High Court of Punjab and HaryanaSAO/15/2016dismissed

Bhupinder Singh Toki v. Amrinder Singh And ORS.

2018-05-15Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan5 pages

!"#"$%&%'() **+,%'#"-%'.*/% ,,"00 '!

1"-&+& 2-%'#"-%'.* '#!*"-& "&,'#"'!& ( 34

5 4

-"&"'!(6

-%7 '&*+ %'8#7$ !"8 - ,,"00 '!

-+'9 ' %&*%8#7$ !"8 --"&,'#"'!

-+&*: '! * - '8#7$ !"8 --"&,'#"'! '"--"&,'#"'!&;!

- +- 7 '.-%8#7$ !"8 --"&,'#"'!

-'/+-* -2 8#7$ !"8 --"&,'#"'!) <*"!*"-!*" ",-!"-&0$ 0'"=&, ,"-2 :>" 00="#! &""!*"9+#.2"'!?

>"-""--"#!!*" ",-!"--'! ; <*"!*"-!*"9+#.2"'!&*+0#>"-",-!"#%'!*"#%."&!? 66 66 4 2,+.'"#%',-"&"'!&"$'# ,," 0 . %'&!-#"-%&9+#.2"'! # !"#8, &&"#>:0" -'"###%!%' 0%&!-%$!+#."8* '#%. -*8 =*"-">: !"- 00=%'. ,,0%$ !%'%0"#>:5 &*2%-%'.*&' '!/* %'.*+'#"- -#"- +0" 8@)8-%2,0" #%'.*%2 &, -!:8$ &"

= &-"2 '#"#> $/=%!* #%-"$!%'!!-% 0+-!!#"$%#"!*"2 !!"- -"&* !"-.%7%'.,,-!+'%!:!5 &*2%-%'.*!%0"=-%!!"'&! !"2"'! &="00 & ! 0" # "7%#"'$" -0%"-8 !*" 0" -'"# %7%0 +#." +'%- %7%&%'8 * '#%. -*8%' &+%!-, -!%!%'>:= :,&&"&&%' '#-"'#%!%'

66 $$+'!&8* ##%&2%&&"#&+%!,0 %'!%&8=*%0"-"$-#%'.%'#%'.'%&&+" ;'0:-". -#%'.2 %'! %' >%0%!:&+%!-% 0+-!#%#'!-"$-# %'#%'.'%&&+"&8 -%" $!& $ &" -" !* ! ,0 %'!%& * 7" %0"# &+%! - , -!%!%'>:= :,&&"&&%'+&"8"$!-6@68* '#%. -* != &&! !"#!* !,0 %'!%&* 7">""'-"&%#%'. >- # '##""'# '! * &>""'2 ' .%'. %-&*+&""* #>""'$00"$!%'.-"'!-2 #""'# '!&!A 0 %'!%&* #-"B+"&!"##""'# '!&"7"- 0 !%2"&!-"'#"- $$+'!&-"'!-"$"%7"#8>+!*"#%#'!#& 0 %'!%& !;* 7"&0#!*"%-;

A!*&* -"!,0 %'!%A=8!*":&""/, -!%!%' ,-,"-!: ""'# '! ' ,," - '$"!/ >9"$!%' !* ! *" '# ,0 %'!%&!; -"='"-,-,"-!%"&5!*%C68 * &"618

* 0%8 . -8 * 0%D'#+&!-% 0*"#;6A @8'#+&!-% 0 -" 8 * &"68* '#%. -*D .-%$+0!+- 00 '#2" &+-%'.;E $-"&>" -%'. /* &- A

@ ;DD;D)8&%!+ !"# !7%00 ."4*. -*8%&!-%$! !% 0 8 '#+&"8"$!-6@68* '#%. -*!= &&! !"#!* !#""'# '! '#,0 %'!%& '# -"&'&0 !"*-%/% '#,0 %'!% ;%&=%"*-%/%!"-#" !*/%8,0 %'!%& !; '##""'# '! -""'!%!0"#! 00!*",-,"-!%"& 0 %'!%& !;* 7"&0#!*"%-&* -"%',-,"-!:%'B+"&!%'!,0 %'!%A '# ,0 %'!%A* &&0#;F&* -"!5 &*2%-%'.*&' '!/*%'.* %'.* ""'# '!,0" #"#!* !*"%&!"' '!&%'$"@@C'%-&! 0- '#. - ."'.-+'#0- !!*"- !" &8 6,"-2'!* %'$0+#%'.= !"-$* -."&!= &&! !"#!* !" -0%"-!*"-"'!= & &8 6

6;6 ,"-2'!*%'$0+#%'.= !"-$* -."& "%&-" #:!!"'#"-!*"-"'! &,"- #%-"$!%'&+-! ""'# '!; 0&%0"#&", - !"=-%!!"'&! !"2"'!&! !%'. !* !*"%&-".+0 -0:, :%'.-"'!!#""'# '! ""'# '! A %' &", - !" =-%!!"' &! !"2"'! &! !"# !* ! #""'# '! ;2%.*!* 7"! /"'& %# $$22# !%'%'*"-,"-&' 0 $ , $%!: '#'! & '"2,0:""#""'# '!A

-2,0" #%'.&800=%'.%&&+"&="-"- 2"#(6 <*"!*"-!*",0 %'!%& -""'!%!0"#!!*"#"$-"", -!%!%'>: = :,&&"&&%'>:2"!"& '#>+'#&?

<*"!*"-!*",0 %'!%& -""'!%!0"#!!*"#"$-""--"'#%!%' $$+'!&?

; <*"!*"-!*"&+%!%&'!2 %'! %' >0"? A <*"!*"-!*",0 %'!%& * 7"'! ,,- $*"# !*%& +-! =%!* $0" '* '#&? <*"!*"- !*" &+%! - -"'#%!%' $$+'! %& > --"# >: 0%2%! !%'? <*"!*"-!*"#""'# '!%&"'!%!0"#!$+'!"-$0 %2 & ,- :"#-? C

"0%" -% 0+-!!/+,%&&+";'0: '#'!%$"#!* !,0 %'!%& !;* 7"&0#!*"%-;

A!*&* -"%'&+%!,-,"-!:!,0 %'!%A '# ,0 %'!%A%'!+-'&0#;F&* -"+!; A!* &* -"!'"5 &*2%- %'.*8=*= &'!2 #", -!:!= &&! !"#!* !'=,0 %'!%A* & &!",,"#%'!&*"&,0 %'!%&!;*"='"-&*%,, -!%"&%& ,-7"#*"& 0";F&* -"!5 &*2%-%'.*8>:,0 %'!%A8

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

66 '# >:, &&%'. &," /%'.-#"-=%!*%'&%G 2'!*&-2!*"# !" -"$"%,!$"-!%%"#$,:!*%&-#"-!*, -!%"& -"#%-"$!"#! ,," - >"-"!*"&+$$"&&-+-!*-% -#"",:'.* 08 80" -'"#%7%0 +#." +'%-%7%&%'8* '#%. -*8';) !( %'$"

2 %'$ &"* &>""'#%&2%&&"#8!*"-"-"8,"'#%'. ,,0%$ !%'8% ':8 0& &! '#&#%&,&"#

4 ) &9/& <*"!*"-&," /%'. -" &'"# ( "& <*"!*"- ",-! >0"

( "&