
& & ;;; 8%3 (9 # >&66 &6& ;;;%+ +# @ 99 +# "& # # + %# #
9 " + 9 ## 1 # 9%9"%%+/ % # + "+,
8 " &?" 1# # %91 %9"%%+# # " +& 1" # # + "+,
8 " 9"%# " # % " +&29 #
## 1 # %9"%%+# # " + %9"%%+ %+ # + "+,
8 " &?" "1# #& 6& 0##1< # /4"
4%B # < ## >& )"#* % #,1%7"#* # # % 1 "%# .< (
(
#1%" #%% %%+9+ (9 # 1" # "%# %%+* "1%#+ + " " & 1 + # "& 8 %# #+ * .< ( (; *" +&8# # +# "91 / +@ "*+ ," & 8 1%" # 9 / # ,%% ""%# #" + & 9# * ##1%# 1 # 91
;
/ % #*9 ## + ," %9 %+ 1" 1* # # + "+ ,
8 " #
% 9 9 *%+ # ## + ," %9& 0 % ""%%+ 1# # " +# # # " + +##9 9 " +& 9 %* #
" + %+ %#
* %# &0 # ##/
#9%9&0#* ## + ,"
%9 " %& =&
%%%9##)"#* ##
+ ," %9 #&
# B /*C # DC> B % DC>