High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3799/2014dismissed

Kashi Ram & ORS v. Juwahara

2017-02-28Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul7 pages

!" #$%

!"

# "$

&&&& '! !(!)*++",-

-

!! +,-

-

!+

&&&&

.+

- ,+ ! + * !

!

&/!)"-+ ! *"!

* + )"

*(

! 0- 12 !

! #"

* -3!"-,+ ! 12+

12+

&/!)"4

5, + 1) 12 + !

&

* + )"

*(

!

67 12 ! 8 #"

* 4#" ! 5-3!"- , ! ( /! 2 -+

4!

+ ! 5+ "

!

!( *+

&/!)"! *!

*0 9 0:;;+! .+

!

*! ( 06;;; ! *!

* 0 9

! "(

-6-:&+ (

*! ( -+

(

&&

2(

7-6-:&

.+

! *!

, < 0;;; ,( !+ -

< " +

-+ +

, + !2!*+ * +

< + <

+!

"*++ "! !*! ( -

+

, !

06;;; + !"-

, !

+

, !- 0;;;-+

(

!,!

< " +

-+ "*++

! + + *!!=

*,+ 1

9+ + ! <

! *! .+

*

! *!

* +

! .+ ! !-+

!

,+ +,!

12+

;.+

* 2 + -9*+

< +

-1"+

+ "!"

-,+ , ! ,+ 9+ + !! *! < -* (!9 + & + + "1& *!!=

, !!

++

, ,2,* ! 2 < " +

-1"+

< " + ( , "!+ ! !!

++

, * 9 < " +

- 1" +

7!

" * +

< -+ -+ " ,

&7&

- +

! + " !

! (!2 1) !* (12-

"& - "

-

+ ( ,+ +

( !-,

+ *! ( , !

! *!

*0 *

6-6-:& ;;

"(

0-:& ! ( 2 + ! (*( ",*!

1 7;;

"

(9 !!* (

1 ( "-+

, <

6;; ( 6;;

7;;*

"

(9 !!* (

+ ( " , "!+ ! <

;;; + ! !

6;;;;,

+;;;-

"

2 (9 2(

-7-:& 66;;;-+ "!+ !(

2(

6-:&, "!+ !

++

*

+

! !*! ( !

<

*! ( - ! +*! ( + "

1 <

*2-+

*!

(9 2(

-76-:&.+

+ ! 2 ( "

7-6-:&! *!

*09 ! >"

++ ! 1

<* ( ! ( "2- +

, ! 2 ,+ 6-6-:& + ( "2 < , ! 1 1 ! 12+

+( !-+

,9

+ *! ( ,,!

!"(

-6-:&

* < *! ( ,+ ! 7-6-:&,+ , +

&& 1 "

06;;;- ,+ ! 9+ , + " * ( " + 1

*! ( 06;;;-+ !*

! < "

, < 0;;;

,

!

1 *

*

! - + ! 8 "! !( +

,*" & ?5 %+ + !

+ *!

+ "

*! ( 06;;;

!

6:& + !

76:& ! ( 2 * @ ''

5 %+ + !

+,21 ! 2

,* ! 2 ,*

!(+

!

! @ ''

5 %+ + !

!

!(

! @ ''

5 %+ + ! 1

! *! ( 06;;;

2 *! ( ;; , <

1 , + !

! * + "

66:& ! -

! "*! ( -

! < "

, <

(( ( @ ' 5 <5 <5 A

&6& B )"

*( 67-+ !8 "!

+ " + 1 !

+ !(

*! ( 06;;;-

" ,+ +,* + (

*! ( .+ !

! -+

, !

< " +

!!

*+ 1 **! * + 1 )"

*(

67-+

&/!)"

-,+ ! + !

&

1) .+ 1) ,

+ < ++ !8 "!+ "

+

+ ",+ .+ ! C , !

8 "! ( +

,

1) )"

*(

! 0 +

! !

"( -+ *!

!

&/!)"4

5+ !

C ! "

!+

+!*"

++ ! "!+ *+

++ *! ( , < - 1"+ ( ,

12 ( ( 4D<5 ( "

7-6-:&,! "! ,!*4D<5/ ++ "!1 , +

+'%&.!8+

!

-1"+ , & <( " & 12

"(

, * +

!"2 & <( '%12+ ! !8 "! "!+ !!*"

++ *

+ !8 "!

" 3 7! !!

+ + !

! "

!+

&0& ( 2-+

+ ( +*"! + *! ( 06;;;.+ ! 12+

+ !,!*D<-+ ( "

7-6-:&+1 ! "!

&#",+!*+ *! ( ,+ + ,

.+ "*+ + ,!* + 1 ( !

&/!)"

&#",+!-1"

1 !+ *"!

/!)"&

.+

+, +

1+++ ( "

7-6-:&+1 ! "!

*+ *! ( 06;;; + *! ( ,

+ !2*! (

06;;;+ *!* 0;;;+1 ( 12+

! + !* 0;;;-+

! (

! 1

! +

"1& *!!-1"+

!-+ "!1 ,+ !*+2

+ "

.+ +

! ( ! 2 ,* * +

< ! * !

-"

+ + *!

- + * + ! (!9 12 ,2

1

! + "1& *!!=

! + *!

0;;;-+

*9

* +

< ! * !

-1" + -

!1

! +

"1& *!! +

* + ! (!9 ! *2-+

+ " , !

+ (

*! (

,

"* !"

,+ +

&& + 1

! 7 12+ 8

! 7; 12+ 8

!.+

+ ( ++ + !

*! ( 06;;;

,++

-+ !

! -+ ( + 1 +( !-+ !2*! ( 06;;;4D<'5+

"21

1 , + ! .+"- "1>"

,! + ! ! *"!

,

"!! * 12+ "!1 ,- +8 "!

2 "

! !

! + ! ! *"!

+ ( -

*2- (

"$

) %+ + ! 9*:! @ E :3

%+ + !!

!1 @ E :3