High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3156/2014dismissed

Amar Singh v. Angrej Singh

2023-09-19Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti11 pages

"#$

""##$% &' # %

"#$

"% &'()*

+, -.* +- (--.

% ( )*$%+,$+$#-.$% /( )$.0+(+%%$#-.$% /%0$""##$%

( +%$*)+10)$++-.$%2+%0 ( &+30$$1$-.$% /%0"%

44444 +- (--./ +

0 $""##$%5/$% 6 *$ )+10 0$ /+# 1'#$ ).""$#$1$+%+*"'17'1*%$.$%

8 "$39#$+%+$#+%+.%'1-:'',0%$+20+.0%0 $""$#"/39*$)+106$""##$%5/$%0$3+*+ $%07'1*%$.$% !

"$39#$ ++# '1 ;)+ +++<- :'',0%$ + /$' / 17 )+10 6 "%5"#$+%+//2$'"0#

17 )+10 6 "%5"#$+%+// 0$ /+# '+% / "+392$9/".+/+."/*$./$1*%%##$%

8 1$+1 %0 #$ *$'+1 ?8- 3+1 5! 0$- .*"++,02$% >?5>@-,0$%+ !?5!=-,0$$ @ =;8 <- @=;8 <-@ ?;8 <-@!@;8 <-@!;8 <-8!>5@ ; ><-,+%%$>/%%$#

$$ >$"7$*$3$+/%09$===

+%'$%$%&+##$1 $#,0+-0+#0$$-+%+.%:'',0%$ !

0"#$+%+//'3*+%%%0$%%0/$%*$)+10+%0 2/$/*%+#$ 0/$%%+%$$1*%% ##$%

8+/$'/%0"#$+%+//$%%0$%/ #$." $.;%0$%+/8+10$< 0/$%0$A.'%5%0'*3*$,%0 $+$1*%+%0"./2+%+20+.0$'*/ ?#$. 2$ "$+ $ $% *9 0 $# 2$ % 3 A.'% $ 1+%

0/$%0$$#$1%0$%02'# .#$%0#$%$,/*)%$%$,/+$;)0$0$3$$.0<3/ A.'%+ / %0 $# ## %0 %* $ .+%+ 2 '#9 *%++%01*%%)##$%

?-%0 "#$+%+// *$+ "% + %0 //+. / )'3 1+%$5A.'%+ ($1+%$%$#12+%03$#$.$#.+$%+-3'%%0/$%+% %''"

#%+*$%#9-%0$*$9-%0"#$+%+//1%0+$//+$+%$%%% /* A.'%+ ($1+%$%- 0$$ /%2$- %0 /$% 2$ B'%%A.'%$1+%%0$#$"%0%*$ .+%+/1*%%)##$%

%#9%0+-%0 /$%2$$#1%+$%+12+%0*%$1%$#+$%%0 '+%#$$/%/$%+1%0+10%/%0"#$+%+// 0"#$+%+//2$$#2$9 3$9$2+##+1%"/*0+"$%/.%$.% 0"#$+%+//$# B'%%0/$%%A.'%$1+%%0$#3'%%0 /$%/'%+%0/+%2,/($9-

#%+*$%#9-%0 "#$+%+///+#%0"%'+%

%+./%0'+%2$1+%%0/$%20$""$+ %0+.$$/+#%02+%%%$%*%%$,+1%0%$%0$%%0'+%+% *$+%$+$3#C%0"#$+%+//0$#.'%$+%/+#%0"%'+%C%0

! "#$+%+//0$..$#%0%'$*$%+$#/$.%/*%0 '%C%0 "#$+%+//+%""%/+#$*$+%$+%0"%'+%390+2$.%$ .'.%C%0 '%0$7'++.%+%%9%0"%'+% *+%-+% +$*+%%%0$%0+2+"+/#$++"'% %+'3*+%% %0$%%0$1*%2$3%$+39"#$9+1/$''"%0/$%$ %0$2+1/$%$%0"#$+%+//2.'%*/(5($*

0$:0'0+ $*- **++1%$+.##'+2+%0%0$+

**++1%-%0"#$+%+//3%$+%0%0'*3+*"+/%0 /$% 0/$%.+$9$*'%+%%##0+ ""%9%+%$9$1*%%## %02+-%0$%/ %0#$+%0+##$1$%%0%+*/$##1$1*%2$ #$." $. 0$##11*%%)##+'#%//$'-%0/-%0+ B'%+/$+$2+##+1 ##%0/$.%$21$+

%2$"$9%0$%%0'+%/+#39%0"#$+%+//*$93+*+

* %0 "#$+1 / %0 "$%+- /##2+1 +' 2 /$*39%0%+$# '%

!""

!"#

&' &'

!"#

( )

%"%0'+%-%0"%"#$+%+//17 )+10A$*+0+*#/$D $'3*+%%0+$//+$+%A D 5

$#A$*+)'0:'*$)0$*$-2+%$D-$3$ E$#$D!$ $*)$$- $%0+#$-0$$$D8

0$/%-#$.'#/%0"#$+%+//.#%0+.

%3'%%0.$/%0"%"#$+%+//-%0 $""##$%/$%*$)+100+*#/%""+%%02+%3A$ D$'3*+%%0+$//+$+%A D5 $#A$*+ $*0 :'*$$D 0$/%-#$.'#/%0/$%.#%0 +.

2+% 2$ A$*+ + 3'%%$# +. 2- .%+/+."9/$# 8!5$%

0$3% +3'%%$#+.$($, 0$/%-3'%%$#+.2$.# !

/%0$+1%0$1'*%$$.39#$.'#/ %0"$%+-%0.++#'+%/+#39%0"#$+%+//17)+102$. 2+%0.%39"$+1+*"'17'1*%$.$% !

#+1$11+/%0+'+%-%0/$%*$)+10/+#.++#$""$# 3/ %0 #$ +%+$# +%+.% '1- :'',0%$ 20+.0 2$ +*+39"$+1+*"'17'1*%$.$%

#+1$11+/%07'1*%$."$39%0%2 '% 3#2-%0"%1'#$.$""$#0$3/+#39$""##$% /$%

0$ 0$ %0 $1'*% / #$ .'# / %0

? $""##$%/$% $ 2## $ #$ .'# "%+1 %0 "%"#$+%+// 0 #$ .'# / %0 $""##$%5/$% $1'%0$%%07'1*%$.$%

8"$39#$ +%+$#+%+.%'1-:'',0%$+*++1%0$""$#/+#39%0 $""##$% $ ./+*+1 %0 7'1*% $ . $% !

"$39%0%+$# '%++0%#9$3+%$9-'7'%$%'%$+$3# +%09/#$2 /$.%-%0$1*%%##++"'%$%

+'#%//$' 0$""##$%5/$%%,".+/+.%$+0+2+%% %$%*%%0$%%0"#$+%+//$2##$%0$""##$%5/$%2%0 .'%*/(5($* 0$:0'0+ $*- **++1% 0 $+.**++$1%%,0+%0'*3+*"+$3#$,"$"+ 1/$+%0$#$%%0$+3#$,"$"2$.%+%$1*% %##$%

8+.+$.2+%0%0"%5"#$+%+// .+ ?#$.$$%*9 %+21#9.#$+*+%0 $1*%%##%0$%%0$%/#$2$ #$."$. /$.%-%0 $#'/%0#$+%0$+$$2$$3'% #$."$. 0 "%5"#$+%+///$+#%"%0A.'%+/$1*%%## $%

8A #+$..'#0$3"#$.%0$+ .'*% $3$E$#-%0*$1+$#2+%A$*+39%0"#$+%+//$ D!++%%2+%$0+%%+*9.$%3$/#9#+'"

0 #$ .'# / %0 $""##$%5/$% $# / % %0 %$%*%/$3$E$#D!200.#$+*%0$%%0.+3/%0 .'*%2$)'+)+10 /$.%-$"%0"#$+%+//F2+- %0.+32$$*#9)'0:'*$)0$*$-20+A$*+$D

0 #$ .'# / %0 $""##$%5/$% $# / % %0 %$%*% / )'0 :'*$ )0$*$- D+% D 20 /'%0 .#$+*%0$%+%2$1%%9"/*$2$)0$*$-9"+%20+%

> A$*++%0"%.$ 0+/$""##$%5/$%1$+1 /$' 0$ *$+ '3'%% 0 #$ .'# / "%5"#$+%+// .A$*+ *$ )+10 D %0+ "+% 0#$.'#/$""##$%5/$%$#/%%0 .'.%/"%5"#$+%+//20/+#%0'+%,+1"+39 2$9/".+/+."/*$./$1*%%##7'%/2$93/%0 A"+9/"+/#+*+%$%+ 0$/$+#%A"#$+209%0'+%2$ %/+#$#+ 0$""##$%5/$%*$)+10%""+%%0 2+% 3A$ D% " 0+ 2 + + ++ $# '""% 39 $*0 :'*$ D 0 %+ +. / %0 $""##$%5/$%0$321#9+12+%0'%$93$+ %+ "$9%0$%%01'#$.$""$#"/39%0$""##$%5/$% *$9,+#93$.."%$%07'1*%$."$393%0%0

'% 3#2 *$9 ,+#9 3 % $+ $ %0 '+% /+# 39 %0 "%5"#$+%+//*$9,+#93+*+

0#$.'#/%0"%5"#$+%+//+0+3+/ $1'*%"+%'%%0$%%0/$.%/%0.$$%0.'*%$'#9 " . 39 #$+1 .+.+1 +. 0 A.'%+ / $1*%%##$%

8A $"$9*%/$%*9 +'#9".39A$*++1%0"#$+%+//17)+10$D $2##$%02+%)'0:'*$)0$*$$D$*$1+$# 2+%$3$E$#$D!

%0$%/+A/%0A.'%+$ 1+%$%+ / $# +

?- %0 "%5"#$+%+// 2$ "%+%0//+./)'3 1+%$-0$$2+%0%03$#$.$# .+$%+3'%+%2$%0$""##$%5/$%20+%%''"- %0/-%0"%5"#$+%+//1%0+".*$,392$9/ $//+$+% $%%%39 A.'%+($1+%$%- 0$$$%

@ A $*)$$- $%%00+#$-0$$+$#A$*+$ D8%"%0+/$.% 0/-$##%0/$.%$$%+%0"#$+%2 '#9". %2$/%0$""##$%5/$%%%$3#+0%0 %$%$,390+*1$+1/$'20+.000$*+$3#9/$+# 0 #$.'#/%0"%5"#$+%+//%'""%0+$1'*%0$ #+'"%0$'%0+%9.+%+

+.$%+%# 0$

22 &!

"#$ !

3$ 24-20+%0$%.$G

* +

- .

* ,

/ / +

* 0

0/$.%/%0.$$%0+..2+10%#9 .+ 39 %0 '% / #$ ++# '1 ;)+ +++<- :'',0%$$ %0 '+%/+#39%0"%5"#$+%+//2$ +10%#9 .$%0$""$#"/39%0$""##$%5/$%*$)+10 2$$#+10%#9+*+++*"'17'1*%$.$%

8 0.+%%/++1/3%0%0 '%3#2%B'+ $9 +%/. % + "$9 %0$% %0 $""$# "/ 39 %0 $""##$%5/$%*$9,+#93+*+

0$.+%0$1'*%$$.3/*$ 0$1%0'10%0%+$# '%/+#.$/'##92+%0%0$3#$+%$./ 3%0%0#$.'# %0+.$-17)+106"#$+%+///+#'+%

/"+392$9/".+/+."/*$./$1*%%##$%

8A 1$+1?8-3+1 5!0$-1$+1%0 #$3$+1:0$$ @ =;8 <-@=;8 <-@ ?;8 <-@!@;8 <-@!;8

<-8!>5@ ; ><-:+%%$>/%%$#$$ >-$"7$*$3$+/ %09$===

+%'$%++##$1$#,0+-0+#0$$-+%+.% :'',0%$ $1$+% %0 /$% *$ )+10 " %0 %* / $1*%%##$%

8A -%0#$2$$1%3# 39%0"%$""##$%*$)+10$%%0$%/ #$."$. "%0%*/$/$+$1*%%##- ?#$.2.+39 %0 $""##$%5/$% $ $% *9 $ %0 $% /+A / %0 A.'%+$1+%$%+/$#2$

)/$$%0 20+"/#$++"'%+..-%0$*+%+"'%

*+%%#9-%0#$+B'%+2$239$""##$%5/$%*$ )+10 "9/7$*$3$+/%09$===

+A !

0'2$ %0 "#$+%+// % " %0 A.'%+ / $1*% % ## $%

8A $+%+.0$1%0+'-17)+106 "#$+%+//0$%""+%%02+%3A$D ./+*%0/$.% %$%+%0"#$+% 0$/%-0A$*+)'0:'*$)0$*$- 2+%$D20./+*%0$%%0$1*%%##$%

A 2$.+3390+*$%%0+%$./*$)+10+/$'/ 17)+10 /%2+%+1-+%2$$$A"#$+%3%0%0 "$%++%0"./*$1+$#2+% /'%0./+*%0$% *$)+10.+ ?#$.$$%*9+0+".$ %0$/%-$//+A0+%0'*3+*"+$+%2$$#+13917 )+10$2##$39%0*$1+$#2+% /'%0./+*%0$%%0 $+$1*%%##$%

8A 2$'#9%+0+ 1+%$%+$# =$%

8$%0$+%92$$#

= %0'*3*$,39*$)+10 "$%/*%0+-/%0*$1+$# 2+% $3$ E$# D! 0$ $# %"" +% %0 2+% 3A % ./+*%0$/$+/$.% 0/-%0"%5"#$+%+//A$*+ %0.+3$2##$%0*$1+$#2+%%"%0'A.'%+/ $1*%%##$%

8A 0 $""##$%5/$% 0$ %$, %0 %$ %0$% %0+ $1*%%##+$'#%//$'$(5($* 0$:0'0+ $*-

**++1%*$$1%3%$+0+%0'*3+*"+$3#$, "$"$%0$/%-%0$+3#$,"$"2$.%+%$$1*% %##++"'% +%0$.+%0$%*9 /'%0 %,%0%$%0$%%0*$1+$#2+%A$*+39%0"#$+%+//+

$3$E$#D!+$+%%2+%$0+%%+*9.$%3 #,+% 0'2$0$+#9%0$""##$%5/$%%"0+ %$%$,+%02+%%%$%*%1$+1/$' *$)+100$ %""+%%02+%3A$D$ $*0:'*$$D /'%0 ./+*%0$%*$)+10'%##0+"'.2+%0(5($* 0$ :0'0+ $*- **++1%20%0"%5"#$+%+//2$$# ##+10+."

(/$.%%0$%*$)+10$17)+102##+1 %0+"'.2+%0(5($* 0$:0'0+ $*- **++1% .$% 3 %$% $ $ '"+.+' .+.'*%$. %0 A.'%+ / $/$+$1*%%##-(5($* 0$:0'0+ $*- **++ 1% $ % %0 3/+.+$9 0 $/$+ $1*% % ## $%

8 A 2$ A.'% 3%2 %0 %2 +++'$# % + .**#9%0$%%0*$1+$#2+%$+%0,2%%0## %0"'.0$ 3+'#9-%$12'#.*/2$%3$ *$1+$#2+%+$.'*%%20*0+%,2 0/-%0 2+%$''$##9,2%%0"$%+$%0+/$.%.$%3%$%

$$'"+.+'.+.'*%$. "$%/*%0+-*/$.%%0$%$3$E$# D! 39 *+%$, $* %0 2+% $ )'+ )+10 + % '//+.+%%3'0$+%0%++.#39%0"%5"#$+%+//

%0+.$-)'0:'*$)0$*$2+%0$%""+%%0 2+%3A$D%"0+2+3+1.+3/$1*% %##$%

8A %0.$+0$-%0$1*%%## $%

8 A + .+3 39 1'#$ 2+% 20 + A$*+$D$00$$#./+*%0$%%0+.'*%2$'#9 %+0+1+%$%+$# =$%

8$%0$+%9 2$$#%0'*3*$,39*$)+10 0+/$.%+'//+.+%%+.$ %0%$%$,39%0$""##$%5/$%%0$%0+%0'*3+*"+2$ 3%$+ $ 3#$, "$" 39 0+ .**++ $1% + 1 /$+%0

0/-%0$""##$%5/$%0$/$+#%"%0%$%$,39 0+*+%02+%%%$%*%1$+1/$' 0.A$*+$%+/ *$)+10D/'%002%0$%%0%$%$,390+*+$/% %0'10% . 0 .$* % ,2 $3'% %0 $1*% % ## $%

8A -0+%%9%.$9"$.0$9$%0/+# $9.*"#$+%%%0"#+. 0/-.++1%0$/$+/$.%'$# "+%+-%0%$%$,39%0$""##$%5/$%1$+1/$'2$ +10%#9+3#+393%0%0 '%3#2 0 "%5"#$+%+// $ D ./+* %0$% 0 2$ $#2$9$9$2+##+1%"/*0+"$%/$1*%%## " %0%*/$1*%%##$%

8A -%0$%/+A/ %0A.'%+$1+%$%+/$#2$

%0$%$9-0 2$"%+%0//+./A.'%+($1+%$%-0$$2+%03$#$. $# .+$%+ % "/* 0+ "$% / $1*% % ## 3'% %0 $""##$%5/$%*$)+10+%%''" 0$/%-01%0+

$//+$+%$%%%/*A.'%+($1+%$%-0$$%0$*$9 20+.0+A 0+/$.%+$#".39A$*++1 $* )$$- $ % %0 0+#$- 0$$ $ D8 0 .'.% / "%5"#$+%+//.#$#902%0$%02$$9$2+##+1%"/* 0+"$%/$1*%%##%0$%/+A %+%+"'%%0$%%0 '+%/+#39%0"%5"#$+%+//+2##2+%0+%0"+/#+*+%$%+

+2/%0/$.%$.+.'*%$./%0"%.$-$ +.'$3%0+.%1+39%0 '%3#2+3$"" $"".+$%+/%0/$.%$%0+.. %/+$9 $ % +$1 2+%0 %0 /++1 1+ 39 %0 '% 3#2

..+1#9-%07'1*%$.$% !

"$39#$

++#'1;)++++<-:'',0%$$%07'1*%$. $%

8"$39#$+%+$#+%+.%'1-:'',0%$ +*++1%0$""$#-$$..+1#9'"0# 0+'3%$%+$# B'%+/#$2/$.%$++1+%0+$""$# B'%#9-%0 1'#$ ).$#""$#/+#39%0$""##$%6*$)+10%$+*+2+%0 .%

0"0%."+..+/*%0%2 '%3#2 3%3$.,%%0..B'$% +1$""#+.$%+;<+/$9-$#%$+"/

+- (--.

+,56* D0%0"$,+15$

D0%0"%$3#