← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/46889/2024allowed

Sherjang And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2025-01-07Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat24 pages

 



 !"!#!$!! !!#! 

#

#%% & '( (

) 

   

 



 

   )* ))

 

 



    

 



  ! ) 

"      

 



  #  ')

$

     

 





  % )**)



   &     

 





  '  ')

( 





 

  

 





  )  

   *   +     

 



   !& +",( -(-(-.!/!   , -  .

   & /



- 0    .

 & /.

1- -2#'334

5# - 6  

.

 & /.

1- -2%!4%%

5# -  " .

  & /



-     .

 & /.

-   .

 & /  78 1- -2%43

5#

1- -2'5)%'

5#

- 9 &  6 .

 & /  78 1- -2%!!%

5#

1- -2''3525# - -   .

 & / 1- -2')'%25# + 

  .

  & /



- &

  .

 & / -  / &.

 & / - "

.

 & /

- 6  .

 & /

  

-  

 " .

+6.

 

* (-(-.!/! 0 (1 234  9

 

 

 0 &

 

& .

.



:-5267 52 8(-

29 52:0)* ))



;!5 <.=>2!772?3 528(-

29:0   )  



;"3?  -%75 8(  - 

29:0  ')



;-2 2@.58( -

29 52:0 )**)



;

-=53  .=>2  -%75  75A  8(  - 

 29    52:  ')



;$>%2.5  528(-

29 52:0 / & 0 

 /

#3

";

 

  /

 /  0

/ <= ;

 !4



5)5#  / 52".

#54.

#5.

#').

#'3

#)

=1 

  / 

1   .

+/ 6 

7 > 28  

  

.

.

.

 



;62-%75B62 #58(-

29:

 

0

 

.

 .

  

 

 0



 <=.

.

<= ;

 !4



5)5#  / #54.

#5.

#').

#'3.

#).

52"

=1



 / /

)

 !78708

& 



/.

433.

 / 

1   .

+/ 6  .

 

! 9 <=   /  0 

   /

+ 

 .

 

-? (  "  @@.

6  .

 .

 



 

  



 &

&   

  /  /  53 =

  .

"  .

 



  

 0.



 - 

.

A .

0

 .

( 



 7 8



   



 



))

  -







 





 " 

     .

" 

  $

>



/ /



 

 #% / 

&

0 &  

 ?



  /B

 



/

 =

 

   





!553

>/

0 

  

  

 ?    

 #5 /   /

" 

B



 0  

&



  



 

   

/   

0 



)     =

55.

   /



  

 ? 

 

 

  

   / B 

 "  

 

.

@@

   

 

 

0 

  

& 

    /

#4 /





.

?//   / 0 



B  

/ /



+91.

 

0 

>/





#    /& =





 & /

   / 



-

;

 #3% 0/



/   / / /  /

    

.







 //





 /

&

 



&  

   /



/

&   A  0

  .

<=



       # @ 

    

0

1- -2#'334

5# 

;-5267 52 8(-

29 52:

  





 

 >  )3

  % -



 &  

& + .

9   .

+/ 6   = C/ 0 53.

  

  /

    >/

D



5

   -



  D @@  

0 

.

/   

&



0 

   0

 ;

 '3%



%5%53 >/

0  

.

//

   @@.

.

-? (  "  @@ 9 

0 

  

   

 

 9

    

  





 %4'

/ 





 0 /  0 

  



%5%53

&   

    

 

   B

  

/



0

& 

 0 

  



%5%53 E& .

  



 

  / 

  .



>/

 

  

0 

   E& .

   B

    

 / /

 &  

  @ 

    

   

& /B

  / 



!553

>/



;

 #'%



553

 >/



   @@ 9 

>/

 5

   -



  

' /B

  

 /  

553 @ 

       

/



  

 @@





 

 

 

 

 

0 

  



55 7 > 2!8



   

/  & @ 

& 

   

 /  

 5 



>/





553 7 > 28.

 /&





  7 > 2#8 



1& F

7F  +&     

;$5C"=%32,,8(!<D2 52:( = /.





  7 > 2#8.



 

   @@ 



 //   /

 B  

      /

 



   





!553 E& .







 

  / 



 

  = /.

   

 & 

 

  .

/



 

>/

>/

  = /.

   

    

 /

   



!553

& >/

0 

  

 9.



& .

 





/ .

 

      /

 



   

 >/





553 &   7 > 2%8 % @ 

     0     

   

 /

0 1&      9

   



/

 C  !4  



1&  / .



     /



/



  

1& F

7F+8    9

    

   /

  0 

+/ F

.

6  .

/  

 /  

&.

 

0  5!

.

  

  <= 



0B

&

/

0 &

 

/



& /  



/&

 0   = /.

<=.

 /

& 

 53

55

/&   /

& 

 

<=



 / 5G 

<=



    0  5!

 ' @ 

     0   <=.

  0  

   





!553

>/

0 





  

 

 



 



55 7 > 2#8.

    

/

    0



   





  !553 9.

& 0



<=

0 & 

/ 

  /

/&  



0 /

   )  

.

& .



/ 

  



!553







&   

&

    

&

 

 @ 

         0/ & 

0 

/ 

/ 

0 

 

  

 

 

/

#54 =1

  /  .

  



 

0

/&

  /  

&  E& .



/& / 0 

  

 

   

0  .



   

/

   /

/  









 

& 

/.

/ / & 0 

0  3 @ 

     0   

  &

<=.

     /&

  0

&

 

/  

 /

 &  &

//  /&  9   $



"  



/&  7 > 2#8

 55



  

//



& 0  

  /

.

  

/    /

   - &.

/  0

/   &  /

/

   



0 B  4 @ 

     0  

.

 

  / 0  //

&  /&

  

/  

 / 

&.

   

 /&



/ .

/

 & &   /  

 /.



  /    /



0

/

/   9  D0  



-  

     

 !

!

 "# 

,2 

  



 

 

     

    

 

  

 !

    !"   

   

      #$ $ %&'! ()$ (*'  

'  +,   -.// -  !

!

 0 012-.// - (

 .3( 45 6$ 7' -..- - !

!

 /12-..(8

- (

0 !89

7''$:&  (, ;

-..0  !

!

 "

1 -..0

(

-.# 

  78 8  4  $,   $  98)  +,

8 -..

 !

!

 

12-..

(

 0.-   (  4  7  $  !'   +, &



 -..

-  !

! 

  0 1  2-..

/  (

 - #  !'7''$( 4 < 49 -...

 !

!

 -

12-...

 (

0. )  )  =   $7

,) 

 !

!

-12

 (

 .35 6!'   $( 47 

 !

!

 #/#1 >

#  (

 - /3    :

  $  '6  :8  

- # !

!

 # 01 

- / (

 #0  ?8)8) @

A$ ( 48

5B8 

# #  !

!

  ."1

- +C

  "01  2

-  (

 -    

%       & '

() 

 !# 

 



 

%  " * 

    



   "% 



    "

  * 

 



 +   % 

!

 # %  !  #   

         

  ,  



"   

 "                    !

"    

       

   

 



%    #    #

  

   "   

 

 '

() 

 " !#   

 !    %# 

  

   !

 #  -

 # *

  

   %   #     

       !     

   "

 !!



 '

(# 

%#  %!             

          #  !

" # !      '

( 

      !

      

         

  

  .  

  "      

 

%

  "   #

      !  

 

%     

    ! /

 

 #  

"

#  

 !   !

  #

     !  "    "    *

     

 ' ()    " *&'(  "

#  0 '!(  "



0 '

(

#          

 

  )  



                %      





     *

  "

#% " 

 



)    

  

      

  

%    

        



         !    

   % #



  "  

!

  !  

%  !"    

  

 # 

 

 







  12 3

   %     "* 

  #

 

"

!



     "

 



  !

 "

     

   

#     

  

   "  

*

    -     

" 

    

"      %  

      !

 ! *  #    -

          

        #!  

  

     %         *   

    ) "  

  

%#

 

  "



% !" "

  

      !     .

;(, (8 $ ( 4D

- !

!

 "

"12

 (



3%   ! & . !   %#

  

"

 %    !      

*   

 



   

                      

!

 

#  4   

      

 

      + 

        

  



 ! #

5   



  

       

6 

        !

    !   "    #     

 3

       #      

        

  !     *

    

!



#% 

#

     #     %!



"# 

  

  #      " 

#% 

 ! 

 !

%   



 

  

%



 

 #  #7    !* !"



 %     !  

  "             

    % 

 #     82   %     "%# "

 

          

  

4  "

5  .

 

      /

 /



 D0  



9A;*  ( 4D     +! ( /

 .

 D0   

,2 19.

   "   2.

%  "



    "



  "  "% 

      18.

 !             

    

       18.

%   !

 %        "       "%        "

  " "  %     "  



 "  "  

  

   

  

   

 



 "

#

    # 

 

% #    %   

            18      .

  

%   "%  

  

   % !

   #  ! 

 

 :11;< =

 

  %   

 * +  $ ( 47    

. /(

"0-2-E3 % !  

 

%  



" ! 

% !   

 

)



%    

              "

        "  "   0  *%  %  "%#

" 

 % !

   "%     "

            #

  !

!

   

  !

  " :11;  .

  .

       >

    ?  .

   7 %).@211 2< :1;   %

  %            ! 

  %        

  %#



   %

 

 %

     "   

                 $



  3   

"  

  #   

  #

  

   18% 9 .

< 1A.

   %

      



     2 #    18 .

 !  $



 

  

 !

 

     

18.

      %     

%!

6.

> 

  "%  % 

  

       ".

      $ 

 6.

>    %  !" *

   



     % !" "     

  0     6.

>  "

      

       " ) %  

      18 .

    %

     2 .

  

 1   A1.

:1B;<          

!

#       "    "

 "      

  %#

* #   !  !           

          

?.! 

 )  ' (%

          

     A1 .

  "!" *

         

      +  %    

     A1.

% !             #    

        A2:1;<%  

    9     .

 :18;<        A2  "  #           C D       &  '

(                        

0     '

( * #    !

!    



         A2 

       !"

  ")    9.

%      C   D&'

(      

!     !"   0'

(            0    '

(        !

     !"  

   %     

     E

%      

    9 A2.

   "%       A1.

#  !  :1B;  A1  E

    

               

   $3      "    "



 "      

   #

'   * #          !      !            

   %

!



  

          

   < :1;  A2  +     $)             

   < #

" 

 !"  "         

   < :18;9$?*

   $)      *                   

  + $3   "     "$ '( *% %            0  '!(  *     

   "     

     "   

   0 '

(  "   

    "   

  0 '(  *   "   *   

                    

"         

 %# 

    

 !!                     %     

   :   

  <# % %  % % 

  !" !"  "  !"#  !"# " * # #  %

% %   0    "$3#  #  "%   "     "%  !" 



      # %              

   

 "     %  ! %   #     

    !"

  !" "

   %#    !

  

     0    "$3     "        "     "

   % %       

   

         

  

"     

     * #

          !"

    

 



 

% !"         

%

* #         

         <F

 

 .

 

    

0

"   1- -2%43

5#   &    

   



0

 /

0

/

/ 0

;

 "

%4

5!

   >



 .

/  



-&  .



 +/ F

.

E>/&

/ .

6      

   <= 

0

    /



//

 

 

 -? (  " @@.

.

@@

  

 

/ 0

& 0  

 

   



    

 /

 C  !4  

 11

 







 -?   /

    .

<=



 

   



 E& .

&  

    & 0 &

  .

    0

   0

& /&

  

/  

 /  @ 

  

0

    *   + 1- -2''35

5# 0   

&

<=

  & &

   9 

   & &



 

   



/

0   = /.

 





 /.



 

   & 6

.

+/ 6   E& .

>/



&  ;

 #'%



553

>/

0  





   @@

 



 

 02 .

   



;

 !3

 /

&



>/

  9.

/



;

 5)



;

 #5

 

 /

5'53  



;

 !3



/

/



0

;

 #



 /

 

5'53 =



//   0

    / / 



 0

>/



0

 ;

 #'%



553.







0 

/

/



;

 #

 /



;

 #3% 7 = 8

 ;

 %?

/ ;

 #5 

& + .

9   .

+/ 6  

     /

//



/



/ & 0 

  .

 

   

0 /& 

<=



 /  .





  /

!55#

 / 

 /

/   &  /   

 & 

 9.

 /



&  

     !      & 0 

 

  

0

/

 #

  .

 

   

 

 

   & &  

 

0 

 

   9 0  

   @@  

 

  







 "

 .

//  9



 

 

>/   

B  

  .

 55.

   /



 

/.



 

 

0 

  

   / @ 

  

  0   >/



  

    

/ /  

&.

 2//

& /

 & 

/ 



/

 9 



0/ 0 +91 



  ?/

 

& B ?

/ / 0

 

   @@

E&   / 



 =  ;

 #3%.

/.





 

& 

/ 

&.



.



 

 

  

   / &  > 2!

0B .



   @@

  

&





   /

   



0/

/     % = & 

 

  



/

/ ' =   /.

 .

/

    0

  



!5553.

/

>/

 .

 - 

.

( 

 .

A

 .



 .

0

0.

&.

 



   E& .

 /



0   53

55.

 <=  0



  

5)5#  

.

      

/&  //   /



 B  

      / .

0

   



!553

 D    



/ .

 

      /

7 > 2%8  

     9    

0 1&   / 5 .

 5!

 



  <= 9.

/&  

  

0  

 

&   / .

/ 

 / 0 

   

//  9

     



&  /

 &  

 /    )  

.

/ 

0   0

/   &  /





/   &  /   0 /

 / E& .

/  .

/  0

/   / &  0 0 

   0 1&  9.

/

   



0 B

  / 3  

 

/ .

 

 

  



/.

  .

.



:-5267 52 8(-

29 52:0)* ))



;!5 <.=>2!772?3 528(-

29:0   )  



;"3?  -%75 8(  - 

 * 29:0  ')



;-2 2@.58( -

29 52:0 )**)



;

-=53  .=>2  -%75  75A  8(  - 

 29    52:  ')



;$>%2.5  52  8(  - 

 29    52:



 9 

 

/

 /  0.

0/

  &

 /

#378

"; =

0

 = & 

C/

/

  &  .



B .





/  

  0



 

/

#378

"; 4 9 .

   *   +  /

 / !55#

 & 

  



  .

 /  0 

- 

  /

&  

     9.

&

0 &.

 

 

  

.

  .

.

 



;62-%75B62#58(-

29:



 



0 

0

  

0

?

/

 

 ?+ - ?1F- /   5 9 0 &

0& & 0



 

 

  0 /





0 

>

 



/ 9 

0  0

  /&   /&

/    / 

'( (

) 1(-(-.!/!4     # A  ?

, (?;

A  0

,

(?;