S v. State Of Haryana And Another






 









     


 




 ! "#$# 
 
% 



 
&


 
#" 
& 







!

&'

()
* +,(-

 
*"


&
.

#

 


&



&
 / %

 0 %
#
"



 # 

  "

1 
  

 " 







 
 

 


 
 *"
2# %  

  "

 
3
45 #   
 

  "

 6







7

 

"  "
 5 '


    
  
      
  %



 

" %


"
 6

"


 !#6 





  




"     $ 



"
 6"



(95:;:
 '

+9,<+,(- " 





 !# 6 '

 

"

    "




"" 

 
 

" 





 "



(9(:;:$




"



(<4:;: 

" 

 
:

"


"

 * 

8
:



 
 




:

"






  '


  




"



(<4:;:



"
  
 

%  



  



4<9=+>= >

8

; :

   

 " 3

# !
   

" 
#

  
  9  "





  "

 6 
 

  
?

 

     ;1( :


 */ 

 +() ;$@ ;1+ *    ;   3 % 
  =7  3

:

>@ ;14 83 

 4)-2.@ ;15 A3 8 "

 )9- ;$@ ;1 ; "
 6
@ ;19

 " BC";
 @ ;1< 
8 " 

@ ;1) :


 /" +(9, ;$@ ;1-




"
 6
@ ;1(, 


" * '

@ ;1(( "     @ ;1(+ :


 3/
 +(< ;$@

 ;1(4 "3
 * '

@ ;1(5 B:./ (<9< ;$@ ;1( 8  )4 ;$@ ;1(9  3 &"7 "

 * 

8
:@ ;1(< :


 

" (9)"" < 3
 "

%  "

  


"



4(4:;:B 

 

    

 8 %  0 1 6  1(


 %   ) 
%
 "

6

  
?!

= >;18:


 */ 

 +() ;$


  

%
A6;1(3%   





(-,)+,(- 

%


 "


  
  %

 






 



 

 














 
2

* "  % : <-








%

*&   *   
  

 
   


  
  2

* "  B "




 " 





   "

# 


 #

# 

 

 = >;1+* ;  3 % 






+9,<+,(-

  "
 6   

"  

    # 
 

  

     

 "
 6


 



 


A6;1+3     
"

 = >  ;14 3 8  3 

     4)-2. 





+,<+,(- 


 3 8 ;

 



'




# 

 "
 6

  

 

 %  


A6;143




 
 "

  

28A6;14.

   


A6;14:





      
"B 
  




* 



  ;

 '


 ":


 / = %> ;15  A3 8  "

   )9- ;$ 


     

%
A6;153 %  





+9,<+,(- 7 #3




 
 
    %







 

  





   


 B!(,$!45)5B "



 

   


  "

 
     

%



 




 

  

 




%
:


 */ 









 
2 * "  % : <- 


(-,)+,(-







%
 






 
2 * "  B "





" 





  "

# 


 #

#  
 

 =%>;1; "
 6





  


!"

4((++,()
*"
 #!

%


B

6   %



B
 

 "


 
& 


  
:3



  
%
  $"

&
  
&  
:



3" 



&  " 


#$ " 
&
 







&B 
*"


(),4+,(- '


&


*"


 
 


  "

 
 

 B

&
.

#

 $#








 

&
"

 / %

 0 %
#   :

 # 

  "

 
 
 B   



 



 

 " & 

 


#

$



&
*"
 # %  

 

  "

 
 1 
  

 " 




 

 

 
3
5 # 



 
*"
 # % B

&
  "





   

      "

   B    
    #

 

 

 " 
    3  


  B
  "
  




B
 

 " &   

    
"

   
 !

&
 B

 

  %   





"/B%
  

 " 

3 "/

& 

&
 3

#  
3 "/

 %

"  "
3 "/ " 



 $



  



 "

  


$  

" 

 "   



   "
"'

+,<+,(-  % 

A6;143    
"
;

!3 ;

 

"
 
 %


     
 

" 

 $

 


"
  ! 6 

 % 
B



$




&  


 

"  




   


A6;1+3     
"
;

!3 

"  


* 

    


    %    


 A6  ;1!3 "

 

(95:;:   


* 

 '

+),<+,(- 

"   

 

;

 



" 99 


 




 

 =% >  ;19 

  "  BC"  ;
 





(-,)+,(-  % 
 

"  %  

 
 





 
&! DA6;193 =% >    ;1<  
  8   " 

 





+9,)+,(-  


  8 


B "'



;

  


 


  '



 #  
   

%



        % 
  


 

%


 



"



(<4:;:  

   
" =% >  ;1):


 /" +(9, ;$




+,<+,(- 


 :


  ;

 





  '



 # 3 8  %

    

% 
 %



  




 
 %


3 * 

 


;

 

 "
# 


;

 



  % 


 %


 "
 # #

  
 = 6> ;1-%
 *






 "
 6

  "





%  

  


 




 ! "#  





 
&3



 "
 6



  "
 " 

$ "
 6  



(),4+,(- " 

  
*"


&
.

#

 


&





& 


#  / %

 0 %
#    

  "

 B 

   #
 
   =6>;1(,


" * '




  "#

%
A6!;1!(,3 % %   





+9,<+,(-  !#6 "
 6% *7 A6;1(,. 






 
#

6""





% 
 "

 " "


 =6 > ;1(("    



"

 ; 





% &
%  B

& "




 
 



/" *

   A6;( 
 A6  ;99  B     


 A6  ;1((3  B  "



A6;1((."



9.


8

A% 3
 =6 >  ;1(+  :


  3/
    +(< ;$ 





(4,-+,(- 


  "



 ;

 


   '



 #     
 
  
  




  

-)(4,5,,))  )49)),55) 

 "  

  

    -954<)44,

"
 6 
 "




%

73 8 B % 
 
 


"

9 A6;1!(+373 8 

&


 



%  A6;1!(+.

 


  #  B  

%

"



9!.

8

A% 3
A6;1!(+:

     
"


!3B  

%
 

A6!(

A6;!(

%


 =6 >  ;1(4"3
 * '




   "# 

%
A6;1(43 %  %   




+9,<+,(-  !#6 

  B"&

  =" >  %   *7  A6;1(4.  B 



 

" 2 7A6;E( 

   






 
"


"    



 6" "
 =6 %>;1(5B:./





+9,<+,(- 


  B :


  ;

 


 '



 # /

%



73 8  %




 $ %





"
 
  

 6 

"
 6$ "
 6

"  


3* 






"



(95  :;:    
   3
     6 




"
 6 





 

% 

 



 

  %



#

*7
%


8 %




&


 



%  A6;1.3
 




 
"

#

"
 6

%
 
 %
%  A6;1:

     
"


"
 6'


 #" 


  # 73 8 

 
 "
 

"

  

 "


A6;1(53  

 "

  

 


       
"

" 3










"

%       


  B!(,$!45)5 

  
 
  :

 " 





  


 $

%




&


 



% 

A6;1(5.

     
"

" 3







"  & "

 %  "  
&

 



8 "" 

   "

  
 

"  / %

 A "

:
# $



"  


* '



 6 

 $






%

 






   

  %


%


$ %




&


 



%  A6;1(5A      
"



"   $  %

 

       


 "



(9(:;: =6%>   ;1(  7 #  3 8       )4 ;$ 





+,<+,(- 


  %


 ;

 


 '



 #
 


 3 83/
 

%
 


 "
 %


'

+9,<+,(-  % 
 

"   "

:
# 






  "
 A6;1(3 



 "
 6 : % B





 %



 

A6;1(.
* '





"

  6 


  "
 6  $    

  
 


"
 6   
  :

"
  6     %  

 

A6;1(.(



"

 

"
 6  %    

 

 A6;1(: 

  3  * 

 








"
 6"



(95:;:   $ "

#

"
 6

%
 
'


 # 
 " 



 
 "
 

" "

    " 


A6;1!(53  

 "

  

 


 

"  % "

 


        

   B   
 
   

"    / %  

  A "

 :
#  '

 +),<+,(- 


"
 6

"   



&99 

"


  





&    A6;!(
A6;!99



&


 



%  %# A6;1!    
"

"
 6 '

(4,-+,(- :

"
'



:


 3/
 


 
 




   

-)(4,5,,)) )49)),55)

" 



  -954<)44,





 "




%

 B

&
 

 



:


 3/
 

% 

  "

 

 9!. 


  8

 A%   3
A6;1!(+:  :


  3/
   

%
 

 A6!(

A6;!(
'

+9,)+,(- 

%



 
  
  


 "



(<4:;:   #8 " 

  

   
"'

+5,-+,+,  % 


 
 :# 7 8$3:""



" 
 


 :

"
"


#

"
  




%



 =6 %>;1(9  3 &" "

 * 

8
:




+9,<+,(- 3 8 

" "
 6 

 
   %   

 

 A6;1( 

  

   





(95:;:3
&  

 C" # 


  





6  

 % 


$ "
 6 
 
 
:

"

 
 


 

 3

 #  






" 





#&







"





:

"
  


8


  # 

 %
"
 6



  #
  
$ 


A6;1!3           
"  


 .   B  "    :

 A6;1(93

D  A6;1!(9.

A6;1(9: 
    =6%>;1(<:


 

" (9)""




+(,(+,+, 


 

8$3:7 :8""'


 # 3 8 

"  %   

F


 


 


 #

 

& "

   "

 8* 


& "
B6

 
" 

E

: 
02A5;:B6

 
 
  

8* 

  !

 %(9.

 

%

AB:;" *'

+5,-+,+,   


 
  

 A6;1(<3

   
"B "



A6;1(<:"



9!.


8

A%  3
;

 %A6;1!(< =6% >1(0 1 



" 

   


   #   
 
   " =  

 

>  3 "/  ;

 

  
 "
 6  #  
    
 
     "  %   



3 "/;




#
 
 
 "  B 



  
 


 "






" " 











$% 
 "
3 "/;

3 8  &

 3 "/;



"





   B 

  #3 8 

+5,<+,(-

 

/ 

+<,<+,(-$#

 #  
 
  " 
  
  3 "/  ;

   




 
    
    " 

  


#  

C" 



 3 "/;

%

;

 ;


/ %

 A 

:
# 3 "/;


  "  

 

     %   


  
  
 

 " "


 

"



 "

  
   
#

 - .


% 

!

 +  C"

 % /"

 
 ++,-+,++   #
3





"

2
$&:

"


 (, 8
 


 /"


  "

  


  :

"
 (( $      

 
  


 



 

 

 





"


    %

" 


  C"


" $ "
 6;1!

   
;1!-    "


 
   


  "

 
 


"$




 




  % 

 $

   




6

 
  D 

 "
 6$    #  
   
  

  
 
 
  


          %  
 "
  #  
 

  B








  " /"


   
 
 


  " !

  +  "

   

% 


 
 

 

C"

 (+ $      

 
 

!

  (    "

















  "

/"




 



 


% 







/"



C"

  
 
  (4 1% 
 


 


6

  (5 $ 

 




A6;143

 "
 6
;1 




& .

#

 


 

#  



 "



 #

 6















  

 





 # 

 # 

  "

 
2# %
*"
3

45 #  
  " 




  "

B # "









 '


  


 

28 


"

%







"
 6 "



(95:;:

 

 

 6;1 "




%

B % 




#

"
 6% 
 

     
  
  

% 


  "   
    
 

 

  %
  6

  


    


   


"

& 


 "

 #

"
"


 

 "


 " 8 
A6;143 

 

 


 "    
%    



  
&  

   

  "



(95:;:

   
   

 %  #
 "
 6 



 


:

"
;1 





+((++,() 
*"
2# %




$6   %

 

 "


 
&


   
:3



  
%
 

 "
 
 

 


 "



(95  :;:  

 
  * 




  "
 6  

   "



 

 






 



 "  $ "
 6 


 "



(95 :;:

& #   "





4((++,() 

"



A6;143



(),4+,(- 
# " 

  "



 #


#  / % 

 0 %
#  



#


 # 



  "



 # *"
2# % "
 

  "



(95:;: 



 "



  

  #
"   
*"
 2# %2"
 "
 6 



 


:

"
;1



 6 

!

!  


" %   



 



 

 " &   



#

 "

  







 "
 6 #
"

 



 
     
 A6;143      

   "

 

 (95  :;:  A6;13      

 A6;143 



 


:

"


 


5

#


 " 

(),4+,(-   
*"
2# %



&
  "

 

 



 
 

  "

  
 

 

   


   "

 

 (95  :;:

A6;131 

 

 

 


"

  

 " 
   3  


     

 

 

    "  &         "

  
   




A6;143  


 "



(95:;:$ "
 6=;1!>




" 

 "
  








 # 
% &

  "



"

   




& #

 
 

&



 

   " $ 



 "

"
 


"

8

#  
#

" 




* +,(-




 



  




"# +,(-$  #

"

  
 "

"
 %
%
#

"

1 

 
"


 



#

 "
 6    "




"

 

 

% 

 
 "
  #   




    

  "
 
:

"





"



%

"
 6 
#

&

 



8 

 
 


 "
 6 ;1-

 " 



 


:

"


  
= "
 6>   




 ! "#  





 
&  

"

  



"
 6=;1>



 




 ! "#  





 
&   
%
  #2"
 ;1-%
 





 6

  "



  # 

  #
"
45 #

 
 "
 6
   "  
 
  $  
   

 

  & 
   




"

 #

"
" $


 









"
 6



# /
  #
 "

   %  ( 2 
 % 





 %

 % ;1(,


" * '

  




 6  #



  #6

"
 6  %   *7  A6;1(,.  

    

"
 
    6 

  

& 



    

 
 




"
 6$#

 6 

2 * "   $2 7


A6;E  

 "

  



#




 

"
 6 (9 $ "


%   % #% 


 
 "
 6


 "

"

%

  

""

  
   -)(4,5,,) )49)),55)

  -954<)44,  



 

 
 
  #
 "

6 
 .


# %

"
 6








"

 
 #

&



 (< 3
 

 
/"



C"

 
 



 
B

G  :

"
 


    

 ! "# "

?!

H

  

 
  

    
     



    


 
                  

     

    ! 

                    "       
      

        
  #



                      
 
     

       $             
 18 % 






"

&

% 


 


$ > 







/"

 
 ++,-+,++   #


  

  "

 2
$&  :

"


   $










   

   

   





  !"

 !

"& 
1
 & 

?

1



  ?