High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/748/2015dismissed

R.S. Gupta & ANR v. Kapil Kumar

2018-04-17Mr Justice Jaswant Singh7 pages

!

"#$ %%#&'

(''%!

)''*%#+!

,#$*$ +#

''

-# . '

./#

$ "#

#

12+ +'!

$3 # ''

#

##!

$3 #

'!

'' +''%$ 5#'

&''

'' 6$%/ $$

# 3'8

$. '

./# $ $ 1##

#$ 8#

&+ + / '$ 8#!

+ #/$

5+# #3 #

9+' +

:!

+ #3 #/$

:

&+ ## #/ $ / $ / #'#'8 '

1#$ '

# '' */$ + +# #/8 $ &+ ## ' /

9+#!

5#'

#$$ $# 3# # + +#

/ ' # (' ; + &# /+ # '#8 ' %3

4 $$ + 5#'

$# # #/

5+ # <#8 '$ (''%

#8 #3 '!

::7 #$ # $=

5+##!

5#'

'' ##$ % 3#

< #'$ $ + # #$

!

#/ $ # #$ !"###$%&' ()**)+ ,- # !" ..

/ 0 / ('

1

; + $'##8 #' %#$ /# %#$ #

'#$ '

# */$ + $ 1## # #$ 8#

+ #$ $'#$ #8

+# &#$!

+ $/$

9+' +

:!

+ #3 #/$

+ ##8 ' '!

::7

>3 +# / ' ' /

5+##!

+# #/8 6$%/ 5#'

&''

''

<#$ '#$ '

# #

?$ $ # + $ 1##

5+# $/% ' + #$ $'#$ #8 &+ '$ /!

+ 3!

/ +#8 /8 $ + #3 # ;$ + #$ *8 / '8% +# #3

5+!

$ %

:

4 ' $ $ + '' / '$ # ' / ; # %3% /+= '#8 '

@ $* +# $'# # #/

/ /!

;/ $ #A#$ 2 $#

#/ 12

13 + &!

&

!" .

#

+'$ $#

!"

$% &"

'"

(

)

"

* "

&"

""

! , )

-- $+ &"

'! " % * , $%

%'"

!!,,*!+

"

$* * ,,+ ** ,,+ / $, "'

'# '*',"

, , $ ,

',"

.'"

'!( !!, ,"

!!,,*!+ '"

(

# &"

. "

!!,, ' ""

1'+

-- ( ', !"

'" . !"

$% &"

$% !!,, ' 2$'+

--

3,

#

5'

+ ! !!,, ' ""

1'+

-- ( + #

5'

%% / / !"

"

!"

!!,, '

""

1'+

-- (

, " %%

+ ! '" ,,#

*" $. 7'

+ !

"( 5 )

* 3

) 0& 6 7 ( + ! "

./ ,"

'

',(

,+ *

+"

.',"

! / %* " ! +

" *

!"

' %* 8 (

*

!!,, '

7' "

*

*""

', .',"

!!,

"

!"

!!,, ' .',"

"

!"

$% !!,, ' % 7'

!!,, ' +( *

#"

+ ! !!,, ' $'

!

!!,, ' ' 8

,.

,#

8

!!,

!"

!"

,, !"

#( 6 % !

!

""

2$'+

--

3,

#

5' + ! !!,, ' ""

1'+

--

"

%% / / !!,

"

"

!!,, '

""

1'+

--

% 2$'+

--

!!, "

/ /"

. !"

$% !!,, ' +(

/ .

*

+ !"

'" . !"

$% &"

!!,, ' " ! ""

'#'

--

,"

#, 1'"# 9: #

5' %

"

'!

*!+ ;/*$ )

--

/

&

((( ;(

)

--

,"

!!,,*!+ # ,"

#, 1'"# ""

'#'

-- ( ',"

%

/:"

.

*!"

*

#

5' ",

"

'!

! ,"

!"(

,+ 7'

/"

/ , !!, ;(

)

-- "

# % "

'!

!!,, *!+( !!, % % ,

, $, "(

<3% #%#$ # ' '$ $& #$ $ % $ &'$ ##% #%'

+# &#$ # $= #3 #/$

5+ #!

$ $'8!

#*!

+##!

::7 ' #'#'8 ' #$

)# 2% 8 % #*#!

#$ +#8 #A#$ ''& '

::7 '

'

::7 ' #$ $# #86 ! !! "

+ !

/

,, * !$ % ! "

. +

!! "

'

* +

!! "

.

(

*!, ! "

!$ ! !! ' *+(

.:

"'

!

%+ % * '

! %* " *!,

!$ ! "

!* !

/ ,$, ",

*!,"

!$ %+<

$

.:

"' !

!

%+

)

!

/

!! "

'

* /

%* !

!! "

.

",

'

* * "

!/ '

!! * !* (

8"

! "

!$ % ! '

',"

8!

+ ! "

!$ =

/ ""

, ! "

!$

,'"

8

+

,, 8"

+= / ""

%'

!!"

: '" '$,'

%% ,

,, %"

** %,,.

**$=

"

* <

3 5,,# > /

* <

;* ?/* # 5** <

!, 5,,# "<

!, 5,,# '" * # 5** (

# 5**

,, : , "

*

"

**"

5** =

# ** " #

! 5** '"

'" ',

$

**

'$, * "

*@ * ,, %"

!, "

,, ,(

4./ *!,+ # * * /

' *!,+

!/

', *+

! "

+ "+ " **'

*: !!, "

,, ,

*(A 5+ $ $ *8 '#$ '

# '' '$ $%+$ +3% #%#$ '

::7 ' #$ &+ #/ $ - '& & ' 9

.::.

&+# # +'$ $# # /, "

"

$% '

!" $'

.,, $,

"

@'"#*

/ @' !'"

',"

'""

% ! ', / ',

#/ ,"( / !/

$, !/

%% ?/*

%% * "

/ (

,,# ',

,,#"

* !!, ,(

' !

**',

!!, "

:

/ $,:(D

5+ %3#$ *8 #8 #'

>3 +%+ + / + #3!

#8 #3 2 $#

3& + #/!

'' /$ ## &+ 5#'

&''

'' 6$%/ $$

# 3'8

'

$ $/$

!"#$!% & '()) 9++# 2%E#$ F @ 9++# #*' F @