High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3553/2014dismissed

Jiwani v. Anguri

2017-12-16Lok Adalat Bench - 38 pages

!"# $$%% &'()*)

#+*( $ , -./%0&--1 $(')'# ("2#''

#+34526"

( 3'"77'88"# 999 3' 7(')'# "77'"8 ) "

3' :'3') 3' 78" #

:' #+ "++( '2'5 3'6#6*(('# ;*5+ )"#55'6('')7"))'5:< 3'8'"(#'5 6*( ):'8!45 ) )) #+3'()* (5'68"("

#"#57'( "#'# #;*#6 # ( 3')"=' 6#2'# '#6'4 3'7"( ')"(':' #+('

'(('5 ") 7'( 3' (( + #"87) # # 3'6 2 8)* 3'78" #

8'5 ")* (5'68"("

36#)'>*'# "8 ('8 '

7'( "#'# #;*#6 # 3''

'6 3'('+ ) '('5+

5''5 ?5"

)#*88"#52 5:' #+:")'5*7# ("*5"#53")# '

'6 2'( 3'( +3 )

3" 3'(7("<'(

:'(') (" #'5 ( "8 '#"

#+ 3'8"#54")5'

" 8'5 # 3'3'"5 #+

, , 3':( '

"6 )4")"2'(('5 # 4"('

!")!#'( #7))')) # 8"#5) '")*( #+

="#"8) "(8"6 7( ) #+ =3'!"

@? 4:' #+ @ 3 )3"(' "88"#5 '")*( #+ A ="#"8) "(8")4"#5 ="#"8? "(8")6 7( ) #+=3'!"

@?4 *"

'5 #2 88"+'B3"

="(4")5'

" 8'5 # 3')* # 3:'

(' #)

* # 3')* 4:( 3'(

4#"

'8<'8*45 '5"

2 88"+'B3"

="(-'

!")"8)"6,)3"('( # 3')* 8"#5 !")) "

3')* 8"#56"

# 3'3"#5)

"#53'(:( 3'( ( 3' ( ('

3'()3'

7(7'( <!")"#6') ("8"#57"( ; # 3 #5* "

8<7(7'( <'

)

3'! 5! '8* !")"88'+'5 # 3'")= #+

"66 7"# '5 3'( 3'

6' *: '+ ) ("(4 063"#"4 #

3'!")"88'+'58< "='#*#5'( 7(')) # )"#6 # #+

* "

)*66')) #5*' 3'5'"

3 '8*3'"88'+'5 3'(

3* : 7(')) #)!'(' "='##7"7'()"#5)3':' #+ 88 '("

':'8 '2 #+

3'2'() # 7* 3'( 3* : 7(')) #)5"<:'

(' 8 #+

3')* 4!3'#

' 3'(7"('# )3*)' 8'")'* 3'8"#5

3'()3"('4)3'!"))*(7( )'5 =#! 3"5:'6 '!#'( #7))')) # 3')" 58"#5# 3':") ) +

5''5'C'6* '5:<

-'#6'4 3')* !") 8'5 ## 6'4 8'5!(

'#) "

!")) "

5''5!")'C'6* '5"

3'( (''! 88"#5* 82'"#5"

'6 # :<

!")"2'(('5

!")# " ! "# !") 3'("2'(('5

!") "(( '5"#5!")8 2 #+ 33'(3*):"#5

,, 3'8'"(#'5 ( "86*( ("

88! #+ ))*'),

D3'

3'(

5''5?5"

) 88'+"84#*88 "#52 54:")'5# ("*5"#5# : #5 #+*7# 3'( +3 )

E$$

))*' )7(2'54!3'

3'(

)'#

8'5 5'68"("

#")7("<'5 (:<3'(E$$ D3'

3'(

)'#

8'5 7'( "#'# #;*#6 #") 7("<'5 (:<3'(E$$ D3'

3'( )* )# " # " #":8'E$ '8 '

3'78" #

4 #(5'( )*77( 3')* 43'()'8 "77'"('5") $D "#53'(#'73'!"+: ( #+35'7)'5")$D 7< 3'('+ ) '('5 +

5''5"#567< 3';"

":"#5 !'(''C3 :

'5")C$"#5C$/4 (')7'6 2'8< 3'5'

4 #(5'( (':* 3'68"

'C"

#'5*=3: ( #+3/*("4" :'3) 85"(4")D "

')34"

#+ #'))

5''54"#5 "77'"('5")D "#5D4 (')7'6 2'8< 7< 3' ('+ ) '('5 +

5''5 5"

!") 7(5*6'5")CD @ 3' 8'"(#'5 ( "8 6*( 4 "

'( 6#) 5'( #+ 3' "6 ) "#5 "77('6 "

#+ 3''2 5'#6'7(5*6'545'6 5'5 ))*') "#5"+" #)

"#5 ))*'!")5'6 5'5 # "2*( 3'#'

(')*8 !") 2 5';*5+ "#55'6(''5"

3')* !") 5 ) ))'5 ++( '2'5 3'"

(')" 5;*5+ "#55'6(''4"77'"8!")

8'5:< 3'78" #

%'"(#'555 #"8 ) ( 6 *5+'4 #54

,, 2 5';*5+ "#55'6(''5"

5 ) ))'5 3'"77'"8 -'#6'4 3''+*8"('6#577'"8 %'"(#'56*#)'8 (

"(+*'5 3'8'"(#'56*( :'8!3"5'(('5 #5 ) )) #+ 3')* 4")

5''5!")(')*8 ("*5 :< -'6# '#5'5 " 8'5 7(2' +'#* #'#'))

5''54") ))6( :'!")# 'C"

#'5-' 3'( 6# '#5'5

!")('8"

"#5)3'!")"# '("

'8"5<0#5'( 3'!(#+ 7(')) #4 !3 8'78"< #+

("*54+ 3'( 3* : 7(')) #)# 3'7"7'()- )6# # ) #*) 7(2' ("#)"6 #!") #+5 "

3!")# !3 63)3' " 8'5 5 )63"(+' 3'( ))*'!")(" )'5("(+*'5 3'6# #)(" )'5:<8'"(#'56*#)'83"2'#)*:) "#6'

"#5"('8 ":8' :'(';'6 '5# 6")'4"7"( ( 3')'8 )'(2 #+ "

5''5!")"(')*8 ("*54#'2 5'#6'

!( 3('8 "#6'!"):(*+3 #('6(5$D "+: ( #+34#'73'!

45'7)'5 #3'( "2*(:* !")7(2'5 3'!")# 7(')'# "

' 'C'6*

5''5#)*636 (6* "#6')43 )'2 5'#6'

!") #2"8*'# 3' 3'(3"#54 'C"

#'5D *=3: ( #+3/*("4" :'3) 85"(4"#5D "

')34#' 3'"

#+!

#'))

5''5/ 3 3')'!

#'))')5'7)'5 7*+#'5+

5''5 !")'C'6* '5"#5!")('+ ) '('5 # 3'

6' *:'+ ) ("(D ) "

3'+

5''5!")7(')'# '5:'

('3 "#53'3"5('+ ) '('5 ")7'(

, , (*8')"#53"5('"52'( 3' #) (* 3'7"( ') #7(')'#6' #'))')3'"

#+!

#'))4#"

'8<D "

')345'7)'5 3'3"5 7* 3 ) 3* : 7(')) #)#

5''5#

"#5 3')" 5+

5''5!")('"52'(

"#5)3'"

3'(!# (''! 88'C'6* 5''5D "8)5'7)'5

3"5 !:( 3'()4#"

'8<'8* "#5$"( "7"4"#5 )'8*.)! 5!#)*636 (6* "#6')4

'('8<:'6"*)' 3')6( :'

5''5!")# 'C"

#'5! 88# '"#

3'#*)78"6'5*7# !")# 5 )63"(+'5 '6 #A 3'#5 "#2 5'#6'6

()3( 4F 6 .('"5)")*#5'(,

!"#$%&"'

"#$%( )

,, )7'( 3'"

(')" 57(2 ) #4"56* !3 63!")('>* ('5

:'"

'5 #8"!)3"88#8<:'*)'5 #'2 5'#6'!3'#" 8'") #' "

#+!

#'))') )6"88'5 (7(2 #+ 3')"

'3'#8<7(2 ) )

3'"

#+!

#')))3*85:'"8 2' ) 3'( :'6#) 5'('5

5''5!")"('+ ) '('5 56* 6"((< #+ 3'73 +("73) 5#(45#''")!'88") 3'"

#+ #'))')3'56* :' #+"('+ ) '('5#'47(')* (* 3 ) "

"63'5 3')"

' 3'8'+"87) # )!'88)'

8'5 #'!3"88'+') ("*53")

7(2' '8 "#6' )78"6'5*7#"5'6 ) # 3'-#.:8'7'C*( #

4!3'(' # 3"):''#3'85")*#5'(, *+) ,-

) .

/ 0 !. !"# #

$% !& '&

(& !( )*+) *, - .

)

, ,

)

- )!-

)1 # 3'":2'5'6 ) #4 3'8"!3"):''#'#*#6 "

!3"88'+') ("*5( (+'(<3") 7(2' # 6")'4'2'#'6 #

3'6 !*85# :'

"#<3'87

( 3'('")#)

3"5# :''#":8'

7(2' 3'7) "6 2'6# 5'#6'3'85:< *( 3'(4 5'

3"5:''#":8' ') ":8 )3 3'56* !")'C'6* '5:<

'(68'"(8<*#5'() "#5 #+ 3'#"

*(' ("#)"6 ##)*63 6 (6* "#6')4 3'6#6*(('# ;*5+ "#55'6('')7"))'5:< 3'8'"(#'5 6*( ):'8!6"## :' "*8 '5!

3 *( #+ 3'6*()' 3'"( #+48'"(#'56*#)'8 ( 3'"77'88"#

6*85# 7 # * "#< 88'+"8 <(7'(2'() < # 7*+#'5;*5+

7"))'5 :< 3'8'"(#'5 () "77'88"

' 6*( -'6*85 # ('

'( "#< >*') 8"! *638')))*:) "# "8>*') 8"!!3 63 )) #'>*"##

( 3 )6*( 'C'(6 )' )"77'88"

'7!'(*#5'('6 #

3'$ 3'("(+* !")(" )'5 #) 5'( #+ 3' "6 )"#56 (6* "#6') 3'6")'# '5

,A, ":2'4 6*78'5 !

3 3' ('")#) "

(', #'54 3 ) *( ) 6#) 5'('52 '! "77'"8 ):'('

'( "#5!

3* "#< )*:) "#6'4 3*) *) " 8 ')*8 "# 8<4 3' #) "# )'6#5"77'"8 )5 ) ))'543!'2'(4 3#(5'(") 6) ) !"# $

% &'

#5;