Prem Kumar v. Dhbvnl And ANR











 





 
























      



            



       !"

#   %& '( ! !"

$   

 












       



            



       !"

#  ) # * + !"

$   

 

!"#$

%&'($
$) 
(''#


*****
$) 
(''#+
%

,# (  $


 

  -.   (   " !!  /.   0

1"  "  &%


  ,# 2$

.+#"

 

%   # . 
 3 425 61 ( 1 

 4 

7 +  + " 1 "". 6 + ,35*8 5

 $

+   & 9#

+ 9  !

+ *

 ,#  '

6(

 '

 "    

 61 $2       $% 

/."  

+ # $ % "! + # 



%.   "" + #  " 1 ""  "

61  (  1 /."   " + # $  ""$ +.

 ".%$ "# +% % %( $ 1 $#"

.$61#  ## .$ & 9#

+9 *

#1 

:" """ 6

"". ,35*8 5

 (  +  61 # $  + +# ""   "#%( $$ 61#$ -.

 "# + ( + $  6 .$$1 + # +1  ,#

# 6+.

1$ +#6 ( ".%$ "# +

# . +

# %;"$#".6 
7 25,#

% # 6

( #.. # +"%$



1  " #  6 !  ,#  % 6  1 . 6 ,#$ #(  % % # #1 #" """ 3

(# "# % $( ""    #   %  ." . !

   "

 '5 72

 

 '5<2

   < 3

 ( " "# +(!

 $# ." =(! '

&# = 1

/ )   + %>  #?'= )>@ . # '5342

$ % 61#9# *  +29%%"

'= )> =   %% 9=5 342:29%%2
5 23<2

229 

 #  6 "

 #  # $!

. ." . !

 

 "

 

 < 3

 '5 2

  

 # ! 6 # ( ;$ ". +#("" 

6 "! " ( # =:
9
+.

 =:
922



" 1 %%   ."  <    .

 

 #  6 "   # ! 6 %  # ;

"

"

% "( # %%

" # #1

&#$

$ 1
 7 3

25."

+# %.9 "# + # %.# 6""1!

.$#$

 ,# 

9. %# .$." $ < #/.+% ,# $  ( $%   ." !

" .$$  #  $" ! "   = + #  ".  # $  # +#% 

" 61 + 

:;'3"

+$!

"!1;$

 & "  # $# 

6 +"

1 !

"  #( #  ""   # $

  61 3  %

  $   # $

 #  # $      !1

"# +( ""$
. 1 .

# 2$

  " ( # "  # $ ( 

 % "! %.   "" + # " " .$$1  5$ 1% %. ,# /.+%  

 9. 6"

% .6/" %   "# + 6 # 9.  # 9. 61 1 + .$ /.+%  #  9. 





 !"#$
%
$&'&
(

$$ &!

$&'& ! /.+%  # 

 9. 61 # +#  "#"

!! 9 8  .1 "% 1( ## "#$"

'= )># &# $

$ 1
 3 425  """ !

(  

=:
9 !

( "

'5342



< 9.  #  (. +. #  # /.+% $ 61#$$ 9.611 +.$/.+%# 9. 
)*+
(, .$  #.5 $$ %

 "

 6 (  .

  A  !#%1 +. # 
)*+
(, .$  # .6# 9.(  1 %# !! #$"

(# "# "!.
+.

<$ AAA#= 1 :" 1
+.

19%%  '.1  .$$1 " 1  -.  (  "! ;$

". $!

+.$$1 (-.

". 1
+.

  

 #?#
+.

@A .# +.# #"

#  # 

#"

.$61# #   " % %  $   #  3  %   # $

1  #

"  1 ( #   6.  1%   "# + #  6 "! 6%# $$ # "".;"$ $!

. #
+.

"" +".  $
+.

< # "

 #  # 6 +   $!

 # !

" "

6 .$  3  % % % $#% +".6 "   "61#

9.A

+.( #!#%"# #$  # !

 " %."#  ;$

  . (# "#
+.

 #1 # ! 

 #

% %# 
 &#,# .6%  % 61 ".  #   " # /.+% $  61 #  9.  
)*+
(, .$ "

6 $$ #"!1 !! # $"

 #/.+%$ 61#9. "

6 ( .

66  9.$ +#$# .$$/.+% $ 61#9. ( ##.6%  # ( #   

 < 3



 ( # " %

!

%%;.5 ;$ ". ("" (.6"! "( ##
+.

  #   %  

 61 # $ #   +#1 6 .$# 61 # 9.  (#  ! + # /.+%  # 

9. A# !# ".#$  $.#$ $56&

" A $. 61  ""   !.  #  (  3

## $

 #"# +% 61# $ # + 9.#$#  $. #   "%#% $ # 3 % #$!


+.

 <  #
+.

$$ 6  # + ! "

 '$ $ -. 

61#9. ".#$   $   !

" 1 +.% %."#  % +.   #(#"

.$$  +#9. # /.+%$  
)*+
(, .$ "

6 $$ # "#"

#  A
)*+
(, .$  
+.

<(  # .6/" %    ".  "

  #    $$  9. ( #. ""1 $$"

+ #  ".

 "!1 #  " 61 $$1 +#/.+% 
)*+
(,  .$ #$"

#6 #.$# +$ # $( #+ 

1# $ 1# "# + 9.  # $ #  

  $  . #  #

%$.+% "

6+ 1

61 !& $ ".

$!

#
+.

A# !

(#%  A % "  #  #  %  

 61 # $  

"( #
+.

"

%#$#  +#16 /"61#

9.,# 6 + "$ 61#9.

"

6 (.

+1  0 # + +    # (  ,# /.+% "$ 61#9.   #  #

9.   +#$ 6 # ("
)
!&-
$&'.















/ 0
1 2
?'*.

@



















8##$ & +2 

12 8##$ 6

12