← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/947/2016allowed

Swaran Singh v. Gurpreet Singh And ORS.

2022-11-22Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan13 pages

  

     





     !"

##$$ % & '& #  !" " 

#        ( 

 )*"   !"

+,  "##$$

    !+,  " #  

----  .

 &"$$+" "#$  

 !""/ &!",$&!  *"0&    * !# /11##  2 " ! 2 $$

   #"! &$& $$ 2&  ! * $2 $/ !34" &$$ 2&  !5* $ 2 $&,$$!6#& +7"$ 8/"+ ($9  * !# 2  6& 

   !  2$  !"$  1/1$ :#"#$   "$ * ! , 1 $*"

  

+; + 3 &  2 1   + 3 2!$ !"  <=# 

&2

  !",  "#$ +" "    ! 2 ""2 

 $$" $ $ "" "#$  $     $*"+ , !

+4 + 3 2 19" :&  !  "$:  / 

  #12 /$ $   2& /1" " 9  ! 2  " !  :& .& " ! "" &$$, " # "&# # 1"#$ "2:&

  !  "$9 5

 +"#$  1 $$ !!"$:&  !  " ,&  2* !#12  2  !/$ $  

/&  "     :#   "   /$1    !  "  $   :&  !  !22# /$2+"  + "  >&+" :&  !  $ :    2  5

     5  ,    !  

  "/* #! ! $! 2 $$ 

 9 5 "#$  2 #   "     ?   &/  !  +  @" +  ", !  /$   $    2&  :#  ":&  ! 

"$/&  2#  9"#$ !

5 "#  2 */ ? &/!  +@" /11 &$1 ,5 $!&$!$  5

" " &!""& $$$ !&# "   2     :& " $    !  !     ,&    "  #$     ;

 9  ", +  

;

 +" ! ""  /$1!"$ :&  !  ,& "#$ +"   "  >&+" "#& #:  25  

, $  !;

 "#$ # " & " &2 5 + 3+ "1+" " ,$ 2 1

+; + 3 2"#$ 9 ",  

" ! :# "  /$1 !"$:&  !  ,& "#$ + "  +"  >&" "#& #:  2 

    ;

 ,  ! 2 3  !    

 

#  "2 ! $ 9", +" $,  "# "&# # 1"#$  

/&

""  "2""  "# :""&$ #1"/"  ! &$& # &"#$ 9/&"       #1   1  2&     "     "  ! &$& $ # &9  ;

"#$    2 !"  "? &/!  +@"  2 #  "   $ !  "  /$   $         :#   

 :&  !  "$9" 2 #  "   2 4 # /&  & &##  2" #     "    9  "  "  #$   !    "  , !  !  "  #     2  A:&,  ! +  @"

  !"#$ +""$1/  1 $$ ! #  2"#   /&" /*&+!, !  & "2/  !"&

 +  "     ##      $   

2  1 !"""   1! 2 $$""  

  " ,$2& 

+; + 3  2 1    .& "  ""  :&  !  "$ ,& " :  / 5

 :  22 2"  >& # ",  " +" 

+ + 3 2"#$ +""""/  2"2  

 9"#$ "/ " "&2/2#  

2/$ *## $$ #  ## 9"    $< =# 

&2 

4+ 3 #/1" "#$  5

 9 "1+"#$  $/ "&2/2#  " 9"   $$ $1 "" $1 "&+""  ! " &# # 19""/   !" $ !"" 2$19" ,$&""&2 "   $*"9"#$ "

4 / "&2/2#  " /12 #   !"  "1$ 9"! 2 $$$$!$+ &$$ ,   &$     &     2 #    /  / !  "&   

 7"     $  *  , &  $!$  #$ "$$ ! !"2  /$1"& "#   29$&  "#$ /  !"&   !" &        " #$    /  !  "  &    ! 2   

>& &$$  $  // !"&    +  "            /$  .

 "   +  " # 1 2$"&



7"  #$   "  $  #$    ,  !  " $$!  "  2 "    !", 2   "#$

"#$ !"# +$$ !&   2

   



 

    

   

    

 

     

  

 !   

       

 

    

 "   

     # $$%&

    $ $    



  '        

(

)    



     



   

) * 

  

(     



) + #  7"#   >&## & $ " , 



.

  # ,"+"#$ !"2      (B  /  :2  !  "

&*",   !"   (B+ 2 ( 2  0& +! 1C$ *(B5+"

D    !"+ B  (B+"

 6 !"(B4+"

*"0&2 + B  +8/"(B "

E6!!  !"+C$ *(B

7"#$  $&# , &&2 $

;

D, +     2 *"  0&  "  :#  &  !"& "&  ##$ ", !/ $+ "  $!$  #  ,     / &!"       &  !  " , +  '& #    !"+       "  $!$  #  ,   !"2   B  ", A:

B 3+"## "$ "  2

 " $ $&, +$,   "C& # 5



 "  !"$ & $ "# +" $

 C& "&8

5 ,& "#$  !  " 9 &8      ,& "      !   "   9  &  8         &  "  "2  $##  2 " / !  "#$ 9&8 4   !  " 9&8 ! "  &$  ! $$"&+"&"#$  # /11##  2 "! 2 $$ >&  "  / !$!$"  " 2 *"0&   :&"$  ,& "#$   2"! 2 $$ , !"/$ $   " # "  2 " 2""6&!2 ": ""   " /1"2+$ !""+"#$ &$/$/ 1 :&  !  "$" &!"C& "   "      2    !+ $  !+2 !! ! # !"&# # 1 12

:#"#$  7"6&!2   #

 

F$ !!! ,/1"6&!2   +" )" "$ ##$ "C&   ?&!+($+""!

$  $  ?&!+($+",6&!2      

; #"##$+"6&!2   #/1"  $C&   >& $1+2"&"#$ "



8& "#$ $!! , " "$"#   !&$  ##$/ "C& +  ""& " #   ",##  " &!"& $

."," $ & $ "# /! !

" &!""  

7" $C&    !"#$ !"# + ", / &!"   /1"2"2" $&

""# "   $!$ ,$! 2 $$ 

 &  """ " ,&2 

+4 + 3 2"#$  2 1 " ! 2  &/>& $1 " &2 5 + 3 ;



 & " "#$ "/  1 $$ !#  2" #   /&"   &$ /2#$" /*&  2  :& ! ! "$ # !"/$   

2&   + 3+ "1 "#$   $ #    "  &  $   /1  1    #  #  2    ! 2 $$



"" " +"F ##$$C&  "/

 ",&$/ , :  !"# &   5 ".

 A, + ;& ""! 2  >&

 &$ &# &# " /1"#$  7" C& "& ""&2/2#  "##$$ 3 2 *"0& "/ !: "/$ *2###  #  "/1  !"/ * $  & " "$ $  #!8

"! 2 $$A:

( "/ #   $  + "/$ *## &$1"&2/2 */1*"0& +  .

"1+""6&!2   # /1" $C&  2"&$/1"#$ 

 "  !" !&2 , /1$ & $   "  #      ! !  " &!"  "   +  .     "  "  $&  ,/1" $C& $$"F ##$$ C&   "$$1  ""&$& 2" 21 7"&!""! 2 $$&#/1"#$     2$$"&#& &2 /&"22+ 

/  "  / ! &$ & 2 #  

 .    #   "  "&!"  "  ! 2      /1" ""#$ /&"/$$1 $      ! 2 $$ $  # + ""2 /!  /1:& $/1  ,& "#$ " !  0 $ $ $ / ! /1" ."  2

  $/1" +2&""&!"" ", !

  ! 2  $$/&"2", ! , 

+ + 3 2"#$  

 +""  !" $

"& " 2" "&2/2#   "##  "&!"$2 !""#$ "/ "2 2 /$ *## $$#  ##  D, +"/$ *## " 1  &$$ /1  $/&'& #   !"+  2 *"0& +""/ / &!"    "*"0&2  " $!$ #  , D" ##   " &  !":2    "+  "  "      "  ,    A:

B 3  .

 "   ,+" "2" 2 *"0& ", !     1! 2 $$""#$ + "  !""2" ,&2

+ + 3 2"#$ +""/ # "    <  = #  

&2    5

 +" 2"  *"  0&  "  &     &2    

4+ 3    "  $"&!" ",+"" #",  " *  "  2 /&" "  :2 +"2"!

&  ! 2 $$+""

  !"2+""## !,"  D"  "!

&  "  !

A:

(

D  "!

& , &#$   !! 2 A:

(





 .      "      "       "  $!$ #  ,""1",  1 2 $ !  "#$   &$! ! 1$$! ! 1 / 

7"&+ "       $1  2  "  "&2/  2#      " ! 2  "   !" 

$ 1/ ,"/$ * ## " 1&#/1"   2 &/  ,  !





"22+"     +""#& >& 2 *, "! & $2"#$  F $1  "! 2 $$A:

( +2  " 

# "#$! /$"  " , &    62/  "1   4+" " /

#  1#  "6 $ ./ !+"&$  ",#/$1$, "#  ""& *$ " +  ""    !    "2  "  "       

D, +# &$"! 2 A:

( !"""   2  " 

A, " +"  #  "$ +""""! $$""#$  "&$

",#/$1#&"2 # "  

;

7"#$  ",$/1"2A:

(B 3

# 8 4"  " "! 2 

" "! !,# "$ "2 " 1/& "   # "" 9""

   $$1!,"  " #"2/&"  ""   

7"2&/*&# 1 :#$ "#$ / !  # "&$ 



2 " !/ "#$ "# &/ $2& 

+4 + 3&"$2&  $*"!  

 " "1" !"$ :&  !  " 2"2 "1" :&  !  "$  / !##   2     1     "  #$1+  "  &    2$  &2 +"&$ ",/  7"  !, /1" "" ":# " "$#$  " 2 $ ,  !&  " &2 

2  &2 +"" &/ "2   "  #$   $2  "  # # 1+  ""    &/6  2   ! 2 $$, #$+"   !" "   $"&  !" 

# &$"  :2  #$    !"!""" & /$$$" 2 !"/&  !  "&$

.

 ,    "  &  &  /,+  .     " # "##$ /1 $ ?&!+($  2$"&$/1"#$ 2#$$1  6& 2$ $1+"6&!2 #/1" $C& !   !

$ ##  2  "#$  & /$

 5 D, +"#$ &  $$ , $    , 1  7"  +  "  6&!2         #  /1  $ ?&!+($    &  2 1

+; + 3"  < =# 

&2  2"$ !"&$$&$ $G " " &!"&    #    ,&    "  #$      !   "



B"&"2 +"#  ##$$/1" # $1$$  !$1



    @ 6  

 !"#$ %&"'

!()$*  "&#

 '# !+,

 "&#