Bhavya Pathania And ANR v. Navdeep Pathania
!"#"
$% &' &' ( )*+ )$" $ $
) , '''
$ ,# ,#.# *
/ )$" ''' #/ $ $ # % 01
'
2 2 2
"
#
"
$ "
#
%%%% 2 2 3 '
&
" '
"
!
!
*
!
#
)
/, # $
!#
(
+ "
&, *
&) * !
"
"
# . "
* " /0 /) (/((
1 &////2 "
! !
""
"*
3"
1
)///2
+ "
1 ! !
" *
1
(////2 "
3" 1
)////2
+
"
" " 6 /7 &( &,,8
" 9 &
( /& /, &,,7
&, /7 (//( " *
+ "
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
+ "
" *
"
* ! "
)
! " "
# " 9 & "
:;
< * #
!
"
"
=
*
"
&, *
"
9 ( *
&&
#*
:;
. "
"
> ; *
! $
&) *
! "
*
4
! "
# "
+
. *
+
* 1
57///2 "
" "
* 1
&&7///2 "
3
+ "
#
1 &////2 "
"
" * "
?
" * !
! "
+
* "
# " " " "
"*
*
+!
"
"* "
?
" "
' !
? ! " "
"
* ! "
* (/&8
*
"
2.56"##"
$# 6
5+
)
,$
.$#
,
)
/, #
"
"
" *
" " !
"
# . "
8
' !
"
"
"
"*
+
1
57///2 "
" !
* "
! "
"
"
!
"
"
*
* " "
"
* 1
&&7///2 "
!
"
*
"
!
*
!
"
! "
! "
" 3" 3"
!
!3 "
#
1
&////2 "
"
1
(////2 "
! "@ * 1
&&7///2 "
1
(////2 "
1
5////2 " "
""3 * &24 *
( ! "
! " " *
*
" "
1
&////2 "
!!
3"
3" "
"
"
" !
* "
"*
,
A
"" !
"
1
&////2 "
"
"
* *
"
"
!
"
+
!
! * "
* 3
!
&/
"
"
*
*
!
*
*
*
B
*
B !
! " "
# " 9 &
*
&,
9 *
"
" 9 (
&) *
" * *
*
! "
! " "
B ! "
#
* "
1
&////2 "
" " "
*
"*
B
! !
" ! " "
#
B " !
* "
" "
B
" *
*
!
1
&////2 "
"
!
"
*
! " "
*
&&
"" !
" "*
" "
*
"
*
*
*
&
&,75
+ " " "
# . " &,75
!
" B
(/C4D B "
&,)0 *
&,75 "
"
" "
"
*
2"2 ""
! (/ C4D B "
&,)0
*
(/ C4D B "
&,)0
!
!
*
! B "
&,)0
! !
" *
B
* B "
&,)0 "
: &(
"
B@
" Jagdish Jugtawat Versus Manju Lata, 2002(5) SCC 422 and Abhilasha Versus Parkash, 2021 (13) SCC 99
! "
"
*
*
"*
*
(/C4D B "
&,)0
! "
"
&4
+ (5 /( (/()
""
! ""
&5
! '
!
B
! B@ " Jagdish Jugtawat's case (Supra) and Abhilasha's case (Supra).
B
"
!
!
* !
B
! ""
E !
! * Abhilasha's case (Supra)
"
#
"
;
"* "
B "
&,75
* " 2 *
!
*
B "
B "
&,)0
(/C4D
2" (/ C4D B "
&,)0
"
! # "
? *
"
(/ C4D
B "
&,)0
!
! B@ " Abhilasha's case (Supra)
"
&)
! !
B
B !
"
:
$
B Muhammed Shaji Versus State of Kerala and others, 2023(2) ILR Kerala 406
* B
Murlidhar Krushnarao Virulkar Versus
Ku. Neha, 2025 (1) AIR BomR (Cri) 227
B Awadhesh Singh Versus State of U.P and others 2025(168) ALR 850
B Kumari Nidhi Gupta Versus State of U.P and another, 2024 (164) ALR 587
B
!
Archana and others Versus Virender Singh, CRR(F)67796 2024, decided on 29.05.2024
*
!
" (/C4D B "
&,)0
$7+#"#
<.
# $
7= &0
"
?
*
B@ "
B
&8
"
125. Order for maintenance of wives, children and parents.
!
"
!
# $ !
!
%& &7
<
*
(/(4
" &55
9 (/(4
B
&55 C&D CD
9 (/(4
* 3" > >
3
&55C&D CD "
F144 (1) (b)
' % &,
"
" * "
! *
&55
9 (/(4
(/
(/ B "
&,)0 "
20. Maintenance of children and aged parents.―((
)
*
& +
& ,-
.
%& (&
"
"
!
"*
B
!
" *
3 "
&()C&D
!
*
* "*
* *
!
((
? Jagdish Jugtawat's case (Supra),
# B
" "
! *
*
!
! (/C4D B "
&,)0
+ # B !
" *
!
4 ! *
+
! #
B@ "
+ B> "
!
+
"
! B@ "
9
"
,&
( / ) 0
& 0
1 (
2 &! &3 &4456(+,,
!
&-
( +7 &$& .
( , ! 8 $ 9:
.
& ;&
< ( +=, ) &-
.
>
( / ?
( +7 &$&& ( +=, ) !
& ?
8
> ) & (4
? Abhilasha's case (Supra),
"
B@ "
+ ' !
9
!
5&&8
( +7 &$&
> @ 5&+ 8
/
9
+6&=;&+==7
+6&=;&+==7 @ (5
! '
"
B
!
*
*
B@ "
!
Jagdish Jugtawat's case (Supra)
! 3 "
! !
B ! !
Jagdish Jugtawat's case (Supra). B@ "
(/C4D B "
&,)0 *
3
? (/ B "
( &,)0
*
B
!
!
"
!
!
= B> " Jagdish Jugtawat's case (Supra), (/C4D B "
&,)0
!
*
!
!
*
!
* 6 (/C4D B "
&,)0
!
()
? !
B@ "
!
&,75 3 3 #
-
!
"
(/ B "
&,)0
:
*
? * "
"
#
-
(/ B "
&,)0
:
*
B
"
(/ B "
9
&,)0 *
3
"""
! (/ B "
&,)0
" *
B@ " Jagdish Jugtawat's case (Supra)
B
3 "
?
!
B@ "
""
!
#
- 1
! (/C4D B "
&,)0
!
!
!
*
"
9 4( 44
4)
!
"
,+&- ( += 476
)
& - ( +=
( +=
&- / /
( +=, 476
& A
( +=,
&
& ,,& ?
4B;
?
.
!
? C &$&&
&?
.
?
( +7 &$&&
? &
?
( += 476
: & ,;&-
?
( +7 &$&&
( += 476 ?
.
( += 476
/ /
& )
!
.
( +7 &$&& & ,7&
( +7 &$&&
/ !
? 9
6&=+&+=&- !
( +7 &$&& .
( +=, 476
&8
/ !
?
!
&%
: (0
!
B@ "
" !
#
-
!
*
"
B
"
"
" !
" "
!
!* "*
" * 3 "
A 3 " "
!
!
*
!* "* " B
(/C4D B "
&,)0
" *
*
*
!
""*
(8
?
""" !
B B@ " Abhilasha's case (Supra)
:
$
B Muhammed Shaji's case (Supra)
;
""
" !
! "
!
!
""
!
!
9 (,
4/
!
"
+4&- -
*/ D .
;Jagdish Jugtawat's case supra [(2002) 5 SCC 422]
,, Abhilasha's case supra EAIR 2020 SC 4355F
( &+7 & $&&
$ G
) H !
&
?
&-
.
+6Abhilasha's case supraEAIR 2020 SC 4355F
!$ G
#
+6&!G
& 9 ! I$ !
G
State of Haryana and others v. Santra (Smt.) +===7(B+ #9 +===(BBB
;= #
;=&( !
G
& )
&E(
#! I$ !
G
4 J & ,==FKKKKKKK& % -
.
""
( &+7 & $&& ?
&( .
*
?
& L
?
?
( &+7 &$&&
) H!
!$
& -
Jagdish Jugtawat's case supra [(2002) 5 SCC 422]
. bhilasha's case supra EAIR 2020 SC 4355F%& ,=&
?
& )
!
* ( +7 &$&&
?
( +7 &$&&
&)
! $ G
?
?
!$ G
&8
%& (7
? Murlidhar Krushnarao Virulkar's case (Supra), * B
3 "
*
*
!! !
* "*
* *
"
(/C4D B "
&,)0
9 &0
! "
F6&-
!
.
( +7 &$&&
?
?
( +7 & $& &
( +=, )! 476& !
* * ?
*
> "
( +=,)! 476
4
&-
?
& & ( +7 &$&&
( +=, )! 476 & -
)M .
,;
0
%& (,
? Awadhesh Singh's case (Supra) B
""
(/C4D B "
&,)0 "" !
!
""
!!
(/C4D B "
&,)0
9 )/ )&
)(
!
"
F7=&
.
?
4B;&- ( +7 &$&&
( += 476& 7& Abhilasha v. Parkash (supra) (
( +7 &$&&
. ( +7 &$&& - (
(
/ !
?
&- / !
?
( += 476&- (
( ( * ,( += 476
& 7+&(
( +7 &$&&
( * ,( += 476
4
& &( +=,476
0 1& B, +=+, &% 4/
?
B Kumari Nidhi Gupta's case (Supra),
B
""
""
""
(/C4D B "
&,)0
9 &5 &) &0 &8
&7
!
"
F;&
* 1&+
& -
+&5&+=6 Matrimonial Suit No.65 of 2021, Lalit Gupta @ Manoj Gupta vs. Smt. Alka @ Bebi ( , ) !
*
& -
( +7 &$&&
"
( +=, 476
8
( +7 &$&&
( +7 &$&& *
"
( +7 &$&&
)M . Abhilasha vs. Prakash and others (supra)
( += 476
)
& -
( +=
( +=
& A
( +=,
& 7& )M . Abhilasha vs. Prakash and others (supra)
( +7 &$&&
?
" ( +=, &- ( +7 &$&&
( +=
476&-
.
( += 476
&
( 6&)M .
?
( +7 &$&&
( +=
476 ?
.
( +=
476
& 5&
& B& - ?
> ( +7 &$&& ( +=, ) !
476
&% 4&
?
Archana's case (Supra),
"
*
* "*
* *
!
! !
"
*
(/C4D B "
&,)0
?
"
!
B
! " Abhilasha's case (Supra) !
' "
9 4(
+ "
!
B@ " * Abhilasha's case (Supra), "
! CD
E
"
!
#
-
*
*
&()C&D '
B !
"
!
&,75
(/C4D B "
&,)0
!
!
!! !
* "*
* *
? !
"
"2 (/C4D B "
&,)0
&,75
"
!
""*
& $7+#"#
)
!
#
)
/, # $
!#
. :"
B !!
# C# &
D
!
(5 /7 (/&7 3 "
! &,75
. "
"
!
*
* "
" " !
2
*
+ "
"
! * (/&8
"
* ! "
+ " 1 57///2 "
*
+
" " 1 &&7///2 "
*
1 &////2 "
# "
! " "
# " 9 & "
:;
< * #
!
"
"
=
*
" 9 ( * && #*
:;
. "
"
> ; *
! $
+
3"
3"
""
'
"
+ "
* "
: "
'
!3 #
'
4)
'* " "
+ " /0 /) (/((
1 &////2 "
" "
# . " !
'
1 &)///2 "
" ! ! " "
B
!
""
2 2 &' &' (
E "
2 G29 E " G29