High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/2994/2014dismissed

Sumer Singh And ANR v. Raj Singh And ORS

2019-09-16Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

!" " !""#"

$$%% & '!""

$ (

"! )* "$$%%

+ !") *,"

-"." ")* $-

//// + %0)" "$% !"''!""

+" !""

1 !") *%%! $ )2"% , " 3 !" !'!"4" 0! 5"%0*4" $

$ * "$%)"0%!,"$ ', $" % *%%!6)2"% , 7 % "%, !!30 +" !")" "$%$ ,"." $%"

#8"$!"* -

97$$%"*!3%30"$%! ." $% !"

9: 3 .%% ; < ), ),"",= 9:$, !*"$%* $ - 9 :

9>" ?"7 "% $ , $ 3, " $ " %%0 " !" * * " 0) " ,0) " $% $ , $* 0"" $ $ 07- > 3!%* $ , *% 3%$ " %"! ," !!"% $ 7"0%, "$%$ " *% 3% $ " %) "

- > !!! "% "0%%% % 3 %! ) ,"""0" !" @%!!! *"$%"3 !" " A $ 0! " " - > 3 !0$ !!! "% ," $ " $ $ 0

!!)- $$ % , !" ) !* %!%3' ," ! 3%0 " 7 $ $% $$% !,0$%3 !!" 7 3!3 ' 0 $ 7 " $% "*! % % )", !"" $%$ " "4 %0 B9"" %%" 8"," "

8% %" %)," " !

%,,30%0- C !"),""

D*)+"!,." 3%2 )

$ 7- )=>"% 0 %A "" !" - 7"$" $ $ 0"3 '3,"$ %!" 0' $% - : %*, ! 7" $%$ 4% *$ " $ !%- :)8%- 9 !3 ",30*%% "$%","", 7"" " 3 0,%%3 > "!" "

!3 %!%%!*% 3%" 0 $!%07""$%$ , !"%$ 8%- 930,! $ "%*%"%>%, "" !$

" %),"""3*"$%3! >

7"""$%3! E$ %E3 "3*%$ "3" ! %$ 3%7"" "3 ,"" "$%)$ 5 "*7 ""3 0,%%)"

!3 %!) $ 8"3 "%",30 3 0, 8

0) >""$%$ 03'7""$ "3% ! ""$% " % "*%$ !" 3%"$%""00 33%!4 30 "%" $7" "%$$%$ " " " A %%0 *% 3% "0 ! " " $ 8%- :B 9$ %%0 %%!7" "$%$ * %*" !" $ " %)" )"$%"* % % " $ " , 3% ! " ! %%!) " , ! $ 0 %"

2" $% " % $% * ! " %%!", ," !"* "$%

"$%!"$ )%%,! ,

F"" "$%, $* " % *%%! '6G ((

F"" " $% % ' !

! " $ $ 0 $ G ((

= F"" " 3%G ((

% ; $ *" )"$%- !" ! " (F 3 4! "

&3"

") !"(F )"

'5 )("! $" (F %8" )*(F=

"" ")""4 "8 H +%% ) I4 $" F ) "

( 8") !"F)"

" !"F=)"

"85 ) ("! $" F)"

'5 )("! $" F:) "

5"F )"

"!! ,%) !" F>)"

5, !")I4 $"F9)"

#% F)1.0F )"

"%5 F

D*F

" !% % "$ )" % . " "$% 2",* '

@%!!! *30"'

! )" $%"%$$%". 6 !), ) ,"",!% 6 !), ),"* '

! "

%%,""'

! $ 30". 3%,)"$%"*88" " . 30,0%!" !

% $$%$ 0!"" 3$)"$ !'

! $30 ". 3%,3" %30"3 -"$$%, " $ $- "$$ " !" %

;"*" % % "$ 3!!

" !""

$ %"'

!$30" %. ! "," ". $$ " %,%% '

%$)""% ")$ " $%"%*)"0%!,"$ ' , $" $ $ 0),""30 ) " "0"* $,"$%" ', $"4 B9"" " $ $ 0),""

3 30" * '3 "0 : I4 :

2" %. "3 *"$%$$ !

(F" 4""" %*!

> $8" 3 " " "4 8% %)"

"$%$ $$8" 3 8%%- 9 !% - :)," $ !% 0 2",30(F % 2" %. " , "% "" %*!$ "$ %) " "%$"$%7 " " $% " A % 0 8! $ $%"*)" 3

1$%"$% %!'

"! @ " "$% 30"$%""%!" )" " * $ "%$ !%- :8%- 9 $ #%. I4 (F=B+)% ;" " 3" $%%%0 * 0$ " $ $ 0 "% " >),"",,%%,""8,%! $%$ "0"03' ""0 %8$ %0" %0 $%"% %$ "40 ),"" "$%$ ",""0 "* 08,%! ! !" $%,

9 4% *$"$ $ 0,"""0"% 0 ;3%" ""* "$%),"""

!3 %!3 0

F""'

! $30" %. , "%%!"$$%)"@ $$%%. %! ,"" %. " " '

! $ 30 " % . ; " " '

! 30 " 3%, % ,%% 3 $ $ $ $$ % * $ %, 2" %%!%0 0" ),"" !""*%% 30". ,"%" ! $$%

# % " $$%% " '

+ "'

! $$%"$ "4,"" "3 *"3

# % " $ - " % "

!"# $

% &&'( ) )* & *% &&'(+, - $ .

$ %/&&'(

- 3%A %, "$$%

2" );0 "$ $$% 0 3 " %!%) *% ,%% '

!$30". 3%,

2"$$% !%0

+ '

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#