Shiv Mohan Sharma v. Ashok Kumar Duggal Deceased Th Lrs Asha Rani And ORS

 



    
 



 



!"!

!#$"%"&&

!'

'

!

("&!)
!( !


( !



( !



!

!"!

!#$"%"&&

!'

'

!

("&!)
!( !


( !

% *% '!+         
 , + "

-.(' / $.('

* 

!0

! , 1.('

* ( !1   (


(* ( 1
   !,#2/ .(' * 3!&&/ .('

* ( 4.)"(

  26!-"(& .7!

(!

!

*/
! 
  *

(0  **

(


 *

(0  **

!(  ! 7"!

.*'!* '!

 

**!!# $"  %"&& .  & (  0"    6 !  (  !  6"&   0 "( $"%"&& .& (0" 6 !. !( !*3"!

128887799.

1.-1&.1/ 
(.

)"((0"&!"0 &41:*: &!

"'  4 .  )"(  *     (    !

4 !

#&( '

*

 -"'. !& (.!**' !. 

6

! '*'&& "

*'"!&6(& 9(   ;!&'!"' * "!

!/! ( !

' (/

 ' !

(#!1.$1: 9 :!

-0(* 6   !" (/  "

! *

& <*  # / .< ! (%!')"((*'&6'     !*

**! 0 !(

6 !

  !*

**!. 6 / !

!!

!!* !"

6!"'! * &,

%"&& ( "'!

(

6&  !=" 6(!

: /!

'*'0"( !(  &!

(!

(( (  > * !( .

**!   (

6(" !0

!' ( *"> "!

/! (

 ** *

**! "' '((!0 & !!

!!

("!

;!'

6  >

''6' ' ! !0

&!

( "!

(

**! 6&

''60

&"

 6>

**! !(&"!

(&

6-0*! 6(*0'"(   (!6

* 9!  %"&&  ?0'!>    "'  4   (  !!"

'

'



**!*  >

**! & !

(' '

''6' ' "!

*"& !(0"! !!> ?( "

6%

 ( ! !!"

('(

**!>

**!( ! "'!

)74  ' !(( !!>/   **' !*"'

4  !'

*'



!!.

6. .
( .@( .1( ( A!! (!!&

**! 6  '"!&  * '

 !!

!!("!

*"!

06

**!>!

!"'

**!*

(4 "

(B!#$" !"! B./'/!( '

((( (!!"/

! (*'"!& * '



'

*"

/#&*

**! !"

6( -"(& 9( '

( ( :>  ' 

' (( (C4 .

 /'!!"

( !(  ! "!

="

!(( 

& ' !>(6 * &* !". **' !* (C4 '  !"

6( ('&

" * "!

="

!( ((  !

! . !

& ="

!!*

**!(! '

**!(*

( !"="

! 4"* /

& &'

. (C' 

 (*

(/ !  ' !& !"!&

6 0- '!'

"(  ':* ,4'/!

 ("

 (0 * * &* !". * . !" /!0

>

**!( ( !!

* '!.* !('06!&

& '!"'>

**!(0

!

 ('

!"( !

!! ::.'

!/ ("

6 '

 (06 ( 6*

(

6  !    ::  06  #&  &"

 

&!>    

'!"'!

(

&

6/! 0

0  ! (> !" /!0

>

**!(

' (

4"/'

(!>

**! "!&

6* ' ' " !

!/"& & =" ( '

'

*

(>          '     !(&    

&0"(*

**!>

**!(*

( !" -"!(

& '  !. (' !!

!

(   ( !(# 

 

60- '!''(& (. *'60 & "06

**! "!

!'"!&& (**'"

6

&0"! (6(6 * < (' ( ( /"

(# '&!

**! &(&

& '!"' ('

 (

**!"(  '::* '*"& 0"! !!/" '

'

('"!

*'!



**!0& !"
*"& &

&!

. ( 6 (*(!!! * !"



(&!*  !.*

/&!!"

!/

* (+  D 

**! 

(

 -"'!

6 (*E ,,  D  !"!0

 *E ,, : D  !"!0(*/*'

A9:*,4 'E ,% 

 * 7(   '!

.

**!( ; 2 -  $"  !  ,D .  !#  $"  !  ,D  ( F"( &!,D:0 !( ! ( &'

('" !

       (.    ( (  (  ; F"(

&!%D  *  &&" !.  4"( '( (!!"

1 0!

& !"

6!' ' 0" (&0"

  !(   (

**! &"6' '

0"! !!(6/#**0' >!"''*

**!  '"!

!  "!'

      &0"!.      /6.  

**!    (&    ' '  0"! !!  (  "*'"& 0"! !!

&

6!"!

/' 6 &&( (4 !&&! 

& /#&*

**! "!

="

!>  &0"! &&  !

**!*'6& 0"! !!*0' ' ! !"

6(

**'0 !

'"

"( ' / !*(&!' ' 0"! !!( *0'  /#      !" 

6  06  #&    &!  * &0"!!

!!./  . (!(

&

'"!

 *  !

&    ' '  0"! !!  (  "*'"& 0"! !!"06

**! !"

6!!"' 

4"*"(

**!(&& -"'

** '      ( (  '  !    ' '  0"! !!  ( *0'  0"! !!  * 

**!      !" 

6  (  '  ! !"

606#&'"(  !!* ,4  '  <"!.    !!"

 /!  ( '( (   6    *" *  

**7!!"

1/!( '( (  6*"*

** 0!

&!"!0

 ;

( (' #  '  &!  

**!   &(&    !" 

6   ''('

/ !!*,4'. 7!!"

1:/!

 '( (0!

&'

"(  ':*,4'/!

=" (!'

/!'!

*&*

 -"'
!"



6.  !"  *  

**!  /!  ( '

(    

;

 (!

 ! !"

6(!

!

**!*'6& 0"! !!(*0' ' ! !"

606( & !!*,4 '.    <!  /!  !  (  (  -"(&   (  ( '

 (    <

**!/ &&  (06 !(-"(& ( '

( 6(*

(

0 * 4"*%!'

@"(& .)"(./'/!!!& ((( %!'@"(& .

)"(./( -"(& (( '

( ( G  ''



/ (*'('

*' ** ' ( 4 !

 (!!"

* !!/'"!

'

!

'*'

6!&!/' * '!"'

!    !

(  

&

6  /"    !'.  /' ''(& ( 4 ! 0

0  ! ( 760   (   (*

( 

'"(  (  
"

 4,4 * 0 & 

( (! 6 

3/  .

'/!

(!!!

(( ( ( ( G   !!

(06(( %!'

@"(& .)"( ?

&(!!!* (/ -"(& (( '

!!

G 06

 ((( %!'@"(& .)"((( (!!!& !

'"(  (  
"

 4,4!

 ( 



 !4".'

*/'/!!!"

( ( !./ 

 ("&'"!

 760   (  4 "0 & 1:9   (0

*

(06

**!!#$"%"&&

(  !  6"&   0   "(   $"  %"&&  &!  

(!.
( .@( .

1(  0 !.A!/* *   !  /

 !  "'  4 .  )"( "& !

4!! !

#&( '

*

 -"' !& (!(

!!'

&"(  * * &

'

*"

!!

!!*

**!(*'"!& *



'

*"

!!

!!("!

* !"

6 !

!

(&!!  (0 

  '

   ( (!  (  

 (  < 

(!(*

(-/ !  ./ !( (C ' (' "

/!

 / !   7    -  /   !    *

(  06   

(!.   6  #  "

 "! 

&  0- '!.     !

' (&    

**!    "!&  

6  !

6  * ' ' " !

!> 

& (

''6' '!, 4 './'!& ( 6 ("! !(*

 !(  " !

!>

**!& 0 ( '

'

*( (1''

/!**' !7!*" !"0 ( !/ &( (! &(-&

6*

**!>!"'( (!(( '

   ( (  1   &(&    "!'

 0 &  '"!

(  06  

**! (* /&*  '

'

6*"  ''(&!"'( (!. 6(0- '.*

**!

#

 !( '

 (-&"!

(  ' 6.

&   !

  (  ! 6  &(!  /    (  *    !(

!

!?" .

**!(!

(  ' 

6

& (0 / (06 ( 6 0

 $D  /   ' '  0 !( !  !

&    &   !

  * ' '6* $ >( (1 !  *6

! (0 ( !!" ./

(1:! !1 "  ( 0*  =" '!  *('!./(!

'

! ((6 ;

("!'

> "&* ' 6(&  ("'

0!

/ /

* "!

*!"'( (!< (!1  :( !*

('" '

&!

**!!  

6&  * &  * ( '

  !&  

**!  * "!&

6!"*' ' 9("! " !

(*"& ' 6*! 6!

( !( !

!0 &

!"'

*'0

"!'

.*"  6&* !!&*( '

  * ' 6*
!.9&! (!0 & " =" (06 '" '

!*

& (& '"!

(06 "&* ' 6(& 

6 % (1(*

(/ !  ' !&

!"#& ! ! !( / !  *

(

' '

(!"( 

(0  <

**!  (  *

(  !

  

'!

' &    

&!      /   !  !  / !

 &   !





(&!*  !.*

/&!!"

!/

* (+  D 

**! 

(

 -"'!

6 (*E ,,  D  !"!0

E ,% : D     ( (!9'"   '

!   

(  

 -"'! 6 (*E ,4" '

!  D '" '

!  ! 

(* ' 6*
!.9!

& (E ,4" 4 !

 D  '" '

!* (* "!E ,,  D '" '

!'"!

*'E ,, 

 * 2  !

( ( '



'* '

! *  &

 ('"!

*  !. 

  4"( '( (!!"

!1! (:*"*

**!( &! (!.!!"

1*"*

**!( &!    ( (!.  !!"

 1      &!    ( (!
!"

 6.!"*

**!/!( '

(/'!!('" '

* (!/!(!!!

(/'!!<!/!!(

( -"(& (( '

( (   &(!!!* (. (!(*

(

*

 (  %!'  @"(& .  )"(.  /'  /!  !!& (  

 ((( %!'@"(& .)"(./( -"(& ( '

( (  (!!!

( !(

./'

*

(!&&  (( 6(*

(
  0 * !

4".'

*/'/!!!"

(( ( !

 "&'"!

 7  (

 ('"!

*  !0 !( !&& "& '( ?!'&
  ,  -"'( /06 ':G*



'*'

 *'. : *   (! '! (!' 6 ="0

 *./'!0 & (06 4" #

& / *'!(''"!'

!* '!

'

"(&

'("'*  !(

!''

!

 *! *&< !( !

" -"'60

& (

**   0 '*0 & ;!&

  !*"./  ;

!!

606

'"0 ' 

( !/ 6!"'0 &!

!*''.

4"  !

 0  &"( (  06   "

!  (  !! ' (   4

77 !0

6''0 /

  ! < * .  "0 '  :  !

 '    

'.  /'

( !/  (( ! !(

**B!&. -6 *.

6. 4"6&

" -"' *

/&'!

!.

6+

 / (!"!

*

6*

**>

0 /   ;!!    !((  *  !'

&    '"

(& '"!

(. #

60 '"!

(.06 !>

' / !!!"''

! 6/"

**(( ="

 *>

( / -"'! '

!!6  "



'6* -"(' '

(&!  ' * '( * !B0 &B!'

"(&

 6("6 *'

0

06 /< * .' ! "

(! &0 '60 & ;!& *"  *  

**  (    

&  '  !  0 &  (  06  

(  C  4  
     ( (  C  4   !

'

(&''('

/ /  ' * '( !/  "  !/ 

 : -"'!0 *"!

(4 "!

 ( !-"' '0 & (/  ="

6 **''"!

 *''

 60

0 (066 "!" ( * '

(& ;'

'!

* 0 '*"!D !4 "!

 ( !/  '("'*

**!& !!0

!"'!(!





!!!'

* 4" 7!'!

4 (!!"

('

!

**!  "(    '!    (    *    ,"-0  "'

4   '  *  !&  

&  '!"'  ?"

*

(&

'

(" * !!&( *(  (!

& *0" (& (/#!'

'!

!(** &

! ( ("(  '*,4'!

 !. ( *(   !

0 ( "

!!

!!0

& 06 !*'

 (    !"'     !    4!!   6  #  *.   !0



"6*!/&'"!

/6!"'( !"

( ( "0 ' ( !6

!&&  (06 ( * 4!! ( "( !"0!

' 6 

&! (  4"* %!'@"(& * 46 /

(!

'* ( ( *  *

'/#/'

!(!"0 ' : ( ! / 

!  ("( !"0!

' &!( *  . 4"* %!'@"(& 6!6 *'

 *( !"' !.*6.(*!"'

(.!6

  #*"0 '  ( !0 -"!('* 4

4"( &! ! ( (!!

''"!

6!".

'  '

(&*-"'  

 *&! 4!!  !*#&6 '#&6(  "!"'

* !!*!

' < * .-"!('* 4 4"!"'6

*  !!'

 60 (3/  . 4"!0

/(

& (!

'( 6 '

(( '( ' !6 / !"'4"!(-"!('(-"(' !((!

"

!!"&-"!('./'(( !!"'4"! ?"  .  

**!  (  ="

6  **''"!

 (6** &

0 * %!'@"(& "(  '* ,4'0" 6(( *  (6< * . /  

(& 6!*-"'(4"!0

/06 /& * /(!

! * ( '

(

&

! '

(&

 *

**!/' 6/

 

(<  4" "&( !

'*'0!

!

**! &"6' ' 0"! !!(6 /#**0'!"!

./''"!

!"!'



&0"!( (C' !&&!



& .  /#&  *  

**!      "!

   ="

!>  

&0"! && !

**!*'6&

  0"! !!*0'' ! !"

6(

**!'0 !

'"

("( ' / !0" *  ! ( &  0!

&

**! & && -"' ** ' ('!

' ' 0"! !!(*0'0"! !!*

** !"

6"'-"'& (06  4"( !#

6!

!

D 4 4"&-"!('  (6  .

**!& ="

6 **''"!  (6 &

 *.  4"/!-"!* ( !!&!"'6

* '

*"*

**7'  6& (



!!* //

&&

 *

**!!!"& -"!('./'(( ! )  ((( %!'@"(& .)"( !*

# '

*

& ! !"0- '(" '

!!

'

(&

 *

**!/"6-"!*'7 /6. -"(& ! !!

(06 4"!0

/

 !

.

/' !"

(!'& *-"!'

< -"(& !' 

/ ( !!"'< !"!

*/!0

((  ((!!!  )  (  '"!

 *    

  !    (   -"(&  
 

  

           06 

;4"/  /!0!

 (

!/!

& & -"('

6( !

  ** '

(06( '

.!

!&&  (06!"'( '

(' 

&!( '

 )  (  '"!

 *    4   !    (   -"(&   !      "# 

 $ %$ & '

'   (06&

2 '* !4"/ /!0!

 (/ 

**(!

0"(6  /

     !

  (    4!!   (  !!

 ( .

**(*

(!"*

 -"'.

!"/!

(0 0

!( *(  !"

'

& (06* &

 <"!. 
  !''

(< -"(& !( '

! !!

(06 4"!0

/ !

!( 
!"

 6. !" *

(06

**!!#$"%"&& !'

'

!

("& )
!( !(!(!!!

( '

   

 !(!  

/ (.    (    &(& 

(&*

!'

(*(

'!(!(!

!

(*''(& 6 !   &(!    ' '

(  
    *

(    **

!!''

 (.!'

4 ! '

(&&!

**!06!

&'

"(  '!(*,"-0"' '.!



' !'

* 

!60  '

!! (06 &!( -"(& !(( '

! !!

(06 4"!0

/

  D  !"'  0!

!.   
    !(!

(!

!

(*''(& 6    !"

2-   #$%&$%''%()*+%,-).%(/0+1  %)-* #$%&$%''%.*'&(23%  %)-*