High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3960/2014dismissed

Ayodhya & ANR v. Ishwar & ORS

2019-11-01Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan7 pages

!" "

##$$ %"& ' (" "

# !"

) "*+ " ##$$

#, "-*+ " "#

....

& $$* " #$ ' ("* / -*" +$$0! "("*/ $ " 1 2"&0 &0 !" '

" "+$$01 0$"

" - 2 +" " 3&

-&" 0

4564*( ($-2$2 #"$$0$* ( & "0 $7 1 0- "

8& " 0 "-+ " -

#" +" #$ * #" & "( " # #$-#" , ()

* 1 ) * ,$$ )

:* 69

* 69 * 69:

:* 69 6* 69 6* 69

6* 69

6* 69 6* 69

6 -&" 0 ; 1 $ -"$7 -$$- ""+2( #"* #$ ("#" 3&$ " " "&

+" " "7"-1$$) 69 *#0 + 0-

4564($-2$2$$ #$ $"" " 0" 0"

- #0 & 0$ 0( " "#$"- +$$07 #$ ) $"("*("## ( ((" #$ 2& 2 0 " 0#" + "& " "2$ ( & "0 "$7 #$ -#$ 2& " - #$!$ "* 12& 1 0 #+ * #$ &" #" 0 & " ;9

< 0 ) $7( "& "3& #$ "-+ " -

"- #0 3& * $& 3& 2" <+$<&" 1

2 0#& *2 ##" $ (" - 0 &

" #"$- "28 &( - 2$7 #$ ##" <&"( $ 7 & ( #"#"$+$&" #&"#<&" & (2" 8 " -8 " "#"

-"* - &$ (8 $( #2 #" " 0 -* &$ ( #" #$ +" # (" 0 7 "( " # &#"#" - "" "7 #$ ) (" 0$# ( ((" & (" 0

/ (" 0 + " &#

#" " " 0 -* + "& "

"-2 0( " # &$ / - &"#" 0& " ;9 <"

< (" 0 ) 2&( 2 - +$$0! *2 #"(&$0 &$ -"* #$ " "$ & 0 - & 0 "- 0" #$ * #""-$ &

#$ 0 #"*$$( 0&(" "-

= " #$ " $ "$$" #""> !!

'&)

#"+*( " #$ " $ "$- " 8& #""> !!

= " & #$ - 2$ #" "-> !

= " #" &2"-8 " 8 "

"#"> !

= " #$ + $"&-"$"- <&" *> !

= " & #$ 2 ""$+$& " #&"#<&"> !

;

? #"(""3&##"& $ "+

" " 0 $"

& $" #"* "$ <&"&)

+&" 0 #$ *&) +&" #$ 0 &$ $+8&0- " & #$ (-( 2 "$<&"

6 @$ 000"+2 8&0- "* #$ $ ##$ <&""A&0* 1*( +8&0- ":

;

# ##$* 8&0- "#2 "$<&" & #$ (" ("""-+ " - "- $ #&( (- "- # 0 "

? 0( 8&0- "# 2 $"A&0* 1* +$ #" "0&$" ##$2" <&"* ( ( & "# #$ *( #& ##" "&0 & $

' + "$"

& $" #"20 "&0 ""

/ #"" +" "0" #"#" + 02 #" 2( - &0 -$$- #" +" #$ * #&($#0 -$$- *( " " 0 / "$<&" & #$ - $" " &- " + ( "0" -$ $- ( " $ ( ( 28 "+ & ""* ""* #$ +2 & 2$#"+ " ' "$ <&" 0+ "&0

" -""- ( " #&($#02 #"" = " @"##$$<&"$"

"A&0* 1 #"#"$ ##" &$($$$0$# ( $- 0 $& #&( $#0 B 1 &#$ ) &8& 8 #& " "

( ( + $"& &# (" #& / $ 0( " $" ("&##$ & #$ ) "&0 -2 / 5#$ " "2 ( 2 #$ ) ( " ("0 $ #2 @" ##$$ <&" 2"+ 0 ( 5$&+ #"#" * (&$ +$$(#$ ) $("

$"$ "&0 #$ # ( ( + $" &(" C5- 0 -"

- &$*$"

"A&0* 1 2"+ D $$ #$"+&$-3&$ 63&""* ( " $" #& $:63&"" $ 0 2&66*( ""# ( $ 0 "#$*( " ( $

( $$ "#$"& *( 0 &00 ($ #0 #$ / ""* 0-"

; #$ * & #$ (" E"

"A&0* 1 "0 $ 8&0- "$<&"*( ( & 2$ ( 0$1 ##$ 8&&-

)&2 $3& $(" ##$

/ ""*' -" #" ##$ " &"2 $0$* +$ ($$ " 8&0- #2 "A&0* 1

/ ##$ -" 0$

?"8

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#