High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2691/2019allowed

Satya Narain v. State Of Haryana

2019-11-20Mr. Justice Amol Rattan Singh3 pages

!"# $#%&'& () *!"+!!,!&( #"&"& (#, -#,'.'

*"!"# !,+!(! #'/ ($#("

) 0 1* 1* ,#'#(") , ##/#($#,*&(234$- %!"#4

,"3#/#"&"& (#, ,*.,#($#,*&(2344!,+!(!

1*4

,!5 3#/#"&"& (#,3!-&(26##(% (-&%"#$ ,"3#% 77&''& (

#(%#'/.(&'3!65#.($#,*#%"& ('8 48948:!($89 "3#4!($ 3!-&(2 6##( '#("#(%#$ " (# +#!,'0 ,&2 , .' &7/,&' (7#(" , "3# % 77&''& ( #!%3

#(%#4;&"3!55'#("#(%#'" ,.(% (%.,,#("5+4!($;&"3 ! &(# '4

<!5' &7/ '#$./ (3&7&(,#'/#%" #!%3

#(%#46+ "3#5#!,(#$",&!5 .,"4;&"3"3!"% (-&%"& (!($"3#'#("#(%#'3!-&(26##( ./3#5$6+"3#5#!,(#$!//#55!"# .,"4"3&',#-&'& (3!'6##( &5#$ ""3#"&7#;3#(&"3!$% 7#./ ,3#!,&(2&(&"&!55+45#!,(#$ % .('#5 ,"3#/#"&"& (#,3!$,#'",&%"#$3&'/,!+#," (5+"3#=.!(".7

'#("#(%#&7/ '#$./ ("3#/#"&"& (#,4 ("3#2, .($"3!"3#;!'! &,'""&7#

#($#,!($"3!"'&(%#3#3!$!5,#!$+.($#,2 (#'&>7 ("3' !%".!5 '#("#(%#!""3!"/ &("45#(&#(%+7!+6#'3 ;( "&%# 7 "& (3!-&(26##(&''.#$ ("3!"=.#'"& (!5 (#4 ,*.,#($#,*&(2345#!,(#$4!,+!(!4" $!+'.67&"'"3!""3#5#!,(#$

.,"'6#5 ;!5,#!$+3!-&(2"!?#(!5#(&#("-&#;!($3!-&(2'#("#(%#$"3# /#"&"& (#," .($#,2 (5+ (#+#!,'0,&2 , .'&7/,&' (7#("4"3 .23 (#

"3#

#(%#' % 77&""#$ 6+ 3&7 !5' %!( #("!&5 /.(&'37#(" ! 5& # &7/,&' (7#("4( .,"3#,5#(&#(%+(##$'" 6#'3 ;(" 3&7 ;#-#,4 5#!,(#$ % .('#5 , "3# /#"&"& (#, / &("' " "3# 7#$&%!5% ($&"& ( "3#/#"&"& (#,4 &,'"5+4 , 7"3#$&'%3!,2#'.77!,+ !((#>#$!'((#>.,#8;&"3"3#/#"&"& (4'3 ;(" 6#$!"#$ @

&''.#$ 6+ (# !(!-"! '/&"!5' -" 1"$4 !,&$!6!$4 ;3#,#&( "3# /#"&"& (#,;!''3 ;(" 6#!/!"&#(" A;&"3;&"3 / ( =.#,+4 5#!,(#$ % .('#5 '.67&"' "3!" A &' !( !66,#-&!"#$ ,7 #,#6, A!'%.5!, %%&$#("4 ;&"3 "3#, "3# "; !%, (+7' '"!($&(2 , +/#,"#('& ( !($ &!6#"#' #55&".'4 ;&"3 3&7 6-& .'5+3!-&(26##(/,#'%,&6#$!5!,2#(.76#, 7#$&%&(#'4!''3 ;(&( "3#0$&'%3!,2#'.77!,+0 #"3#,#!

"#,/ &("'" "3# ,$#, "3#5#!,(#$!//#55!"# .,"4 $!"#$ ((#>.,# 4;3#,#&("3#/#"&"& (#,;!'!55 ;#$" "!?# 3&'7#$&%&(#'!($!;!5?#," /,&' (4"3#% ("#("& (6#&(2"3!"3#% .5$( " ;!5? (3&' ;( !-&(2% ('&$#,#$"3#!,2.7#("'4"3#

#(%# ,;3&%3"3# /#"&"& (#,3!'6##(% (-&%"#$4&' (# 3!-&(2!""#7/"#$" '"!($!'!

'.,#"+ ,!(!%%.'#$6+/, -&$&(2! ,2#$$ %.7#(" (!$&

#,#("(!7#4 ;3&%3 ,!.$!($ ,2#,+;#,#3 ;#-#,$&'% -#,#$6# ,#3#;!'!%%#/"#$ !''.%3'.,#"+ ('#=.#("5+4 "3# %!7# " 6# ,#2&'"#,#$ !2!&('" 3&74 5#!$&(2" #-#(".!55+3&'% (-&%"& ( ,"3#!

,#'!&$

#(%#'

@ 3.'4"3 .23 "3#,;&'#!2,##;&"3;3!"5#!,(#$*"!"#% .('#5 3!''.67&""#$4" "3##

#%""3!""3#/#"&"& (#,3!'!5,#!$+6##('3 ;( 5#(&#(%+43 ;#-#,4'&7/5+?##/&(2&(-&#;"3# !%""3!"3#&''3 ;(" 6# :

+#!,' 5$&("3#7#7 /!,"&#' !($;&"35#!,(#$% .('#5'.67&""&(2"3!"

3#&'!%".!55+ +#!,' 5$4!($5#!,(#$*"!"#% .('#5( "3!-&(26##(!65# " ,# ."#"3# !%""3!"3&'7#$&%!5% ($&"& (&'!'&"&'43#!5' 6#&(2! &,'"

"&7#

#($#,4"3#/#"&"& (&'!55 ;#$" "3##>"#(""3!";3&5#7!&("!&(&(2"3# % (-&%"& (&(,#'/#%" !55

#(%#'"3!"3#;!' .($2.&5"+ 3!-&(2 % 77&""#$ 6+"3#5#!,(#$ .,"' 6#5 ;4 "3# '#("#(%# &7/,&' (7#("

&7/ '#$./ ("3#/#"&"& (#,&',#$.%#$" '#-#(7 ("3' ,#!%3 "3#

#(%#' "3!" 3# 3!' 6##( % (-&%"#$ ,4 ;&"3 !55 '#("#(%#' " ,.( % (%.,,#("5+ ;#-#,4"3# &(#&7/ '#$&(,#'/#%" #!%3

#(%#4&# '4

<4#!%34&'7!&("!&(#$ ('#=.#("5+4;&"3"3!" &(#$#/ '&"#$4"3#/#"&"& (#,; .5$6# ,#5#!'#$ , 7%.'" $+./ (3&7% 7/5#"&(2'#-#(7 ("3' %.'" $+ #%#''!,+;!,,!("'<,#5#!'# ,$#,6#&''.#$!%% ,$&(25+

B3#"3#,'/#!?&(2<,#!' (#$

#'< B3#"3#,#/ ,"!65#

#'<