← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/763/2015dismissed

Superintending Engineer Yamuna Water Services Circle Faidabad And ORS v. Kamruddin

2015-04-20Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri7 pages

     !" # $$$$$



   



 

 

  "#$ %&'( ) ************

+

,

- 

  ***********. 



   



 

 

  "#$ %&'( ) ************

+

,

+  +

  ***********. 



% &!'   !  / 0* + 1 (2'( *    



 

    

   

 

  

  

 !( 



)

 $+



+ (3# (

 

+

*

  !*0

1*

  4(1(+

5 1    %

.6*7#8 .6*7#91  % *$+ : 

  %

: 

.6*7#8*  +   

+

    

+5 + !7**8

%( +!

;&;



)$<;+ :+ +5 #*3*9

%(+

 ;011+%(+ 

+5 + !1 

*, + !5 + 

%(1( (

5  %(+

"  &+



=+

>)

  +  

 *8+

1   * '1    %(  1       +     &+

 =+  >) ? +  +@ 1+ +2   + %   

1 ( 

+

*  A+  

% ++     2 ! +++ 



 % :1 + (  ?

1 +(

 ( 

*A+

        %

 !  BB   2  / +  

 1+ +  +  $   -   / +  +   +  9*7*C      + 8:   

    *6*:

 *8  &9"3) *  +8 :  + %   <2 ! %( 

 %( ( 1 + ( ?

 

(

   1*A+  :+

 %+!++  1

 9( 

+(C7 +

 %5  1 

 + 

1   (

5 *  @*/"!+  

  '(   B      + 

  +  

  ?

%+ 

 1 : 

  * +; % @*/"9 :

+5@*/" +  1  +     +  

  1       

1    +      @*/"7  +   +     8  :  (

 %

+%(+ * A+%

1  

%

:  

+ +

+ %  +( %(%++! * '1    %(  1      +     

   ?

 

  :(  

+

* . +

  % 5 +  !

+    

   

          

    !"#$ %#&'$($1+

+ 1  +%  +

 %(

+(C#9*A+(1  +  (    %  (+  *

(

 

+%  +%  ?

+(C##

  +  (* A+  ( 

  +

  +  !  1

 %(+ !    1   : (  

*A+%  

+8# 7    

    

   

 

!

"

 " #$ " % $  &&

 ' 

!(    !"

 !)   % '

% '   &&%

 

    *!

    & +

 + "  )$       (

% " ,  && %%    ) " &  "  % '  + "!

  ) ! % !$ 

- !

(  %    !"  "     (  

   .    

 !   &  "

 '!

 "   '    

 '

" "(    /

&   '     .   

!$ ( +

 ! %0 ! $)   

 

" " 

"

(  % ( 1,  && %%    )  %$"

 +   "

'

  *!

   & 

  (

 % "  (

*!  "   +     +  (   '      )    

*!

  %!" '

  $  , 2 " "

 +    %$) "

!&  )! 

 "

- &      '

   

   %   !

  "   / 

& 

 % (    ( "

,  " '

  '

!  *!

 

"

(     )%     && %%  &&

 "  !    ) %  "



'   

 $    "   )%  

"

"!



 ) 

& " " / "

  +

%!   $  + '

  "3!

% 2  "

  +  "

    *!

% $( 

!%  !

 ! 4 !"  % "

*!

& " '

   % '

% )% '

  &  

!  

+&%  

*!

& " '

  %   "    + 2  & $+      *!

  ,  &&        *!  "    ) " "  /& "  %$      

%  

      

& 

  & " 

   +  ( %% ) ! )%    &!

$  % "       ++  )% & & $   + ! 

  % 2 %$ ) & "  +  ) %  " '  .  (+ !

+   ) 

 *+  *   ,-*      

!"#.%#& -- %& /00 +  %   +  ( (   

( + +   (+ 

* A+ + 

%

  1 +



*B+ % %  

+ 89       ,!2 +  5  6

        



"!

 %  % &+ 

&   7#  88

! %"  ' & & $  %$

 ! %  ! $ ')!

!+  ' "!+  '  

"  " )   %+  "  "!

%   '  (     '

 '       '  

  +!% 

 "" + 

 "     

 & 

''  " " &  "  % "(  !+ 2 ' & $+    

 

 "  +  "  )$  

%% 0

! ( !%"  + !  ' 

!&

 "& 

)

+  '

) "   "!%'  

 -

%

  

 +  ( !%") )    + 

!   %% + ,      & +

)%   $  0 !  $ !&

 & 

"" &   +  !+  ' (  !  ! '

+&%   ! $ *!  + !"  '

)

"  % &+    55  ""$ , &

%$

%% 9 " *!

: 95  + '

 " ;  

 77

!( % "   '  ! $ !   + 2  & $+ 



   %  )  "  & 

!&

 "+ $ )   ' $

 '

 + $ )  2 ( '  $     

  !

    + $  

 (  ' % " % $ "& $+ + $

  + "! % $  

,!

  

+!

) "  +  " "& "(  !

 +  8< 

6 = "

">)$9 '

< '

 & % 2 ' => 

77

! &%

"   %  !&      &    %!" '    &   9 (

++

 "

( + "  



 ?

++! $

 '     %)$ " % )   %$   2 '  ( $    & & $    $    

+ +)       !+

 (  !  &  " '

" *!

 

  @ A+

+   +

   

+ +

  

8:    1(% :

+ (C7 99( +  %(   

+

%     + 

* B 1  %      ' >% +  !

+   

% +& )   *+  *% +&   %  ?  1

 

 +    

* '1   +           

  +  ?

 

  :+( + 

+

 9 + 

+

    

+

% +'

+!*      !   #