Ashwani Kapoor v. Intelligence Officer, Dri
!
"#$# %&'()'')
*+ !
! %',)'') -./
))
# # % 0$2$ 33
4 )))
$* %!
%
( /-/
))
# # % 0$2$ 33
4 )))
$* %!
%
& 53 ) ---
!"
#$#"
%&
$'$# #$#"
( )* +(
,(-
*&
.
/0. / 1 --4) 3 ) +4
!"
#$#" %(1+5 / 1
$'$# #$#" / & & %(
1+5/ 1
+(
4/ 164/ 78""71437$97#$#": & ) &
!"
#$#" # 3 0( 8#-4 + 0) ) + 4/ 1645/ 78""71437$97#$#" + ( 9 ";9<;<;
<( 9! #
++/ 1
+ = +
0%& )) / (* /.1
0+ (++ (+(0)0 +
& ) ++ + +
/() .6+*"" $ $"#$#" /(+ & ) + +
0%& (0# 89;=/< 9$$ ';>(<#$$ ;>(< 9$$ # ';>(<"$ "$ ;*-<"$ ;
(/ <9$$ 9# ;
( / < "$ #8 4?/ "$ 9 ;6 < 9$$$ ; 6 < 9$$ # ; 6 < "$ ;5
<"$ #$ ;5
< #$ " ;5
< 9$
!;@ <"$$ #;@
<#$$ 9;@ <9$$ 9 ;( / <#$ #$;( / <9$ "; ( <"$$ #;= > /
< 9$$ # ;= > /
< "$ 9;= >/
<9$ ;= >/
<" ;/
<9
9 ;/
< $" + ( (
& (73 (14 # #!"!87 ( 0 &) + + (0 ( ( A ) -1 B )0/ 1( ( 9! #/(+( 1+ +(0
%& )07
0%& / & & ;
$'$# #$#"<
;
!"
#$#"<
3 ( ;
!"
#$#"< 0 )
(
(%& +
1
/() $ $"#$#"/(+(+ / 1 (
%& $ $"#$#"3 ) %& +
C . ()00 #$9$
#$99+A + ( #'.
( 0#$#" $.
( 0#$#" ( /() ) 3 & ( )( )0 ,+
0) " 3 ( / & & ;
$'$# #$#"< / && )
( %& 6
) + $ $ #$#"
++A + ( +
)( $ $ #$#"3
/ && /() 06((& +6 7&
+ (: (+ 1 4!!9 '$$""
3 1
*( +4 : &1 (
)(&+ /(+(+ 1 (&+)0 +
)0/ && &)0( ( ( , +
0) 5 ( / + (+ (+ %& $ $"#$#"6 %& +
C . A
0( 0 #$9$ #$993++A + 3 #'.
( 0#$#" $.
( 0#$#"
01+0 /() 05)+D( )( + + + )0 +
)) )(( 0( 3 /() A
0#$ 0 ( 0 +0( ( ( / 7 3 C ( 0 &/ && %& 0 7 3 %& ()&& / & & : 0 %&
/ && )( +7 &++A + ) (++++ 1 3(+ ,+ ) ( ) D(()01+ + +06( + : ( )+ ) &+ ( ) 0 (+ + ( + 0D(3 0) E / & & ( ) 6 )%& +
A + ( '!" "#/
$ $ #$#" )(++D(
(
00/ && /() $ $ #$#":( (& 6 7&
()(+1 4!!9 '$$""
/(+ (+ 1 (&+)0
)0 / & & 3 /()
A
0#$ 0 (
(A 3(+ ,+
++ D(6( ( 3 ) + ( + 0 D( 0) ' 1 ( 8 3:F)( (
0 ) (( + D()0() +(+ 0) 3 + ( + 0)
+ (3 A ,(+ ()
G
!"
#
$ % "
!"
&
!" ' ( ) "*
!" ! "
#$
% "!
" !"" & # &!
"!"
$
"&"
'
%
("
% ! "
#$ #
&
)
"#
"!"!
""( $("! ("
!"
$
"&"
" # " !"% $" "$ # &""
& " "& ! "
#$"
$
"&" !# " "(
$
!"# !"
$"& "
& " $
! &
$!"
*& ! "
#$)
# ! !
!"
$
"&""( !!
"#
'
%# "
" (! ! & !!
"$ #
&"
"
"
$""*
"$ # &
! "
#$) ( ("
"&
!" & ! "
#$
$!" "$
!"
(! ! & !!
)
(
%
"( "(( !
"$ # $""*
"
$"&
"( "
$
"&" ! # " "( & " "
!$
!"
$
"&" +"
% ( !"
$
"&" "
'
"
!
% # $(% !"# & " "& ! "
#$
!
/ 1%&
1
+ /() : ( + (0
# #!"!87 ( ( /(+ ( + ) $ $ #$#"
A / && ( '!" "#7
/
(
( +4+A ) ()0/ & & + + 0/ && /() $ $ #$#"1 A
0#$ /() 0 (
(A 6 %&
C . )A + + + A +
C
0 (0 #$9$ #$993
#'.
( 0#$#" $ .
( 0#$#" /() 04 +A )()0 + + : /( ) A
0#$ #0 (
(A 1+0 %& $ $"#$#" 9$ 5(&+ + (+++ %& / &&
( ) ( )0 )0
)0 / && 4
)1+ + +0+ )( ) 0&
0 ""$ )A +)/ &&
)$"$9#$# $$ #$#"+0 ( ( 0
D( 99 6( + 7 3 7 3 (+ + ( ( ( &/() ( 9#
( ( ( ) (+++ +A + ) ( ++ )++
) & 1 )0
+ D( 0 )3
)( 3 + ) & + ( ( + 0D( 9 1 (1 3
:)
) 0 (+) 3 (
,( (
) ) (()0 0()
6--7 '()'') - .8
0$*
9#%:;0
$ % !& $;