← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/5150/2018dismissed

Chanman Lal Since Deceased Thr Lrs v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2019-03-11Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia8 pages



   



 !"!#$%$&'() 

       



'  *+

 ,,,-+



!"#$ %  $

#&'

(#$"$ ))))) ,,-+. *

 $& #+,-../0..12$3.0/ 3.3242./$%

#



#30  ## $ ./10  $ 6 6+#  (  

$ ! 

27..4227$(#  &

&0178-3432 '



#

#  42.842./ 

#+

,-3.32-42./#



    (# ( #

 & $42.8$   .0 

 # - ++ 



 & #/0 +1&" 2!0% 3%+&"#45$%$ $&11!# 0&" 2!0%.66 ,(($2$07 ,$&82  20582+ %&" 2!0%3%09&,  !&" 2!0%.

66 ,:  ,/$9 21  2!0%;%,<12%$1"0

 2!0%      $3$1  66$    &#    #  ##



#  

$# 

#,-...2-42./ #



    

472.42.1 #,-3781-42.8#



     

4.2442./ :  &

&#

##( 

 # !9#! #

#+ # ## # &



#  #,-..12-4220#

       

432442.;$  #



 4$2.$787<-   :# &#





(

$ $( 

 # %#+



 #+

 ##

(

# # (



 # & +

:  #   #     #

   #    # #  

$##



%

   

  ##  $#+

$%  !

 +#

:# 

#432442.;$#  =#6

$(

# + #



 #$    

      

 



  $% #

 ' $##   !

 $## $

! #

 #

%# # #  

#%

&

+& &+

#,-../0-42./#

 >      $ =7-   ##  ?#

   .328422/  ##$  #  ,-../3-42./$  =.- #@ (# ?#

482.42.4$#,- ../;-42./$     =3->  #  ?#

   47.242.0  

 =/-* !  ?#

..2;.11;$#,-3.0/-42./$  =.->A#  ?#

41204223 :



$# $,-3.32-42./$ =.- ?#

..234223 # $:

 

=  ?#

 2;.24222 432;42.0$

#% ' $##    

%

?#

 (



27..4227 



! #

 ' # 

#%

$&%#

# # $

!#+ %#%

$

#+# 

 # #

(# (

'

$#

$# 

 

 ##+## &

 ?#

B% +9   ?#/0 +1     #&   ##

#  ( & 

+

$

+

##$#2$07,$&82 $  ?       (      (

# 

#

 

& #+(  9 ##

 : ,/$9 21  $#(  $

#+

$%    $( &    

%  

 &

#+         ?  $    &  +#%       



 #    +

          (

   ( 5#

$  (# ?

#+    (  

  #  .04    

 ##: # :# $#  #  

$#  ?#

9 #, 0$& $#



 ## (     #      ## #  #  5

#  ( 

4/.4.11;   '  3     %#+

 (  =# $  ($  ># #$ A C# :

%#+



# ##$ #

$#  #  # $2/27.118

  #!9#! #:  #  

$# # ##  ###$ (#

(# %  &

$# #

## #

#  #

2!%22=1  !% 7 $(# ( ##+ #+ ($

#



 $ #

$

#

(

$ ( #

  

 $

#+$#+#



9 

 ?# != /"!#!%!">9+

 2!0%;%,  !09& ):,6( # (

 7 $(# ( 

  #

(#  # (

&#+#







 ?

 + 

 # & (#  # 

(# ( +(

#

 ##$  # %=07   & 2!0  ;%  ,<!#$1  +&"

#45$%$ $&  $#!0  (  6  ,  $  #  (      

 

# 

( ( ##+ 

$

( #& &

: 0$7!%2  ?5/0    2!0%  ;%  ,  !    09& 

 2!0% 6,@$.2 4 41

 



&#   ? 

& #+ (###    (

(## #+(  %#

 #

( 

%#  %#

 D8'

###$







 #+ ?#

?#

 &  ' (#### #

 +?#D:

 #&# E#,## ##F #  + (   ##+# 

###  

 #+

#

$

#   

 & !

#%  +# #% #?

# /' #% ##"

,# #



# %C

& #$:.10.  ;$

  (##+  # #'+ ( 



 .174  ( #  #    &

  #    D  (   ###

##    

9 ## 

$&# (%#

 ###$## & 

 # !

# #  C + $# &

$

+ # (

($  #  #$ #

?

# 

+#

&(F 1: A  % A  $:.11/   448;$     ?    (#

#+   

 



3;3 $( # ?#    

    &       ?#  



+#% $

GD( ### 

# &# &

#

(## #+(   

#&

 (  ? ###  5#&

F .2  H#

#+    ##  #

$  #   #B > 9

%+=

 *  42.7 .4;01# (%# # #

# #

D???

% !&#

#& 

!#+  #   

  #    #+##   

% %#'

#&    

#     &

   #    &

(

 



 ???

#?  ' $  & %#    #

      #+    #  # #     +#+

    %   & !

#

#:# 

 # #  5#

( #+

&

9 #

#

& #

# # # & +#% + &#  #&   ????

%##' #+



#%

 -

#   $

$ ! #  #

& ?#&#

#   5#

&

&

$    

$  (##   +   F  

 > (9% ##*#

 42.7.0 /. ..  '          #9 #

-#

   #  

#+    # #    #  

( (# (#+ # #

  ( # #& (

 # #

 (&#

# # +#+

(

#%

 

#

#3 ### $ .1;7# 

 ##

 ?



#&  #+

'#  # +# (  %# ## 

#

(# 

#  $  # %# #+ ?#

 

  #

 .4:# ( 



# # (#  !

  #+ 9 #

#   

 # #

$  !

#  #+ & 

+ 

  & #

!

# 





  ##+   .7: A! * %A * $ .11;;4;8$# 

 # ##

#+#+



  #

##9  #+ !( +

# ##

  #        ?#   

  



  '    &

%

          #  ( 9 ##

# + #+#+



.0 %# (

 # 

&# #C+  * %  * $:.11847;;$ &

%#+

GD#

#   !

#+% ##+ +

(!

- (   #  #  9# #+I  # J'

       

  - 

##$ #%#

  & # %# (# 

+ ' #+$ $ #+ #

(# ## 

 F

  .3:<  #

* %E#: # * $ :  .1/1    ;80$  #   

  

 (

## (

+   & # ( ## (



 %#

' 

## 



&

%#+

GD'  

(# & 



## - +##+ # (#  % 



  

## %#+#&(  &

 

# 

#  & 

I

&

F .;  :    #  

$    

#+      

#  

# #

.2 4 41 #+ # # +

F ' # 

#%

%#+ % ##+   .3 $ & (

 #  #((# 

?



# # 

(#& (

 !#+ 

$!

#+#%# ( &%

#$# #

## # # 

0178-3432 ###+ +(## # &#+#+

 + 

#%

   

-       #&    &

(

$#

 #  

 &$

#

$+(# #

0#2 2.)  ,,-+

 

    !  "

# $% 

'

!  "( '