Kanta Devi v. Charan Singh And ANR


 

       








 

  !

"

#$

""##$% &' %  

$&% 



"% 

 '()*+ 

,- ./+



,.

) ../ %
(  ) *+,$-.$%/%+$""##$%

00000



,.

) ../0 ,

+$""##$%
*$%$,+$/,#1'#$.$""$# $1$,%  ,2"'1  3'12%  $  .  $% 

5  ,  6+,.+ $""$#"/$1$,%3'12%$.$%

!,2,,1 %+',%/%+"#$,%,//"$9:,%,$# ,,#'1;),,,,<- +$16$$6$,2,

"%+/$.%/%+.$-*$%$,
$""##$%="#$,%,// +$/,#',%/"2$%,3'.%,%$,,1%+/$%/2 $#,$%,1%$/,1""%: 7,%'$%, ''$19, $1$-  +$16$$  6,%+  %+  9'$,  $  %$,#  %+,  $  /'%+ %$,,1%+/$%/2$,,1$:%/.%'.%,%+, ""%:  ,##1$##:  $  /.,9#:  $#1  6,%+  %+  #,/  /  2$$%: ,3'.%, ,.%,1%+ /$% %% %+$, ""%: , ,% ,1,$#,%,$#+'$/%2#,+,1%+'"%'.%'/+" $,%62%+$1$%2%+
%+/2$$#',% /",/%++',,"'%

,%,$##:%+',%6$/,#$1$,% +$$),1+
/$%  $$13,%),1+
/$% 6$,2"#$'9>'%#:

+ .$/%+"#$,%,//6$%+$%+,$.
+$$#16,%++$'1+% $2#:  +$,+:$  ?+$  $,  $  2#$%$  $,  $   $?$3  $,

,1,$##:%+""%:6$6$"9:++'9$,#9$1+

$,6++$$#$:@",$%+""%:6$,+,%9:+$#1 6,%++.+,#,>'$#+$ %6$.#$,2%+$%%+/$%+$ ,1+%-%,%#,%%,%+$,""%:  +:6,/#'%,$# "$6$%%1$9%+',%""%:

+:6$#@%,1 %+$%%$#,$%%+$2$/'%+.+$1%+$%'/%+""%:

+:6$#%+$%,1%$,.%'.%,,##1$##:$/.,9#:  %+$9./"#$,%,//-%+/$%,##1$##:$/.,9#:2#,+%+ ,%,$#+' 7$9'%%62%+$1$$,.%'.%,/ +"$.+$1%+$%'/""%:/2,%,$#%.22.,$# ""%:

+%+:6/'%+%+$%,1%$#,$%%+$2 + /$%  +$  %$?  ,##1$#-  /.,9#  ",  /  %+,  ""%:  , 9'$:

+/$%6>'%%#,9$.?%+$.$% ",/%+""%:9'%%+:+$/'$'#%,2$%#:%+',%6$ /,#

%,./%+',%6$1,%9%+%+/$% +:+$ /,#"$$%6,%%%$%2%9:%$?,1%+$2%$%+$%%+',%6$ %2$,%$,$9#,%+"%/2 +"#$,%,//+$..$#2$%,$# /$.%/2%+ '% )+6$%.
6/%+""%:,>'%,

+,""%:6$,1,$##:69:,#9$1+ $,6+$"",%,3 B$#*$#$$+, $#6/%%:+# +1,% $# 6/%%:$% A

8 ,"#$.. ,3B$#*$#$ %+9$,/$/$, $#6/%%:/,#9$1+ $,#%+

!
',%""%:9$,1 7$#16,%+%+""%,9$,1

$7 !,%'$%,$19,$1$-+$16$$$#16,%++,6,/ +$ *$#$-,/$'/)'3,%),1+- +$$),1+$$13,%),1+  1$,1 %+,$#-$$12%%##$% 4 856$@.'%9:.,,1 $'2/  4#$.$/'##$/,$#$#.,$%,1$,1"#%  -7 !$7 ..,1#:-%+"#% 7$% ''$19, $1$-+$16$$6$,%+6+,"$",/$13,%),1+

+,/$.%6$6##6,%+,%+?6#1/"#$,%,//  +,%"#$ "'..6$,..% +',%/,#9:%+"#$,%,//6$%,2 9$ )++$  

 %/,#%+"%',%  +/$%   6$  ,  ",  /  2,  "2,  ,  "$%  "/2$.  / $12%%##$% 4 85$%+%+/$%+$.. 6,%+%+""%:,,"'%  %6$"$:%+$%%+',%/,#9:%+ "#$,%,//6$6,%+'%2,%$%+$22$:?,#:9,2,6,%+ +$:.%

2  %+  "#$,1  /  %+  "$%,-  /##6,1  ,'  6 /$2    

A  $  $,%,$#  ,'     6$  /$2  

!

 C+%+%+"#$,%,//,%,%#%?,3'.%,$"$:/D

 

C+%+  %+  "#$,%,//  ,  %,%#  %  %+  ",  /  %+  ',% ""%:D  C+%+%+',%,%2$,%$,$9#D 

C+%+%+"#$,%,//+$ 

%/,#%+',%D 

#,/

%"%+',%-%+"#$,%,//@$2,+#/$C$ %$//,$,%@ $@ C=".%,#:-*'#"),1+-

#?- //,./2"2%'%-+$16$$$C $%+$/% .#+,.

7

%9'%%+,./%+"#$,%,//-%+/$% 
$13,%),1++,2#/%"",%%+6,%9@$C
$ %  .'2%  @   %  @ A  +  /$%  $#  @$2, '2,%),1+;B 

<-'3$9)%$%6 "$%,-(#6 +$16$$$C -)$$93,%*'2$- 1,%$%, #?- //,./)'9

1,%$-  +$16$$  $  C!-  +?  *'2$-    C,%  $  C7-

$2+  *'2$-  $29$$  $  C5  $  $+,  $$  $  C4

+$/%-/$%.#%+,.

/%+$,1%+$1'2%$$.9:#$.'#/ %+"$%,-%+',%/,#9:%+"#$,%,//*$%$,6$,2,, 3'12%$.$%

!"$9:%+%+,%,$# ,,# '1;),,,,<-+$16$$ #,1$11,/%+$/$, 3'12%$.-*$%$,+$/,# ,,#""$#$1$,% +$$ ),1+$$13,%),1+"%=/$%-6+,.+6$$#,2, , 3'12%$.$% 

5 #,1$11,/%+, 3'12%  $  .-  %+  $""##$%="#$,%,//  +$  /,#  1'#$  . $""$#

+$+$%+$1'2%$$.9:#$.'#/ %+$""##$%="#$,%,//  B$.'#/%+$""##$%="#$,%,//$, %+1'%+$%',"'%#:""%: 76$$##%%%B$%,#9$1+

$,6+6$6/%+""%:

 +,/$.%+$9./,29:

*'#"),1+- #?- //,./2"2%'%-+$16$$C  +$".%+#%%/$##%2%@  $#16,%+,%"#$ @ !

 +"%=/$%+$.'2%/%,%#,%+, ",   /%  %+  $%+  /  ,#9$1+  $,  +'9$  /  %+ $""##$%="#$,%,//-  %+,  ""%:  ,  ,+,%  9:  +  $#1  6,%+  + $'1+%$,>'$#+$ B$%,#9$1+ $,',1+,#,/%,2

5
$1%##%+""%:,/$'/$:" %,6##%%# "",%,%+$%,%+@.'%,/ $#6/%%:2 @.'%,/$12%%##6,##./$:%,%#,/$'/%+

+  ,  %+,1    .  %  +6  %+$%  $:  /  %+  /$%   $""$.+$:.'%/#$6?,1".,/,."/2$./$12%% ##$% 4 85 +/-$13,%),1+"%=/$%

.$%.#$,2$:,1+%-%,%#,%%,%+""%:,,"'% /$.% %+$##1$12%%##,/$#$/1.'2%.$%$%%+ 9$.?/++'9$B$%,#9$1+ $,  +,"/1$,1 "$:2%/%,$#.,$%,  +/-%+/$%.$% ,$:9/,%'%+",,/).%,5!
/$// "%:.%  +/$.%/%+.$$%+,..6% ,1+%#:$"".,$%,%+9:%+ '%/,%,$# ,,#'1;), ,,,<-+$16$$6+,#"$,13'12%$.$%

!

%+/$.%/%+.$-,..%+#1$#"",%,6$ ,1+%#:.,9:,%,$#,%,.%'1-*$"'%+$#$6+,#"$,1 3'12%$.$%

5 +/-%+/,,11,, %+$/$,3'12%2$:?,#:9%$,9:$.."%,1%+"% $""$#$%+',%/,#9:%+$""##$%="#$,%,//?,1%+#,// "2$%,3'.%,-2$$%:,3'.%,$",2$:?,#:9 . 

+$.,%+$1'2%$$.9:#$.'# /  %+  $""##$%="#$,%,//   ""##$%="#$,%,//  +$  /,#  %+  ',% / "2$%  ,3'.%,  %$,,1  %+  /$%  /2  $#,$%,1   %$/,1""%: 7,%'$%, ''$19,$1$-+$16$$ $$#/2$,,1$:%:"/.%'.%, .+$1,1,%$%'

4
,##1$##:$/.,9#:$$#',%/2$$%:,3'.%,,.%,1%+ /$%%%%+""%:%,%,1,$#",%,9:2#,+,1 %+.%'.%,/+"$,,##1$##:$/.,9#:9:%+/$% $%2%+ 
 %+/2$$#',%/",/%+ +',>'%,

+/$.%/%+.$,,.$%%+$%""%: 76$6 9:B$%,#9$1+ $,+'9$/%+$""##$%="#$,%,//
*$%$, +, /$.%,%,"'%9:%+"%=/$%  +"#$,%,//+$ @$2,*'#"),1+- #?/2%+//,./2"2%'%- +$16$$$C 6+"'.%+'22.1$,1"#%  +$##%2%#%%@  ,,%+$2/,#9$1+ $,$%+ ,%"#$,@ !

+,6,%/'%+./,2%+$%,#9$1+ $,+$ 1, $#6/%%:%,3B$#*$#$ %+$.2,%+ %$%2%/*$%$,C%+$%++'9$@",

 +$#/%9+,+,6,6*$%$,-%+$""##$%="#$,%,//$#16,%+ %6$'1+%$$ %,$#2$%%/.%+$%$/%%+$%+/ ,#9$1+ $,-%+""%:,>'%,+$9%$/,%+ .  /  2"2%  '%-  +$16$$    (',.,"$#  22,%%- +$16$$,%+$2/#1$#+,/B$%,#9$1+ $, +/-%+ ,,"'%%+$%""%: 76$$##%%%B$%,#9$1+ $,9:

2"2%'%-+$16$$

%,$.$/"%=/$%9/%+%,$# '% %+$%B$%,#9$1+ $,+$1,1,% $#6/%%: $%  A

8  ,  /$'  /  ,3 B$#  *$#$      %  "  %+ @.'%,  /  $/$,  $#  6  /  %%:-  %+  .'#  / /$%@$2,C5 $2+*'2$6+6$/%+2$1,$# 6,%/%+$, $#6/%%: .$%1,.$##:"

A
%+$%%+$, $#6/%%:6$6,%%$%%+$?,1/B$% ,#9$1+ $,,6+,.+,3B$#*$#$6$$"",%$"6/$%%: +#  6$/%+2$1,$#6,%%%+$/$, $# 6/%%:6+,.+,@   "$%/2%+,)$$93,%*'2$-

1,%$%, #?-//,./)'9 1,%$-+$16$$+$$#%"",% %+  6,%  9@  $  C! $  ./,2  %+  1,%$%,  /  $/$, $#6/%%:,%+//,./)'9 1,%$-+$16$$, 6+,.+B$%,#9$1+ $,+$1, $#6/%%:,/$'/ ,3B$#*$#$  "'.%+,1,$#.,   $#6/ %%:$% A

8 @ 

%,$.$/"%=/$% %+$%   %+  9$,  / %+,  $#  6  /  %%:-  ,3 B$# *$#$ @.'%$12%%##$% 4 851$,1"#% -7 $7 7,/$'/)'3,%),1+- +$$),1+$$13,%),1+   "''$.%%+,$12%%##-%+:+$"$,%,$#.,$%, %%+%'/  4#$.$%+",6$$##,,%+, /$' +$,$12%%##$% 4 85,@  6+,.+, $1$,".9:@$2,,1+?*'2$-C,%$C7

./,2%+$%%+$12%%##6$.,99:+,2$%%+,%$. /%+"$%,-$/%6,%,1,%6$$%%+2$%+:+$$//,@ %+,  ,1$%'  $2,%%,1  ,%  $  ..%  ,  %+  ".  /  2$1,$# 6,% +,1,$#$12%%##"/,#,@  %6$ %,+,1,%$%,$# 45$% 4 85 +#$% %:/+,1,%,@   $+, $$C4/%+6,%/ $12%  %  ##  +$  $#  ./,2  %+  /$.%   +/-  %+ "%=/$%#.,.,1,..%"%+ $#6/%%:$% A

8 %+,9$,/6+,.+,3 B$#*$#$+$@.'%$12%%##$% 4 85  "%+


.,%$#,%+$/$,$12%%##$% 4 85-$/%%+ .,"%/%,$#.,$%,%+",6$$##,%%+ $%+:61,%+#,9%:%'%+""%:$"%+, ,$%+:.'#$,.%'.%,  %6$/'%+2%,%+$% %+:.'#$#,$%%+$29:$#,16,%+%+2"2%'% ,.%#:

+$""##$%="#$,%,//+$,%+$/$,/$.%-+6 %+.@$2,$%,/*$%$,$C,2$%,$# ',1+. @$2,$%,+$2,%%,,%,$##:%+$%+6$$6$/%+/$.%%+$%+ +'9$B$%,#9$1+ $,+$1, $#6/%%:, /$'/,3B$#*$#$ )+.#$,2%+$%++$1%+'1+%+ .%%  /  $,  $#  6  /  %%:  ',1  /'%+  .
@$2,$%,-+%$%.#$,2,1%+$%%+"6/$%%:6$1,, %1%#.%,.,%:$6$%..%, )+,%+@.'%,/ $##1  $12%  %  ##  $%  4 85  1$,1  "#%  

6- ',1  +  /'%+  . @$2,$%,  + $2,%%  %+$%  + ,%,$#+',,%'$%$%$,%$./$9'%!=7/'#1/2%+"#% ,,"'% )++$6+%+.%'.%,6$9,1$,%+ "#%,,"'%  )+/'%+$2,%%%+$%6%+,$%,"#%: 9',#,1%+"#%,>'%, ',1/'%+.@$2,$%,+ $#$2,%%%+$%$,,3B$#*$#$6$".,$#/,/++'9$ B$%,#9$1+ $, "$%/2%+,$13,%),1+/$% +$%"" ,%%+6,%9@$C%"+,%$%$?,%+6,%% %$%2% $#@$2, '2,%),1+- #?/2) B$C % "%+#.%,.,%:..%,,%+$,"2,$++$$# "#$..2/%+9,##@  %@ A %+6,-%+ $""##$%="#$,%,//+$%,"'%%+/$.%%+$%/$% $13,% ),1+,,",/%+""%:6+,.+++$$,%,"#%:

8
9',#,1 +"%=/$%+$9$9#%"9/%+ %,$# '%%+$%%+9$,/$12%%##$% 4 85@ - $13,%),1+$1%"'.+$"#% 79:"$:2%/%,$# .,$%,$%+$/%-+6$+$%+",/%+ ""%:6+,.++$,.%'.%, +/-,%,,1+%#:+#9:

%+.'%9#6%+$%%+,1+%//$% $"%.%'%+ ",,/).%,5!
/$//"%:.%-

,6/%+/$.%$.,.'2%$./%+.$,.' $9  %+  ,.%  1,  9:  %+  '%  9#6  ,  9$    "" $"".,$%,/%+/$.%$%+,.. +/-% /,$:$%,$16,%+%+3'12%1,9:%+ '%9#6 $%+$2$$..,1#:'"+#

'#%$%#:-%+$""$#"/9:%+$""##$%="#$,%,//, ,2,  +..,/2%+%6 '%9#69%9$.?

%%+..>'$%  ,1$""#,.$%,;<,/$:-$#%$,"/

 

,.

) ../ 

 

,-"1+ C+%+"$?,1=$

= C+%+"%$9#

=