High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/83/2015dismissed

Jagpal Singh v. Sadhu Singh And ANR

2015-10-19Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

!"##$%&%'( $")#*+ ",-

!./!0%'., //#00!'"

1#*&2& !3,2%'., !'",#* #&/'3#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.& 4,#",#* #/*"#*&0$!0/!/#*&5!6)#!007#3"&##",#823.5#'"9 )#*##**#3"",# #/*"#*&*'"9 4,#",#*",#823.5#'"&,203)#*#/*"#3%'",#%.#&"9

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

3%&/2"#*5",#"%5#%55#5*%!0&,7'*#3%'",#&%"#/0!'%')#"7##'",# *#&%3#'"%!0 ,2&# ",# /0!%'"% !'3 !& 7#00 !& ",# /*/#*"6 ",#

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

*3%'.",#$**#$"'#&& ",# &%"# /0!' !'3- ",#*#*#- ,%& 7' 3$25#'" ,!

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

342 '(-.&