High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6275/2015dismissed

State Of Punjab And Others v. Surjit Singh

2016-01-08Mrs Justice Sabina5 pages

! ! ! !

"#$ %$&'(')* "#$ %$&'(')* "#$ %$&'(')* "#$ %$&'(')* ")+",- ./

")+",- ./

")+",- ./ #"#$ +)0"1")%#2$,( 33$44")#( 5$,(+( +,0'#')62 $(3)%$)# * * * * 78 78 78 78

,$($)#*

,$($)#* ,9 '%2+/%%4 +)0"1 , 9")("4/%:&"#$

,#2$&":$"#, ;;;;;

;;;;;

/ $(3)%$)#2"% '4$%(+'# ,%$&4","#')&2"44$)6')6 #2$ ,%$, %"#$%

/ <2$,$1-/ 3$)"4#- &$)(+,$

($,:'&$")%,$&:$,-

= #2$"44$6$%4((##2$#+)$

>/ /?

@A<"('B3($%+3)2'B 2$&"($ #2$"33$44")#/')1,'$ /<"(#2"#2$<"( <,C')6"("$)',&4$,C<'#2 D $3",#B$)#) "4($ "44$6"#')(/&2",6$A(2$$#%"#$% . E

<"(($,:$%)#2$ "33$44")#")%)#2$1"('( #2$')F+',-,$3,#/'B3+6)$%,%$, <"(3"(($% 2$'B3+6)$%,%$,<"(&2"44$)6$%')#$,A"4'") #2$6,+)%#2"#'#2"(1$$)3"(($%1-#2$33$44"#$+#2,'#- ")%&)($F+$)#4-/#2$,'62# #2$"33$44")## '4$")"33$"4<"( 3,$0+%'&$% $(3)%$)#(')#2$',<,'##$)(#"#$B$)#":$,,$%#2"# #2$'B3+6)$%,%$,2"%1$$)3"(($%"(3$,4"< )#2$34$"%')6( #2$3",#'$(/ 44<')6'((+$(<$,$

,"B$%1-#2$#,'"4+,#*A G D2$#2$, ,%$, %"#$%

'((+$% :'%$ )%,(# %"#$%

1- %$ $)%")# "(

%$#"'4$% ') #2$ 2$"%')6 #2$ 34"')# '( '44$6"4/ ",1'#,",-/B"4"

'%$/+)&)(#'#+#')"4/"6"')(##2$:# ')(#,+&#')(/ 3,:'(')( )(#'#+#') )%'" ")% 3,')&'34$( )"#+,"4 0+(#'&$ ")% '( 4'"14$ # 1$ ($# "('%$H

D2$#2$,#2$34"')#'

'($)#'#4$% ,%$&4","#') 3,"-$% ,H

D2$#2$, #2$ 34"')#'

'( $)#'#4$% , ')0+)&#') 3,"-$% ,H

E D2$#2$,#2$(+'#'()#B"')#"')"14$H

D2$#2$,#2$%$ $)%")#(",$$)#'#4$%#(3$&'"4 &(#H

$4'$ I

",#'$(4$%#2$',$:'%$)&$')(+33,# #2$',,$(3$&#':$ 34$"( ,'"4 +,# :'%$ 0+%6B$)#@%$&,$$ %"#$% E %$&,$$% #2$ (+'# #2$ ,$(3)%$)#A34"')#'

2$ ("'% 0+%6B$)#@%$&,$$3"(($%1-#2$#,'"4+,#<$,$+32$4%1-#2$

',(#33$44"#$+,#:'%$0+%6B$)#@%$&,$$%"#$%

') ")"33$"4 '4$%1-#2$"33$44")#(A%$ $)%")#($)&$/#2$3,$($)# "33$"41-#2$"33$44")#(A%$ $)%")#( 2":$2$",%4$",)$%&+)($4 ,#2$"33$44")#(")% 2":$6)$#2,+62#2$,$&,%":"'4"14$)#2$ '4$&",$ +44- ) #2$ 3,$($)# &"($/ "%B'##$%4-/ #2$ 3+)'(2')6 "+#2,'#- #2$ 34"')#'

<"( 2'$ )6')$$,/ D / <2$,$"(/#2$'B3+6)$%,%$,2"%1$$)3"(($%1-#2$$&,$#",- #:$,)B$)# +)0"1/ D 6"')(##2$,%$,3"(($% 1- #2$ 3+)'(2')6 "+#2,'#-/ '$ 2'$ )6')$$,/ D / 34"')#'

&+4%2":$ '4$%(#"#+#,-"33$"41$ ,$#2$$&,$#",-# :$,)B$)# +)0"1/ D #2"(1$$)2$4%1-#2$ )714$3$J+,#')+,0'#2(2:$,(+(2"',B")")"6')6 +,0'#2(2:$,(+(2"',B")")"6')6 +,0'#2(2:$,(+(2"',B")")"6')6 +,0'#2(2:$,(+(2"',B")")"6')6

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

3+)'(2B$)#'(3"(($%1-"2'62$,"+#2,'#-/)"33$"4 '( ":"'4"14$ +)%$, #2$ $6+4"#')( "( '# '( )# )$&$((",- # 3,:'%$ , #2$ ("B$ # <"( "4( &)#$)%$%#2"##2$,$'(),'62##"33$"4+)4$(('#'( 3,:'%$%+)%$,#2$+4$(,$6+4"#')(4#2+62#2$ ",6+B$)#4C("##,"&#':$"# ',(#('62#/'#(<$"C)$(( 4'$( ') #2$ "&# #2"# '# #,'$( # 34"&$ #2$ +4$(@$6+4"#')(<2'&23,:'%$)"33$"4)3",<'#2 #2$+4$(@$6+4"#')(<2$,$"33$"4'(3,:'%$%#'( #,+$ #2"# <2$) ") "+#2,'#- 2'62$, #2") #2$ %'(&'34')",-"+#2,'#-'#($4 'B3($(#2$3+)'(2B$)#/ #2$ ,%$, 3+)'(2B$)# (+

$,( ,B ) '44$6"4'#- <2$) ) "33$"4 '( 3,:'%$% # (+&2 "+#2,'#- <$:$,/<2$)")"33$"4'(3,:'%$%##2$2'62$, "+#2,'#- &)&$,)$% "6"')(# #2$ ,%$, #2$ %'(&'34')",-"+#2,'#-, "4<$,"+#2,'#-")%#2$ 2'62$,"+#2,'#-3"(($("),%$, 3+)'(2B$)#/#2$ $B34-$$ &)&$,)$% '( %$3,':$% #2$ ,$B$%-

"33$"4<2'&2'("(+1(#")#':$,'62#6':$)#2'B1-#2$ +4$(@$6+4"#')()$B34-$$&"))#1$%$3,':$%

2'((+1(#")#':$,'62#D2"#'( +,#2$,/<2$)#2$,$'("

3,:'(') "33$"4 "6"')(# #2$ ,%$, #2$ %'(&'34')",-"+#2,'#-")%<2$)#2$"33$44"#$,#2$ 2'62$, "+#2,'#- "6"')(# <2($ ,%$, #2$,$ '( ) "33$"4/ $J$,&'($( #2$ 3<$,( #2$ %'(&'34')",-

"+#2,'#-')"6':$)&"($/'#,$(+4#(')%'(&,'B')"#') "6"')(##2$$B34-$$&)&$,)$%2'('(3",#'&+4",4- ( <2$) #2$,$ ",$ ) 6+'%$4')$( ) #2$ +4$(@$6+4"#')("(#<2$)#2$2'62$,"+#2,'#-, #2$"33$44"#$"+#2,'#-(2+4%$J$,&'($#2$3<$,(

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

%'(B'(("4(+

$,( ,B")')2$,$)#%$ $&#")%2"(# 1$($#"('%$ 2$ F+$(#')/ 2<$:$,/ '( <2"# &)($F+$)#'"4 ,%$,(2+4%1$3"(($%')#2$3,$($)#&"($#<'44)# 1$ ,+'# +4#($)%#2$B"##$,1"&C##2$")C , ,$2$",')6 #2$ B"##$, 1- #2$ )"B$% %'(&'34')",- "+#2,'#- (')&$#2$"33$44"#$"+#2,'#-<2'&2'(#2$ 2'62$,"+#2,'#-2"("4,$"%-#"C$)"%$&'(')')#2$ B"##$, ")% '# &"))# 1$ $J3$&#$% #2"# #2$ 4<$, "+#2,'#- <'44 #"C$ " %'

$,$)# %$&'(') 2$($ 3,&$$%')6(2":$1$$)3$)%')6"6"')(##2$"33$44")# ,'62# ,B#2$-$",?. #'44#2'(%"-")%#2$"33$44")# 2"(1$$)+# $B34-B$)# ,"44#2$($-$",(# )$(#"6$/#2$"33$44")#2"%

$,$%# ,$6"44#2$ ",,$",( 2'(("4",- 3,:'%$% 2$ <"(,$')(#"#$% ') ($,:'&$)#2$3(##<2'&22$<+4%1$$)#'#4$%"# 3,$($)#)#2$1"('( 2'(&)#')++(($,:'&$#'44%"#$

D$2"%(+66$(#$%#2,'+3#""33$",')6 ,#2$ ,$(3)%$)#A")C ##"C$')(#,+&#')(')#2$B"##$,* 2$,$(3)%$)#A")C/2<$:$,/2"(&2($)#,$0$&# #2$

$,")% 2"(')(#$"% (+66$(#$% #2"##2$")C <+4%4'C$#3"-&B3$)("#')##2$"33$44")#(')&$ '#2"(4(#&) '%$)&$')2'BD$2":$&)('%$,$%#2$ &2",6$("6"')(##2$"33$44")#")%<$ ')%#2"#"3",#

,B#2$ "&##2"#B+&2&")1$("'%') ":+, #2$ "33$44")#')(+33,# 2'(&)#$)#')#2"##2$&2",6$ 2"( 1$$) #,+B3$#$% "6"')(# 2'B 2$ ')F+',- "4( 3,'B" "&'$ 3,'B" "&'$ 3,'B" "&'$ 3,'B" "&'$(+

$,( ,B%$ $&#("(3')#$%+#"1:$/ #2+62<$B+(#"%%#2"#<$2":$)#6)$')##2$ B$,'#( #2$("'%%$ $&#(2$"33$44")#'(")$JA,B-

'&$,D2"#'( +,#2$,/#2$&B3$)("#')"B+)#/'

%',$&#$%#1$3"'%<+4%&B$#"1+#( 4"C2(A 2$ ")C '( " )"#')"4'($% ")C ")% #2$ B)$- 1$4)6(##2$3+14'&2+6$"B+)#)#2'((&"4$ &"))#1$3"'%#")-)$ ,%')6)<,C%+,')6 #2'(4)63$,'%0+(#1$&"+($#2$")C $$4(#2"#'#2"( 4(#&) '%$)&$')#2$$B34-$$$&")&$,#"')4-1$ 34"&$%')"%$3",#B$)#<2$,$2$2"()#2')6#% <'#2#2$B)$#",-#,")("&#')( #2$")C/(+&2"( #2$ $(#"14'(2B$)# ($&#') $#&/ $:$) "((+B')6 #2"# #2$")C2"(,$"()(#4($&) '%$)&$')2'BI 2+(/')#2$ "&#(")%&',&+B(#")&$( #2$3,$($)# &"($/#2$+,#(1$4<,'62#4-1"(')6,$4'")&$)#2$%$&'(')

#2$ )714$ 3$J +,# ') +,0'# 2(27( &"($ (+3," 2":$ %$&,$$%#2$(+'# #2$34"')#'

(+1(#")#'"4 F+$(#') 4"< ",'($( ') #2'( &"($ <",,")#')6')#$, $,$)&$1-#2'(+,# '(B'(($%

")+",- ./

")+",- ./ B"2":',