M/S Jai Shri Ram Enterprises And Others v. State Bank Of India And Another
!
!
"#"!!
"
$# "!
%
# #"
& '
$(
$# "!
$!
$)&*"
!
+ # "
!
'"
'+ !
$)&*"
!
+ # "
$'
'+ !
%"!
!
'"
'+ !
,
-$./0
! "# $% & '"# $%($
( ) *
&+ ,- &,!-"
./% ( $** ( ( ,0 !!
&,!-(
1 $ !2 ,- &,!- "
. 3% $ * $ (
$** (
( ) *4
&!
,- &,!- "
. 2% ( $ !2 ,- &,!-
* 5 3!2 ( 6 !0! 77
*$ 7$ (
* "6
* 5 * % * (
9 $
( * *
1 $ ! 77:
$ + !, $ /, ,, ' * &/ ,, $ 1 $** ( *
! "## $ % & " '( )*+,! -( ./ 0( 1 - ! #2 $ % & " ' % 3,444+"""#+,5 0
6 ( 7( .8
! ### $ % &
" $
( $ *
" %,- ,'
&,!3
* $ 6 # ;$ 6 < &,,& " = >% ( (
&& ,3 &,!2 6 !'"&% *$0!/-+!-,9
* * 5 * "5 % 7
*
*
5 ( $
'!
,'
&,!/ * .
* $ 5 6$ && ,& &,!-'
'07( (
*!2 ,,: *$ 5 6 $
5 6
< * !2 ,+ &,!- $ ) ($$** $
* * ?(
* $( 5 6 &/ ,/ &,!- $ '
+! 7 ( 77: :
$ $
* $ !2 ,- &,!- $** $ ?( (
($$ * *
* * 1
?(
(4
$* &!
,- &,!- @ $
4 ) ( ( &+ ,- &,,!- ( . ,0 !!
&,!- (
7 /6 <";$%&,,&"=>%
* * ( 5
$ ( ( 5 $ *$** ( * ( 8 5 ( 6 7
< * /"0% ?A 6$7
'.
2
3.
/
45 4/65
.6.
* B 4/
* 7.C &,,0"'% 7 "7 %&'0 ,!
!!
&,!2 * 66
* 6 # ;6< &,,& " ( * ( $ $% 7 ( * 4?
*7 8.
27
7
7.B & * 9 &,,-"00%7"7 %0&/
D ( < *
* ( ) * &+ ,- &,!-
$ ( ( . ,0 !!
&,!-
$ 9
$ ( (
*
$** ( ( /"0% E < ( ( $ *
* $ * * /"0%
/"0% =9:(& (
; <=3& && ( & ( %
&
, (<=& (> && (( ( & %&
( ( / &? & % % (( /( % & (
% %&&((/ @; <= % $ &
( / (
/ %
A < = %
& (A <= %( ( A <= % % /"0%$ * $$ "!% - 8 $ * $** 8 5 . (
(
$$ * $ (
/"0%"%" %"% "
% (
8 5 $ 1 '.
2
3.
/
45 4/65
.6.
* - 36.0, ?A 6$7 *( $
( 6# 7 !-0!
(( ** ( B'
& ( ( ( @, <= . 6 /( ? 8 5 ( "")& 6
(( % & & (
C
. &&
/
(( <= /
/ %? / A <= % ( &
< = /
& (% (% <= (
( C 8 & 8 & / C
<=
(
&& (
( & / C %
(( & %
/
(
(C % & & & (
/ / < (C&=& &
( & C
( ( <= & (& ( % & %
( ( (%/ ?
(
& ( % %
%&C && <= ( (%
% ? ( (( <= .& (
(/% ?
%
(D ? ( % ((
% &((/ /
( & (% /
( & % / & &(
C / : ">& 5 (( & . & ( &
( &
D / C <= '
,/% . &
$ && (
? & ( & / E(
/ C % & (
( C( & & &
<?=
(
* "%
* ?A 6$7 ( $
( * ( $.
$$ ( $.
$$ ( $** ( 5 $ ,!
!!
&,!2 1 ( 7& ( 6<$$ 6 7' ( 6 7'
!
B
& ( (
% ( (% /
& $ +
(
&(F 7 '
&
B. & & ( % ( %3 C & ( %
% & ( & ## ## / <
( ( $( . 7 '.
2
3.
/
45
4/65 .6.
* - 36.0,
( * * $.
$$ *
*$ ( * *
!+ 7 <
* 4 . ( $ $$$( *
1
* ( $$ 9 ( $.
$$ /"3% ( $ 9 1 9
* ', A $$ (
(
$(
$ *
( D *
( /"0%
$ ( 8 5 $ $ ( .7
'.
2
3.
/
45 4/65
.6.
* - 36.0 ( B !-
4 *$ ( * 8 5 ( 9 $.
$$
* (( * /"3% $.
$$ $$
* * 1
(
$
* $ $( * ( ( $ * * < (
$ $
$ *(
!
"# $ ;F
Whether speaking / reasoned :
Yes / No Whether Reportable :
Yes / No