High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6264/2015dismissed

United Church Of Northern India Trust Association And ORS v. Shiv Raj Masih And ORS

2018-02-12Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul7 pages

! "#

! $%

" !#

&&&& '" %" ()$*

", &&&&

$ '") ", # "

)

.. )" & /, "

", " , *0

, )

.. )" & /,

,+ " " /# " / , (# /0

" 2-- 3) "

" $# / * ,"#"*1, " 3), " /, (# /0

" .4 3) "

+ $# / 5 "+ 6*%#7 "*1 0 8" ) * , &

5, " 9

:6 , #

" "0 (# " "/ ,

5" , " 6 0 #/) "

3"# ,

&& 0/ 0 *"

*" " 0

,0 #"/.

; &.%" * , , #*,

& ,#"

,, 0 3 1 "

, #"

") , 3

)

(03

", ) "<<&<< )

3) , ,

+ $# / * + * #) + # .44=< 9 ,#"

", " ! "#0"">;, :,3 #", "+ ""

, " " 0 # "## # " "# # ) 0 "

, #"

") + #"

0 , " " ,"

#/,

, 3

, " / 0# * 3# , 0# 1 3),

"*%#7 "+

" 4?<<< * , "

" * ")

%# 4 (03

" , ) " <<&<< 1, , 1

, 1 ","/,

+ "

, #"

")'

&%( "%,, 0 ,, ,3 #, "> 3)

& ,#"

", " ,"

#/, " -<<4

" "

" 0/ 0 * "

* " "

"),#*, 0// "

/, # ") , ) " <<4 ,

1, 3 / , "

0 "

,")*0 )*,#"

", " 561

3 )

#), #"

") " @ ", , "" ", 3 + &0 0 " 50 03 "

6 "

, #"

") "# # ) + #"

0 "

"1, ,

, + # .44=<*"

3 + *1, ,1

+ #"

@ # 3), 1 + )

/0 1, ,,3 0

&4&

1/,

% 03 ""

," /

3 )

#), #"

") ," /

3"# ,

00//, #"

"1, ,, ),+ "/, , #1 *

, " 1" 0 "/ " 0") 3( / , , # 03 , ,#"

, "

3) ' " , 7 %,

4,+ "/, "

" , 0/ 0

, ,#"

, #, ") " "

%( "%, ,

" " " /

7 , "# ,#"

", " 56

,#"

", " "#

5 6

0 , /

" * , " #" "0 ,

1/# & 96 A, , "

"0 (# ")

"B''

6 A, , "#

03 , "

"0B' A, , ",

,+ 0 #"1,

, , 0 " 0, #"B ' .6 :

, "# # 1, , ",

"0 (# *, + #"+ /0

.4,, ,

." # )0// ,

,#"

,, "

" *, )"

")"

"0 (# , /"

3), + #""

, (# /0 " # "& 9 13)1)

" #,

7/"

"0 (# " "/,

0 #/

&.& ) 3"# , 0/ 0 *"

*" "*") " 0

")0 , ,

, " 7"

"0 (# ")

+ , # )

, # "

") + ) 0//,

,# + ", "

# 'A* 1, , , " #* 0/ ,0 3 , , "

, 1 + ",

& @0 , , / " ) 0 , +

1"/ %"7 'A= - , 1 , "

, / , ,/ , @

)/,, " 1 " )0 " , , " 0 1 + "1, , 1#C# 1," /"

" 0 "

, ") ", *, 0 , , " 1 " )

, , 3# , 0"

+ 3))/,, 0 1 # ,

," 0 ## '# 1)/, " ) 3 1 + " 0,

" 0 0 3)'A* ,/ ",, " " )0 " ,

, " 0 1 + "

, 3"/ + / " )3 ", "

+ 1, ,, 3 1 , / , 1, # ),

#03 " ." 0//,

, " )

$03

", ) "

<<&<<*

#03 ", 1 3 1 "

, # ") 1 + ",

" #

#03 " . + 1, 0//,

, ,% + ", & @0 'A, / " ) ,, 1

3 #

7* 0 0 " #0 "

,* # " #"

, # * " /" " # 3) " /""

0 1 + "

#0 1"

3), 1 @

1/ @

"3 # 3

#", "#3 , ,

#03 " ."

&-& 0//,

,, 'A* + , #/,, + "

#0 1, " /"

, 37

#0 3)

" ) "3 3 + 1 + " , & @0 , 1 ,

/ " ) 0 ,,

#1 "

=?=- #", " 0 ,,

, 37

+ " ) , " /, 37

#1 # ) , "

#", " 0 , "3"

#/,3),01," /"

# C# , " 1 "/ " # , " #", "

0 , " 0

#*, 0 #1

)," 0 ,

#C# , "

, + 1

3 + 0 0 3)'A*, " ,/

#// ,,

#C# 1 0 3)

" + )0//,

#03 " ,, ", " + /

#0 "

+ "

3),

#3 ,

#03 " ." + )0//,

, ), 3 * ,

1 ,+ 3

+ #0 #

#0 1," /"

0/ 0

#03 " ,,3 / , *

, ,

#03 " ." # )0//,

#03 " , " , "

")"

"0 (# 1," /"

0/ 0 *"

*" "*") " 0

#03 " ,"

") C# ), " #

/ ,

+ #"

//" + 3) ,

" (# /0

.4 3) , " #"* &

" , " E 1 " #" 1 + "*+ /0

" 2--*E 1 " #" 0 ,

" 3), " #"1

&2& ,

" "

#0 *

& ,+

, " 0#//, (# /0

" 3),

#"3 1 E " #

", ,"/# ," , , , #" 3 1 ,+ 00 / ""

" "

/, + 3),

*, 0 +

'A&( ,F#* A* 87

' *8"

%#7 "* ,

# <--<5@'A=6, 0

,#"

, ", " %#7 "1, ,# " ' / %#7 ", 1#03 "

#1--<-4?4?45@'A=6 ,

#*0 #

*=& *=&1 " ,

# 13 / " 3)%( "%, 1 , " " , #", "

"/# ,,0 #1/" 3)'#(3F + "0

& ,#"

, , 3

,0 #*

/1,1

0 03 "

# <--< 87

' 2-- , #", ""/# ,

1 " 7 "

, *, "

" *, #103 1 3 3

,+ , "

" #

", "# , (# /0

#"3 1 " / ,

"0 (#

" ",

0 "

"/,

# *

, /"

1 3 ,, " ,

1 " " C#"

+ ,, )" # )0//,

, ,#"

, # + ", "

") # , #/, & @0 *,

5'A6, 0 ,0 3 , "

&?&

, ,#"

,*3# #"/, & @0 ,1 , 0

, , 1 , "

, ,#"

, , #0

" )0 ", ,#"

," 0 " 0

, # ,

+ / " )3 , "

1, ,0) 3 ,,

" )0 " , ,#"

, , #"3 1,+ " #" /

1 " 0//,

, ,#"

, ,+ +

3 ,,, )"

, ,#"

, #3 C#

1" , " " /# "

, ""/#0 "

, " " #"" /

3)3 , , #"3 1*, #"

)" "

" , 1 " /0

#"3 1

/ )*" 0 !#

( + A, , " 7/=" G =

A, , ""

"3 B G =