← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaTA/628/2016allowed

Dipti Jain v. Shishir Goel

2017-02-15Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi14 pages

   





 ! "# $ 

%  &  "

&&' "

(! )* !* + '

 !&"

"

,# -.,) ,)/) ,.

 

    

      ,)/) ,.

012.3   !

!

  



 "#



   $  %  %& '  



 () *

+  (,-- $% %  & 

  . /  !

   0 '

  10 2+ 2 0    

      !  3  

4!

     

!  '    !

           5      0 

 10 2+       !

  +

   

 10 2+  '+    *    !

         0      *      6  +

   

    +    0 

+ / 10 2+

     '+      0 4

    !+ !

0  0    /  '

  10 2+    ,7 '0 8 +         +  10 2+ 6   

      

            3   



 ()  0 '

  10 2+ 6        

   !

+      +    6  0     !



 !

      + 0 10 2+  '

    + 0   !

  



 () 

    '   + 00                   0  +    !

 ++

 0        +   '  

:    3 



 "#

  

      0       + 6 00 0 

  

    

   '   0                  0+   ;

    0   '+   

  

0  !

 '+      !   %    '  !

  +  

:  ' !



    0 +  +0 *% 

0

   *+

  + 



                      

 !"# $% &' (  ) * 

+ 

! ,- .(% /  *.($+++ + 

0#  ! & *.&   $++$

, " 0*1.   /.&. $++, +  $#+ "2 3

)&4

1/ 533 $++

 

,

  ( .6 ( $++

 , ! # .&( .& 4.&(  &6 *. 2 7&68& $++# ,,,

-% 19 * $+0 , :

"# +   $+ $ ):,!    $+,: .  "0 $9; .&$++

 / $#" , &  $+ "  / $ !.% /4..&4.)' 

*$+$ #  / #! :    0 !

*% 

0

 (#   +0 06'7 "

+06+806'7 "

+6+*+"

) "9*%  $ &   + !

   



< 

      





                       

 

    

          

     

 

  



  ! "              #   #   

           

       

    #  

"

$    #   #    

       

%  #     #      

  #      #

   ##   %



 

%      

         

   

 

 

%  &  ## 

 



       %       



 

$      

 

#      



    

 &         

$    #    #         

 ' #    #

  "         

  #     "

       

     "    ( +  +       + )6:+;" ;)7;<$ & *% 

0





<$ &  

     

 

     

     

      



'

      

  "

        

   

 "           



  #    $    # 

 

      

        

           

 "

      





#    #   #       $ )       # 

"   

        " 



 

   



*



    



#  



 #    

     



 

# 

  &      

  + 

    







 %     #      

  #      

       #  

    

#           $     ,                

  

- 



.( :      !

*% 

0     !



  (= 7) "7(=  : 2 ,#- "7(- $

0   . > ?

 @&  : 2 A,A "7(- $ + >  . .

+ @ ?

:!&

      +0 *% 

0

   *+

  + 

     !

        +  !+  00 

    



 ()  

 10 2+      !

0 6      >' *+

,( =*-!

 $ &             +    !

*% 

0

  *+

  



% /0

  "

)

 " #

              

$   ##





-1.-.

 



  2

 4  )      2 -1.5 

  

  

 

      

        

 6  " 7



"   -. -.     

 

" 

    - .

    % -

.      

 "



     

 

 % -

.       

  " 

     3 $ 

          

      

   

  $   6 " 7



9      $ "   

  

 $ 

   "

    



         

    $      

"    

       :

"

; 1!8<==8 

 :    >  "+ 

     



'  

    >   "    +          

        

 $       &   

 

   

  "

)

 "       "   

         

       "

  #     

$     

  $    

    #     

#       $   ## 



 & 

  



  

  ,

  

 -1. "

)

 "

1= '    

  

                        ,

              

 ' 

 "

  

    #    

   

 6  "     

  "7



9 7



9   7



?  

     "  #      

      , 

  

 -1. "

)

 "      

'% /)''

> <    ,, '   #    7

  +        6 "  "

    

    

  

   

    $

  

 7

+  1@

18A1 6 #   & 

 . :/;  ,$'""+ %=  "" ,$  "   9

   #     

     #   #     

        

             

  ,

  

  "

)

 "        

$

       6   "      

   #  6 "

'

        

                  "

   #  

    

   

 " '

 

  #   #   " ): 1/. "$ &9  &







 2 3' 

                     

"               " 

$     "    #   

   

  

 

    

5        

"  

3 $

    "   # 

            

     

>+   :  6 " 1/ <  /     9  -   

,    $  



 & '      2 3;  

    

   

    



 -1.-.-

. "

)

 "    

#                   

& 

        # 

   

$   



    "     

       







 

       

    

          

  



       

   

 "   

  #

       #            

    



'        

 # 

  

 

  

 7



" 6 " 

  "

)

 "       

      "  

               

  #                

  '   #  

 

        # "   

    "              

  *            #   #          9  *

     

  "    

6  "7



""             

 

   

    "

-B



 .   7

  +         6   "   = - 6/ 269       

!     $+!         

    #

 "   

  

 

         , 

  



 

    " #               "    

 

$ "     7



9  

#  7



"

9   7



                  



             6 "

1A ' &  %  /  *  *    #$ >  5

6 "    

  ,



  "

)

 "            

          

' 

       # 

      

  ,



 -1. "

)

 "       

$ 6 "  7



9        

#

 "  

      #       

  #   

                    " 

 

   '

  



"                            :

"

; 1!8<==8 

     )

> ":   " > 

> 9  +

1!

$  



   

  

  "

)

 "

 



        

'       # "    

      " #   

   



   

  

   

  #        

     &     

 

    

    #     

 #           

4  

   , #  

      

   >  

  " 



&       

      

      

     9    #

 

     

 



-   -  .  /  ;  /9    

, . # ? & */.&  @  $++$  &9   &  , "      (  &      1& :$++ . !0".

( 4+       !

+    !

*% 

0

  *+

  + 

  

+!

       ++ 



 ()   0 '

  10 2+         +  + !

   0      6          !

 

         6      + 0 10 2+  '

   0        :   '        0       +   

0 

         3   



 ()  0 '

  10 2+

2  + 0 

+      0         0 

           0   !

 



 ()  

  . /  !

       0 '

  10 2+ +!  /

+ '

     0       /

+ 10 2+   !



!

    0 0    !

 

:  /

+ 10 2+ 

+        0  +   

0     !

    B     0                  ?,)/) ,.

0@ (- 7" "7(A 

 B '+C 1C2 B   1C2