High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3485/2014dismissed

Baljit Singh v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2016-02-08Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain5 pages

! ! ! !

"#$ %$&'(')* $+,-",.

"#$ %$&'(')* $+,-",. / 0 / 0 / 0 / 0 "12'#')34 55$11")# 6$,(-( 4$ -)2"+#"#$")%#4$,( $(5)%$)#( * * * * 78 78 78 78

,$($)#*

,$($)#* ,9-1%$$56')3441-:"1'"/%;&"#$

,#4$"55$11")# <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< /

/ 55$11")#4"% '1$%(-'# ,%$&1","#')&4"11$)3')3 #4$,%$,(%"#$% = / ")% 4$&"($ #4$51"')#'

>"55$11")#/')+,'$ /:"( #4"# 4'( "#4$, :"( :,?')3 "( " )(#"+1$ :'#4 #4$ %$ $)%")#(")%:"(?'11$%')")")#'>#$,,,'(#5$,"#')') #4$.$",=

55$11")#:"("55')#$%"(")(#"+1$) =@==0 ) &A5"((')"#$ 3,-)%( 55$11")# :"( "%;'($%+$%>,$(#) ==@"(4$:"((-

$,')3 ,A

"-)%'&$)#4$"11$3"#')#4"##4$"55$11")#4"%,$A"')$% "+($)# ,A%-#.:$ ==@# = ==@/4$:"( %'(A'(($% ,A ($,;'&$ ;'%$ ,%$, %"#$% == 4$,$"

#$,/ "55$11")# :"( ,$')(#"#$% ') ($,;'&$ )

= /"55$11")#"3"') $11'11")%,$5,#$%+"&? , %-#.)@ 55$11")#4"%,$A"')$%"+($)# ,A

%-#.)A").&&"(')(/:4$)4$4"% "11$)'1155$11")# :"(,%$,$%#+$%'(A'(($% ,A($,;'&$;'%$,%$,%"#$%

= 55$"1 '1$%+.#4$"55$11")#"3"')(##4$("'% ,%$,/:"(%'(A'(($%+.#4$55$11"#$-#4,'#.;'%$,%$, %"#$% ")%#4$,$;'(') '1$%+.#4$"55$11")# :"(%'(A'(($%;'%$,%$,%"#$% $)&$/#4$(-'# :"( '1$%+.#4$"55$11")#&4"11$)3')3#4$'A5-3)$%,%$,( ) #4$ 3,-)% #4"# #4$. 4"% +$$) 5"(($% ') ") '11$3"1 A"))$, :'#4-# &A51.')3 :'#4 #4$ 5,')&'51$( )"#-,"1 2-(#'&$")%-1$( $ $)%")#( ') #4$', :,'##$) (#"#$A$)# ";$,,$% #4"##4$"55$11")#:"(%'(A'(($% ,A($,;'&$"(4$4"% ,$A"')$%"+($)# ,A%-#.:'#4-#1$";$ #:"( -,#4$, ";$,,$% #4"# #4$ "55$11")# :"( " 4"+'#-"1 "+($)#$$ 55$11")#:"(51"&$%-)%$,(-(5$)(');'%$,%$,%"#$% ")% 4"% "'1$% # 2') #4$ %$5",#A$)#"1 5,&$$%')3(4$'A5-3)$%,%$,(:$,$1$3"1")%;"1'% )#4$51$"%')3( #4$5",#'$(/ 11:')3'((-$( :$,$ ,"A$%+.#4$#,'"1-,#*> B C4$#4$, #4$ 51"')#'

'( $)#'#1$% , #4$ %$&1","#')"(5,".$% ,D

C4$#4$,#4$,%$,%"#$% 5"(($% +. / -)2"+/ 4")%'3",4 ")% ,%$, %"#$% 5"(($%+.)(5$&#,$)$,"1/ /")% ,%$,%"#$% = ",$'11$3"1D

C4$#4$,#4$(-'#'()#A"')#"')"+1$')#4$ 5,$($)# ,AD

C4$#4$,#4$51"')#'

4"()&"-($ "&#') # '1$#4$5,$($)#(-'#D

C4$#4$,#4'(&-,#4"()2-,'(%'&#')##,. ")%$)#$,#"')#4$(-'#D

0 $1'$ E

",#'$( 1$% #4$', $;'%$)&$ ') (-55,# #4$', ,$(5$&#';$51$"( ,'"1 -,# ;'%$ 2-%3A$)#F%$&,$$ %"#$% %'(A'(($%#4$(-'# #4$51"')#'

>"55$11")#4$ ("'%2-%3A$)#F%$&,$$:$,$-54$1%')")"55$"1 '1$%+.#4$ 51"')#'

>"55$11")# +. #4$ ',(# 55$11"#$ -,# ;'%$ 2-%3A$)#F%$&,$$ %"#$%

$)&$/ #4$ 5,$($)# "55$"1+.#4$"55$11")# 4";$4$",%1$",)$%&-)($1 ,#4$"55$11")#")% 4";$3)$#4,-34#4$,$&,%";"'1"+1$)#4$ '1$&",$ -11. %A'##$%1./"55$11")#:"(:,?')3"(")(#"+1$ :'#4 #4$ %$ $)%")#( :$;$,/ "55$11")# "+($)#$% ,A %-#.")%%$5",#A$)#"15,&$$%')3(:$,$')'#'"#$%"3"')(# #4$"55$11")##4"(+$$))#'&$%+.#4$-,#(+$1:#4"# " 5$,-("1 #4$ ')G-',. 5,&$$%')3( ,$;$"1( #4"# #4$ "55$11")#4"% 4'A($1 ,$&$';$% #4$ )#'&$ )

($)##4'A+.#4$)G-',.

'&$,')#'A"#')34'A"+-##4$ 5$)%$)&. #4$5,&$$%')3(:$;$,/"55$11")# "'1$%# 2')#4$')G-',.5,&$$%')3(55$11")#:"(($,;$%:'#4#4$ &4",3$>(4$$#) ")%#4$("A$:"(,$&$';$%+.

#4$ "55$11")# 5$,()"11. "1)3 :'#4 #4$, %&-A$)#(

)#4$, )#'&$ %"#$% = :"( '((-$% # #4$ "55$11")##"55$",+$ ,$#4$)G-',.

'&$,")%#4$("A$ :"(($,;$%)#4$"55$11")#5$,()"11. $(5'#$ 4";')3 ,$&$';$% #4$ ("'% )#'&$/ "55$11")# "'1$% # 2') ')G-',.

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

'&$, '( +"($% ) (A$ $;'%$)&$/ #4$) #4$ -,# &"))# ,$> "55,$&'"#$ #4$ $;'%$)&$ , :$'34 #4$ ("A$ 1'?$ #4$ 55$11"#$-#4,'#.1)3"(#4$,$'((A$$;'%$)&$') (-55,# #4$&)&1-(')",,';$%"#+.#4$%$5",#A$)#"1 "-#4,'#./#4$("A$4"(#+$(-(#"')$%A$%$ $&#')#4$ ')G-',.4"(#+$5')#$%-#+$ ,$#4'(-,#&")')#$, $,$ :'#4 #4$ 5-)'(4A$)# ,%$, -,#4$, A,$/ '

%$ $&# '(

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

$+,-",. / 0

$+,-",. / 0 A"4";',