← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1064/2017dismissed

Harpreet Singh v. Mukhbain Singh & ORS

2018-08-03Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry7 pages

  

        



 

!"#"

$% ##&& '"( ()%*

$% %"($%% + %" #    



 

, "- 

 %"

##&&  '"( ()%*

$% %"($%% +  %"

#      

 ." ")%/0% 1"2 3 % "% $#&12 "%##&& , 

 "% %4(#12 "%##&&  , 

 "56

12 "%"#  , *%%##& 

 "$(8 3"%"6($8 3""2    9%-($8 *

$"& 9% -($8 %&& #



   &*/% #"&/$

%

("" 

$    ""

2   */*%  % :(" *&3 3% &   "

$  %(  "

&" #"8

-(

+"

&"%#" "&$"%*%%

 ##& * 2

&/ #*/ 88 -($8  ( 3%

% "8

" 88 +%()%*

$%%#&

% &( "

&"  )

$ 

   &&$  &     

"$ "   ;

 < (  */  % 8  %($%  4 "&  .3"   "

/!&" !"#"

$%

2("   3 %"# %& 8("

$ * $% * 33 %

=( &"& #"8

-(

,8/* %"%!"#"

$%  

 (

*"%"()%*

$%+%()%*

$%( " 

&% 13%"%#"#"/3 ('

&&$! #("1 9% &-#("1 "

. &   *"%"

&3 "> %(* !"#"

$%13%"       #%3!"#"

$% , % +%()%*

$%1%#&

%% 3/"& 3 

# &)"% #"#"/%" 3& $ 3 %% 0%$3 

$%1%" 1

(

*"%"%#&

13% "

$

-#("1 *

$& *(% 

(&  */%#&

($$%%%(&##

 % #3""

/ 1%""1%#&



$  %< (4 /

2(" 

 

!32"1"8 81%#&

 8) 3%%" 38%

$3" $ 1%""%

&&%#3""

/2

 

, % %#&

% 8/1%8  

"8% 8*(%

  &&1

3   

9%#&

("%"

#&  %      3% &  % %

$  # " /3 %     3%" &"& 2< (&

2("     %* %4 /" & " ? 1 ?1?

@3%

%3"$ " ;

 "%

%4 / 6

3"

 8 3 &*/    %/ & 8%%/"*  #("

%""2&(*& "  ? 1 ?1?

@ & %(  #&%

 %#&

%)% 8&&%#"#"/ 1%""11

@ 3# %"($%* )" "   "

$"8 &&3 % -2A 1'

)""12

"" (8 0)% 3 %"# & 8("

$ * $% * 3%"  1

@#" "

@3("%"" 2 " 8  %#&

 %""" #("

%"&# (&& 

& #/8  1;

1? @ 

3%

%3&" ""% #&

!("%"#&% -2A %" 8 *21("%" "

 $"8 &&3 %     

?"&& "  ? 1 ?1?

@  )

$ -2A %"1!"#"

$% %< (&

2("    0%%:(""<8

$%2

2 &*&  &%2

("" &/" "

$%%&< (*/  

2("    *$(" 

%2

$  *  < (  "  % 

   %  4 "&  .3"  

  "

/ &&("%"1)#

$

2 3%"& % #*3 %#" 1 #"

(&"&/     1%:("%2%& % %8 (%4 /< (

% 2("*/%#&

 +"

  &  "  %  ##&&   %  (*8   %  % #&

        &  %  (   3 %  &  %     %  %  " 2 1;

1? @#"$"8 && 

? 1%""1%

 & /"& !%("%"(*8 %  ##&& 3 3"%

 



3  % 8 &/ 

3%

%3&"("

%(3( & )!("%"(*8 %2 ()%*

$%& $3 %'

" 

$% %

& #"2!

1%(*8  %%&< ( 2&   %%"% 1&"

&"%"# % #

(%*%%$"8 &&  

?

2("  -2A   $"8 &&< (*/ -2A  #      

 2("              %2    *

#"( !("%"(*8 %

%"#&

1%#&

% 8 " #1;

1? @!32"1 %* <#&

%%" 3 $"8 &&< (*/()%*

$%%"($%!"#" 

$%

2("("- 



$%

?"& %& %"1

@#" "!(*8 %%#&

 " 2%#/8 ( "%" $"8 &&!("%"

(*8 %

()%*

$%% 1(#

"

$%1%  % * <8

3%%#



&&/%%& $3 %% %"

?

8#

*/'

"

$%%$ %"

 

%



"8% 8*(%

*(.B  (#

"

$%% * "<8

 % # !

1% 8 (#

"

$%%$ ( "*( &&("%"1 %*

"$(%%" 8/%2* 8 

%C" !# &1 %32"1   

  *3  -#("     %&  3%"  C" !# &  (  8( % 1%""1 % #"2%%3%2

$ ) 3&$%

9%  :("%  "(&&/ &/D %2

*"($%

" " 3 %%%&#%&"

&"%#" #""8 -($8 #*/%:("*&3 #"  ?%, : "  1 1  $ & % 3

3 %( "*

$  %#"

#& =(

$% 83 %&&8"

&

"

(8

3%

%%2 8% 3 ) 3&$ %(*- 1%#"

#&8/"#( %" 

% %3% %" /8"

& %*  % &/

& "8  % 8  */  %  $ 1  "  %  &

$    %  $   %2  *

2 $(% 8 , %#" 1%$"8 &&

2("("- 



$%

? 8 */ 1 %& 3$"*&%"1

@#" "

1% $"8 && 8 1%"  " 3%/ 3(& < ("%$"8

2(" -2A %"  

?$"

$&&%& A 1

@#" " %"

<#&

%#"%$"8 &&

?1

  %# 3*& 2"*(()%*

$%3 

#

& 2"%# !32"1 8/*

% -2A  8 &/) 3 !"#"

$% "% &  /"!

1 ##" % -25(8"A

%"3%%2%2$"#(" %3 %(#

3") 3 !"#"

$% &&("%"1 ( & &"&/#"2 %!"#"

$% (& 8&/$%&< (

2("% *"%"

&3  *"%"

&3   , ( %

"

(8

1%:("%<8

3%%"%

%$ 3"##"

$%#"

#&3 %&&% , #" 1 % &#"2%"   && ("%"1*%%&&$$"8 && 

?%2 *

#"( *"%:("(*1%" 8 "#

/

#&

$ %8 %3 3 %"$"%

"8

$ 2  3 %"$"%

1%32"1 %(& 2"&)%%3 3"<8

%:(""

"*&#"

, / 1&%()%*

$%3 &&/ "&3 % 1

**& 2%()%*

$%

%

%4 /3(& 

"8%

#%3     #"

(&"&/  3%  %  %  (*  *(  3" $

   %"$"%"$(8 %&"

&"% ##&& %%#&

%  &%( 3 % & % 1 8/*

%

%"#&

1%#&

%<#&

%3% " 2%8(  % (8%$"8 &&3 %("-

 



$%

?   #( !"#" 

$%% 8&8 3% &##"

$B %%$"8 && 3 "

&%($%1!"#"

$% & 88( 1

@ 3" 2"

8 /1%32"1" #

@"

 8 / #"2"8% "/

%"$ "% "

*3%

%%*

#"(  E2 #"  %, E2

 13%  #"/   

 "&     2  

  3 %  %"  #"/   (

"/ "& % #1% *(" #"2

$%$ %3 %"# % "   %#"/3% 

#  2 

, #" 1 3

 (

"/"& % #3 %&8  +%()%*

$%#&

,3" <#&

%3 

3%8

"1%&%#"#"/ % & &  "/2



(##"%" , 2 3%" 1%"  $"( 

""3 %%

("" 

$ ""

2*/*%%:("*&3 0%%$(&" ##&" 8  &&%#

$8 && (##&

1  /1" # 1

2 3%*2 -($8     

!

   "#$%#$&'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$01 $'./ "#$%#$&&$(/&%)23$1 $'./