← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3749/2014dismissed

Shri Krishan v. Prem Chand And ORS

2015-02-25Mr. Justice Arun Palli7 pages

  

   

        

 

    !  #$$%% & ( )*"  "  # $

     

  (   *"  " +,-,  "$$%%  ...  /""  $   %% $$  )0 1 %%2 

"3'4) 5

 61   " $    5  /""  " 3'4) "'% 1 $   4 5 ... 

 % ' %10"$%



10" % '  , 3'4)          $$% $    4

 "    2  $ %0 $    6" "2-  1  " ' - "  4'%   $$%(  "% -"   - 2'%1   10"  4 %$ 

'   ' % 10 " $%

- "0 $ 0    %  - " "0 2  2    $

 $'$% " "  " 2" 0)

  "'

-" % -2 %%4%- '%%   ,        3'

  2  % %)-    4 "  )     4  $

 " $%

 7 2  ,  " " $%

 "$$   1 " 2    $

  $% " 2

"2    $%  ) 8 10 %  9:;-   " %

<  0 - $'

 7 2 )  " "=' 4   % - ,'    ->'" '%  "'

" ) 2  %%4%   ,   "         " $ '% $

 " $%

 ,  "

' $ $ 0      8 2%4 "  %)- "'

" '  -  2  $%-   %- " " ' $ $ 02  % ' >'$%

  - "1)"2  

 $'

   4   2%%  ??- =' 10   ,- 22  - "   -   " , 0 4"  %  " )  '% %0-, 4   % -"

' $ $ 0 2 % 10       6"   -  "2   $

'%  6 %' - 

  ") 

'  ",     - '

 " " 4 2  1 '4"    10 " $%

  $ , " " %  

2   '%

' $     -  $ , " '   ,% ='  " 2%%  ??- " =)   '$

 4"+,-  ) -2"$ ,"=' "2%%  :=/ <  6"    $ ,- " " % 

 2 '%%  ,- %0 '$  "$%

- 2"" "0 $$  %0 %   " 4 6"'

- " %   >' 1  4'$ " 4" "$%

2

%1%1   '% %0-" '2 

 9 4 44 , 4

 "  - $%

$    $$%; $$%%'  ,2") 

'-,      %0 "  '

"$%

2 

)*"   % *"    $%

 ,8 , 2  22   ) *"         !   "$$   1 " % *"    !   /     "   

@ =) -""02  ' 1 " )%0- ) *"  - ) !        !    !2%  4"   (/-     "   

@ =) - " " ' $ $ 0 %%  " "    % *"  $'

       !   2  "  A82 - !   !')  (/  % ) " " ' $ $ 0 2  % >' $%

 6", ) ' $  "$%

"2"" $'$ $ 02  %:, 2  ) % 10   - " ' $ $ 0 2 $' $ 1  % ' 6"1 -2  %' " "  2   $    "   %

$ $ 0   " $%

      !   %"'4"- $%

 %) ") %,   1 " =%'

, 2 ' $ $ 0 $'

- 1' " 4 2  1 '4"      '1   "  $% 0 -2" "%%4 2  ,  12  " $  - 2  )    " $%   ,  2  1 '4"       "  4      0-    " %) "   , " ='2%%>'" <" " -" '$ $ 0- " ,' -"'

""1)"2  "  6$ , "=' " 2%%  ??-  % =)  0 " 42

"2%% -   "   

@=) -   " " 2

*""3' )      )1  - 2  $    " )   ='  " 2%%  6"'4"- " =)   '$  4"+,-  ) / -2"$' $ ",  1 "2%%-1'"  ) 0 ,%"" , $ " "2%% >'  ,  =$%  ,  " $     " 2

" $' "  "')1 )$ 

" $   "   -1"" 2

 $' "  "')1 )$ 

 '$  " ')   '$  4" +, /  % ,  $  " " $$  % 4 2"   , 1   " '1 4      4    " 2%%  '% %0-  2   %' "  '$  4"+, /  " )$%0 $ ' " 2%%

:=/ <"2  110") -"   -"'%

1 )  42

"2%%" 42 1 '4"     10     =$%   2"0

   "  4 2

 " 2%%   >'  2 =)   ;' " - " 4 2  1 '4"      "2 " 1" "  2

 "  $

 20 6" 1 -    " $$  %0 %  $ , " '=' "2%% ??-$' $ ", 1 ='10" )"  , $%

"%

%  $ , " $'

   $  - " ' $ $ 0 " %%   "  " - " $ $ 0    $' '%  %0 1     % $ $ 0 %%"%4%" %*"  " 2   ,6"'4"-%%"

'4" %*" 2 

  0   $ 0  " % - "2, -  2  %  " $%

 1

 ) *"     %0 "  "     )% %0- ,     !   %  "  "   ' $ $ 0   -    " ='  %   -  ,'   - "  %  '%  %0 1  )   %  >' " "  10  - 2"" '% 1      " )  $  6"1 -2  %'"  2 )$%0   "    ' $ $ 0  " =  

"   -2""'%1")

 $  "3 % A82 -$%

1 4 "  >'" '$ $ 0-'% 1"%1=%'

,2  $

      '%- " $$% 2  $ %0 $- 2"%"% 4" " %$ ,"2%%  ?? $%

 2 "% 1 "  "     % 4 2" " "  %4% "   6" %   =' 10   -  ,'   2'%  %0 1 

    4     %  "    '% -2""2'%1 )  ") $   7"," % '

%  "$$%%  $ '

"$$ 18 A  '

%   " $$%%  '%  $ ' "2" %'

 ,10" $$%% ' 2 "    0"$     

 

)  0 ) % %%4%0 B )$%0 8     "

'1)

"2 , 1  "'  1%2 3     '   )$ "

, 

    "  4') 2 ,  %

  

 - $%

 ", %  $ , "$'

 0 -" '$ $ 0" =%'

,%0 %%   "  " - 2    %   %  $ 0  A82 - ", %  $ , " '   ,% ='  " 2%% 

 

??-10" )"  ,-'% %)") % 1"=%'

,2   '% * %0-  " 42

"2%%2 =) " 42 1 '4"     $ , "1" "  2

 "

$

20 :, " 2 -  , " ' 

2 >'   4" )"  "2'%=' 2%% %0 ,'   " 

)'" - !  /     "   

@=) - " "  )"   " ' 1 " %8 ""4, " %%

'    ") 6"'

-     %0 "  "  

' $ $ 0- 1 -   " %  =' 10 ")-  ,'   - '%  %0 1  )  % "  "3 $ $ 0 "28 "$  - '1,-"  " %0 = 0 4 '

- %  $%'

1%   %2-      2" "   1 4 

%   " $   $$%  >'  %2- )'" %

0 '1  % >'  %2-     

   $$% 1 4 ,   )     4%0-

 February 25, 2015 Rajan ( Arun Palli ) Judge