← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6084/2015dismissed

State Of Haryana & ORS v. Kamlesh Kumari

2025-05-03Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil12 pages

     



   

 

 !" " 

   

"

"""""## $ %# % 

"

"""""   & "

    #  



   

 

    #'

#

"

()*+(  !"



 # 

"

 

&' '( )'&*



" "% - -

. "

%

+ 

"    "%



)& '/ )'&/

   #"

+0&*))10+0)'&* "



 /*

 % -

/*



 

-  % 2   " 



'3 ') )'&4

 %

 "

)& '3 )'&5

  )     



%

"



%  $ 

% 6% % . 7 & - 

7 ). 

   

 " # "

 &55( "

  

  %



 .".





 .  &  "

%% 2" "% %"

  "# 8   







   % "

   6  "%

% 

'1 && &55( . $

 '/ && &55( - 

$ %. 7 ) -.



 % $

 '* && &55(

 . 7 &   " . 7 & 

 % "



 "



&1 && &55(

 

)1 &) &55(

. 7 ) 

7 1

 : "% "

   #

  

    . 7 & "

 % 



'( '* &553



"

;<

+:9 =>!

:; - -

$  

 #

  . 7 & 

 

"



&' '4 &553 '5 '3 )''3 - 

"  &5 &) )'''

> " % .  & "

  %   #



+?0&331*0&55( 

@

     A # "

! -

 

  -  0   # "

 

 "

;<

+:9 =>!

:;

 " .

 % "

% " #

 



  % "

"  .  &   "  - )'

   "

   - "%  :-  . "

7 /

$ %   -  

 # 

 " # 

"

. -

   # ;# 2 #"

< 7 )&)5) &553 - 

"

&( '/ &553 

 " % #8 



2 )) && )'''

"



.

# "

.

 "

&5 &) )'''

#  

 " 

# "

+?0(5/50)''&

%

# 

< 7 &&)5)0&553   "



!%;  B C

D . 7 & -

< 7 )&'**0)''& # ;#

% "

% 7 (5/50)''& ""

"-

< 7 &&)5)0&553

=

< 7 &&)5)0&553





&& '( )''4 %

+ 

    

  !!"

#$% && '

 -  . 7 &

%

&4 && )''4  "-    

# "

   "

#   8  . 7 &    

 - #



 

7 /. 7 /

 .

7 &

)

. 7 &

+  ?  7 )3&& )''( # "





)1 ') )''(





%

- 

2 %   . 7 &

   % 

"

&5 '3 )''( '( &) )''( .

"



#

-"

"

)1 ') )''(

.  & 

 " - +%  > 

%   " .

%

  -"

;<

+:9 =>!

:;

#

" 

"

%

)1 ') )''( .  & %

    

" - ""

"

&1 '1 )''3 - 7 4'0)''3



 #  "

  

"

 "

 7 &&'1* )''3 - '( '5 )''5 #  %  # # " 

'( '5 )''5 . 7 & " 

< 7 /*/130)'&'

++ 7 (*(5 )'&' -

'( '5 )''5

" ;#

% 

&) '* )'&'

-"

. 7 &  %  #  = %  -  "  %"

  

"



)4 '* )'&'

&) '( )'&& "

7 )'&)40)'&& - #    %

  " + 



%  $  

+ 

" ,   "%

%

 " 

%

&4 && )''4



"

% 

 . 7 &

&1 '1 )''3 #

- - 

- ;#

% @   

  !!"

#$% && '





)& '/ )'&/ 

#



" "%  -  

% 



 #

#  . 7 & 



%  -"

;<

+:9 =>!

:;



 "

&1 '1 )''3

 

%

&4 && )''4 $"

% . 7 & -"

" -

 

  =  

'( '* &553 

-"

" -

 

 .

 7 &  . 7 & 

-   ?  

   '( '* &553

  "- 8  #  &)   %   G





&' '( )'&*



" "% # "

  !"



 #

.

7 & ( &   )  *   +,, 



  "

.

 



&' '( )'&*





" "%   "  #%

7 &.

% 6% % %

#

-   " - 

- H#

%    



  

 #% 

   # 2

%



 %

% %   %# - ""



  

7 &.  %"

   - - 

% %



% 

$ % B  /C 

 I< +% = I

  " " %     -  

 " "

 



% 



 +%%

 

 & . " 

2 %   %

 ""%  

 % "

%  "

    .

 

7 &331*0&55( B

!%



C

, 

%  

 - "  

#$  %  "  # H# 2   .

7 &.H

%

&4 && )''4

  

$

- "

&1 '1 )''3

%

 

7 )3&& )''(   #%

7 &.

  

  " %  

%  -    

%  

    

% - ?  7 )'&)4 )'&& #   #%

  

%      



 #

$



 * ,  -'+,

 >   

.

 

 .

% 

 



-0

&' '( )'&*





" "% #%

   #  

 

   



  



    

7 &. 

  #  #  



  

 # 

"

 &55(  #"

 "

9%% 92"

%"

 8    % "

"   - 

 " "

# %%    $

 '/ && &55(

   /

$ %

 

  #%

% 7 &. % '( '* &553 #

   %  

   I< +% = I 

7 &331* &55( B

!%

:

C 



-

  

 7 &. "



- "



$ % -    "

  7 &.

 % 

 B "  7 )3&& )''(C %  - 

"

   %  "  %

 -

I< +% = I   

 $   %

   " "

%

%"

  > " #  7 &. 

%  !"





%



&' '( )'&*





" "% /      

     

 

2%

% "

&' '( )'&*





" "%

    !"







 &''

++ %

#  -  " 

-   -0

#

  

- 7 #  - # 

% .

-"

 

    

" # " #  %  %

 $ 

 "

  %

 

% %

" 

  

%     % -  "



8 #

! % 2

 

2

* .

,  /  1   2 3'





."

 2 



 

 

   

   



        

    

 

     

 

  

    

       !    

"    

#   





   "

       "                 $"

       "  

  

  

    

     

  %

       





  "   

             

          "   &  

'

 (    

 "  



       

 

        ) 

*    

  



  > 2  /    .

    *

 ,   4 1

# % * 3  5#'676% && '7"8   +,

    

    



                             - "  



 - .  /     ! 

    (      "        " "       ! /      

    "0        



  1+ > 

"



09

9 :

 

 /  & 9  9 3& & 9 5#'6;<% ( && 7(78 +2

 / 

"  

  -     

  

 "   "  

"  / " "     !

      

  - +

"

%  

   &. 

 #  

  ).

%

  

  + "

 &.

 "

9%% 92"



8  



  

 #   %  % "

 # %  " #  

  % 

 " ""

  # 

  % '( '* &553 

- -"

-0#

I< +% = I 

#



-

7 &331* &55( B

!%

:

C  

$ %  )   % -  % 

% #   " 



  %

%  " @< +% = A -  

 "

 ) 

 #"

  &. 

"  &.  % 

 

%   "

"%     " " 

#"

"

0 H    + 



  = 1 

  # !!"% && '

 

"

 2 J%  B C " # "

G % 

- -"

"

 %  - 

 

 % 2"

   %  # %

    

 

 "

G # "

" %

 # 

 >  

.

   " " %  &

 - % %  "  -

I< +% =

I 

 "



 " 

  #" %  % #  # 

 %

# 28  # "   -  "

8 # 

-



"% "  # 

% 

% 

#  

  

#



 - " 

 % 

  "   "

   

% # -"

   #

 

" "



  %2 

 %  "

G #  % "  #   # %

* &     " !"





%



&' '( )'&*





" "% # %

 BC  





   # !" " 

  3 $ 

!%  4 %# $    4 %#