Nitin Singhal v. Anil Garg

 



      

 
























































   

  !"!#$ !

!#
!#%& '  !

!#( )" #!'

(% "*#+#

,$- ./ ,




0   

 
 
 






0  1


 







!

 "

"
 
 

#

 
$
% 
 

 


 
&
#

  $
%

'(
 





 
&

 

)
'*'
""



 
 

 
&+ 

 
#

 

 



 
   
&
#

 
"
, +
$, 
-%
.

 # 
 & +

 
'/ (!

0(00


 





 

#

 

 

 


 ₹/0**((1 1
$₹ ₹ 2
 3

 
& 

0**((1

% ₹

+ 

 
#
 +
 

 

2
 
   
 


 
0(' '4


 

 
+

 
 &
+


5
0'6

 &
 +


 


3+
#

 
#
 



7
 
 
  ₹  

 
 

5 '(*((

&

8&#
0('* # 
 

& 3
 &


  
-&#
0('*
 

 ₹  
& 

2
 3


&
-&#
0('*


( (2 0('9

'

₹
&
 
0**((1
 
  +

 

+ 

 
0'

''

0('2


 
# 

 &
 

& 

:

 #&
 
 ₹


/0**((1
+
 

;
 

 


!

!

0('9



!
""

) &&


 
 
 


 
 ''

(/ 0('9

 


&

'0 (!

0('9

- 
 




'

(!

0('9
 
#



'(
 

#+ 


 &&
 
&+

 

< + 
 

)&   
 
&

 

 
 
$
< 
 *%

 



 
&


 

'

'( 0('9
$
< 
 2%





 && 
= +&

>





 


 
  



 
 
&

 

'/ ''

0('9


)
'*'
""

+

 


+ 
 
  
 

 




 


+

 &&

&
) 
 
 
#
&
#
 

 & +




 
#



 

 
!
?


0
$ %

&  





 
  
 




 



 &&


 &

 



 

" 
 
# 

 
 

7



 
 
 @ &


!

""

 
#

 



& +


# 

 



  3+

*


 +
 
 




 + 0




 
#3
7


&





!


"

"
 


&& 
 



 
 





 &&  

 
 




& 

+



 


 
 

- 

@ 



 

 

 
&

 



 &&

&

   

#
+ 



 

#

 
 
 


" 
& 
&
 

+ +
 

  





 

7

 

+ 

  

 






#=
+
 && 
 



  #
# 
#
  
 



!

>
#


 
#
+ 

  

  


@ 

#



 

#

 
  

&#


!
?


'$0%
""

 
 A) #=




 #  
$'%



 
+
 

 
 &B $ %
 

#

< +
 

&
C $#%
 



 
3




#

@  
& 

&
  #
#

 



 

+B $%



 C
 $%


 &


 &
 +

#



<
 &

&



 


#

 

 C
 $%


+




 &
+ 

 





#

@  
&  




# 
3


#

 
 
 
 &&   

 #



+

 

 
$%
 
# 

#

< +
 

&
C
 $%
 



#

@  
& 

&

   #
#

 
 


 


 &

+


+




#


@  
& 

/

7


 
&




  #

 




 


 

 


 


 
+ 


8
&

 + +
 &



 

#
&




 


 


&#

#

< +
 
 &
C


 


#+


  #

 

+

 
  


 
&
  +


 

+ +

 &


50'6


 &

 &
#

 




 
#
 

 
#

 


 


 
#
 & 

# 

 
+&


 
 



#
 @  
 &

&


 
#
&
+
 


 


#




 
 
 
 50'6

 &

&
&


 &
#

 

 & 3

 

#

 

 
+
 



 

'(

)
 



#
 &


 3

+ &  
 
 


&#


!
""
 
 
@ 
 

 &&


 


 

.&
E

<
E

?


0$0%


!

?


0



FFFG77
""


 4





 && 
 


#
 
#

 
7
 

 A0
#"

!

!# "233 (4"2!

"B
$'%

 






& 


 



 
#
  #
+

 

 
 B $ %


&



 

 


 
C $#%
 





 


&#

 
 
#
 &


 C $%

+

&& 
#

 &#
 
 





 
 &B H$I

FFFG77


"

"
  '/(!% $0% &"233#" &"2!

"& ''5!#(36!#**#+!7 

 

&

& 
&
&

&
#
#

$ %
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< ''

7


&

 
?


 


 
 


FFFG77

""

 &&


 


#

 .&
8 4

<
E



 8**#+!7 6
,,

,,
 9:;< $ %

 $8 &


 

% : JJ
 
 

 
+ 

 
FFFG77


"

"
 
'/(9

? JJJ

*







#
 &&







# 

 


 
&






 

 

#



< 


  


 

# 




 &

<+
 &

? JJJ


 &

? JJ



+
 





" 
& 


7







#


 JJJ


 

 




 &&

= +&

 +




#


&

" 

  


 
K 


& 
#
# 


 

"  #
 


 






 

 &

 


  #
 

 
#






&
 


 


" 
JJ

 
JJ

0(

, + '0

7


 

 &&


 
+ +
 

''

(/ 0('9
 
 


.&
8
4


<
E 


!
?


0
""



&



 $< 
 %

7 

 &&
 





* ?


'


""





 
 

?


 

 




/
?


2
""


 

# 

 
 
 


)&
#




 
#
+
#
 



/
?


2
""



 

 
 
# 


!
""


 

@ &


!

?


""

'

8

#
?





FFFG77
""

  

#





 

  

 
?



 

 2



8:( +2( ( & ** ( #  + #+ # B
$'%
7

 
 




 
 
+

 &&

 
0



 




 


< 



 
& 


&


  
 








#
 




 

 


" 




 

&

$0%
I



 &&


 =  

@ 

#



 
  &

 
#
 


&






 +
#
&

 


$ %


 

+




 
  
#
+
#

 


 L
 


  
 




 
&

#
 



#
  






  L
 



 


 
& 
#

$4%
 &  + #+ #  # ("  #  ** ( # 1  &  *'

!# !

 "& ''

&(

("(=# &+ #+ # "233#" (>2+%3# !# (3    6 !# **#+!7  

 

.&

& 
# #
&
&

&
( 2(# 5'# '"" & # #+ 4" (3

&+

 "(=!  
#

 
+









& 
 &

 +
 


#


 


 

$*%

 
& 


&


 
&

 
 &&

= +&
#
 


+
   

& 
#
&
 


&



 
 &&

 


 
 

 


&  #
+ 

&
 


 
&

& 


" 

, +

#
=  
 
 


 

#
 


!



" 

 
 

 

#

 


 
 


 #  


 

 




#
 

#

 

 

<   
 
 


 


& 
 &
# 

 

&
#

 

#
 
&
&
 



 
 

#
+ 


& 

&

#
 


#

 

" 

$2%
<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< $!%<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<D '4

7

 
&

#
 
?


 


 
 


 




@ 




 
" 





&



 
 
 
 @ 



&
$ %

 &&

= +&

& 8 4 

<
E

 
#
  #


 

  &

 



.&
8 4 

< E
 

 6-
,,
 ,  
,,
 9:;:< $ % 7
JJ

" 

JJ ) 
8JJJ


0(JJ

FMNJJJJJ

  G E"JJJJJJ -  I
 +

 


 

" 
& 3
 +

 & K

 



" 

, +


  & 
#


 JJ

J

0(



L3


 

 +


 


 
 

#

#
 # 
= +&


 
+ 

 
$

+ 

 &

 

 &%

? JJ




 

9



- 


 


0(J '*

7

 
 +
 
&

 
 ( '( 0('9
$< 
2%


 +
 &&

= +&
#  
 




 &&

.&
8 4 

<
'2

7
 
#

#

 
 #+023 ()"
&'

=!1 ;?@ ?

!=!'@: 



FFFG77
""

&& 
 

 

 




?



  

 
# 





 

< 


  

?


0


 &&


#


.&
8 4

<
: 




 
#
 
 


 FFFG77
?



""
 
&


'!

7


 


&

$< 
 %  
 



 &&

.&
8 4

<
E
 ""C


 +



 



 &&
 .&
8 4 

<
E
+





 
 # 


 O
 

'9


& +

 
'/ (!

0(00
< 
 '
   

 


 
#

 
#

"  #


 
" 
#
3+





  
# 
 
&&+


&


 
&


 

+

 






 
  3+

 
#
 

 
&
#



 
"   
 
+

&
 
 
 
&
 +
+ 
 


& 
#

 

/



'/

7



#



 



&

 


0(

-&

=35(1 ?

0  @ (#2  

:
) 3+1 
M18 :
? #
M18 '(