← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5981/2015dismissed

Uco Bank And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2015-12-07Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

 

     

 

!"##$%&%'(#$#)*#+,- 

 !'.-/#+')#'"'0%! '0#+"!.%'1-"2+312%"&2!%+)!'-#!0 %$# --!+!'%45.!"!,

 "2#+& 66#55!'"& 7#+&3& "!"#!+8!'! "2#+&  #&6'0#'"&  !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.&  92#"2#+ #6+"#+&5$!56!6#+&)!8*#!55:#0"&##"2#;301)#'"<  *#+##++#0""2# #6+"#+&+'"< = 92#"2#+"2#;301)#'"&2350*#+#6+"#0%'"2#%1#&"<

+#&#'"( +!5.!11!-0/$!"#- +"2#!66#55!'"& >>>>>  *)+%,'

?=@ 

+  "2#  +#!&'&  )#'"%'#0  %'  "2#  !665%$!"%'-  :2%$2  %& &366+"#0*8!'!%0!/%"-0#5!8=0!8&%'+#%5%'1"2#!66#!5%&$'0'#0 &"!'0&0%&6&#0

  2#!66#55!'"@0##'0!'"&!+#%' #135!+#$'066#!5!1!%'&"

"2#$'$3++#'"%'0%'1&!$"&!'05!:-:2#+#*8"2#&3%"%5#0*8"2# +#&6'0#'"@65!%'"%&+)!'0!"+8%';3'$"%'0%+#$"%'1"2#!'."2'3+ "2#  $))%")#'"  !&  "2#8  2!0  3'0#+"!.#'  "  1%/#  "2#  *!'.  13!+!'"## 3'$'0%"%'!558 !'0  %++#/$!*58-  2!&  *##'  0#$+##0  *8 *"2  "2#  3+"& *#5: +!5.!11!-5#!+'#0$3'&#5!66#!+%'1'*#2!5"2#

 !66#55!'"@0##'0!'"&2!&+!%&#0)35"%@50!+13)#'"&%'&366+"&"2# 1+3'0&!66#!5-:2%$2!+#&3))!+%&#0!&3'0#+(@ !

& 6#+ "2#"#+)&!'0 $'0%"%'& "2# $'"+!$"- "2# #)658#+-%#-"!"#!+8!'!@65!%'"%2!0")!.#!0/!'$# 6!8)#'"!'0"2#'1#""2#*!'.13!+!'"##%'5%#3"2#+#A * '65!%'!'0&%)65#5!'13!1#5!3&#"2# !1+##)#'"-%"%&+#/#!5#0"2!"!"%+&"!0/!'$#6!8)#'"%&"*# )!0#!'0"2#'"2#*!'.13!+!'"##2!&"*#%&&3#0A $ 2#$'"+!$"+!'0"2#%$%!5&"2#55!2!*!0!'. !+#!5+#!08%'/5/#0%'!'  !&"2#$'"+!$"+2!0)!'!1#0" 1%/#"2#*!'.13!+!'"##""2##)658#+A "#+  "#+)%'!"%'    "2#  $'"+!$"  '  =

-  "2# #)658#+@+#&6'0#'"@65!%'"%  2!0  +!%&#0  "2#  0#)!'0  + #'+$#)#'""2#*!'.13!+!'"##'

-:2#+#!&"2# *!'.  13!+!'"##&  :#+#  1%/#'  '  ?

  !'0  "2#  %+&"

13!+!'"##:!&%&&3#0'? 

'#&&#'$#-"2#+#%&!'

!66!+#'"$553&%'*#":##'"2#$'"+!$"+!'0"2##)658#+!'0 !  +!30  2!&  *##'  65!8#0  36'  "2#  !'.  "  %&  %'  "2#&# $%+$3)&"!'$#&-"2#*!'.:+"#!5#""#+""2#+#&6'0#'"&!&" :2#"2#+"2#$'"+!$"+2!0*##'%&&3#0!0/!'$#)'#8!1!%'&" "2#*!'.13!+!'"##+'"-:2%$2!55#1#0581!/#"2#$!3&# !$"%'""2#"!"#"%'/.#"2#6+/%&%'&#$"%'="2# 6#$%%$ #5%#$"*8%'/.%'1"2#;3+%&0%$"%'!&6+/%0#0 3'0#+#$"%'"2#%/%5 +$#03+#0#A # !0"2#!+#)#'"%'#0!$"&"!.#'%'"$'&%0#+!"%'- 6#+2!6&"2#&3%""2##)658#+@+#&6'0#'"@65!%'"%:350

/ 2!/#!%5#0-"23&-"2#+#%&%55#1!5%"8!'06#+/#+&%"8-)3$25#&&- &3*&"!'"%!5B3#&"%'5!:!+%&#&+0#"#+)%'!"%'*8"2%& 3+" 2!/#2#!+0"2#5#!+'#0$3'&#5+"2#!66#55!'"@0##'0!'"& !'0!66+!%&#0"2#6!6#+*. 68"2#5#""#+-/%0#:2%$2"2#*!'.2!01%/#'!&&3+!'$#" "2#36#+%'"#'0%'1'1%'##+- 2"!.-%+$5# 9

+!'$2- 2"!.- !+8!'!-2!&*##'!''#C#0!&''#C3+#@-:2%$2+#!0&"23&(@  



   



    !"! #  $% &'()(  #  $#* +       %  ,  )(  # %#   #   

#  #-&  . / $0%  .1&&234  $ 3    /   ,.   . 

#

5

6789,   + :;.  5,  %

#  %  ,  )(  #%#

   #    

#   #  -&#   ( $  !

    !

    .

.  .      

.  

   .<6##7  +,= 1 +; '#-%1( $#4% 

# &

#/       5+    

 #  !     

+    , + 2

     +5 !

        +  +#  +  8    !"! #  $% &'()(   $#* +  :1  .   /  /

,  ! .5 !



0 >

 /  .  

   

#    ? !<6##7 +,=  +;



-%1( $  %.4  ! '.   !  

  !       .

  .     .    %

    / $    5  .      +.  

  /   +  5     5 /    8    !  "! #  $ % &'()(  # $#* +  :9   %  #,  )(  %#   #

  

# #-&#

 +/ +   .  +

5 +  !

 

  ,

 .

.. .  

.  ,   +    

     !"! # $% &'() (  # $#* +    ,.

  + .  

 .  %

  '-%1( $#4% 

# &

#/ #



+  $   ,$ !

  !    + ?  /   ,  . 2, /  !  /  ! + !    5,0 ;

1  5 +  ( $!

 

 ?  <6##7 +,=  +;

;

( $!

 

5,

  < @ ;

'    + !

     +

 .  ( $!

  +.+ ,

/ 



   5.  < @ ,;

  !

       

+   

  

< @ 



 +.1  

 . -%1( $# &

#/ @ %   !

 +

%.4  ! :

'65!%'!'0&%)65#5!'13!1#"2#!+#)#'"%'#05#""#+-%"%& +#/#!5#0"2!""2#*!'.2!03'$'0%"%'!558!'0%++#/$!*583'0#+"!.#'"

 1%/#13!+!'"##!&6+%)!+8*5%1!"+!'0'"!&&3+#"8!&"2#6!8)#'"""2# 36#+%'"#'0%'1'1%'##+-!+#)#'"%'#0-'"2#0#)!'0:2!"&#/#++%12" *5%1!"%''"2#%+6!+"!'0:%"23"%"&%+&"$5!%)""2#$'"+!$"+-%'"2# !)3'"'"#C$##0%'1=

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

$"+ '  )8 /%#:-  "2#  !'  2!0  *##'  !$"%'1  !&  &285$.  %'  '" 6'0#+%'136'"2#%+*5%1!"%'2#+#%&!66!+#'"*+#!$2*5%1!"%'!'0 +%12"58&-"2##)658#+2!0%'/.#0"2#6+/%&%'&#$"%'="2# 6#$%%$ #5%#$""#'+$#"2#*+#!$2*5%1!"%' 4##6%'1%'/%#:"2#!+#)#'"%'#0!$"&-0'"%'"#'0" 0%#+:%"2"2#%'0%'1&+#'0#+#0*8*"2"2#3+"&*#5:-:2%$2!+#*!&#0 '!66+#$%!"%'+!5!'00$3)#'"!+8#/%0#'$# $$+0%'158-"2#!66#!

145 '(-.&