← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/1115/2017dismissed

Satpal Dua v. Municipal Council (Now Municipal Corporation, Rohtak) & ORS.

2017-02-23Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi9 pages

    

  !"#"$% &



  '(#)#

         

 *% +,**-*,.

(#$ %

 



      *-*,./   0( !

 """

"  #"

 

  $% & &'$( )*

   )* 

    *  )*

+ 



   "



 && $& &'$, 



               #

  

        )** 

 "   -       )*

 

 . #"

    " ) / #  #  "$001 * # - 2 #   

3 .&&, $, 4 $40$ 5   / # 4%   0  #2  

3 &%(, 0 ( $406  

      #



    061 *   ))  *   

  

  3 (,'7$.   *8  9  )

   :      

$, 4 $40$                          # )*  ;<!;  

 9#  :# *$'=:$&=   :

"

 > <  

  "7

 )

  "  "   )        

") #2   # 

#    9       )

     

  3 &  #   

    

  3 $  )*   "     "     

  $6=+$(= )

    " 

                 :   )           #  "$'=:$&=

   #  &4*  *   # * 

  ")

* 

) 

# # "7 #    ;<!;#  "$'=:

$&= ? ")

  

        "

 #

 "#  

 # * )

  

3 &    #

 " 

    )

    

        #     "   

 #   " @+ $ A    

 

  #

 *  B5//

& & A      *          

             

B5/ . A     # )*  <!

      "8? #       

3 &

 <!            "   # B5/ % 9  3 .   #    

3 &   

     

    #

  

   # *

 *  B5/ ,  A         #    

  3 &     #  ) 

 #B5// 6  A            #  )      

#B5/ ( A          



B5/ 0 A     #   

 B5/ 4  

A )      

)     #

* 

) 

   

     " "    

#   

      "*   #

   )*  





 && $& &'$, - 

    )

    #    )     )*    

        

#"



 $% & &'$( ?

  

     ?



    



     +    

      C<!=   <: /$  )

       

  +        *

  *   *#

    +  1    C<!=   <: /$

  

   *    # "

      5     

  

  9  

3 &  1"        )

) 



    

3 &  )

 # #  "  C= C!= 

)      <: /$ )*  #  # ) *      # )*  C<!= )

 5 "          # "  :

    

    1*      # )

* *  )*



          "          "  

#"



 #  )  



    



       "

   ")                      "      )*    

 D"

 #"

  @+  

      

   

      

    

  

   

 

    

     

     

    

   

               



   

!"#$

  

 

% # 

$&'(&'$& )*     

   

  +  #

    

% # !",-

      ).      

  

        

  !"  #$  

  

     

!",-

!",   

  

% # /

   

   0#!

   "   

       %

1



        

  

 %

1

 

!" ,( "    

     %

1

2  

    



3   

 

        ()&$4     

   



%

1

  ()&$4  (5& 

   

!",( !        5*&$4    

"

 &   

       

     



       

     ,



      

 

        







          

  

       

%

1

7% 

  0





       

 

 



      

       





      2 

 

            

  "   1  

 

   

                  

  

8

0 

 

  







   

       8

0  6      

  

      





   

   "     

  



 

 

     

   

  

        +    

          

           9    0

    

 

    

   !

"#$%&    % 

 '( #  )

)

  "  & 

 

      

     + 

      

  

               



       9     



9 





  

    9       8

0         

      

  

     

 

 



       



    7    0#!      

!",(    

        

  !"  #$       

      



    

 #  

  :5         

  /    

        0#! 



    

     

!#    

    

           



 

 

  :5        

   2   

 

 #  

8

0 

        

  



    0#!4

         " "     

   

   

    

  #"

 5  +  

# 

      C<!=   <: /$      #

)

       )

3 &

*" )

 5 *     )

    )*   

        E   

#  )  *  

 

##     #"

 #  )     

 ) + 

)*   #   "

  ? ;)  #   @+ $  $5"  '

#6   678 $"  '#  $ )#"$   $5 , /

2

:

6  "

;  *)$"!"< 1  )$!"1  6 15"/  =;  "

#  6"



"!('#)( << 0 2=;,(# $  $ 6(/

40 

& *)$"!"< 1>>"

'#"(

6 >/?:

)(, 0243029 3 6*)$"!"< 1>>"

"(# '#(7 $

##/?:4 , 029 , 56="("$@6'#*8 "$@6/

020"A"12 02      "

               *        

   "*    

#"



 )*

  D"

  ?

          *1     #    ) 1     *1   )

    

     

 " * "      :

 "      $''    /  9

   #  

  

   "   )    )* ? ;)

 #  * (

) +   , -( .. "&

 &

 3 "#

       #   

 )      #



 

     " )  #    *) #  3  

)

#

   1

*   #"

 

    

  )*

?



       * ) +)  #  

"   # 

  

&

0*-*,.2 >5#   A    "7 

@ 73 A   )

@ 73