High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3889/2014dismissed

Manpreet Kaur v. Parminder Kaur & ORS

2015-12-04Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal14 pages

!

"#$ $%&'&()

* "(+,$$#-"., ++$//"(# 0'

1# ",1&(2$,-".,"(2#3$,'

$'+(2$(#'

)

! "#

$% &'%(!)* + # % )* ,

&'%(!) '

%#%-).-( *

/

# "

#

& $'

"

"

( ""

"" ! (

)

" " " *$ ""

" ,( ( (,,, '

"# (, - ./ 0

) ,)

"#

, *

' 2,,, 0 $"#

3)

(,,, 0 " "

)3("

4(526

# '" 5 " ! (

) " # 7"# *

'

, $"#

,3 (/ "# .

/ +"# "" ""

" "

) ""

# %

""# " "

# '" $

""# " +"# "# #" ""

% ' " "

"" " )- 0

&- -)( ,. ,) (,,( &"" &

$

"# "" '" " 0 '" "" " "

% "

" " '"

" " "" " '" "" * "

"

$ ' "# # $"# " "

% " "" $ "# "'

$"# % "

" '" ""

'

$ " (2 ,. (,,( $ "# " " ""

$' $

"0" " 0

""# & " " % %

$ 8 (

( && 9" $ #

%

" " +"#

$

8" % *

#" " #

'

9" $

'" " "

# "

"%

" *" "% % "

# #"

/

" "

$ " "# " '"# " ' "

&5

!

"

#

$

%% # % #

&

(

% % %

)

#*

#

+

*#, , %

-

* . & &

/

,%

.

.

: " " " "

" " "

;

9"

& " " ( .

, "% " ' " ""

# "

#

"

"

& " " "# $" ""

" +" ' %

" " 3

""

$"# '"'

"" ! (

) $"# #

" "" $"# 5< " -

32 9"

& ""

"" % " )32 ""

32

$ "

#

,2 ,/ (,

=

" >" '" "" "

#

,) ,2 (,

<

, '"# $ "

0"

( #

5 2

&%# # %

*2

% %#

%

# *

3, * * #%

%2

%

*

% . & &

2

#

4

#*

#

%## $ 5

00 *

*

# % *

2

*

*

# 6

%#6

6 %## $ 5 00

%#

2

7 8&7 9 3 & # #

% %

" "$ $

"# "

#"

"" ' + $

"# $"

" ##" " 5"5

) ,1 (1 ,= 11, ,2 ,/ 11(

), ,;

11(

?-"$" 52 5;

"% " -"

( & " '"

"#

@5

" ' " ' "

%

"% " +"

% " ' "

"

" %

$"# % "%

#"

" " " < " '""# $

) % "

"# " $ ""

"" ! (

) <

"

# $"# # " " " 0" %

11,51

11( ?- 52 5;

+" )

: "

9 " 4"$""6 4"

A A6

5 1,

2-#--) #) !- ) -) 3: ; 2 * # % ;2 *: %; 2 <:

;2

% *

# # * #

%

%

*

# = ;*2

%

*<:

;2 *: %; 2 % 0

3% //)

;2 %

>!<: 8

! 1 %1

# %

#% ;

2 ;2

*: %; 2 %

'

3% //)?

;"2

* # % * * ## # % # !

*

$2 %

& &# % /+"; /+$2 % % * :

%@* **

2-#--) -(0"

%#) !-35 ; 2 %#% % %

* #

#

*

%#*

% ;2 % * %

* #

#

* %#%**

%#*

% ;"2 % :: ;2

#

%%

A #

*

%%

#= ;*2

#

% %%

*

#

#

% %% 1

" +" )

" " """ : " & -- 6'! -0

2! -6 /7898:+ 8;

0" " $ """ : ' +"

" " "

"

% "# #

# " ' < "# """

$ ""# ' " "# " +" <

# """ : # +" ) "

# +"

-% " % "" " "

"

"

"# "# '" "#

#% # " +" '"

%

% # ' ""# % "# " % "#

/ "'

- -- 6'! -

4

" *A$ - &

& ( %%" 7% %: #"

0

2 %!-)- )% < ) 7% %: #"

/ 88= 7: +,9 *A$ - &

"" ' "$"" +" )4

# " '

" # "

" $ " ' " # " '" $"% '" "$"" " " ' ,/ ,1 1== "'

- -- 6'! -

4 - "$"" +" ) " " # '" "" 9 " -""# "# ' " # +

#"

% " B#"

.

+" " " # %

"#

"# " +" '

1 ,/ 1== "

;

<

"'

$0

# *A$ - & )< - )% )< ) -'

2- " )%'

'0

6- -

/788=:>;;

?-& "6'! )% )0

. ! )% /+@@87+:

7-0- : =4 "" '

" $ " " "# " %

1==

= 0"

'

" " "# " %

1== " "$""

" +" " 0"

$0 "# " "

" "$""

#

"

9 "

% *" "" "%

" $" "% < " " $ ""

" *" "%

# $

$ " # "% " ?- $ # " $

$

"

(, +" = *" +" "$

*" %"# " "

"# "" >"% " $"# " "" < + "% " " "# $" "

" 5< " $" '"

" "

(

< "'

" " ' "

32 0"

"

0" ! 4 "

+" " " "'

" "# "" % & $'

(( C" ! 4$6 0 % "# " +" #

1== % % 0" " 0"

"

"" 8 (

( &&

" "#

" ""

"" '" % 5 "

" "

"

$ " +" " " " "" " % "" % " '" "# #" % """$ " " " % ""

" $ " (2 ,. (,,(

'

""

" "

" "#

#

9

% $ ""# "

""

# "#% 0" ! 46 46

'

"

() C" ! 46

"

"0" " $ ""

# " (2 ,. (,,( '" $

% "0" # % "$ '" $"#

% #" " - ? "# " $

'"

# "#" " $

% "0" '% "$

(2 ""# & $'

" "# "

% ""#

% # "

0" ! 4#6

" & $'

0" $% # " 6)32 ""

32 '" % "$ "

"

'" +" = *" +"

(/ >""# "

"#% "" $ ,2 (, /

34