High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5873/2015disposed of

Mohinder Singh & ORS v. Nachhattar Kaur & ORS

2019-09-10Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh9 pages

!"#$%&'() %%*!)(($

!"# & ' !"# $" +++++ %*!)(($,& ( %%' $ $$ ) "

" '

' "" )+ (* )+ *

%" )+

"% " $- .*

- ")+

%(*# ".*"'- """

" / - )

-" $$ % )+ ""

% 0 1*"'! 2*"

# ".*"'- """

" 3 ) !

$# *%+

' !$" " "

5 "- * ' 6 % - " # %% ' " " 898!4

' %"* "- * ' 8:- -$ " '%6 %% 8 $ .

+ 9858

' !

""% #"

' %

. -

)

% 5 % "- * ' % - 4

' "

" + 9959 % # ') " "

% "

" % # ' ) " $%

' ;*"< %%"

" 9

#* $%

" &* - = * &* - = * ;*" '

" < %% "

" 99

#* $%

> $%

! +)

+ 5! - 6 -* - $%

) "> $%

%$ +

%$ * "> " "

' ""

$ $%

- *

+ # ' ? * > $"," "

%" - ' $% +). $ -

+@%* " " 898

*"*-3

-$%-" #*"? #! ) "- "

' !

" >.

5 % - * ' 6 % - "

" .

+ 98584

$ - " - $ ">.

' ?-

" $ ;%* # $ , % " * 6 %% 8! '% " 4

' ! " "

% " % ) " )+ 4

' %% -

" $%

#)" "

$ + "

- * > $%

%"$%

' " 6 $%

%# ' #-

" -

% (* -" * $"*" $ .*"'-

"(*

""$$* + ""* # "?

# ' "*% $ % ' -

% "!

%(*."%

$ * % " % "% $- .* $ +" A#* %%+! *

- " % # ' $ ) ) " ) ! $$ %$ ")+** *%

% 0 1*"'! 2*"

$$%% (*

%(*

%% % ' "

%" $$ % (*% $ #

%+ "" $ + "

$* #%#" $ $$ $%

# )- , 6 ,, 8 5 " )+

' ; ) *'

" " 898 (*% *%" '* $.

+ 9858!%# $;!4

' !

) ">.

"")5 "-$ '6 ,, 858" )"

3 * '*" %% 5

%*"

' $ "" ) . "

"6 *-)!#+5 *%") "-") $ #+ . % "*% $#" 5 ;%* #$ . % " $

/ "

' *%!

% "+ "

"6 *-)!

' "% #$ * "

B* $ * )" " 3 # -%+ '*" ) (* #

%" $$

#+ ' $$ # " *%+")+ %"

"% #+ $$+%" *' *'

" %""!

' "

" B* $ ' ) %"" B* ;

" % ' $# / > $+ ! C C ? *%" *

$$ (* # *)B* .

+ 98588!9 5 !9 5 8!9 5 !9 5 8

">.

$ "")5

4 '

$ "

$*"6 *-)3 ""

! '*" %% "$* *" " 898 5 6 ,, 8!

' -* " )

" % "" *%" $.*"

' $%

, *)

$" -* ; '* % $$+ " - "

%$*$

%% "#* (*% $ ' $"! +! *$$"

'"")+ (*

*)- %$ %%'"%"% ")+4

# %""$$*"")+ $%

#"% #"

' !

) " + $ ' B* , 4

$*" 6 *-) " *$

' ! - *"" )+ $%

" - &* - = * 3 * '*" (* # ' %+ %" )+ %+ '*$ ".*"'- ;$ C"% #+ $$+C*" / - % "% #+ $ $$+! !

' $ B*

' ) " 898 *)- - ")+*% #

%"$# + $ "

- * * + 83 '*" $ .

+ 58 A;0 ! $%

# "")5 6 ,, 8! !B* ) ' "

"6 *-)" 3

* '*" $%

#)"") % "

" 6 *-)! -$%

* "%

'% $ $ ,

% %+ )+;$% $$"" / $

% !98 (*% ! $%+! *%" '*

- $%

" $B* ,

%% "! + *%")-. 6 ,, 85 8 " + *%" ) % # % $ )+ ' * $ $"

'! "

3 *

'*" 4

' * #)

"") ;%* #$

"6 *-) ; , 4

' !

6"% #+ $ * " 3 # "*% $ !$*" $ $5)6

"$ "*-*$$% ""* ' * '!

)#* ")+*% $ 3"

$* )%+!

5 % -$ ' 6 ,, 8 - * ' 8 -

! $"

" "

"6 *-) ; , ! ) %" .

+ 9858A;, "*)B*.

"> "

$*"% ")%'" * ) '"+ $ # %+ " " > B* " % "" $$*"" )+ *'

" "*-!

- $B*

$*" *-) ) # "

" % "% #+ )+4

' (*% $" "

$*" - " .

$"*"" $">

%# $ ;! A;, + 98583

!%*- /"5 $

' !

">.

$*"6 *-)

5 ; , "

">.

' ; ,

%% 5 #)"") - (*% $" "

$*" #+ 5 "-") #+ . % "*% # "" 5 ;%* #$ -3 '

# *- !

' "% # '$ B* %" ) *'

" %""

' > ) '!

' ) '

% "+ $ % " 4

%% *%"

B* -$% ' B* 4

' ) % "" $#" " 3 # - ! 3

" - (* #-- " ' $# + )+

' "

% "+ "

%%) '5 ! !

B* "% #+ $$+)+ -

' > (* #*"$# / %%+ )*

* $$

' $ $* *" *'

" %"" 5 "") . % "! "-") $ "

$* ")+

' *' % """

" 898(*% $"

%" + $" #

% ) - " )+ 5

#* 5 "") . % "! 5 %% ' % " ) *'

" %"" "% # %$ +

%$ %"$ "- 6 %-$% "# " +

> ) ' (*

")+*% $" * "% $ $

*6 '% $ * % .

+ 58! %# -

' * ! - 6 # " %% 5 "

$*"6 *-) "" )

"% " *

"" ) ;%* # % " - * ' 8: - * % % " - * ' 8 "

$*" 6 *-)!

6 #+ $ "(#%+!

" $B*

' ; , "

$*"6 *-) $"! + *%")-5 "

$*"6 *-)3 # ! * -

)% )+ / $

% !98 ) - ! *!." >

" "

" '-* " ) *'

" " 898 *%") %'

%B*"+ - $ $* "% "> "

% -* "*- %

; '* % $$+)* ""

' #*" %% "$*$3#

)#!.*"'- ""$ ")+ (* ) %% " *

'%+ "*% %+!

"% ")5 ; ,

6 ,, 858

5 " ;)+ 4

*" ) ! $$ $ %+ %% "

"-!% # ' $ )

D0&*% E < $ ', " +, < $ )% +,