← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24860/2024dismissed

Azad Singh v. Chief Canal Officer Bhakra Water Services Irrigation Dept And Others

2024-10-22Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger6 pages



     

 

  

   

!"# &#'()($*

+ + 

,!& -(*./ ++++++ #"("($*#0 ) 1#0)2) /(#%

%%('#0 $"/#0)

++++++ #)4$*&#*")    5 6 +

-  -

 0#)#*"

 0+ ++ 6$/!*7

&8$'!"# )+

)+ 4!)!*!

/!9!*7

 !0:!*!+

+ +  -

7

+

6

+ #"("($*#0

,!& -(*./ %(3#& (*)"!*"

'(8(3 4#"("($*

0"('3#)  ;

$*)"("2"($* *&(!7 (*"#0 !3(!7 )##<(*.

!

*!"20# '#0"($0!0( )#""(*.

!)(&# &!"#& + =+ >

**#?20# 7 4!))#& (8()($*!3

%%('#07 !"#/!@!&

)/$0"

5 5A &!"#& ++ >

**#?20# ;7 4!))#& -24#0(*"#*&(*.

%%('#07 !"#/!@!&

)/$0"

5 5 &!"#& + + 

**#?20# 7 4!))#& /(#%

%%('#07 !0:!*!

)/$0"

5 5+ +

0(#%3:7 )$B# 0#)(&#*") 8(33!.# !)!*.!7 #/)(3 !"(!7 ()"0('"

!"#/!@!& )2@B(""#& !* !443('!"($* '!*!3 !2"/$0("(#) )!*'"($*(*.

!*

(*$0 #'"+ >=7 C(33!

 8(33!.# !)!*.!A 43#!

"/#0# *$ '!*!3 "/#(0 3!*&)+

"

40!:#&

"/#(0

>=+ + !'0# "!<#*  6

(*$0



"0!*)%#00#& =6

(*$0+

%20"/#0 40!:#0 B!&# '$*8#0"(*.

=>+= !'0# 

!*$"/#0

+;

+;

!'0# "!<#* =;=6

(*$0 )/(%"#& =6

(*$0+ + '!)# .$"

(*8#)"(.!"#& "/0$2./ '$*'#0*#& D(3#&!07 9/$ !%"#0 )("# (*)4#'"($*7 0#'$BB#*&#& '!)# )!*'"($* =6

&()"0(@2"!0:+

)'/#B# -#'"($* ;

!0:!*!

0!(*!.#

'"7 ;

)/$0"

5;

'"5 )2@B(""#&+

)'/#B# 42@3()/#& -#'"($*) ;7

 ;

'"

(*8("(*.

$@E#'"($*) )2..#)"($*)+

B!""#0 %(?#& > + + > -(*'/!(

/!9!*7

/$&(!

C/#0!7 !"#/!@!&7 9/#0# )'/#B# #?43!(*#&

)/!0#/$3&#0)

9/$ !""#*&#& /#!0(*.

0#)4$*)# *$"('#)+

+ "

!44#!0) B$0# "/!*  )/!0#/$3&#0) !""#*&#& /#!0(*.

E$(*"3:

)"!"#& "/#(0 40$4#0 !9!:

#?()"(*.

)$20'#+

"

%20"/#0 )"!"#& "/#(0 )!*&:

)("2!"#& /(./#0 3#8#3+

"

)"!"#& #?()"(*.

)("2!"#& '$0*#0 '/!<7 "/#0#%$0#7 .#"

@#""#0 )("#7 "/#:

40!:#& "/#(0 )/(%"#& !0#!+

/#:

)"!"#& "/#:

9(33 B!*!.# '$20)#7 @#!0 '$)"

!&E2)"B#*"

@$"/ $2"3#") "/#:

9(33 @#!0 '$)"

0#B$&#33(*.

'$20)#

(% !*:7 9#33+ +> -(B(3!0 0#F2#)"

"0!*)%#0 B!&# $"/#0 )/!0#/$3&#0)+

"

!44#!0) 40($0 !440$8!3 )$2./"

>

/(#%

%%('#07 9/('/ !''$0&#&7 8(&# #B$ &!"#& + + >+

6#!0*#&  !%"#0 #?!B(*(*.

'!)# 24$* (*)4#'"($* )("#7 '!B# '$*'32)($* F2#)"($* B2'/ !9!:

#?()"(*.

$2"3#"7 9/#0#!) 40$4$)#& )$20'# *#!0 F2#)"($* = !'0#) !0#!7 9/('/ 2*'$BB!*&#&7 '!**$"

B!&# '$BB!*&#& #?()"(*.

)$20'# &2# *$*!8!(3!@(3(":

'!4!'(":

#?()"(*.

'$20)# "/0$2./ 4(4#3(*#+

''$0&(*.3:7 =6

&()"0(@2"!0:

!33$9#&7 8(&# &!"#& + =+ >

**#?20# + + ##3(*.

&())!"()%(#& !%$0#)!(& &!"#& + =+ >

**#?20# 7 40#)#*"

!3$*.9("/ $"/#0) 40#%#00#& !* !44#!3 @#%$0# - 9/('/ &()B())#&7 8(&# &!"#& ++ >

**#?20# ;+

%20"/#0 !44#!3 %(3#& @#%$0#

&()B())#&7 8(&# &!"#& + + 

**#?20# +

#*'#7 40#)#*"

'(8(3 4#"("($*+

>+ #!0&+

+ $*3:

)2@B())($* 0!()#& @#/!3% 40$4$)#& )!*'"($*#& &$9*)"0#!B &()"0(@2"!0:

(+#+ !@$2"

 !'0#) #'"+ C(33!

>=

+ =+ /!8# '$*)(&#0#& '$*"#*"($* 0!()#& @#/!3% 4#"("($*#07 /$9#8#07 &$ %(*& !*:

B#0("

)!(& '$*"#*"($* !30#!&:

'$*)(&#0#& 0#E#'"#& 8(&# &!"#& + + 7 $@)#08(*.

    

      

     



  



  





   ! 

  

 "     

     #      $%&

'  





  



  ! 

' (

 

   

   

#      



   ') %$*'&   ! 



  



 ! +,-  #  

 # +,- ,,-   !  

  $%&

     



'   )   

   $%&

     



          

 .



  , /  "

!

0  . , "(  

  

 

 ' 1        

     

*$

%% %2 

3"

    

  

 

   !  

' . " #   

               

 

 

*$

%% %2 

3

4  '

       "  

 

  

         %'55'% %*   .



  , /  "!

0 

.   , "  ( '   1        

       4        

   %'55'% %*        .



    ,  /  "!

0  . , "(  '

)    

  '6 + 6#!0*#& '$2*)#3 %!(3#& &()3$&.# !%$0#)!(& %(*&(*.

0#"20*#&

*$0 )/$9* 9/!"

40#E2&('# '!2)#& 40$8()($*(*.

=

$2"3#"+

20"/#0B$0#7 ("

4$(*"#& /$9 (B42.*#& $0&#0) !0# 4!"#*"3:

(33#.!3 $0 !0@("0!0:+

;+ *   

 

          

    !"A !

(8()($*

#*'/ "/() $20"

$@)#08#& 2*&#0 $'7 "   

 

  ') , -

    4  

 '      #

   

        

 

#      

"    

 

 

    

   -

%%  ,



    

  

'

   

  



+

* #   

     $%&   '(  

 ('A !

(8()($*

#*'/ "/() $20"

$@)#08#& 2*&#0 HI0     #

  

   

 # 

  

    #

     4

 "



          

     !           

    

     

   

 

 "     #!  

  " ## #   

 9 + * 8(#9 !@$8# &()'2))($*7 %(*& *$ '$B4#33(*.

0#!)$* (*"#0%#0# (B42.*#& $0&#0)7 9/('/ /!8# !44!0#*"3:

4!))#& "!<(*.

(*"$ '$*)(&#0!"($* (*"#0#)") %!0B#0) @#""#0 '$*)(&#0(*.

40$4$)#& "0!*)%#0 $2"3#"A B!?(B2B 9(33 (00(.!"#& 40$4#03:+



 + #)23"!*"3:7 (*)"!*"

4#"("($* %!(3) !''$0&(*.3:

&()B())#&+ + #*&(*.

!443('!"($*

)7 (% !*:7 )/!33 )"!*& '3$)#&+

 -





+ + 

)E<) /#"/#0 )4#!<(*.

0#!)$*#&

#)

$ /#"/#0 0#4$0"!@3# #)

$