High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/648/2015dismissed

Gurbax Singh v. Jai Parkash And ANR.

2015-02-23Mr. Justice Arun Palli8 pages

!"#$ %& '(()) *"

+,"- & &" ' (

," ".& /))01 "&(()) 222 3&&" "(""

)) (("

/4 # ))5

&6!%/ 7

8#" ""&"(""

" 7 3&&" & 6!%/ &!) # "(" % 7 222

") ! )#4&()

#4&") !"0 1 6!%/ "

(() (" ""%

& " ) /

8& &50()

# "& !"0 & "%!)" (()," &) 0&" "05!)# " ""#4&""% )(

! :" )4 0 ()

("4 " " " 6!

5& ("4" " " & "/ "

" % &"( !)(

5 "

&(;! %"!)!") ) 0 /(" -&5 0 -& " 9<<< < < / = 0 !1))%>-) 0 " ? " )" 5 ) )/ & & "% " )

0 5 ))%)0 1 5&!

@ 5 / & &

!/ )

"% #" !/ 5 # #4 #4 ()4 "! !( & ()

;! )40 1 /! 9A

) )#)#

!) 1" )1" & 0 (!"

! & ) 0 ()

&" 6!

5 ) )/0 " " % & "/ ) ! ) 4 /

" @ 5 1""0 & ()

&(( # &# )!5 "

! ("("4 & 1" " %"/ ));! ! ) - )0 " "1 4

&" "0 "/& @ 0()

& ) )4 ) / !" - ) 0 /(" -&5 (!"

! "% "

<= &" "0()

1" ) 4) & @5 / &&()

& $!& )

()

/- 5 ) )4 (/#"0

90&!

! @ 0 5 ()0 " )0 & & ()

& ) ) / !" - ) 1 )

0 & @ 5 & & ()

& 1" $! & )

015&&& !("("45 ) )&

@5 ) &&!/ ;! 5 "% #"0 (!"

! &"0 (

!("("45 1")1"& @ 5 / &()

&(!& % !" #& ) &(" &5

) # " &!#% ""0? " &$! ) 0 &(( # & 5 "

(

& /"

! 1 ""0&!" #)5 !

0&&!%&0&

)

B$,05 ))%# "% #"!/ 0#! & "" !# & ()@ 0# &/ ) ()

)$/ 4&"5

!((" & )/ ()

)&1"4 1)4

;! 0&!

0#!" )4!( &/ &5&

0 5 $! #4 &/ ((" )40 ()

) &"% & !

& "%" & ""40 ("1&& ) ;! !)4$!0 "% "#4& /( !&"4 :)5 %& 30 %5

;! 0 & )

$!#4&()

1!" +,"- & & (" +,"- &&/ ) ((" 3 ("1& )/8&

"# ;! 64& -"01 30( &#&& )

0$!#4&()

05" "##4&/ C!"&"0 & ) 5" !)4 "1"&()

&1 %!

/ &/ # ""0 & (! & &!/# /("

< % !" &"!( ) ) 0

"1) & & " )

& )"4 # (&()

&/8&#-(% ;! #"

&(&%"(&

0 & 5

&" & / ) #"

& &!/# /("

!#% ""0? "& "

& " "% "

& ""#4&()

&5& 5&4 5& &

$ & &!/# /("

!( !/ &5 & / #"

& (&%"(& ( (("!

4 %" 0 ()

) "

=$/ & "# 64 & -"0 1 3 !) )40 5 )! & & ) 0

)%) 1)!/ ()

) %" 5 " ! ) ) 5 $!

0 & (" ! 5

! #4 & ()

" #! 4"

90 &!

0 &

!5 ((" )4#""#4/C!"&"0 ()

) ("1&/ ) #

!) 0&!

/() ! " )" 0 5&! - % " " (

/ #) )5))5&&()

#"!%& "" 5 & -& " %"5" ") & 4"

A ,)

) #" % "" & !"" "1 !""("1&

/!& 0& ) $/ 45

"/&1 405&!)("1& (

" !)0& ! &" "0 1 & (() (" "" #4 & ()

& "5 /

) " & (()) /()4 - "" & !#/

& 5" 1 # " & !" #)5 "6 " ! /("&

&""%!/ 5 1 ! &!%& !)

!0@/ &

"15&&

(() 5&))4 1 /" &!

0 )#) # /

"&"

&"# %""&" " )

"0 "&()

!0&5 ";!" ("1 & & )

0 5 "% #" !/ 5 1" $!#4&/B$ 0 & "" ("10 & & ) 5 &" "% !/ " 5 # #4 54 "! ()4 #4 !(

: &/ ) 0()

) $/ 4&"5

!((" & )/&

5 "" &5&& ;! #"&&!/#/("

< % !"

& ""40 !))4 ("1 & ! 1) $!

:)5 %& 30 & % 5

) ;! 0 && !/ 5 $!#4& ()

1!" & #4&/ D-5 064& -"0130& "# )

!0 & 0 #& & )

0 $! #4 & ()

0 5"

"##4&//!& 0&("1& " ;!#& ) & 5" "" & "% " B$ B$ D-5 0&&" %5

) &"/() 3 ) ("1 & $! )

)4 & ! $! #! 1 & "% " ) ;! ) ("1 "". )40& ) #"

& (&%"(& & ()

0 %5

&" & /5 !)4&!/# /"- #4 & ()

!# % "" & "

& " "% " ) ,)

) $() &5&!/ ;! #"

& &!/# /("

) & (&%"(& /!& 0 ()

=$/ & "# ;! 64 & -"0 1 30 & 54 5!)

! /

;!&$! "% " 1!" & ,)

&&%- 5;!& )

0 )4 &/ &(/#"0

0"/ !

!# ""1 5 )("1& ()8&" "0 !0&1 %# ) "#!4"

((" )4 #""#4/" &5&(!"

! & )

0& !) /! 1!" 1/! 9A

& ""#4&()

&5&&

)) 5 !( (

! ("("4 8&# 0& ! ")" 05&!

;! ) ")

/ #)D"

) " & (()) !) ( ! &5 & )!

&5" !"" )4""#4#&&!" #)55" &" ""4&( """ !

" "/ 4 /")))%)4 @ &5- &( 0 !#10&" &")4 $ 4 %"!

0 ) ()!

#) )50 "

" 5& & " # %

) & (" (() ;! )50 /!& )

4 !# ) ;! )50 " "

(() # % 1 /" " %)40 /

February 23, 2015 Rajan ( Arun Palli ) Judge