High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3241/2014allowed

Chander Parkash Soni v. R.S Grewal & ORS

2016-01-21Mr. Justice Amit Rawal20 pages

! "#"$!

%%&& '"( ")"*& " %

&+(,"- *"

%%&& '"( ")"*& " %

.!!""%""&& *%%",/0&&* 1(2, 3

-0""""%""" 345 .!!"!1(2, !(&0"%"

! 23 #"

$6!&7"8* ! ""

"+(,"'!"78"%%&& 9 0!%%& "#( 6& 7"8* ! "'

0!8:

78 ""( )(%7 +

$)"*&78""% 9 0!%%&

;;;;

"" ,

!&& % * 2(&" %%&0"

& ! "#"$!

' )"*& "

&(!

&+(,"- *"

' )"*& " &!

*!"22"

8 !

2 " " 0/ 0! ! (" 0&*7 *!"0/ ( "

% !( %"%"/

! "(% 7 7!80

" " '

$ 6!&7 &"

" 8 0/ " "

"+(,"'!"7&"

( &%%"

2 0!&%%&& (0, !( "% < * ,

0&7"7! *"%(

% !!% 0/,!

88 +("=> "

2!9 ""%%" !",

*(&0%2 80"

!!"(&

,%(2 1(2, "0!! ("0&* -!"% %&

(* &( 2

! %%&& & ,

2 % !%

2& "/ !*

! %& !%"!"

% 2 8

!%&

!%", !"> "

2!)"*&** "!" &!( !*

"7/&&* 2" &("

!%& & 2* !,!% "( &&27 0"

%&6??@&A *7 &&27 &B

7B(!

!+!

6??@ *" (!"

7!" 2"

(&("&& (

!&62 B(!

9!0 ("!"%&

!( !!

88+("*

&&*& 8

1/!"

" * !

!",!.

&& @ @

7!"

2!% !%"%"/", *"" &&!"!"!! > "

2!7!%"%"/* 0/!

,*,(

! ,"!

2!)"*&!"!%&

C @C !""

! ,,!"!%&

7%&

" :)"*&!0"!"%&

D(&!"-!( ("!"

%&&(7!9 ,-< "7 "

997B(!

!! !( 6@7& 1 & ,("

2 0 2! @0 2!7

* ,<=*&!<*(","!

88+("=> "

2!)"*&-!", !, * !0 ! "8"/" 0"

2- A

"*"0/9 ,-< " 99 "(&

2 "" @C -! !, ""!9 ,-< "*!&& 2

&( 0"

2C@ @C-!,*" !,""! (%!

(" 0"

2 A @@* &*!

!* %8 ""

A @@7*!"

7 *!&!9 , -<=.&!-<(",!

88+(")"*& 0"8"0/! ,-<%", ",!" &

80/""(

2 !"",!,

!!%("

2!"& , &/!

88 +(" A @@C %"!%&

27!"& , "

2!& 8

! !( ( & ! " 7 <

2( ! 9

! "(, 7!%&

(2!!% !!(*&& !!!%&(0/!"!%" 9!0 ("!"

%&!!

88+("%"! !.

&&7 ! "

&(!%"%"/

/ / /"0/!"7 * 0( !%&

-!%%&& !( 0/$

%&7!"> "

2!* !* "!%"%"/

7!/" 7,(!&7( * ,

0&! "(

% &/(2!0/""

2!%"8 5#( 10E"0 "

7 @ @

" ,% F

G-!(2!<( ! .

&&*&

*!& 2 0* !

88 +(" !"0"!"7"!

2!)"*& 9*("!"!(!%%&& 7 * &&",

!&& <

2( ! !, " !

88+("& &"

7%" *"8"

7!&"

& ("", (

""&!8 7!%&

!* 0<#.

"!(, 5<# 5<# *!" %%

! * 0< & <,

* 7,(!&7(, "/8 "

&0 &&5< 7 ! "" ! 9 , -< " 5<

@@5<

6!! ("0&* !0 !"& (, "/ 8 7"!( ( !.

&&<(0/> "

2!2

& , "

2! !

8 8 +(" )"*&7 ! 0 (%!& 0/ > H0& (%", (" *!&!!"& , "

2! 8" 0&(* "!

% !", 7!%"%"/*(&"8"0$ "!

2!-!"" "" C@

2(&" %%&0"

2CA C*&,*!"

& ( 7!( "% 2

!" * & !

("*!

&"&/

2(% !%&

2!%" 7,(!&7"& (, "/8 7 !!! 7!"

7!& $ !%&8"% 7( !( "% * ,

0&!

88+("* &/& , * "!%"%"/ /"

2!"0/!"("

2!"& ,, 0

& , * "-!%%& &0/!%%&& *& ,

! "(, 7!", 2(&" %%&! 0 &0"!

(" " '

$ 6!&7 &"

" ( & 0/ " "

" +(," '!"7 %%"

2 0!& %%&& ! " ,(& &"2(, *!

!" (,"!"

0&*

-!%"!

@ @7 , / %" 0/*!," *!( " %/0&"0( &

" &

(

% " ! ",

! /

8("70(

&(%"

(% 0( &

2"" & 0/ 7( &* !

2!& &"7 """!

7 *!

!"!(

(0, !%"!" (&&(0/! > H0&(%", ("

! " # $

! ! %&''()*+ ,-..7!%"8 !0, "0& !"

2!! *(&0%"8 "! !!5>&"7

7 /"

2!"0/& 5 !&"(&0< 0/ !

%"!1(2, ( 6 !> H0&(%", ("

+ /( # 0 1 ()*%&23+,'&4 ( !("/ !%", 7!! "! ("/

/ 0(

( &7!"" ""/%"8

7%%&& *"

( 0/"!

88+("

)"*&78 ",

! / ( !"!7! (%%&&

0 8"

"%"70(*(&0 7

7%"

(",

% 78 "

! /

(%%"(! 7"& (%

1(2, !

("" "

5 $ # + 1 / %&26!7*-%358 7"!

88+("!2 8

!%"%"/,

&&", 7! !0 !&0(&&&2* "B

!%"%"/*(& &"("

2! 1/!%"%"/("

2!"& ,*!

&( !"

2!&(!%" !%"%"/ $!8 ! "," %" !%"%"/

-!"% %&

&%"8 /(, "" !*!"> "

2!** "!%"%"/ A -! !.

&&"

08"

(%"%"/ !%"%"/

%(! 0 ,

&&7

7 !0

, +!

& ! 7

7!" ,

!!%6! ,/7 !0 !&0/> H0&(%", ("!"!

88+("!& ,

"%"!", !.

&& 0&(* "7 !", 7!

0 % !

! %&

0/ ""

2!",/ &

2!( "% -!(!%%&& 0

2 !0 $ *&2 0/!9 ,-<(!"

/7!" *!

!*0

2% !

88 +("7!0 % !9 ,-<(!"

/8 5<

75<

5< A -!1(2, " "0/!

CA C C@

&+ *&-!%" "'")"*&

!"7 %%& 0&! "(, !

!7! !&(%%&8"% !

("!$

" !" (&&(

! 1(2, 8 7 # /1

-6%6%*,*,4-4*!

! %%& 0&!

! !0 "/7*!!& ,

" &(%", 70(F>"

G!&(!%", ! 58 !"* 7! 7 !"

7!(%%&8"% ,

2!"0/, !* "!

%"!

2!)"*&-!

$(%!

C %&8"% "

2!&/7!* , >*8"7 !1(2, " "0/> H0&(%", ("

!-!8"H (%"* """ 8 ",1(2, " "

CA C! *(&01(2,

%" ,

", !&& !80

2(% ! "(, !7,(!&7 %%&& !(%"/!&&*

(0 &D( &*"

"",

0/!

.!!"!

((0 8

"!! 2!* "!

.!!"!% ! 0,( &*(& !,, !"*! 2* "!

%3 " #( 6& 7 &"

" ( & 0/ " '

0!8:

78!8!, &/ "8"!"2(, " 6!&0/"

2&&*

2(0,

2!"(2!!

2" "0/> H0&(%", ("

"" 7 &"! %(*0* !0"!"

" ,&/"!

2!)"*& !

88+(")"*&7 *!"

!0 !&!!

88+("!& ,

! %"%"/ ! "

2!*(& "!""

2!0&(* "!

% 7!""7 !! 0 !&0* "7!(& &( !%", " !(!(!%%&& & 0(!"%" %%&&

$!0 "%" 8 &0&( "! @ @ !! *%%& 0&

2" "

CA C C@

&+ *&-!%"(%""0

2(% ! "(,

@ !%" *& %%& 0!& , &"&/ ( 2

*!,!( "% * &*!

!*(%!&0/ !

("9 !", 2(&" %%&7!&&*

(0 &D( &*!"

9 : >!&"* ! !

("1(2, " "

2(&" %%& A @C & ")"*&'"!

88+(")"*&7(%!&0/(%", ("7*!"

!0 !&!!

88+("! "

2!.

&&7 !.

&& &/28!"& , "

2! "!"!7!( %"%"/ *"D( "0"8"!&2&! "!B!

)"*&7!")"*& !

&2&! " !

2!!0 !& &D( "!* "!

!( %"%"/ !!

2!!!&0* "7"!

88+("

(& "! /"

2! !", < 7 !""7"& !

%0* !%&

0 !& &"

%"! !.

&&7!

88+(")"*&(&

& "" "!%"%"/ "

2! /*(&& ,( " "=&

(%%"!

7!"& (% &&*

2&*

5,"

# +;

< / = -6%%>170%22 !& ,,80&

%"%"/ "! %"

@@ /"*(& &,( " " %"%"/7 ,(! &7 ,( &

,,80&%"%"/

1 $ 5 7* # ( 5 # , 7* -6%6' +,,46> !*!"%"!.

&&7* "! 0 &&* 1/!%"%"/1

&/("

2!"& , "!7,&! "20&("

!%"%"/ &! "* "(&& ! ""% 8!" !"!"" !""

!& %"%"/ " 2", ("!%"%"/0D(! 0*

!! !

"%"/

7"> "

2!!

2!"!

8+(")"*& !", 7*(&"8"0$! ( & &!

2!)"*&7

!%", !%"%"/(& 2!!

"%"/ " / !("

"%"/"

2!*!

!! * %", A >("!"(0, !!" "$ " 0* ! B7 7!""7! /"

2!"0/"!

8+("*(& 8"

%", /"

2! !", -!(!%%&& "%"9 !

"2"7 1(2, > H0& (%", ("

! ? , # 5 , / -6%%3+,,-'6 8"

(!"

1(2, &*!

!"2 8 !"

0&*

< # 1 * %&&.-+,,%%% 8 7 # /1 -6%6 %*,*,4-4 /, # ?

-666-!7*''3 5@ ;) # 8 + ; < -66>.*,*,4-'

+ + # 5 * -662> *,* ,..2 +1 / 7* # * + -6%> .+,,4>4 1 " # / * + -6%3%),,4%> >!&"* ! !

("! !" &%/!.

&&!* !, && (%%&

<(" ,"!( " 1

++ A

" 9 )

+ +

B 9 < + , 1

+1 8 9 B

/ %4+ %&..

(0, ! (""

!2(&" %%& &( " ! & #"("( & ( &8"/" 2 % 8(0 &D(

&*"

-! ""

<("C %

7*!"0/"8 2

! , &!%%&

&( " # $

2/!( !%", !

0!!0"!" ""& 2

28 8

"%" ! .

&&7( & ( &!,"*!

!*! ,%

20"! > H0&(%", (" > H0& ("/!

&""

!( &&! !% &B8# 0/> H0&(%", ("7

,(!!!%%&& !8, !!/*(&0 0( 0/! > H0&(%", (" 7!""7!/

0 %", $ (% ! %& ""/ ! $

! ", % !(%"/" , &!%%& 97!8!"&"

( &"!%" %%" ! %%"0$ *&&&* 0" ,!8 *! %%&"80&&*"!&&*

2" -! " "

CA C0/!

&+ *&-!%" "'")"*& !"*(&

0%%& 0&"!1( ! "8"/

%" 2(&"

%%&7 !%", 7!!

("!"& (% !1(2, " "0/!

>"0 B&'8

2!(%"7*!"

! 0 "/!.

&&*!*2 8 & , "

2!!&( !%", " 7*!"7

7 *0 "/!"&

,&/"!

88+(")"*&&(!%", 58 !"* 7!

!%"

2!" !%&8"% -!

$(%!%&8"% -$

2(%!%&

8"% ,( ,

2!* "!

%!%&

-!.

&& %""

0!< !!%-! %"%"/"

0!"

& 1 !"I"! $0"8 /7!"

% !%"%"/,

&& <"!"

0&* " %661 < A ) >6

) " * >66@ " > # A ! 1

" !

! ! 1 ) 9 C+8 A

" ) )D * ,,7 )

) 1 ) * -@> B ) +)B 9

-!" !"%!,"-!"% %&

! &%"8!> "

2!*!* "!%"%"/6!

,/7 !

"%" !.

&&!&"/

& /7 *!"0/ !0 !&!!

88+(")"*&*(& D( "! 0&(* "!

%7"7"

2!7%"! !.

&&7*2 8 !"=("

2!"& , !""7!%"%"/!0 !&"8" 0$& & &)"*&

BD( "!(&& * "!

% (&&(0/!> H0&(%", ("

! " H D("&/%%& 0&!!9 ! ", 1(2, 7!> H0&(%", ("! (!%"8 -, &( (& 8

2- #" 7

@AA7*!"

! %","

@ @ -!

!", 7 @AA7" !( +- (

F- G G

% B

" $

% - E

(

!!5#( 10E"0 "

7 @ @" !(

! 7 &

"" 0& &( 7!(! !",

! /*(&0! !

88+("!, &/" !"

2! /

8("%%&& " " 8*!0/ !9 ,-<(!"

/7%"8 ""!"(2!5<

75<

5< A7!"& !

%!%%&& !

88+("*! & &"

< !", 7!(7!%& !"% %&

!!(!%%&& *(& (

0& !"0/"1 -!"&8 %"1(2, " "0/> H0&(%", ("

! " G " "8 8 !(! *(&"!( & 7 , 8 , H +>% ) F F "

G" (

(

B D +

%&33( " A " (

" ( B +.% ( % / %&3> F

% / %&3> ;+.%( %&33 ! ( ( " ( %&33 8

( (

%6 ? +'4 " ! ( )

+ ) <

+'4 " ! ( +

%% , D A 8 , <

1(2, 7 & 0 , # 1 / %&&4>4/*043. , &"%"% ""1( 70" > H0&&!

> 2! ("7 *!&!"

2! 1/!%"%"/ * &&

&("

2!&(!%"%"/ &$8 ! 9*&!*!"0 "/!0 2 8 & , "

2! %"! !.

&& ! D( "!(&&&2 * "!

%7 "! / 7!""7! *"!& 0%"%"!%"8 "&7 @AC-!"&8 %"

2" "

!", 1(2, 7"!( ?

9 B B +

; A "A

-!" "

!%&"6& 7!7%"! 1(2, " "0/!

"% %(0* ! 0&

,&/"!

2!)"*& !

88+(")"*&7 !0

!&!"!

88+(")"*&(& &(!%", -! *"&

"&"*(&, " /

& 8 8 " ! / &&/ %&%"&8 %" !

2" "0/!

A @C &")"*& '"!

88+(")"*&7"!( ) 8G+ , < G

) / +/1 "9 -2 - %&&% -3 2 %&&3 B / + / 1 ( / +/1 D 7 , +/+ / * + ? +/ + 8 + , D

@ +/+ D ", 5

A / +/1

-! ",

2 !8 0 (%!& 0/ > H0& (%", ("

!1(2, > H0&(%", ("&7 !

8"0 !&!"!

88+("! "

2!" /-! &

0,%"8 8 " /0/%"

*!!& , "

!%"%"/ ,/8 *7!(!%%&& &*"

( 0/"!

88+(")"*&*(& < =<

2( !

!" , -! ",/7 /7 " ! "% %&

*! ! D( "!* "!

% , !

88+(")"*&*(&0 $!1, %"!%"8 &

2 &* 0/( "

% 0"

2!,"%" 58 7B*"%%&& ("*!

& ,

2!%%&28 !

2!!"* %(!"!

88+("!

( %%&&

! ( %"%"/ 0(

,/ 8 * "" (&/!&!! "% 0, &&2& !", 7

7 , % ""!%%&& !0

( 7!/

(",

7!0! / ",

, "!

88+(")"*&%&

="!,( 0/ %

2!" 7!

*(&

&!!,!("%"2

2&&2( $% 0/ &

2!( "% 0/

2!%"8

@! &#"("

58 2

2!"(2!! !%%& & ( " # !""%!" 0/!

("7 *!"

!0 !&! , ! "("%"!"

",! !%%& 7 "

0&!!" 2"

, ! ! *!8" 0, ! * " ! %(%"%"/7! "(*(&0&*/! +%

8 *!", 79,!8 *! 1(2, "0!! ("0&*" (

! /&* "!"0/ -!D( &* 08" *"

8("

!%%&& 2

!"% %&

"",

!&& %"&(!"% %&

$1, !%%&&

/!2"( 1, "8 &0&%"!%"8 &

2 B* (& &/70!%%&"&&* "!0%"%""

2&/ !"! "!#