High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5781/2015dismissed

Avneep Saini v. Jarnail Singh And ORS

2016-12-13Mr. Justice Arun Palli7 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

+ ,(##-!&(& --#..!("

,#/'0'

!/(!&.&(12!($"2#/'

#'-($#("'

) 3 4 4

/#'#(") /!1/!5$,%!"#5

/"2#!--#..!("

/6!( !('!.5$,%!"#5

/"2#%!,#!"/'

45 2&'&'!(!--#!. &.#$78"2#-.!&("&

"#/2&''0&"'##9&(1!

$#%/## -#/6!(#(" &(:0(%"&( !1!&('" "2# /#'-($#("';$# #($!("'5 <!'

&(&"&!..8$#%/##$&(2&' !,0/78"2#.#!/(#$&,&. 0$1# 0(&/ &,&'&(5 !"#21!/2!2&7570"&("2#!--#!. &.#$78"2#$# #($!("'5"2!":0$16#("!($ $#%/##<!'/#,#/'#$78"2# &/'"!--#..!"#%0/"!($2&''0&"<!'$&'6&''#$ "2012<&"20"%'"'

2# !%"'5!'"!9#( /6"2#:0$16#("' "2#%0/"'7#.<5!/# "2!"&(2&''0&"5"2#!--#..!(";-.!&("&

2#/#&(!

"#//# #//#$"!'-.!&("&

2!$ %("#($#$"2!"2&' !"2#/5=!/&($#/20$2!/&5<!'#!/.&#/&(!%"0!.#>%.0'&,# -''#''&( "2# '0&" -/-#/"85 $#'%/&7#$ &( "2# -.!&(" /6 ?"&6# &66#6/&!.@!($!

"#/2&'$#!"2( A

5"2#-.!&("&

!($2&'7/"2#/ 6&"!&(&<#/#&(!%"0!.5-#!%# 0.!($0(;&("#//0-"#$-''#''&(,#/&"

2#$# #($!("'<#/#$#'%/&7#$"7#?7/!,"8-# -#/'('@B <2<&"2&("#("&(5<#/#"2/#!"#(&(1"&("#/ #/#&("2#-''#''&(

#(%#5"2#'0&"<!'&('"&"0"#$( CA -(("&%#&''0#$""2#65"2#"2/##/#'-($#("';$# #($!("'

2#/#&(!

"#/ /# #//#$ " !' $# #($!("' !--#!/#$ !($ &.# "2#&/ </&""#( '"!"#6#("5"!9&(1-/#.&6&(!/87:#%"&('(6!&("!&(!7&.&"85"2#-.!&("&

2!,&(1%6#<&"2%.#!(2!($'!($2!,&(1(

#"% (6#/&"'5"2#%("#("' "2#-.!&("<#/#$#(&#$5'"!"&(1"2!"

"2#8<#/#(#,#/"2/#!"#(&(1"&("#/ #/#&("2#-''#''&(

!($ !%"0!..85=!/&($#/20$2!/&2!$!./#!$8'.$2&'.!($!.(1"&6#!1570" "2#-.!&("&

"!9&(1"2#7#(# &" </(1#("/&#'?'"!($&(1&("2#(!6#

=!/&($#/20$2!/&@ A /#-.&%!"&(<!' &.#$78"2#-.!&("&

"%("/,#/""2#'"!($

"2#$# #($!("'!($"/#&"#/!"#2&'<('"!($50-(<2&%2"2# ..<&(1 &''0#'<#/# /!6#$78"2#.#!/(#$&,&. 0$1#);

" #$

* 2#-.!&("&

#>!6&(#$2&6'#.

!($!.'"#($#/#$!%-8 "2# 3%& /"2#8#!/ ; !($!%-8 !&' ()&78<!8 $%06#("!/8#,&$#(%##!.'#>!6&(#$(#D0.$##-&(12!' E;

2# $# #($!("' #>!6&(#$ $# #($!(" ( 5 :!&7 &(125 <2 $#-'#$&("#/6' "2#</&""#('"!"#6#(" -(!--/!&'&(1"2##,&$#(%#!($%('&$#/&(1"2#-.#!$&(1'!($ !/106#("'5"2#.#!/(#$&,&. 0$1#2#.$"2!""2##>%.0'&,#-''#''&( "2#

!"2#/

,#/"2#'0&"-/-#/"8<!'-/,#$5<&"22&6'2<(&( %.06( %0."&,!"&(&("2#3%& /"2#8#!/ ;C5!'!.'78<!8 &' ()&#("/&#' /6"2#8#!/ C"&.. * ''0%252.$&(1"2!""2#$# #($!("'2!$(%(%#/(<&"2"2# '0&"-/-#/"8!($2!$("#,#(7##(!7.#"-/$0%#!(8<&"(#''<&"2/#1!/$ ""2# !%""2!""2#-.!&("&

'3 !"2#/2!$7##(-''#''&( "2#'0&"-/-#/"85 "2#-.!&("&

2!$#,#/8/&12""-/"#%"'0%2-''#''&( + E&"2"2#6!&(&''0#$#%&$#$&( !,0/

5"2#"2#/ &''0#'<#/#!.'("2#.$&( !,0/ "2#$# #($!("'!($%('#F0#(".85"2# '0&"<!'$#%/##$&( !,0/

-("2#$# #($!("'2!,&(1 &.#$!(!--#!.!1!&('""2#!

/#'!&$ :0$16#("!($$#%/##5"2#.#!/(#$ &/'"!--#..!"#%0/"5!

"#/2!,&(1$0.8 ("&%#$"2#-.#!$&(1'!($2!,&(1/# #//#$"2#&''0#' /!6#$5!'!.'"2# #,&$#(%#.#$78"2#/#'-#%"&,#-!/"&#'57'#/,#$"2!""2012"2##("/&#'&("2# /#,#(0# /#%/$ %!//&#$ ! -/#'06-"&( %//#%"(#''5 2<#,#/5 '0%2 -/#'06-"&(<!'/#70""!7.#!($"2!""2#-.!&("&

&(2&'%/'';#>!6&(!"&( 2!$!%"0!..8!$6&""#$"2!"2#!($2&'7/"2#/<#/#("&(-''#''&( "2# '0&"-/-#/"8#(%#5&"<!'2#.$"2!""2#-/#'06-"&(!""!%2#$&( !,0/

A "2#/#,#(0#/#%/$2!$7##(/#70""#$78"2#-.!&("&

2&6'#.

5<2&%2"2# .#!/(#$&,&.G 0$1#2!$("%('&$#/#$

"<!' 0/"2#/ 0($78"2#.#!/(#$.<#/!--#..!"#0/""2!" "2# !"2#/

5=!/&($#/20$2!/&52!$($07"7##(/#%/$#$" 7# &( %0."&,!"&(1 -''#''&( "2# '0&" -/-#/"8 &( "#/6' 7"25 "2# 3%&> ;

!($"2#&' ()&5> ;

570"!$6&""#$.82# 2!$$&#$( A

2#/#!

"#/5"2#-.!&("&

<!'(<2#/#/#%/$#$"7# &(-''#''&( "2#'0&"-/-#/"8#,#(&("2#/#,#(0#/#%/$<#,#/5 7'#/,&(1"2!"7#&(1"2#'( =!/&($#/20$2!/&5"2#-.!&("&

(/6!..87# #>-#%"#$"'"#-&(""2#'2#' 2&' !"2#/570"<&"22&'<(!$6&''&("2!"

(#&"2#/2#(/2&'7/"2#/<#/#-''#''&( "2#'0&"-/-#/"85!1!&("2!"

&( #/#(%#G-/#'06-"&(5!.'$&$("2.$1$ C "&'"7#("&%#$2#/#"2!""2#.#!/(#$.<#/!--#..!"#%0/" &/'"

7'#/,#$&(&"':0$16#(""2!"#,#($# #($!("( 5:!&7&(125!--#..!("

7# /#"2!"0/"52!$!$6&""#$"2!""2#!--#..!("'2!,#(%(%#/(<&"2"2# '0&"-/-#/"85!($!''0%25(#&"2#/-!/"82!$7##(!7.#"#'"!7.&'2"2#&/ /#'-#%"&,#%.!&6'"&"<#,#/5"2#/#!

"#/5&"<!' 0/"2#/7'#/,#$"2!""2# $# #($!("'!--#..!("'7# /#"2# &/'"!--#..!"#0/"2!$7/012"!?%-8 !'!.#$##$$!"#$ *@5,&$#<2&%2(#2!(&(12<!''2<(" 7#/#%/$#$!'!%;<(#/!($"2!"!'-#/"2#%-8 "2#3%& /"2# 8#!/ ;C5> ;

5! G*/$'2!/#2!$7##(-0/%2!'#$78D0.$##-D!0/5 <& # :!&7&(12$# #($!("( 578 !.<&($#/D!0/5<& # !/(!&.

&(12 $# #($!(" ( !($ 0/6##" D!0/5 <& # 0/6!&. &(12 $# #($!("(* .$&(1"2!""2#%-8 "2#'!.#$##$<!'!-07.&%$%06#("

!($:0$&%&!.("&%# "2#'!6#%0.$7#"!9#(5"2!"0/" 0/"2#/<#("(" 2.$"2!""2'#%;<(#/'<#/#("6!$#!-!/"8""2#'0&" &.#$78"2# -.!&("&

5!($#,#((##92!($!($!("2#/ !/$##-&(125<2<#/#!.' /#%/$#$"7#%;<(#/'5<#/#!.'("6!$#-!/"8""2#'0&"

("2#!

/#'!&$/#!'(&(15"2#%("#("&( %0('#. /"2# !--#..!("<!' 0($"7#?&(%('(!(%# "2#1/0($' "2#!--#!.@5!($ "2#/# /#5"2# &($&(1' "2#.<#/%0/"<&"2/#1!/$""2#&''0# <2#"2#/ "2#-.!&("&

<!'#("&".#$"!$#%/## -#/6!(#("&(:0(%"&(/("5<#/# /#,#/'#$ &6&.!/.8 2.$&(1 "2!" "2# (0' " '2< "2!" "2# '0&" <!' 6!&("!&(!7.#&("2# /6&(<2&%2&"2!$7##( &.#$5!($"2!"2<"2#-.!&("&

2!$

" &.#"2#'0&"2!$("7##('2<(782&65!.."2#"2#/ &''0#'<#/#!.'$#%&$#$!1!&('""2#-.!&("&

5"2#/#78/#,#/'&(1"2# &($&(1

"2#.<#/%0/"%6-.#"#.8

#(%#52!,&(12#.$!'!7,#5"2#!--#!. "2#$# #($!("'<!'

!..<#$!($"2#'0&"

$&'6&''#$78"2# &/'"!--#..!"#0/"

("2&''#%($!--#!.5/!1/!5 .#!/(#$%0('#. /"2# !--#..!(";-.!&("&

52!'$/!<(!""#("&( "2&'0/"""2# !%""2!""2#'!.# $##$'/# #//#$"78"2#.#!/(#$.<#/!--#..!"#0/"!'-!/" "2#/#!'(

//#,#/'&(1"2#:0$16#(" "2#.#!/(#$&,&. 0$1# 0(&/ &,&'&(5 !"#21!/2!2&75 <#/#!%"0!..8#>#%0"#$!

"#/"2# &.&(1 "2#'0&"!($ "2#/# /#52#%("#($#$"2!""2#'!&$0/"<2..8#//#$&(/#,#/'&(1"2#<#.. /#!'(#$ &($&(1' "2#.#!/(#$&,&. 0$1#

/6!( !('!.5.#!/(#$%0('#. /"2#%!,#!"/';$# #($!("'

( "2#"2#/ 2!($5 /#&"#/!"#$ "2# /#!'(&(1 1&,#( 78"2#.#!/(#$ .<#/

+ !--#..!"#%0/"!($(!"0/!..85-/!8#$ /$&'6&''!. "2#!--#!.

A !,&(1 %('&$#/#$ "2# !

/#'!&$ !/106#("'5 !' !.' "2# :0$16#("' "2#.#!/(#$%0/"'7#.<5"2# &/'""2&(1<2&%2(##$'"7# '"!"#$&'"2!""2#'0&" &.#$78"2#!--#..!(";-.!&("&

<!'(#'##9&(1!$#%/## -#/6!(#(" &(:0(%"&( !1!&('" "2# /#'-($#("';$# #($!("' !($ ( $#%.!/!"&( !(89&($2!$7##(-/!8#$ / #(%#5<&"20"%66#("&(10-("2#%//#%"(#''/"2#/<&'# "2#'"!"#6#(" "2#.#!/(#$%0('#. /"2#!--#..!("5""2##

#%""2!""2# '!.#$##$/#.&#$0-(78"2#.<#/%0/"<!'#>#%0"#$! "#/"2#'0&"<!' &.#$5 "2!"'!.#$##$(#,#/2!,&(17##(#>2&7&"#$78"2#/#'-($#("';$# #($!("'&( '0--/" "2#&/%("#("&('5#,#("2012"!9#(3:0$&%&!.("&%# 378"2#

&/'"!--#..!"#0/"52<#,#/5#,#('5<2&.#$&'!1/##&(1<&"2"2# &($&(1'

"2# &/'"!--#..!"#0/"&("2!"/#1!/$5"2&'0/"7,&0'.8%!(("$&'%!/$ "2# &/'"/#!'(1&,#(78"2!"0/"5"2!""2#-.!&("&

2&6'#.

2!$!$6&""#$&( %/'';#>!6&(!"&(5"2!"(#&"2#/2#(/2&'7/"2#/<#/#&(-''#''&( "2# '0&".!($ #(%#5&("2#-&(&( "2&'0/"5"2#%("#("&( "2#.#!/(#$ %0('#. /"2#!--#..!("!($#,#(&( !%"<2!"<!'2#.$78"2#.<#/ !--#..!"#0/"<&"2/#1!/$""2#'!.#$##$'/#.&#$0-(78&"5#,#("0!..8 6!9#'($&

#/#(%#""2#0"%6# "2&'!--#!.5&(,&#< "2# !%""2!""2# '0&" &.#$78"2#!--#..!("<!'(.8(#'##9&(1!$#%/## -#/6!(#("

&(:0(%"&( !1!&('" "2# /#'-($#("';$# #($!("' 2#/# /#5 " /#-#!"5 "2# !--#..!("&(2&'%/'';#>!6&(!"&(52!,&(13%!($&$.8!$6&""#$3"2!"(#&"2#/2# (/2&'7/"2#/<#/#&(-''#''&( "2#'0&"-/-#/"85!($<&"2#,#("2# /#,#(0##("/&#'("/# .#%"&(1&("2#&/ !,0/70"&( !,0/ "2#&/ !"2#/5<2

$&#$( A

5'##(/#!'("2.$%("/!/8""2##''#("&!. &($&(1

"2#.<#/!--#..!"#0/"5""2##

#%""2!""2#!--#..!(";-.!&("&

%0.$("

'##9!$#%/## -#/6!(#("&(:0(%"&(52#2!,&(1!$6&""#$"2!"2#<!'("&( -''#''&( "2#'0&"-/-#/"8&(!(8%!'#

('#F0#(".85"2#!--#!.&'$&'6&''#$ 70"<&"2( /$#/!'"%'"' <#,#/5<2&.#$&'6&''&(1"2#!--#!.5&"&'6!$#%.#!/"2!" ("2&(17'#/,#$78"2#0/"'7#.<5!'/#1!/$'"2#"&".#""2#'0&"-/-#/"85 '2!..7#%('&$#/#$!'!(8-/-'&"&('#"".#$('0%2"&".#5&(,&#< "2# !%"

"2!""2#'0&" &.#$78"2#-.!&("&

<!'(.8(#'##9&(1-#/6!(#("&(:0(%"&(5 <&"2(F0#'"&( "&".#2!,&(17##(/!&'#$#(%#5!(8'0&" &.#$78!(8 -!/"85F0!"&".#""2#'0&".!($5<0.$7#$#%&$#$<2..8(&"'<(6#/&"'( !..!'-#%"' "2#6!""#/5<&"2!..'&$#'!".&7#/"8"/!&'#<2!"#,#/-.#!'!/# .#1!..8!,!&.!7.#""2#6&(!(8'0%2-/%##$&(1'5<2&%2<0.$"2#(7# %('&$#/#$("2#&/<(6#/&"'!($$#%&$#$

-9G(&"&( E2#"2#/'-#!9&(1G/#!'(#$ #'

E2#"2#/#-/"!7.# #'