High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/44412/2019dismissed

Shankar v. State Of Haryana

2019-12-20Mr. Justice Arun Kumar Tyagi27 pages

"#$$

# %& $ '

(

!!!!

( )$ "

$%&'() *

+,( - - #

$/&0 ' 1 - -1) # 2 #

345 66,&

6+6+(6$/

((

$/,8' 1

#9 7

( :

* 6+6+(6$/2

247

8 2 < 5= ".

# 7

. 7

-# .

(66 # *

. 2

6+6+(6$/ 2

> 34*

>(> $666

# . .

7 # ?

(+68(6$/

$&0'() - -

6+6+(6$/ 0 "

$,6 < 39

$&0'()*# 2#

!" # $

% "

# 2 #

$%&'() - - + "

2 #

- #

. # 2*

-7

* 2.

##* - (+68(6$/*

39 #

0%>'+) 57

* 39 *

(%6%(6$/2

.2 34 * * # .

6%6+(6$/

6+6+(6$/*

345 ,,

6%6+(6$/?

39 #

5 0+%>

(+$6(6$/ * *

2 7 '@)

392;#*

5 $(&(+

(+$6(6$/ #

39 5

>0> $/A5($,+

(%6%(6$/ 34 5 ,&

6+6+(6$/ *

# ,,

6%6+(6$/.

.2 *#

# 8/834.2 .2 ,&

6+6+(6$/.

.2 .2 8/8

6%6+(6$/ ?

8 4

# - #

- #

% - #

6+6+(6$/

$&0'() - -* (86+(6$/*

< .

$,65 #

0%>'+) 57

# 2 #

$%&'()

- -

.2 ## *

# - #

- &

# $

% -

- ( '

) *+ ,-

- / $/ /

) * #

/ /2 $

!" #

% /

1 !

) * #

/ %

& ?

- #

>+>

$&0'() - -* 2 <

$,6"

39 "

# 2 #

$%&'() - - "

.2 .

4 .

- ##

12#

- '*+ !,(*-+, .-,"/ "0$'

,+!,+1'2#312 $$ $1+ - "425 .

- + - "4 !

44"

*! $356

(*48 "/ +' "9,:!$'

*";</ / / "

5$6$7$ ,

$%& - -*

# *

2 ## * *

(+ > /

" #.7

6 *!

! "

>8> $ % "

' &

& ( ) %"

* "

, ---... , '

>%> '

/ ,

.#1

..#.

# )

#2 $6

06/ - -*

. * -

> 3$

7 7

# .

( ) *

45 456 4567 457 45, 458 45 86 4587 . ) ,9

:5; *

>&> $ .

( ) "

( )

( ) &

( ) = &

, & '

, "

# = .

>,>

$# = %

#> $$ " <

1 2

(')

- - ## *

. 2$#. , * ( ? ? ,

#2 $(

$&0 - -*

2# .

## * /$

7 # #

#.7

= 0

454564567 45745,45 845864587 450 . ) , 9 :5;

# $ 6

>/>

+ @

* '

45 456 4567 457 45, 45845864587 450

. ) ,9 :5;# %

+ @

# 4

# 9

>$6> ;

# 5

& &

* "

# : A

' $ 5

$#2 $0

$/6 - -*

8# # "* 9

>$$> +& ,

# $ % , ! "

#> $+ -# '2) 2>

'$)

$/6 - -

" <

1 2

(')

- - ## * 3$# . ,

? ?

$ 4#2 $8

$/0 - -*

> :

8# # "* !

+ <

>$(> "

,#> $% 4+' "9,0$, ' ) 7'*=+ - *+

066/$/+/

?6$$6$/+/

##6($6$/+/"

60$6$/+/2

6($6$/+/*

## 1

##1 #

* *

#?68$6$/+/

## 1

##1 $/$6$/+/

# ##"

# $($$$/+/4 *

2 #

60$6$/+/ *

4 *

# #2

'2) 2>

'$)

$/6 #- -4 *

$&0'$) #- - *

'()

$&0 *- -

6($6$/+/*

##*

>$0>

$/6'$)'2) *

$&0'$)'2) #- -" ## * 2

> 29# $; B9B , 4

. +

#6 4 * , #9 ,

( 2+

* #2 6

$ C #% C 2 * 2# % #+

B#%

, "

6 , + #%

2 * #2 6

4 , # %

#2 $& 4'

+>"0$ ,4' "9,"/ , +!1 *";<

>$+> "/+>"21 2 561 *";<233##:

* #

$&0'() - - #

< -

#E<.

:##

E< 3 E<

* .

2# #*

(/0 - -*

2 < *

>2 <F*

* 2.

* # B#

$/6'$)'2)

- - 2#

4 *

1 #

## 2

. *

< .

## " :

12# - +' "9,0$ , ' ) 7'*=+ - *+ #

2 1

1 B

'()

$&0

4 #

>$8>

#- -

'8)

$&0 *- -*

" 1

')* #

2 #

2 2 2

'8)

$&0 - -" #

< 1 **

2 ##

* #2

DD*

$$ !,<*/"/"

, +0$ '

4, ) 77'*=+ - *+?$4 * #

*- -

'8)

$&0

- - .

- -22>

'$)

$&0

" 1 ') #

" B

* * 2 2

* 2.

. 2>

'()

$&0 - -

##*

< 2

# 2

>$%>

$%$ - - # *

#2# *

. * 2.

$, 4 "+4*+ *

"0 ! 9 "0$ $'$ @"+$) 12 $$ $1+ - "4273?

D :

12#

$&0 - -

2 2.

> 2#1

* #.

, #.

? ?

* # 6 + 49 , , ) :B: , A

D + 6

)

EB :+,D$:4 $B4F

>$&> ? ?

9 + 4 4 + $;6

#1 : + 4

* # .

& # /

+ , #2 $/ 4+ "/+(*-+- "0$1'2#712 $$ $ 1+ - "427??

# B

$&0'() - -*

/62 ##

* #

# 2 #

$%&'()

- - 12# - 2

> 35# %

5 7 & , G# H

* + 4 , #)#,# + $ + 4 $ : , #)#,# C

! 7 , ,

7 .

#D#+#) ?

& 7 A

D ?

2 2 +

# %

>$,> + $ + 4 : , #)#,#%

+ 4$

6,!" <

#% * + 4$I , #)#,#

& /,

, #> (6 4 '*+ !, (*-+ , .-,"/ " 0$ '

,+!,+1'2#312 $$ $1+ - "425*

* *

2 *

* #

# 2 #

$%&'() - - 12# - 2

> 35#6&

( #;4#$;$)

$ #;9#$;$1

#;5#$;$+

) '

4;#;#$;$ % % , & ) ?

4#;B#$;$ % / , % , '

$#;#$;$ 6 + 5$, ) , % , '

>$/> #;#$;$% , & + 5$, #)#,# #1

) ?

#. < + ,

),6

+ 5$, ) , *

+ 5 , ) ,# +

# %

< J 5;

;

# .

, #%

)

+ &

>(6>

+ 5$ , ) ,

, &

# :#A

+ 5$ #

+ 5 , ) , #%

)

+ 4;B, ) ,

+ 5, ) ,#% , ) , , < # 6 # 8

#8 + 5$ , ) ,"

K &

>($> ;

;

< ,

, + 4;B, ) ,# %

"0+ 6 0

" "

##!+

##! 6

* " #

# .7 !

/,-,-,

" 0

+ 6 #

* 7

##7

6 #

##! "*

;

6 7

> ($ 4 </*4A

A $:$0$ "4"0 ! 9 "9 "> 1'2 7 12 $$ $ 1+ - "42 3 * >

* 2.

$,6

* #2 12# - .

* #

$%&'() - -

# *

$,6

>((> (( 4' > -:!$' 1 $$,"/ 9+,212

1+ - "4276B'*.,, "' "9,:!$'

*";< 7 / / / "6$5$712 1+ - "4276B*+=4 ' "9,"/ , +!:!$'

*";<

?"/

0 "/ +:!$'

+>" 63?5/ / / "

?$$) # :

$&0'() - -2.

# E<.

1 * #2

* #2

$%&'() - - *

** 2 # :

- +-4' "9,4 !(4:!$'

*";<+ - "4- !

44"

*! $

7"/(*48 "/ + ' "9,:!$'

*";<+ - "4- !

44"

*! $356

7 (0 4

9 :

; ' "9,C

"/"

, +:!$'

*";<"/ , +!

- 5 +%8/ (6$8

06$$(6$, ?

$&0'()- -2

#E<.

## 2

0%>'+) 57

2 #

$%&'()- -IJ" 7

12# - + ' "9,%! !

##2

,4' "9,%!!

>(0> - - 2 #

4 -

2 *

2 .

2 # *

. *

12#

- '

D ! "94"/"

, +:!$ ,/$ (,4 / 7 12 ' ?6 '

,+!,+ :!$ ',+/,"/+ : ">. "9+ "/ , +! 7 12 '

> 3

& #

A#8#)#+#6

# *

+ !

>(+> + B;, #)#,# %

? ,

# A , 0

? + 4, #)#,# A#8#)#+#6

* # 1 , 0

+ 4, #)#,# "

< * :;

, # < A#8#)#+#6

# . , 0

A#8#)#+#6

? "

>(8> <

6#> (+ 4.!,(*-+C'*"">:!$'

+>"

531 @2

$%$6(6$/

* #2 # :

- .

2 7

; ' "9,C

%! !

12# -

+ "/+(*-+- "%!!

</*4A

A%!!

$ (8$ 4. ##

* 2 #

.!,(*-+C'*"">%!!

12# 7

12#

- '*+ !,(*-+, .-,"/ "%!!

# (% 4

* 2

. 2 12#

- + ' "9,%! !

) $'$ %! !

) + "/+ (*-+ - "%!

) </*4A

A%!!

'*+ !,(*-+, .-,"/ "%!!

"/ *44 ",

, ! *+ " ,4' "9,%!!

)

$&0'() - - 2

#E<.

# 2 #

$%&'() - -

%6/6 $,6 .2

#E<.

(& ?2

- &

# $

% # :

>(%> ( '

) *+ ,-

- / $/ /

) * #

/ /2 $

!" #

% /

1 !

) * #

/ %

. .

. 2 12# - + "/+ (*-+ - "%! !

) </*4 A

A%! !

'*+ !, (*-+, .-,"/ "%!!

# *

$ (, 4

6+6+(6$/

$&0'() - -* 2

(+68(6$/2 <

$,6 *

39 *

2 #

$%&'() - -

(/ 3

.# 2 2

39 *

(%6%(6$/*

$,62 .2

34* * #.

345 ,,

6%6+(6$/

345 ,&

6+6+(6$/" 39 *

345 ,,

6%6+(6$/2

2 7

392

(+$6(6$/ 39 *

>(&> 2

39 . 2

(%6%(6$/

39 # # 2#

(%6%(6$/

2 #

$%&'() - -

$&0'() - - < $,6 06 ## * . 2

# 0$ *

* .

# 39 7

392

392 B

( ) $$ ;

#A H

A5 H