High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1031/2025disposed of

Sham Lal Alias Shyam Lal v. State Of Punjab And Others

2026-02-12Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja6 pages

$ &" $# &" $# &" $# &" $# ;=$#9;9<7 >8 ;=$#9;9<7 >8 ;=$#9;9<7 >8 ;=$#9;9<7 >8 0+ +$!

0+ +$!

9 9 9 9;99;9 9;9 9;9 9;9E

'' ((&!"

'$!. !"

'$!. !"7 8

6 6 6 6 &/*'"&-./$0&" "% &'' ((&!" &)*+!,(&-./$0&" &!. &1%&"*'"&-./$0&" #$

'$!. !"$ !*%&"&"%-./$0&" 2+ */&3%&!&!3&)&-./$0&"

&"+4%&"&"%6&'*-./$0&"

+"% " $ '$!. !"$9C &5&!' "6&*-./$0&" #$ DDDD -7 &(8 -7 &(8 -7 &(8 -7 &(8 6 6 6 6 $999 $999 $999 $999: $#9;9< $#9;9< $#9;9< $#9;9<

&) +! "%+ &''(+0&"+$! + #$ 0 0$!.$!&"+$! $# . (&) $# E .&)

+! #+(+!,"% &'' &( ( $"

"+0 $#"% &''(+0&"+$!2& +

* .

."$"% '$!. !"

$!9E;F9;

;9< &/ /+!, % &. ( &! . 0$*!

( #$ "% '&"+ &!. #$ "% &

5 !"+$! . +! "% % &''(+0&"+$!- 2%+0% 5&4 *##+0+ !" 0&* - "% &5 + &(($2 .00$.

.+!,()-. (&)$#;E.&) +!#+(+!, "% &'' &(+ 0$!.$! .

$;=$ $;=$ $;=$ $;=$ $#9;9<7 >8 #9;9<7 >8 $#9;9<7 >8 #9;9<7 >8 ?@ ) 2&)$#'

!"&'' &(-0%&(( !, , %& 1 !(&+."$"% 2&..& &" . ;=;<9;9< '&

. 1) "% ( &! . ..( + +0" *., - &,& 7$% %&(+8 7% +!&#" "$1 1 # .& "% A # !0 $* *"B8-2% 1)"% # !0 ' "+"

"+$!

' # .*!. 0"+$!

=;>=$#"% &!. 0H*+ +"+$!0"-FG7#$ %$"A A"% .+ 5+

. FG0"B8#+( .

.&""% +!

"&!0 $#"% &'' ((&!"2 ?9@ + #() "&"+!,- "% .+ '*" (&"

"$ "% &''$"+$!5 !" $# 0$5' !

&"+$! 2 2+"% ' 0" "$ "% &0H*+ . (&!

!. '&0 ( #$5+!, '&" $# 6%& $ 99C9 7 +,%& 9 + 8 &!. 9G; 7= +,%& ; + 8 ' "&+!+!, "$ / !* "&" $# /+((&, /+!&,&- &.1& " $E- % +( 6%&&- + &,& 7 7$%&(+8 % &0H*+ +"+$! +! "% % '

!" 0& 0$55 !0 . / /+. !$"+#+0&"+$!

.&"

" .;9;;&!.;;<9;;

* .*!. 0"+$!

G>E$# FG0"-#$"% % '*1(+0'*'$ !&5 ()#$ ""

"+!,*'$#

+. !"+&( 1&! &" - +"):

-#$(($2 .1)&!2&.*!.

0"+$!$#"% FG0"'&

. 1)"% &!.0H H*+ +"+$!$(( 0"$7#$ %$"A"% B8$!;9;F9; ?=@ &

. $! "% 3&5&1&!.+ #$ "% ) & 9;;E:;- 2% +! '+/ /&" "% I" !"$#CF"% %& +!"% (&

'$!. !"$ 2& 0$. ."$1 $2! "$"

&!. 0$5'+ .+!6 &$ 99C97:98&!.9G G;7=:;82+"%"% &'' ((&!"1 +!, ! +!'$

+$!$#<C9G"% %& - 0$. .& $2!

-"% .+ 5 !"$#0$5' !

"+$! 5&. &00$ .+!,() ?G@ ,, ,+ / ."% $#-"% &'' ((&!" $ *,%" # !0 *!. 0"+$!

;> =$#"% FG 0"- "&"+!,"% +!"%&""% / !* !"+ 2 !$"0$ 0"& .CF"% &$99C9 &'' ((&!"$2! .

97:98-2% & +!6%& &$9 9G; $2! "$"% I" !"$#C=. 7=:;8-% 2& $ & % &'' ((&!"&( $'( &. ."

CF"% %& $*" $# 6%& & $99C9 7:98 2&

'*0%& . 1) '+/&" . !" $#$5%+5 /+. ,+ " . &( . ..&" . =;<#$(($2+!,1)5*"&"

"+$! !")&"$ G= &!0"+$! .$!9;;< "2& $'( &. ."%&"!$'&"

"$# &$9G;7 7=:;82& / $(.1)"% &''

((&!""$'+/&" '$!. !"$ &

*0%- "% &!

!. 0H*+ +"+$! $(( 0"$ 0$5 55+"" . +(( ,&(+") 2%+( 5&4 4+!,

.+ 5 !"$# #0$5' !

&"+$!& ,&.

'&"$# #6%& &$9G;7=:;8+!#&/$* $# '+/&" !"$ ?<@ ! "% $"% -"% "&!."&4 !$!1 % %&(#$#'+/&" '$!. !"$2 "%&" & ' "% / !* 0$. +! "% #$5 $# # 3&5&1&!.+ #$ "% ) & E : $!2&.

"+((9; :9-'+/&" '$!. !"$2 0$. .& $2! +!'$

+$! $# '&" $# 6%&

& $9G; 7=:;8- & *0% "% 2& !$ +(( ,&(+") $ ' /

+") 0$55+"" . 1) "% &!. 0H*+ +"+$! $(( 0"$ $ 2%+( 5&4+!, .+ 5 !" $# 0$5' !

&"+$!+!

!#&/$*$#'+/&" '$!. !" $2+"% ' 0""$"% &+.4%& !*51 ?E@ % ( &! . # !0 $*" /+ +. +"

2&. .&" . ;=;<9;

;9<- .+ 5+

. # !0 ' "+"+$! ' # . &" +!

"&!0 $# &'' ((&!"C(&!.$2 2! +!,&,,+ / ."% $#-"% % '

,*(& "'' &( 1 !' # . ?@ % %&/ % &. ( &! . 0$*!

( #$ "% '&"+ &!. ,$! "%$*,% '&' 1$$4& 2 2 ((& 0$.

$#"% 0& 8 #+!. *1 "&!0 +!"% *15+

5&. $!1 %&(# $#"% &'' ((&!"C(&!.$2! ?F@ '

' * &( $# "% 0$. %$2 "% %&" +! "% 3&5&1&!.+ #$ "% ) ) & FE:F7I := =8&!.:97I :G8-"% &''

' ((&!"2& 0$. ."$1 $2!

+! C=. %& $#6%& &$ 99C97

+$!$#C 7:98&!.9G;7=:;8' "&+!+!, ,"$ "% / !* "& &" $#/+((&, /+!&,&-&.1& "$E- % +(6%&&-+ &,&7 $%&(+8&" /+. ,+ " . &( . ..&" .=;<7I :

:8- CF"% %& $*"$ $#6%& &$99C97:982&

$(.1)"% &'' ((&!"+!#&/$* $#

'$!. !" $ :&+ +!,% #$(($2 . 1) !"

") $# 5*"&"+$! 1& . "% *'

'$! 7I :98 "+!

!"()-!$ %& $*"$#6%& & $9G;7=:;82& / $(.1) &'' ((&!"

'$!. !"$$2 / -"% / / !* &*"%$+"+ 2%+( 0&)+!,

!"+ +! "%

*1 H* !" 3&5&1&!.+ #$ "% ) & E:- $5 %$2 0$.

. . $#CF"% &$9G;

'$!. !"$ "$1 0$:

%& "$"% I" !"$ 7=:

;8& 2 ((-"%$ $*,%"% &5 2& ! / '*0% .1) '$!. !"$#$5 &'' ((&!" +"% % "% &( . . .&" . =; < I 0*" . 1) "% &'' ((&!"

" +! #&/$*$# '$!

!. !"$5 !"+$!

&1$*"&!)

&( $'*0%& $# $9G;7=:;8-!

!$.

'+" 1 !&##$. .$''$"

"*!+")- '$!. !"$2& &1( "$ '$.*0 &!.'$ $/ &!).$0*5 !"2%&"

$ / "

"$ "&1(+ %&!)'*0%& 5&. 1) %+5#$5"% &'

'' ((&!""$2&.

&!) %& +!6 &$9G;7=:;8("%$*, ,%& '( &2& $*,% ""$1 &+ .1) '$!. !" $2%+( &'' &+!,& J:"

$5 '&" $# 6 & $9G; 2& &(+ '*0 . 1) %+ #$ #&"% - %$2 / &,&+! !$ .$0*5 5 !" "$ *''$" "% &5 2& '

'$.*0 . $! 0$. 1) . !" $ % . '$ $ +"+$! 5&. 1) '$!. !" $ +! %+ 0$

: I&5+!&"+$!- 1 +!, ( /&!"+!"%+ ,&.+ I"&0" .% *!.

: K%&/ !$"'*0%& .&!)& & &$#6%& &&$9G;-1*" $5 '& "$# "%+

6%& &&!$2& '*0%& .1)5 5)#$ #&"% )#&"% %&,+!

+!,% '* 0%& . & '&" $# 6%& && $9G;

; 1*" .$ !$" 4!$2 #$5 2%$5 5 % '* 0%& ."% &5 0&!!$"" ((5$ $!"%) &&!..&" 2% !"% &+.( (&!.

'*0%& .%&/ !$" !&!).$ $0*5 !" %$2+!,"%&"%&,+!,% %&. '* 0%& . '&" $# 6%& && $9G; 0 +/ . "% 0$5' !

&"+$! &5$ $*!" #$5 5 "% $##+0 $%&(+ +! '

' 0" $# "% &0H*+ . (&!. +! "% ) ) & 9; E 0 +/ .&!&5$*!"$#

9 9=(&4% .$!$" 5 51 +#"

&5$ 5$*!"+!0(*. ."% &5$*!"+! '

0"$#6%& &&$9G; $*+ 2&$# (&!.

!.$#6%& &&$99C9-2& $'

'*0%& .1)5)#&"% %&"(&!.2 '* 0%& . #$5 %)&5 &( +! "% ) ) & < %&/ !$" ! 0$') ) $# 5*"

*"&"+$!$G="+(("$.&)&5<"% %0(&

&5!$"+!'$

+$!

!$# &!) ) &( . . +! ' 0" $# (&!. 1 1 &+!, 6%& && $ 9G;- 2%+0% 2 '* 0%& . 1) 5) #&"% %)&5 &( ' "+"+$! + +.+!, &" +(( ((&, * *((&'*&+1.& /+!&,&+ &"& &.+ "&!0 $#6#$5*((&'* * &5 5 !$"+!'$

+$!$#&!).$0*5 !

%$2+!,5)$2!

%+'H*&6%&

$ 9G;%&/ !$" !&!)5*"&"+$ $!+!"% !&5 $#5)%&,+!,% % #$ &&$9G;% #$*/+ 2&$#( (&!.2& '*0%& .1)5)#&"% # #$5 %) )&5&($!=;</+. & +4 4&$9E<+!5)!&5 "%$*,%2 5+!

!$&""%&""+5 "+ 2$!,"$ *, ,, ""%&"&5!$" !"+"( ."$, " &!) 0$5 5' !

&"+$!H*&6%& &&$9G= "+ $#*"% 2$!,"$ *,, ""

%& &/ . '$ +!,#&( ()L ?@ ! /+ 2 $# &#$ &+.- $!0 $!. !" $- #&+( . "$ '$/ & &!) '*0%& 5&. 1) %+5 #$5 "% &'' ((&!" &1$ %& +! 6%& & $9G; 7=:

:;8 ' "&+!+!, "$ "% % / !* "&" $# /+((&, /+!&,&- &.1& " $E- % % +( 6%&&-+ &,&7$%&(+8-"% ( & &! . # !0 $*"2 !"2$ $!, 2%+( !$!:

*+"+!

!,"% &'' ((&!"5 ()#$"% $!"%&"!$ ##$"2& / 5 &. $!1 %&(#$#"% &'' ((&!"#$"% 0$ 0"+$!$# # 3&5&1&!.+ #$"% ) & E:

:- 9;;:;9- 9;;E:

:; &!. 9;:9- 2% +! '

'$!. !" $ 2& %$2! "$ 1 0$. .1 +!,0 0$:

%& +!6%& &$9G;7=:;

;8 ?@ !"

"% %*51( $'+!+$!$#"%+ $*"

"-"% ( &! . # !0 $*"2 2 !" 2$!, %&/+!, 0$. . "%&" "% 3&5&1&!.+ '

$.*0 . $! 0$. 2 !$" "$ 1 (+ . *'$! !

!#&0"- "% ( &! . # !0 $*" #&+( . "$ &'' 0+&" "%&" &""

" .0$'+ $ $# ( /&!"3&5&1&!.+ #$"% ) ) &FE:F"$9;:92 .

.*() '$/ .$! 0$.

.& I :="$I :F ?;@ $ $ $/ - '$!. !" $ !$2% % .+ '*" . "% / !* !"

0$. .+!"% 3&5&1&!.+ #$"% ) &FE:

F7I :=8&!.:97I

:G8 ' "&+!+!, "$ "% % / !* "&" $# /+((&, /+!&,&- &.1& " $E- % % +( 6%&&-+ &,&7$%&(+8-2% + +!"% &'' ((&!"2& 0$. ."$ $1

+$! $# C=. %& $# 6%& $2! +! '$

$ 99C9 7:98 &!. 9G; 7=: ;8

&"% - . !" $ %+5 (# 2%+( ()+!

!, *'$! "% &#$ &+. 3&5&1& &!.+ . CF"% %& #$5 "% &'' ((&!

!"+ '*0%&

!" $*" $# 6%& & $99C9 7: 98

%* - +! *0% 0+0*5 "&!0 - '$!. !" $ $ %&/+!, #&+( . "$ '$.*0 & &!) .$0*5 !"$#"+"( ( H*&%+ $2!

%+'$'$

+$!$/ &!)'&"$#6%& &$9 9G; 7=:;8-2& .+ .0$5' !

&"+$!& &,&+!

""% &0H*+ +"+$!$#"% &+.4%& !*51 -2+"%$*"

""% 1 +!,&!)+,%"-"+"( $+!

""% +! ?@ 00 0$.+!,()-+!/+ 2$#"% &#$

&+.. "&+( ..+ 0*

+$!-"% '

&'' &(+ &(($2 .&!."% +5'*,! .2&..&"

.;=;<9;9<'&

.1)"% ( &!

! .

# !0 $* "+ % 1) "& +. % &'' ( ((&!"C(&!.$2! + % (. !"+"( . #$ +$!$#C=. &$9 ( & $#0$5'

&"+$!1 +!,$2! +!'$

9G; 7=:;8 ' "&+!+!

!, "$ "% / !* "&" $# /+( ((&, /+!&,&- &.1& " $ E- % +(6%&&- + "+0"&,&7$%&(+8$!

!&00$*!"$#+"

&0H*+ +"+$! ?9@ (( ' !.+!,&''(+0&"+$!7 8-+#&!)-

%&((&( $ "&!..+ .$# 6 8 6 8 6 8 6 8

1*&) *&) *&) *&)9 9 9 9----9;

"+4 7 7 7 7 9E 9E 9E 9E J% J% % "% ' &4+!,C & $! .

% "% '$"&1(