Sukhwant Singh v. Jasvir Singh


 

       




 !

"





 



 !"#$

%&!

##$$%& '( '#()%

%&!

#&   *+,-.



'/ 01.

 '0 ,001 & )* +$$,-%& .&/%##$$%& )*%0%$,-%& .&/#& 11111  '0 ,0012 '

/%##$$%&2.%&3*(4/0%&*+5//%.+$ 5($% *-##%$%5%+&+6#(57(56&%-%&" 8

#%9:$%+&+%$+&+-&(5,%$%/%+0/+-/&/ %##%$/%9+6+%&/7(56&%-%&  ;

#%9:$% ++$(5<(++++=,%$%/%0%(#/$ /  .%-&  .  &/  -%  %  &/%&  %+  *+5/ 3 #&2#$%+&+.. /%  .+$  (+&  .  -:  .  >,8 , 2
 +

, 2
%#+-+#%$%6(&%  ,; , 2
%+&&%&&/%& .8?#%(6.6  >

&

8%$50+&/.(&( +&&%&&/%&.8?#%(6.6&/%&..+$+5.(+&&+$$+& %$+@%&+ /#$%+&+..%$$5&/%&/0%(+5&/9(+.

66++  5&  (  &/  %6  %  &:$  .  )2  %/%$  %+5

6#%:, %+)%4&,$$%0%$#(,/+$%+&+-&%$%/%0/+-/ +$##+&/+#--.&/#$%+&+../.%&0%%.%6

%&+$$%5%%0%,/+$%+&+-&%$%/% /:0/%+5 %$+5 % 5 $%&+/+# 0+&/ %-/ &/     >

, &/ .%&90 2
.6&/#$%+&+..0+&/+&&. ?

#6&/+8?#%(6&/#&A&&/%&/B(+6:. /+(,&#%:&/$%%6(&,.#(-/%.%.&+$+@&- %56&0%(-+&0+&+59&0&/#$%+&+..%&/ .%&+&/#-.0+&5%+5-+#&. ;,;

, 2
9:&/.%&/.%&%(&#%:&/+%6(&%$50+&/ +&&&&/#$%+&+..6%/#$%+&+..B(&&/.%& (69.&+6&&(&/6:%#&/&6%-+&+.&/ %56&%&  >

9(&/.%+$#(&..&/6%&& #&A&&/&/%($&+6%&$:.(&6%4&/#%:6& / .%&+&((#&/%6(&%$&%$5%$&+-%&

8(*-&+;

2;CC2 >2  &/(5//+-($ )%$9+*+5/ /%/%$,-%&,%$%/%%+&0%#$+9:&/ -($.&/#$%+&+..%6$:) (+%,-%& / .%&0%-%$$(#&&(&/%6(&0+&/+&&9(& %6(&0%#%+ $&+6%&$:,&/(+&0%.+$ "

&+-.&/(+&0%5+&&/.%&0/-&& &/(+&%.+$/+0+&&&%&6&&%4+5#$+6+%:97-&+&/%& &/(+&0%&6%+&%+%9$+&/#&.6/#$%+&+../%


&.+$&/(+&0%&/%+5%:-%(.%-&+&.+$ &/(+&+&%##%-/&/ (&0+&/-$%/%/(+&0% 9%9:&+6  6+&.&/-%,&/.%&+&/% 90 , 2
  >

%%$$5+&/#$%+&/0% B(+6&.&/.%&&%+%$% +&/%+5%: $%##&:/.,/0&/#$%+&+..#%+ , 2
%$%

"
0+&/(&&%4+5%:-(+&: .%-&,&/%$$5%56&/%9 ##%.%(($&$:9:&/#$%+&+..+-+%-0+&//+0# %0+& .%-&,&/.%&6+5/&/%#(&/++5%&(%% 0+&%9$%4#+&.6 /.%&+%+$$+&%&# 0/+5%&(/%9.59:&/#$%+&+../#$%+&+../% -%(.%-&+&.+$&/#&(+&/(+&+.%$,.+$(0+&/(& 6+&%&/%66%:4+$:9+6+ ;

/#$%+&+...+$7+&&/0+&&&%&6&+0/+-/ /+&/.%-&&%&+&/0+&&&%&6&%+&%&/+-$%+6 +&/#$%+& 6  &/  #$%+5  .  &/  #%&+,  .$$0+5  +(  0 .%69:&/&+%$ (&" "



  
 





   

 

 
 ! 

" 

 

 # $

!%&&

" 

  
 

  '  (%&&

)  

 *  +!      "

  

+  

(%&&

  

 , 
 '

   (%&-

 

  
 ! 
 !

  !

'


 

(%&-

   ,  , !(%&-

.  

  !

,
(%&-

 


;
>     &  #  &/  (+&,  &/  #&
#$%+&+..  %+ *+5/A%6+/+6$.%D
%$A%6+%0%&*+5/% D %*(/+E%$%D
"/%.&,$%-($.&/#$%+&+.. -$&/+- !

&9(&&/-%.&/#&
#$%+&+..,&/ %##$$%&
.%&*(4/0%&*+5//+6$.&##+&&/0+&9A %D
/%.&,.%&-$&/+- .&/%+5&/%5(6&%%-9:$%-($. 9&/&/#%&+,&/(+&.+$9:&/#&
#$%+&+..0%-0+&/ -&%.%&0%+-&&6%4&/#%:6&.%6(&+ B(&++ , 2
&&/#$%+&+..0+&/+&&,%&&/%&.C? #%(6.6&/%&.#%:6&&+$$&/.+$+5.&/#&-%% %&&/%&.>?#%(6.6&/%&..+$+5&/#&(+&&+$$+& %$+@%&++7(56&%-%&  ;$+5%55+ .&/+7(56&%-,&/%##$$%&2.%&/%.+$&/%##%$ 9.

  &/  E0  ##$$%&  (&,  0/+-/  0%  %$  +6+  + +6#(57(56&%-%&" 8 /%.&,&/#& 5($%-%##%$/%9.+$ /%/%&/%5(6&%%-9:$%-($. &/%##$$%&2.%&%$%-($.&/#&2#$%+&+.. E%-($.&/%##$$%&2.

+%.5-(6& &4%:

$%.6&/#$%+&+..A-(&%+5&/%56&++#(& /%##$$%&2.%&0%&0.%:%5+-($&(%$$%,&/., &/0%B(&+.#%:6&.$%6:/B(+6: &#(-/%.&+$+@/&%&%49:&/#&2 #$%+&+.. + .%$ % ---& +  .%-&&/.%&/.

&/%##$$%&2.%&/%6%$+50+&/&/#&2#$%+&+.., (&/5%9.(&:&/#$%+&+..6+5/&/%9&%+/++5%&( -&%+9$%4#%#%&%6##%#0/+-/0$%&-&+& %+%56&++#(& /$%-($.&/%##$$%&2.%&.&&/ +#(&%56&%&  >

A
%.&&/#%-+5+ &/$+ /%6.-+90%0+&&0+&/+..&# / 0+&  &  &/  %.%+  %56&  %&    >

 A
  % +&&0+&%&/+&%&6&-%&9%.$:$+(#/ #&2#$%+&+../%.%+$&#(-/+94.%--(&&/0 &/%&(6. , 2
0%5+%%$%&&/%##$$%&2.%& &/+%6(&0%.$-&+/++-6&%A&(/$%-(& 9$0/%.%+$&-+&/%.%+.%-&%/%05$:- &/(+&.+$9:&/#&2#$%+&+..&/9%+.%56&%&   >

A
 &+#%:&/%&&/.++55+9:&/$%

++$  (5  <(+  +++=,  %$%/%  6%:  4+$:  9  &  %+  9: %--#&+5&/#&%##%$%&/(+&.+$9:&/#&2#$%+&+..
%+*+5/6%:4+$:9+6+0+&/-&

&/&//%,$%-($.&/#&2#$%+&+.. +/+9+.%5(6&#+&(&&/%&&/.%-&.&/-%%&/ %56&%&  >

A
+($:#-9:A%6++5 &/#&2#$%+&+..
%+*+5/%D
%0$$%9:A%6++5 9&/6%5+%$0+&%6$:%0%&*+5/%D
%*(/+E%$ %D
"/&%&%49:&/%##$$%&2.%&+$.-&%+-&: /$%-($.&/#&2#$%+&+...(&/.&&/ -
A%6+%&+.*(4/0%&*+5/D
,0///%%6+&&&/ .%-&%$$59:&/#$%+&+.. +&/#$%+&  /%&+#(& /+

>
+5%&(&/%56&%&  >

A
/.,&/.%-& .&/-%%&/+--0+5/&$:-+9:&/-(& . ++$  (5 <(+  +++=, %$%/% %  &/ (+&  .+$  9: &/ #$%+&+..4+5-:0%+5/&$:-+7(56&%- %&  ;%&/%##%$#.9:&/.%&0%%$ +5/&$:+6++7(56&%-%&" 8 &+#%: &/%&&/%##%$#.9:&/%##$$%&2.%&+6+%$  /%-+&/%.%+%5(6&%%-9. 6%/%5&/(5/&/-.$%&+%$ (&+ ++$*(+&  > ;. "-+  ;/#$%+&+..
%+*+5/.+$ (+&  .  -:    &/  9%+  .    %56&  %&    >

, %--+5&0/+-/&/%##$$%&2.%&*(4/0%&*+5/90% (6. , 2
%%5&#%:&/%60+&/+&&%&&/%& 8?#%(66%/%+%56&%&  >

A
 +#-9:*(4/0%&*+5/%D
%/+++ (##&9:9&/6%5+%$0+&A%6+%%0%&*+5/D

%*(/+E%$%D
" /0+&-%&5+-%$$:&%&&/%&&/ %##$$%&2.%&*(4/0%&*+5//%A-(&&/%.%+%56& %&  >

A
-+#&.$%. , 2
0/+-// %5&#%:0+&/+&&%#&/&6%-+&+6&++ &/%.%+%56& &/-%+/%,&/%##$$%&2.%&-&&&/(+& %.+$/+0+&&&%&6&+&$:,&%4+5&/&%&/%&&/%56& +B(&+0%5&##%.%(($&$:+-+%-0+&/&/0+& 0/%(##&.#&2#$%+&+...(&/,&4&/&%&/%& +&+#+9$&/%&#&2#$%+&+..0%%9$&5&/++5%&( 9$%4#+&.60/+-/0%$%&6+(9:&/#&2#$%+&+..

!
.(&/&4&/&%&/%&&/%##$$%&2.%&/%%$+50+&/ &/ #&2#$%+&+..    0%  & /%+5  %: $%, &/., &/ B(&+.%++5$%.&/%$$5#(#&%+0, +&/5(.%##%$,&/%##$$%&2.%&&4&/&%&/%&&/ %56&  +  %  .5  %  .%9+-%&  -(6&     &/+  -%  &/ %##$$%&2.%&
*(4/0%&  *+5/  &##  +&  &/  0+&  9A  % D
/-
A%6+%&+.%##$$%&2.%&+6%&+%$0// %6+&&  &/%&  &/  #&2#$%+&+..  +  (+5  &/  9(+  .

66++  5&  (  &/  %6  %  &:$  .  )2  %/%$  %+5

6#%:, %+)%4&,$$%0%$#(,/+$%+&+-&%$%/%  +&/%%+$%. , 2
%$50+&/+&&%&&/%& .8?#%(6./+0(,.#%:6&.$%%6(&.&/ $%,.#(-/%.%.&+$+@&-%%&&/+&%5,/&%& &/%&/+.%&//%9&%+&/%6(&.6&/#$%+&+..%//% %..+A/++5%&(/%.&,/-$%+6&/%&/+.%&//%&( &/&+%6(&9(&/-%&#(-%:#.5%+5&/%6 $%&#%&.&/-
A%6+%&+,/.(&/%6+&&&/%&0/%: %5+-($&(%$#(-+$&&/-66++%5&&/
.6++( %6+&&&/%&
.6AF0%+(#&%++5&/+%5+-($&(%$ %$+50+&/&/#$%+&+...(&/%6+&&/++5%&(%56& %&  >

A
%&#+&%%$50+&/0+&%0%& *+5/%*(/+E%$,0//%%$%..+A&/++5%&(&/%6, %&  &/  &+6  .  A-(&+  /.,  &/  &%  &%4  9:  &/ %##$$%&2.%&+.%$+.+.6/+-
A%6+%&+%D
 .(&/--&/%&//%&.+$%:-6#$%+&&&/#$+-%: &/%(&/+&:.9&%++5/++5%&(%56&A
+% .%(($&6%/%##$$%&/%&%4-&%+-&:&%&%+

8
/+$+%9+$+&:9(&.%+$&#&/%6.%-&&/%##$$%&2.%&
*(4/0%&*+5//%%6+&&&/&+-%.&/#&2#$%+&+.. /.,&/.%-&.&/-%%&/+--0+5/&$: -+9:&/-(&. ++$(5<(++++=,%$%/%%&/ (+&.+$9:&/#$%+&+..
%+*+5/0%+5/&$:-%&/%##%$ #.  9:  &/  %##$$%&2.%&
*(4/0%&  *+5/  0%  +5/&$: +6++7(56&%-%&" 8

+0.&/.%-&%&/-+-(6&%-.&/-%% +-(%9,&/+-&5+9:&/-(&9$0+9%## %##-+%&+.&/.%-&%&/+-- (9&%&+%$ B(&+.$%0.%-&%++&/+%##%$&.+%:%& +&.+&/--(&.++5.&/&0 (&9$0+.%(.&/ #&2#$%+&+.. ($&%&$:,.++56+&+&/ 5($%*- ##%$.+$9:&/%##$$%&2.%&*(4/0%&*+5/,&/%6+ %--+5$:+6+ /--+.6&/&0 (&9$09&9%-4 &&/--B(%& +5%##$+-%&+<=+.%:,%$&%+#. ! 8

"

 '0 ,001 /

-

'/34.

D/&/#%4+52%

2 D/&/#&%9$

2