Vivek Gupta v. Uhbvn Ltd.
!"!#$ %
&'!( )*+
++ ,, #
'"
& &- # !.,!'!
& #!/ 01!0!
"+#2 #
3$ 41331
0,
#!#/56
! "
#
$ "
%
&%
' ' (%! )
"
"
* ('
+
,
-
,
#. & $/ & 0 % 1 / 2 3, 4 )
/! "
%
*
56 070*/ %
3
8 )98 "
( ) "
# %$
8
3,1 , 5
) ."
:;
# $ "
<
"
"
" % ! "
' " %
"
"
#. & $
%%
+ < <
"
%
"
" "
"
= "" = ." %
+ " 9
" 1 = >
6?
< " "
@
" "
1>
% "
"
%
?* ."
/
"
#A ( 4% 0 $ / "
"
"
#. & $ " / %
% "
+
%
: . "
B "
" "
/
"
9; % ;
" "
"
, "
A
& 6
"
"
"
."
"
"
%
."
# $
" "
%
8C D "
2=6
F-(! <*)& <"
"
#. & $
"" "
% "
=
3 D
"
>
%
" "
&% ' G?
# C
F
&
#. & $
< !
* HA D:/ "
; &
0 % 1 / 234 )
% " I9)) . % "
,
. &
I9))
C
I 9)( : C
I9)(
C
&"
I9)( D
$ ; .
-
)C A8 'F
)C
" % ,
&%
' !G?
#F-) >D >
F-) A(9234 ;
F-)
& A
& F-):
&
2?:D6= F-) );
3
F-)=7) F-)):
F-)C6*75 3 &
F-)C6375 & & %
F-)C6&75 * &
5 ?( &
5 ?F &
1.
$ - 1 % ( A(9 (C
" G?
#F-( &
6 F-( &
D;$ =
% &% &
, & "
& / "
! "##$ % !&'" & " "
&% '
" ?
-
"
%
%
.
F-) ): "
& "
&% ' " " %
"
F-(:
"
@
-
% <(:<
F-(: -
"
& F-( "
2?=6 D; %
? ! A
& 6 "
" , & "
"
#. & $ & +
#. & $"
& / "
.
,
* (' ,
% & , & %
& ,
"
% #A D >$
*
!"
, A
' A
* "
"
F-)C6*!
" #$ " /
%
F-)C63 "F-( D; "
"
8C"
" < :< " -
8C"
"
< <
"
" "
%
;8C "&9D 84* "
"
."
"
"
" "
" -
% ."
% %
< < " "
" < << < :
F-) "
&
%
" , G?
#C % !
"
" "
. %
6 " +
"
"
% ? 6 ? "
?
"
$ . % "
" % " " +
% *
= F-):! "
& "
%
%
"
" +
% "
"
"
"
+ %
%
&% ' "
"
& H "
D
"
&
, # $ % :!
& + "
" 9 1
&)& "
"
<%
, < A &)& D 9
"
"
,
&% ' "
"
" > &
"+
" %
A &
+
, G?
# ( )*+) , )),**
)+ +)+
) )
)) , + + - . &/0
-
+)
)+ 1
( )*+)
+
)
)+)
) ,, . &( 2 *
+ ) *
+ ,) ), + )!.&( 23"1 ( )*+)
, , )
+
*
+
),1
( )*+)
)
-
+)
) * )+ + 4)+)15 F
+ " "
% "
%
% , " &
+
& %
" 9 1
&)& & + + "" &
, %J
%K
" ? ; .
&
%
"
+
%
= & + " % = F-) ):
&% ' "
"
%
%
&
"
?
5&
"
&% '
6 F-(!
? -
,
! "
6 ,
! " &
F-)?
)?:
F-(?
"
"
F-)?: " " =
"
"
% 9 53 "
? !
D; F-(?!
"
? 8C " % "<
< " -
8C
"
?
"
"
"
9 +
+6% + 53 "
"
> , =
% " + " "
% &
* ( '
=
-
D & J
-
%
"
& J ! , : " "
"
9 1
&)& " &
" A &
%"
" " : " %
: "
+ 5 3 " " 9 1
?
! :! ! "
"G?
#
!! "
#
$
"
%&
'
(
)
(
&
'
$
$ % (
* +
$
$ %
, : %
,
"
, " .
J 53 " A D F
* " % % &
0% "
- "
"
J "
"
+ " "
&%
' D -
-
&
" " F-(? " D;
D %
"
J
"
"
!
"
D
" ;84 53 "
> .
5&
" A F
*"
&
" "
% %
?& "
" A
0%
?
&
"
% "
" "
A 0%
"
; 9 53 " "
+ 5 & < <
& / ?&
; ""
,
"
% %
"
" %
" " :
& / ; "
" " "
& +
"
= A &
% 9 1
"
% "
" " +
" " " 9
5&
=
9 1
+
" %
? "
& "
5&
"
"
&
%K " &
9 1
&)& "
%
" "
.
" ,
&%
' "
A &
"
&
% "
, "
/
F- )?: = %
"G?
#6 )*4 *4 7) 4+ ) +
+)+ ) + 3 + +)3
+ 4 ), ) +
+)
4 ), $
+) ) +4) 3 + +)
*,
% 3 +)+ ) !
"4)
,) 3 + , +)
+) 4) + )
) 44) ) ) +),+)+,) ++, +) + # + ) 9/:
;
) 4)5
/
"
&
, F-)?
!
#" % "
!" "
$
&
%
:! .
%
. D, "
& = F-)?: "
%
%
&"
="
"
5 ?' " "
%
% " &
53 "
D; F-(?!
& : " H!
? 8C " %
"
! %
C" :=; 4* "
& D
"G?
<; 37=>#969=369.(.9&&?
!
"
3 4
3 4 ,) > )
2) + 28
2 , )2@>6# !
"
# +), + 3#$ ++ -
- )
3#$ ++ - -
) !
"
6 ,, !"
@
!3 + 4* ) + '8
"
.#
!
"
( )) ) $&
$
!
"
( ))4) $&
!4" 9 !3 + 4* "
.+ ),8=A !
"
( )) ) $& = 0$&)
!
"
( ))4) $& = 0 &)
!"
,> )@>6#A $ &
(
, + B= $ & ) 5 53 "
"
"
""
"
!
%
#. 6 / 6H. 65.&$ . "
"# 6/ 6H. 65.&$ A % !"
"
"
7 / . " #
"
$. "
!" %
#
"
$ ! %
"
" % # %
"
6 6 6 65.&$ % 0% %
% "
" %
"
% %
"
.
" .
-
"
& "
% %
= F- )?
)?:
%
!" " "
: / : F-(? "
% "
? 8C
"G?
#H. (2A1.*H)9CF1A2))HE C!
!
*%
*%
"
! <6) < ! "
0% 8C - A
" % 8C >8C" H
!
& A %
*&
?
% *&
:% % 8C ? 8C - A
" % 8C ? >8C" H
!
!2 8C
C
!* % 8C 8C
C
- @ 1
8C
!F- " :=;
%* % 8C
- >8C @1
8C
G ;B
%- "
%
H
$
"
? 8" "
" % & D
" &
:
"
:=;
4
C
"
"
D!
@
?
3)
% 3) * = F-)?:!
"
"
"
"
"
?
"
A
1
3)
"
" ? 3) 1 3)
" "
3)
& +
% 53 "
"
"
"
% %
0% "
"
"
% , F-)?
)?: (? .
F-(?
%
"
D 2 "
&
:;
F- )C6* ! "
< <
% F-)C?63!
"
%
-0% "
% . % %
"
" + "
%
, %
% " "
"
% "
&
%
% " K % "
"
0%
%
% &
>
"
%
" "
"
%
%
" "
"
; & +
"
&
"
6
&% ' + " "
= * + "
"
+- A &)& 9 1
%
! %
& / ; !
"
2
"
"
+
%
"
% = %
%" " ::
& "
" : *
53 " 9 1
%
" "
%
+ " "
" " % "
%
" "
" " "
"
. - , H &
#/!1 , #2 # 5 &% 35 # #2 # 5 &*.1= H
==
" (%3 %
"G?
<: >
)4 )
C 0- = , )
))* *
* 4)
,
, , ) 4 * *> ) + )+)4 ) )4
*
+ 4 4,) )
44))
+D ) )
4E ))
) -4 ,+
+) )
+ )4 )
+
) 4 ,,+ *) 4) , )
) ), 4
* +
),)4
)), #) F>)+)+* )),
+ ) ,
++) 4 )
, * * ) 4)), )
6
** 4
D ),
#)
-+
) (
*> >*) - ,)- ++ -
),
+ )
)4+ ) ) ) C 8)- *
4)) 4,)
+D ) +)
4 + ) ;- # &)+ #)-) ) * 4 )-,) E )*
4 4 )),C 0-= -# &)+ #)6 +) /,)
#) * 4,
C -= 0-# &)+ #)& * 4 )*) +)
#) #) )
+ #) * 4
+ )),
+D 5
L G ,
(%3
; <
' %
" , M , "
% A
&'!0, "5:*0 &!:*,"5& "
% 0;5 .!& #2 # 5 &*.1 =A&;D "
, :*,"5& "
"4 "
" "
(%3 H &
A & "
(%3 & !&25 &! 1 , #"
, % 5 5 !&0 #6 5 )& " 3 # / 0 #
&265 #2!/ &5 #2 5 &"*.1=;
)7!=
"
, & & + 53 " , + " "
?
"
+ 9 1
&)& A &
9 1
"
&
: .% ""
"
,
& "
?
"
"
%
" %
"
"
%
> %
%
"
" *
" <31= ; & %6
C
6 C 1