High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/986/2015dismissed

Parshotam Mohan Lal v. Jagdish Chander And ORS

2015-11-16Mrs. Justice Sneh Prashar7 pages

! "#$$%&'&()

!!"

#$% &'()* (" ( " "!

+++ ) *+

" "-.('

. (/""! "()'" 0 1"2

" /""

""( ""! " 01"2

,$'$(#) ."3.

"-4(56 "

---

. 7)8"'. "6 (!!" ) "(/9!!"

! )

"")

""( ":!!"

;) !.'

"-.('

(("6""( <

!"() *)5) .)

/9 " "( *)5) &.('" &.

) =)5)) 4 >?) @4 () )) ' !"

) "( /9!!"

&'() * (" "")

" "

""( :"!

;48)68.!" (/9 " ) !!" "*. 5)("-.('

A <

7"" "5

""6!) . "("".

(" !!"

) "(.) !"

""@) " ) "!

&'()* ("

) "' 9 "

") ' .! " ( )) ' 6 .6 5" " "

".) ' ) 6 !)"( ) 3 A2 2B2 4 3"8 A2 43 )) . 5) '" 68 )47") >?) @"")

""( ":.) 9; 7"!!"

! "("(

" "(" ) ".) *.'4" '8) )/ ") 4#)

4 .) (" ( " /"6 " -)

8 " " .)

!!" 97".) 98()5)("( ' "68 " () ! "" ") ".) 8@"!

C (" " 5" " ' '()!.

" (()

6"/"

8""

"") .) 4 43.!

"- (*&.-4(56 "8""

!!)

"( "/) 48'5" ")8( (("6"") "

"8(8!"( (!6""() ' @) "8(. " *. 8""!"

'C 8 "'"( "8( 98 @"!

' " 8 . " "! "

)/ ".) 8 "5") "D6 .)5"!") 9 ()

(" 6."8 '

. ) () "/ "4"() "' 9 (.

8 . 98) .

)6" ( ".)

9 &'()* (""!

5)(" "

(""(( B

) ) " "(""() "' (! "()

B ") /.

(/9 ")( "(""( . " "!

)' "

".! 9)"6 .6 " "/9 '"

') ! "(/9 " (/.

!9"( !"

)5"("') B "!

!!""( (6

" E"! "("(

")8 ") !") "! !.6"(/9) .) *.'5)(" "(""(( B

( .

/) ")( "(""((/""

"()) ' "' /-"6 8) "'( 6. ()

) " "6."

6 ! "("(4"./

""8"" )5"! ) *.' ""

>?) @ ((.) '! "! !.6"(/9) ( "

" .) *.'48"" " "! " ""

"8)"( "/.

(98 .

") "!"6 )5"! ="

9) ' 6 )

4"!9"( () ) A ")5 6

"! )"4)."8"""

"(F

"! )"((.6"("5)("

6" !5" " @"

/9 * )(") "6. ((6.

9"5)("

6"!(.6"(/9

"! )" "./ )) (" ")/" 4 " ) *.

)" '

" 6 .() ' .) (" *.' ( /""

! "( ( "9 8""

() '"D6 .)5"!") ()

@ "!!" )" (

. " "("

)8 /") !") ""5"

.""6( "/) " "(""("D"6.

) 5.4

A () )"(

!!" 8!"

""(/9

') "-.('

( ("6""( "( <

!"(/9 " "( ) *. 8)6 8 () )"(/9 " "((() =) )6 &.('"4>"?"!.5)("-.('

(("6""( A <

< >"" ) ''')"5"(4

) "( ")

"'. "6 (!!" 7"./ )) ("/9."3.

"-4 " "( 6.

" "!""

5"/""

6 )(""( " "(6.

'."( "*. /" 8 ( ) "( !!"6) " ( 6 )(" " (6.

$D< )" )

!!" )"8)68! /) !6""() ' (66() 8)6.) 98 ) -)

" ") !

(6.

)$D 4!./ )6 )6"' !./ )"()

"8!!"/9.) 8"") " (

!!" 9) ) -)

( "5"/""

! "(" "(6.

" 6

("( !! )6 .

("("A. " < "*(" *)5) 6"(." ) "( /9 " !!"

'8) " !!" /"

" " )

!!" "*. ""@) '!" )) !(.6"(() "5)("

6" !5"

"(6.

$D<8 6 )(""(/9 " ) !!" "*. (

"-.('

(("6""!"(/9 ")(*. )" ". . ) / ".

(" 8 F989 !""

.) 4

) "( " "(""( B

"D"6.

"(/9)/ ".) ) 5.

&'()* (" "'.

98 -)

9/"

8""

" (( "5"/""

"D6 .)5"

!") )/ ".) 4 ""

"4"6. (

"/"

")' ") "

!""(E8"5"4.!)) ' 94"

()( ! "()/ ".) ! 9 ( "!

(""8) ! "("(! 9 ( )5"(" 8.' " ) 66.!9) 9

)) '6 .6 5" " "8"" )6"(/9 "*. /" 84 & / () "9"

B A$D=A"

"6 ""

9 .

B 5. "!

&'()* (" /) " "(""("D"6.

) 5./9.) ("

88 /") !") 9"!

6 ) "8 ("(5"!") 9/9) 5"

( " " "D"6.

" "(""(C 6

"D 4 ! "() ' .) ! 9 8 "6"9

) "'.

( ) ! "() ' " "6"9! 94 !!"

(""5"( /"() )"( "8)" 4 "")6 6."

' / " ) *. " ) !!" "*. 9 (/9.) "!

( "

)") ) 9!

8""

">) ' " ) !!" *. ".

(" :

! " #

" #

" # %

" # $

& "

)

* "

!( )!(

+ ,"

4) "/ " "( ( !"6) )6 ! .

" .) 9 " 5)("

"') ""( " (""( ( "(

$D= ( ( ("( 5" !") "!!" 9 ( "5"

(""4 """

) 6!" /" )"5" "6

98 ) -)

" "' ") ("6""().) ,"

" "'"( )

!!" 9$D<4 8)6

(" )"(.! 46. ( /"

"6 98)68("6)/"() @ .

/"4

< )((6.

96"8 " !

"8)"4

" 6 " " "( 6.

" "!""

' " !!"

"( '.

") " !!" 8) .

!".) ' ("6)) ) !! )6 (() "5)("

6"4) 94

8 ()!"( B 96"4 "")./

)5" (6 5) 6) '"5)("

6" !5) ' ) 9 "

2 ! " .) !!" 9 ' !!"

() ) 9 /" "/) 8)6 "")8""

() '()

@ (7"-.('

( "(B

$D= !"( /9 " "( (() *)5) &.('" "

) =)5)) 4 >?) @ '8) "8(( "( <$D=B8)68 (". " *. 4" / )"( ""(/""

( )/ " ()5)() ")-)

)" 7.4 ' ") ) " !!" 4 " " ) ""/9 () )"( * *

7)!!" 8 ) "( .6

""D!)9 " ) !")( )"

"(" 9 B(9 '8) "!!" 4 !! )6 .

"6 ") 6 6 ( (" 98 ) "(4/.

) 6"

"") ") "!!" 4 "") '.

6 ( '.6 '(" 9) ) ) "!!" "!! )6 )() )"(