← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6134/2015allowed

Ashok Kumar And ORS v. Anita Rani

2018-03-20Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan13 pages

           !

" #$% &%'()(*+#,'-

.

/ )-0123#,#*&$-%,) 44%55#*$) 6%,)2) *($##*( %)4*&%*$



#$% &%'()(*+#,'-

.

/ )-0123#,#*&$-%,) 44%55#*$) 6%,)2) *($##*( %)4*&%*$ + 7 8 18 

,%)%*$+ 

   

   

  

   



 



  

   !

 " # $ %!  &

"  ! # 18   '  "  (

  



!   )* &+$, - &,$, * !    (          

   

       "      .,&$, -     !     /         "          $&, $, &  $$,0$, & 

 !   / 1/2



 

   



 

3 

-+ -, - -, ,,,43



50-6  

 75*6  



8 



 7                ) &,    $, *    9   

  

3         ) --:$  ,&,.$,,0

!

;!33

1; !

2< !

;="

 >

1

2 *0 &

,,,43(

       )$      )   

 1!

  

2     )&             )   $  %      !!   

    ?    3

$*    ?

;  

            !   <   (       $,, 3$,,$     )  "      

 ! !

%!

 

 

 !           !     )      )  !    

!

< @    !   !   <   !A    

  B

      ((( '

< :'     ) $ 



    !

<  ! ((('

<?

  <! 

!

< ?

 

!

<!

<  

(  $, * 

!

!

<<  %  <    -+ -,





   !

!

(

         A  !   )++..00    $- ,,,43

 ! &, $$,,- 

     

% A ! !  )& !     

:

-,



 ,:,-$,,- A!  )++..0* $, ,,,43

         A      

  !  $0,.$,,-  % 

        ! %



   A)++..0*  ,:,-$,,- ++..00  &, $$,,-       $, ,,,43$0,.$,,-%!

<   ! 

(

 

 

-+ -, ,,,43 (   

   

     ) -*+&4,0    ,$,.$,,0     !  

   !   , -,  

 A!  )+-:0+-     .

$,,&                %     C,0,.$,,*    -     - -, @!   

! (       !      < 

 %  

   

 !$,, 3$,,$    "

  

%

 A ,:,-$,,-  :

-, A &, $$,,- $- -, ,,,43% 

 

! 

   

 !%

  $0,.$,,-          A    !

<            $, ,,,43               

!  

    ) 



!



!

 

   ,.,&$,,*     A &,

   <

                !     %  !

<       

 A

  !  

!   (

     

   

 "

          - ,,,43 

         

   ,0,.$,,*



 

 A  ,0,.$,,*% 

    C?

<  ?

"



"



C?> 

) > %



 A -

  !   7   

    

"   ) --:$     ,&,.$,,0        ) -*+&    ,$,.$,,0 

   9  

      

    

 

 

 





 !

"

 !    

         /   1/  2         "  $$,0$, & $&, $, &  !D    

 (

! 



  !  (       

  

     (                      --

 

 !  !

$,,0       !

    

! 

  1

3       2    "     

 (

 

1

 2  !  

% 





  !

 % 

    (!  

    9

A)++..0*  ,:,-$,,-:

-, ,,,43 $A)++..00  &, $$,,-  $- ,,,43 & $, ,,,43$0,.$,,-

 

A

 +%  , -, ,,,43 A )+-:0+-   .

$,,&

 A!  )++..0* ++..00   A ! 

   

 ! %      A$, ,,,43  $0,.$,,-D     A  , -, ,,,43  

     %    A          

  !    A  )++..0*  ++..00   ! 

   

  ! 

 7

A     A   # %        A       ! 

%  1@?3

2 ! ((('

<,:

$,,*DC ?  &      7(



3 ) 

    



  A!  )+0-.,+  & ,&$,,- :

-, ,,,43  A!  )++..0*  ,:,-$,,-:

-, A !  )++..00  &, $$,,-$- ,,,43 >

!!

<%  A 

   !!     A   !  

9   !      

 

 ,$, $,,* ( 

    

               

,+

$,,* 



  !

)  

 ((('

< <   

 

!! % 

 ! !

< D  )  

 ! 3:     ,&

$,,* <  

       

   

! !

< D 





  !

)  

! ! 

D   < 

 

<   7

     !

<!

 1

2  "

  < %!

<  

    D  

 <      

<

    ! %  

   7(



7 E@3

!    

  

!

   ,$, $,,*  !

<   "

   ),, &, ,+,:$0! 

 !     !

<    A!  )+0-.,+ ++..0* ++..00%   A)+0-.,+     

/

   !

<  

 



 !   

  

!%E@3$

 A

 ! 



!

   $, ,,,43   %  !

  A !





!

 



!

< (

   A    

A  

 

!

3

  )

     ) 

!



  



D  

"!

<         

  

!  

   (((  '

<  3:  D !

<        



!

          " D

  !

<  !D   

     3)$&&  $, ?

<

 3)$ +  + ?

<



!  @-,6 %



       F <

?

<

D           -- ,,,43

: 

 

    3@     

  A  !          $0,.$,,-  

   

!  

     "  !

<      (((  '

<    :    

  

!

 "!

  

 ! " ! ;2$$(55&#$%$-%#''2*$)-#<%*$ ;%%*)%$$5%&;%$=%%*$-%3   ! 

        ::

B

     $,,$      *0 &

,,,43 

! 

 !



!

D    

   

        D           "  C)$ +  + ?

<

 " 

      @                 

    ,$,.$,,0   

        

        ,$ $$,,04   ,* $$,,0!         ,$,.$,,0 < <

       +,&$,,.

 <

<         

!



 

    "            (((  '

<    :    A      

   !@

                   E@  $     &,   !   

%   

 !  

!

 !

 !





  

!

  



 C                @   

  C?> ?

"

  



!  ,0,.$,,* 

 



  - 



 

 

 A ,0,.$,,*  A

 %  ! 3@ 

 

    

<  

  %   <   < 

  <    7      !  !  B !   "! 

 ) 

!







!





   ! 

      % 

 ) --:$$,,0   A   ! !       $,

 (  

   

   7   

 

    !

<    A 

     %  

 

 

    !

<7 !

<    7(



%      !  !  G

     @   ! !

   

 

 %

) --:$$,,0        A:

-, $- ,,,43 !

  

       !                 $, ,,,43

! %    %     

     !     ! 

 !     !<   

   

  

!



 

 ! 

 



!

     E@$    &, ,,,43 !   

 %   

 ! !

 !





!

     8 @

 

    

 !  (    A  !

                 &, ,,,43 ! !     





     

 

 @  7       C? > ?

"

 

   !   



 ,0,.$,,* 

"    -  







 A ,0,.$,*   

           ! 3@    

    !

   C?> ?

"

    %  !  !  !               ,0,.$,,*      A   - ,,,43 

         

      !     %    A !     ) -*+&$,,0    

     , ,,,43 ,$,.$,,0 (    ! !     !   

  ,0,.$,,* - 



       ! 

 % 



 !

 ! 

% ! 

 

 

% ) ! 



    "   $$,0$, &

 

 $&, $, &   !    / 1/2      "   

.,&$, - !   /    

 (  -- ,,,43 

  !    !

      

! 4

  506     

   !   





      

  

      

    

  18    #,'-

.

/   

 < 4  H

  !

9 )